4 Reasons Why The Hobbit Shouldn’t Become A Trilogy

Turning The Hobbit into three films will mean that the quality of the movies will suffer.

Peter Jackson confirmed at Comic Con this week that he hopes to film new footage for his epic two-part adaptation of The Hobbit, which has fuelled rumours that Warner Bros might decide to split the second movie; "The Hobbit: There And Back Again", into two parts. Thus making The Hobbit a trilogy. While this would be a great financial move for the studio, I can€™t help but feel that turning The Hobbit into three films could mean that the quality of the movies will suffer. Here are four reasons why I believe The Hobbit shouldn€™t be made into a trilogy...

1. The Middle Film Problem

While I personally consider The Two Towers to be my favourite of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, I can appreciate the criticism of a few who believe that it is a story without a true beginning or ending. I can only imagine that this problem would be amplified in a proposed middle movie of a Hobbit trilogy. At least with The Lord of the Rings, the final shooting script was written with the intention of there being three separate movies, with the Two Towers having the resolvable plot arcs of Helms deep, the Council of the Ents, Saruman€™s downfall and also Aragorn€™s personal journey into accepting his heritage as heir to the king. The Hobbit would not have this luxury, firstly because it was not written in this way and secondly because they are adapting from a book that has only one major story arc. It is because of this that a middle part to a Hobbit trilogy would struggle to find any resolvable plot threads and, as Prometheus has taught us, this is likely to frustrate audiences.

2. Sometimes Scenes Should Stay Deleted

I think before the filmmakers go ahead with filming this proposed new footage for the proposed Hobbit trilogy they must ask themselves if the new scenes will benefit the overall story. It seems reasonable to assume that Peter Jackson has already filmed all of the scenes that tell the story of the book and that any additional footage that he films would merely be added world building and character development. While scenes of this nature do have a part to play in any good film, too much world building can result in the story becoming lost and the pace of the movie suffering. For example, although I enjoy the extended additions for their contribution to the cinematic world Peter Jackson created, I prefer the theatrical cuts because they focus more on the story. Furthermore, if Peter Jackson did decide to go with three films he would probably include a lot of scenes that ordinarily wouldn€™t have made it into the original vision for the two-part adaptation. This could lead to the inclusion of some weaker scenes that may let the movie down as a whole. For example, I am sure I would have enjoyed The Two Towers a lot less in the cinema if they had included the extra Ent scenes that are present in the extended edition because they slow the pace of the movie massively.

3. It Could Change The Focus of the Story

The Hobbit book is one that plays out entirely through the point of view of Bilbo Baggins. It is about his journey into the unknown, how the quest changes him and also how his relationship with Thorin Oakenshield develops and changes because of this. I believe that for this reason a movie version of this story must keep its focus primarily on Bilbo. I would argue that Frodo€™s plot in The Lord of the Rings is an important part of a larger story that is told from different points of view and so therefore it works in the Lord of the Rings to expand the sections without Frodo present, especially when his quest starts to slow down the pace. While I appreciate this adaptation will follow Gandalf€™s parallel quest, adding further scenes that do not include Bilbo (as I assume they will) would tip the balance of the story away from being about his character.

4. It Could Damage The Legacy of the Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Ultimately I can€™t imagine a way in which changing the proposed adaptation from two parts to three at this late stage wouldn€™t damage the overall quality of Peter Jackson€™s presentation of The Hobbit. I am sure the fans of the series would prefer to be shown two great movies rather than three mediocre ones that stretch the story of The Hobbit beyond recognition. The fact of the matter is that The Hobbit is simply not as epic in its scope as the Lord of the Rings and so therefore does not need three movies to support the plot. The last thing that I would want, if I were Peter Jackson, is for a Hobbit trilogy to be mentioned in years to come in the same breath as the star wars prequels as films that damaged the legacy of the originals. At the end of the day I am sure that Peter Jackson has the best interests of his films in mind and if there were a filmmaker who could pull off a three-part adaptation of The Hobbit I€™m sure that it would be him. I can€™t help but wonder though if studio interference will be what kills The Hobbit in the end. It will be interesting to see how this story develops.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a 20 year old law student with a passion for film and television. I aim to not be too cynical about film and to approach writing as a speculative fan and not as a critic.