5 Best Films About Being In A Band

This Is Spinal Tap Music isn't just a mathematical process on a stave. The medium of music can be used as a social commentary, and as a road map to our very culture. When it's combined with film, it becomes entirely ingeminate of this idea. Being in a band is a way to harness music and its power, after all - a way to to tame the beast of organised sound. The modern media portrays being in a band as something like freedom incorporated, with an emphasis on sex and drugs. I'm not talking about One Direction and their life of Twitter feeds and sausage rolls, of course. I'm talking about rock. The truth, however, is rather different. Being in a band is hard work: playing to tiny crowds, travelling up and down the country, trying to tame your gag reflex thanks to good ol' Jack Daniels, which - although kind of cool-looking when it's fixed atop a Marshall amp stack - actually tastes like horse p*ss when you drink too much of it. The sex, for most bands, usually involves a drunk, well-proportioned lady offering to share her Scampi fries with you, or your mate James accidentally licking your neck whilst he's asleep in the car on the way home. The drugs? Can of Red Bull and a Nurofen at the end of the night - you know, to block out those "huge roars." It is not the huge success that ensnares the true spirit of being in a band, then: if anything, true success ruins it. It's the all about the adventures you share with your bandmates in the beginning, absent-mindedly stroking your own ego and committing your soul to every string bend, even though the only person around is the sound guy, and what does he care about your musical talent, anyway? Still, being in a band remains one of the best things you can possibly do. If you can't manage that, of course, film has opened many a window in this world for all to see. Below, then, are 5 movies which I believe perfectly capture the comedy, the tragedy and the spirit of getting together and making some noise. To do so, I have stuck primarily to fictional stories (biopics are a different beast all together). Are you ready to rock? Let's take a look...

5. School of Rock (2003)

school of rock The year is 2003. Avril Lavigne is flying the spotty flag for pop punk, and Dido is inspiring suicides everywhere. The world was in a music slump, and a power chord only seemed like a distant memory recalled by people with moustaches that called everybody 'dude.' I was at college studying music, day in and day out, with the constant dulcet tones of smelling like teen spirit the only ones to be heard. Then School of Rock was released and gave a kick to the gentleman sausages and lady gardens to people all around the world. Jack Black nailed the part of Dewey Finn. The usage of real musicians, rather than actors, to play the parts of the young band members was a stroke of excellence. They were rough in their implementation of their talent, yet they clearly enjoyed every single note with a glee only the uninitiated to reality is blessed with. The true ingredient for its success,however, was the light-hearted, 'PG-13' approach to it all. It appealed to a demographic that discovered that AC/DC was actually pretty great, and not just the music your Dad listened to whilst fixing his old Sierra. It certainly gave birth to a whole new generation of musicians that count the movie as an inspiration to pick up an old plank of wood with some metal wire on it, and plink plonk their way to greatness. It's a bit Hollywood and steeped in life lessons and idealistic schmaltz, but so are most of Led Zeppelin's songs. It's not what it did; it's how it did it. School of Rock encapsulated exactly what playing music is: it's childish and unrestrained and it acts as the dynamite to blow open the soul and let everybody have a good old gawp at it. It also showed that talent had no limits - those kids could really play, and play they did. It also happens to be the best thing Jack Black has ever done (but that isn't saying a lot).

4. Still Crazy (1998)

Still Crazy Still Crazy is just a great slice of British cinema. It centres around a band called 'Strange Fruit' that truly hated each other, and were plagued by jealousy and resentment in the 1970s that blew it all during their biggest ever gig. 'Strange Fruit' had everything that makes a legend. The money, the groupies, even a lead singer that OD'd in a Little Chef. Yet it was not to be. On the biggest night of their lives, the gods of rock blasted the stage with lightning, the guys gave up, and that was that. They all went on to live lives haunted by what might've been, and tortured by what was. It revolves around getting the band back together to play the anniversary gig of the one that spectacularly failed and it plays host to a gene pool of eclectic British comedic talent. Bill Nighy is the lead singer still attempting to live old glories with nothing but a memory of success in his pocket, and refuses to accept the encroaching onset of aging, whilst Jimmy Nail is the bassist and unsung hero, now living life as a roofer. Timothy Spall also stars, playing the stereotype drummer to perfection - older and fatter, but still wearing the leather trousers. Stephen Rea is the optimistic keyboardist living in his sister's council flat and working as condom salesman. Bruce Robinson (of Withnail and I fame) is the guitarist trying to run and hide from the past. Oh, and Billy Connolly plays their roadie in a stroke of genius casting. The miming of the playing the instruments is sometimes distracting, but Nighy and Nail actually lend their voices. It is first and foremost a tour de force of British comedy. It is both an ironic parody of '70s excess that meets modern day nostalgia, and an interesting character driven expose of life after rock and roll, and whether that spirit can be captured again. Unlike Spinal Tap (more on that later) it is more restrained, and actually becomes the better film for it. It is actually my favourite film on the list, because it's an incredibly human tale and it explores the relationships behind the music. Above all, it truly encapsulates the embarrassment and silliness of it all. If you haven't seen it, do so. If you have, why are you reading this? Go and watch it again.

3. The Commitments (1991)

thecommitmentsscreen The Commitments is a different beast to all of the other films on this list. It works as an incredibly powerful drama, an uplifting comedy, and a biting social commentary of life in Dublin in the early 90s. Based on the Roddy Doyle novel of the same name, The Commitments follows a man that is disillusioned with the Dublin music scene, so he gets together a band of misfits and forms a soul band with wonderful multi-faceted results. As with The Full Monty and its Sheffield setting, the desolate landscapes of inner city Dublin are wonderfully realised here, grounding the film in a reality that the previously-mentioned pictures simply don't. The audition scene in the lead character's living room is a grainy and excellent parody of The X-Factor, years before that crap actually stirred Cowell's loins. The comedic elements are handled with a deftness that is likened to being kicked in the nipples. However, the thing this film gets absolutely spot on above all else is the coming together beautifully onstage, and creating an experience of truly poignant music for the audience. Not only this, the almost ethereal and exotic magic of American soul music is brought to life in the dark and dinghy worlds of Dublin clubs. Except as soon as that last note fades to black, the animosity flares up and explodes in their faces offstage, and the film wonderfully highlights the tenuous balance that threatens to explode at all times. Again: the usage of real musicians in the title roles is an excellent addition to the aura of reality the film offers. The true revelation of the film, though, is 16-year-old Andrew Strong as the lead singer; his voice is titanic and full of unrefined raw power. The band itself still tours today, but with the original members mostly missing (although they did get together in 2011 to perform a 20th Anniversary tour - I saw it, and it was great). Plus, to the blonde backing singer: if for any reason you're reading this, my bed sheets will forever hold you in the highest regard. The Commitments truly wraps up the package of the dysfunctional band, and pays credence to the fact that behind every great note, there's an even greater 'F' word.

2. This Is Spinal Tap (1984)

This Is Spinal Tap Here it is: the film about being in a band in at number two. I believe this is one of the best and funniest comedies ever made, purely on the grounds that it is filmed as a documentary, and what you see is pretty much exactly what being in a band is all about. Every band I have ever been in personally, the rehearsals have been riddled with references and homages to this iconic piece of cinema. Genius is a word that is thrown around far too much today, but This Is Spinal Tap is about as close to genius as Mozart's pants were. It harnesses the pure lunacy and ludicrous meanderings of being a musician, and the painful embarrassment and false idolisation of ones own talent. It is a biting satire of the bands of the 70s, but it does it all so tongue in cheek it makes it go numb. If you don't laugh at 'this one goes to 11,' then you are surely missing your soul. The thing that truly makes this film a great one, though, comes with the fact that most of the dialogue was ad-libbed by the cast, and it's this interplay between the actors sending up versions of famous musicians that truly sets the pants alight. Amongst all of the jokes and the absolutely side-splitting situations the band find themselves in, it is a fitting homage to being in a great rock band. It really does encapsulate the highs and lows of being in a band, which I am sure every musician can associate with in any context. This is Spinal Tap carries off the playful charm of ego, and puts it in all in hugely creative and genuinely hilarious cocktail. The playing the gigs at ridiculous locations (the airman's ball is a highlight), the stroke of brilliance that is the henge monument with midgets dancing around it in the centre of the stage (and the incredible band reactions to the size of the henge monument) and the exploding disappearing drummer are all at the epicentre of this extraordinary film about music and its related modes. In fact, as I write this I am actually laughing as I recall these scenes. Now I have to compose myself as I attempt to justify why This is Spinal Tap isn't number one.

1. Almost Famous (2000)

almost famous The reason this movie is number one, then? Firstly, it's not because this movie is the best film of the five. It's mainly because it's told from an outside perspective of a young journalist who follows a band around. It's the wide-eyed innocence of the young man that carries the film as such, then: the extraordinary wonder of being around a creative minefield, to the bitter disappointment that concludes with the idea that making music is the same as anything else in life. The music itself is magical and esoteric, yet the minds behind it are only human. This film simply delivers that human story behind the music. The creative masterstroke here is actually in the usage of the groupies as vehicles for the narrative. 'Stillwater' is a fictional 1970s rock band, but it is placed in the world of real rock giants, placed in a world of indulgent solos and mysterious lyrics wrapped up in a haze of narcotic splendour. To phrase the great Hendrix, it's all shown through the purple haze. The scene in which Phillip Seymour Hoffman describes a band's music using almost Roman-esque rhetoric highlights the idolism and faith we place in the creativity of others - and it perfectly sets up the successive disappointments of the humans and their artistic endeavours. The 'Tiny Dancer' scene marks one of the best in modern cinema - the simplicity of music carries away the animosity and for a brief moment, nothing else matters but the next lyric. This captures what being in a band is ultimately all about, the main reason why people do it in the first place: the music. Harvard medical students in the 1960s would categorise each patient by their 'story' - the 'story' being how sexy their illness was. We are defined by our weaknesses. Almost Famous is the musical progression of this idea, because it shows that guitar solos and drum grooves and screaming vocals all sound like they were conjured up out of Olympus, but each one is written with real human feeling. It adds a layer of humanity to something we use to define our lives, cultures and other people's perceptions of who we are. Beethoven said: 'Music is a higher revelation than all wisdom and philosophy'. Have a watch of these films, and you may agree with him. Like this list? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Historian and Archaeologist. You can follow me on Twitter but I seldom go anywhere.