5 Films That Challenge Romantic Ideals
Regardless of how you feel about romantic films, there are a few that delve a little deeper than your average happy ending, by the numbers romance. A good romantic film will captivate you in ways that are completely relatable and so genuine that you'll feel it. A great romantic film will give you no choice but to invest yourself emotionally in the characters and hope for the best. If anything at all resonates within by the end of the film, then you'll have successfully been initiated into the world of cinema in a way that only this genre can provide. Films such as When Harry Met Sally ('89), Swingers ('96), Lost In Translation ('03), Sideways ('04), and Up In The Air ('09) exemplify the idea that the very notion of love is progressive and ever changing. These films challenge the audience to react to uncomfortable situations in relationships in a way that is accepting and forward thinking. Though not always straight forward, the intent behind these films is commendable and in this article I'll elaborate on what makes each film unique in their portrayal of romantic relationships. 5. When Harry Met Sally (1989)
Directed by Rob Reiner, this film sees Harry (Billy Crystal) and Sally (Meg Ryan) both en route from the University of Chicago to New York in an attempt to pave their own paths. At that point they're more friends than anything, in fact they both are irritated by one another. Their flaws become immediately apparent to one another and are completely turned off to one another's idea of relationships. Harry believes that a platonic relationship between man and woman is impossible, where Sally believes the opposite and is disgusted by the implication. They part ways and run into each other years later aboard a flight, in which it's revealed Harry is married. Then, years after that encounter, they bump into one another again only to find Harry's divorced. From there, they form a friendship and deal with the emotions that are brought forth because of the strong foundation they've built. I like that both characters carry such disdain for one another from the get go. It's an interesting pairing and really enforces the idea that opposites may in fact attract. As the film progresses, these characters deal with their friends (played by Bruno Kirby and Carrie Fisher) having what's perceived to be a solid relationship and still being single themselves, crossing the line between friendship and endearing love and confronting those emotions. It's a constant struggle for both Harry and Sally as they come to terms with the idea that their pairing may be a mistake and that they probably wouldn't work well as a couple. This is what makes the film work as well as its predictable ending. What makes the ending that much easier to accept is the fact that it's easy to become emotionally invested in either character. You feel for them, believe in them, and their interactions are so authentic, that you'd swear you had similar conversations. These are characters that are well deserving of one another, but like all relationships, that moment of bliss comes only by investing time in another and affording them all the patience one could possibly provide.
4. Swingers (1996)
Set in Los Angeles, Swingers has an atmosphere like no other. It stars Jon Favreau (who also wrote the film) as Mike and Vince Vaughn as the outgoing Trent. Mike has left New York and his ex behind while trying to make a living as an actor. Despite years having passed, he's still very hung up by his former girlfriend leaving him for another man, even thousands of miles away. Trent tries to bring Mike out into the social world and liven him up a little. Mike is so consumed by the thought of his loss, that he constantly checks the messages on his answering machine, hoping that his ex will call back wanting to get back together. He can be self-loathing and distant at times, but he truly does try to step outside his comfort zone and back into the real world. What makes this film unique is that it's told through Mike's perspective. A person who's fallen out of love, but very much hung up on the idea that there's still a possibility at reconciliation. It's easy to empathize with the character as we've all been there at one point or another. In a lot of ways, Mike leans on an emotional crutch that stunts his growth as an individual. When he separates himself from Trent and builds up the confidence to talk to Lorraine (Heather Graham), a woman he meets at a club, he finds that not only is she responsive to his needs, but that the ability to progress was within him all along. It's easy to understand his sorrow and rationale in his dissonance. It's a story of how to become whole after your other half leaves, how to pick up the pieces, how to survive heartbreak, and perhaps a reminder that no matter how bleak, there's always hope.
3. Lost In Translation (2003)
If Swingers was about being enveloped in the despair of loss and possibility in rekindling relationships, Sofia Coppola's, Lost In Translation is about being within the confines of a safe marriage and still feeling lost. Set in Tokyo, Bob Harris (Bill Murray) is an actor on business who sort of meanders about the city with little to no direction. The line that separates him from truly engaging people is one that is a cultural boundary that makes communication that much more difficult. That line of separation is reflective of his own marriage. Both he and his wife seem very much at a literal and metaphorical distance in their marriage, to the point of where they may as well be separated. His story runs parallel to Charlotte (Scarlett Johansson). Charlotte is an American who's been living in Tokyo for some time with her self-absorbed husband, John (Giovanni Ribisi), who is a photographer very much involved in his work in the entertainment industry, and as a result, is neglectful of Charlotte's needs. Both Bob and Charlotte form a bond born of a mutual sense of disregard and loneliness. What I enjoy most about Lost In Translation is that it doesn't set out to demonize either character for making the decisions they do. In a lot of ways it's about acting on a moment and doing what's right for yourself in a relationship. No one should ever come second or be forced to question the sanctity of marriage from within the relationship itself. Both Bob and Charlotte's actions are justified and while they never fully cross the line, their bond is far more meaningful than a simple friendship. Thematically, it's a very challenging film and goes against any traditional notions of a romance, but in a lot of ways it's very adherent to the idea. Even though some would be hard pressed to not take the leap in a relationship where there are feelings of confinement, Lost In Translation is a reminder that romance and love can exist worlds apart, despite age difference, distance, and status. It's very much a modern romance that can be unsettling to watch, but as the film progresses, you may find that it's very much a reminder of what should take precedence and what is most valued in relationships.
2. Sideways (2004)
Based on the book of the same name, Sideways tells the story of Miles (Paul Giamatti) and Jack (Thomas Haden Church), two college friends embarking upon a road trip through California's wine country before one of them is to be married. While it's Miles' intention to have a good time drinking various wines, Jack has an ulterior motive, that motive being one last sexual escapade before he walks the aisle. With Miles having been out of the game for two years after a divorce, Jack justifies his actions by assuming he can afford his friend the same luxury. Eventually, Miles gives in and plays along as they meet two women and weave a web of deceit and lies. Both Jack and Miles learn a valuable lesson by the film's end. Though their actions are deplorable throughout, the initial plan backfires on them when they actually fall for Maya (Virginia Madsen) and Stephanie (Sandra Oh), the two women whose paths they cross. For Miles, Maya is a big deal and a potential partner. Their interest in wine and literature is what brings them together and makes it easy for them to move past their previous partners. Jack and Stephanie start their relationship off in a more physical manner, but evolves from there, however he has so much more to lose. Eventually, as one would expect, the plan crumbles and they're exposed for who they are and their motives. Both men in the film are in their mid-forties and are seemingly trying to progress in life by adhering to certain social formalities, but in doing so have found that these formalities aren't necessarily conducive to their betterment. Miles is an introvert and terrified of stepping into another marriage because of this, and Jack is just as afraid of commitment. In many ways, the road trip and Jack separating himself from Miles, forces Miles out of his shell and into the arms of someone that genuinely cares for him and that he cares for in turn. Jack, on the other hand, learns the hard way that the facade he's put up would only gain so much mileage. It's an illusion that he could've very well kept up and left his soon to be wife for, but eventually Miles' honesty slips through and shatters any delusions he may have had. It's only in that moment that both men realize their own worth and what could truly be waiting for them if they simply look forward. I think Rex Pickett had written something profound when he released the novel and director Alexander Payne perfectly framed the tone. It's one of the few films that I feel directly tackles the issues of commitment and progressive relationships and manages to capture them in a way that has changed the way we look at modern romantic films. It seems a natural progression in this genre specifically, and it does it so effortlessly.
1. Up In The Air (2009)
Ryan's life consists of all the things we hate about travel. His job has him flying across the United States in order to fire people, thus he hasn't settled and lives out of his carry-on luggage. His world comes crashing down when he's given the news that Natalie (Anna Kendrick), a young hotshot has introduced a new, more cost effective way to go about his job. She's introduced a way Ryan and his fellow agents can fire people from the comfort of their own homes, saving the company millions in travel expenses. In trying to prove a point, Ryan decides to take Natalie along with him to experience a few firings first hand. In their travels Ryan meets Alex (Vera Farmiga), who also travels for her work. They find that they're both similarly turned on by elite status and form a relationship based on that. As the film progresses, both he and Alex become more intimate and closer than he's ever become comfortable with. Ryan even goes so far as to invite Alex to his sister's wedding and the idea of settling down himself seems more viable than he considered possible. In the end, he flies to Chicago to visit Alex and finds that the life she leads at home, isn't exactly what he expected, nor is it what she implied. This film has a lot to do with perception. Often times what one perceives a relationship to be, doesn't necessarily compliment another's perception of what they expect from a relationship. It's a hard lesson learned, but not an uncommon one. The realization that his job is being grounded, puts Ryan in the same position. This grounds him back to reality and forces him to focus on where he's at in his career at his age, and where to take it from there. Through Alex, he finds that she is in fact a key component in living a life more fulfilled. Unfortunately, he comes to find she's already in a relationship and has kids. She saw Ryan as an escape from the everyday, the mundane. Though she misled him, she makes it very apparent that their fling was nothing more. With all of these films in mind, I feel that they not only challenge romantic notions and work outside the genre, but they ultimately make for better films and more well rounded characters. I would argue that there are various facets to romantic relationships and they're not always cut and dry. These films in particular are captivating in that they directly reflect the ideals and perspectives that make relationships so important and lasting. What makes these films so relevant is that they are all as honest and from the heart in their tellings of the modern romance. All of these films break convention in that they don't necessarily lean one way or another despite the actions of certain characters, but they look to express that which is difficult to even begin to gather words for. We've all lost someone important in our lives, we've all felt hung up on someone to the point of obsession, we've all made compromises for others, or felt stuck in a relationship. Everything about every one of these films is relatable and may even strike a chord, but more so than anything, they are honest and all the more endearing for it.