5 Great Directors From 5 Great Filmmaking Nations

John Ford

What defines a "great director"? Not influence; of that I€™m fairly sure, though the broader appeal of a director€”any director, spiritual or commercial€”solely rests on their place in "cinema history." And if it is influence that dictates greatness, Tati most certainly would not be appearing on this list. Whatever the case, this article will determine€”whilst not being restricted to€”some of the greatest directors from some of the greatest filmmaking nations.

5. France €” Jacques Tati

Jacques Tati

I start with the most obscure choice on the list. Jacques Tati. Most would make a case as to why Jean Renoir, Jean Vigo or Jean-Luc Godard should be crowned France€™s GOAT, at least of the pack with forenames beginning with €˜J€™, which I cannot argue. But Jacques has something no other director has ever had before, and what€™s worse is that I cannot explain what it is. Perhaps it€™s that M. Hulot€™s Holiday (1953) was the film that gave birth to modern cinema.

Or perhaps it€™s that watching Playtime (1967) was the single greatest cinematic experience I€™ve ever had. Or, perhaps it€™s simply that Tati, when at his best, contained both best Chaplin sentiment and Altman community. (It might be more useful to consider Tati the director in the company of modernist control-freak auteurs Bresson and Antonioni, who didn't make comedies but created their own worlds.)

Tati only made nine features in his lifetime. One of them, Oscar; champion de tennis (1932) is believed to be lost. For the remaining eight€”Gai Dimanche (1935), L€™‰cole des facteurs (1947), Jour de fête (1949), M. Hulot€™s Holiday, Mon Oncle (1958), Playtime, Traffic (1971), and Parade (1974)€”I confess with great remorse that my acquaintance has been a farce, having only seen them through DVD, laserdisc, and videotape.

The issue of format matters most in the case of Playtime, the only movie Tati shot in 70-millimeter, because although I advocate seeing all of his (or any artist€™s) work in the proper format, Playtime on video is the same as 2001: A Space Odyssey (Stanley Kubrick, 1968) or Lawrence of Arabia (David Lean, 1962) on video: the television monitor cannot possibly suffice.

Details from Tati€™s mise en scène are muted. The spectrum of colour becomes limited. The reduction of a 70mm. presentation to the scale of a television set is similar to reducing the performance of a symphony orchestra to a badly done audiocassette.

As a filmmaker, Tati has recurring themes (the leisure class, modernisation, children at play, mass entertainment), and his compositions seem as mathematically calculated yet spontaneous and vibrant as Welles€™. His movies beg for purveyors of theory to figure them all out for us.

Nothing against the theoreticians, but given a filmography that includes titles like Playtime and Parade, and films that make constant references to having fun, anything short of complete submission to the Tati audio-visual experience carries the risk of revealing oneself to be one of the square, too-serious types that Tati constantly teased: the angry young Socialist in Hulot€™s Holiday, the ultra-precise American in Playtime, and nearly everybody except Hulot and his little nephew in Mon Oncle.


4. Germany €” Fritz Lang

Fritz Lang

Fritz Lang was one of Germany€™s earliest auteurs, having written and directed almost all of his films produced in his home nation. It also becomes apparent€”in some diverged way€”that Lang had control over the writing in his Hollywood productions, too.

To demonstrate this idea, take a good look at Spione (1928) and The Big Heat (1953); both have a potency that disallows what is commonly known as the femme fatale, and, because of this, relish in blissful deceit. It€™s entirely possible that Lang wrought Sydney Boehm€™s screenplay into something less bourgeois than his other commitments to paper, which includes the fraudulent High Wall (1947).

Born in Vienna in 1890, Lang studied architecture and engineering at the Vienna University of Technology before he left in 1913 to study painting in Paris, where he became aware of the new currents. Still the most astonishing cinematic treatment of legends, Lang€™s "Die Nibelugen" saga Siegfried and Kriemheld€™s Revenge (1924) pioneered the mystical grand narrative, producing the link between imagination and human memory. Even Lang€™s now-antique special effects are wondrous in ways that have nothing to do with improved technology and everything to do with artistry.

Lang€™s Metropolis (1927) is the mother and father of all science-fiction. Lang's cut ran over two and a half hours. After its premiere, the movie was trimmed by 40 minutes, then shortened again and re-edited for American release. For 75 years, it has existed as a magnificent ruin. (Commercial cuts acted on Metropolis "as winds, rain, barbarians, etc., do upon classical edifice," Stan Brakhage once observed.)

In a suitably epic archival undertaking, all the surviving material was culled to create a restoration, which represents about 80 percent of Lang's version and returns his narrative structure (reintegrating lost subplots and extending familiar sequences) while it revives the original score.

Like most other spidery aesthetes, Lang encountered problems when refused full artistic control over his pictures. (His acting role in Godard€™s wonderful Le Mépris suggests as much.) M (1931), Lang€™s first "talkie," was almost abandoned before production because Stakken studio denied him a space to shoot it. That, added to the life-threatening pressure from the Nazi party makes M€™s creationa miracle in itself. No less of a feat, then, is it, that M would become one of the most cinematically laborious films of the 20th century.

What perplexes me most about Lang is that he actually garnered more respect in his day than he ever did after it. I could write an entire article listing the influences of these magnificent directors, but has anyone had the ability to charm Alfred Hitchcock, Luis Buñuel and Stanley Kubrick and into filmmaking, other than Lang?


3. Italy €” Michelangelo Antonioni

Michelangelo Antonioni

Of all the directors on this list, Michelangelo Antonioni is the least known. Why is this? I don€™t think it€™d be fair comment to say because his films are the least accessible; that prosthetic title goes to the German. But the films of Michelangelo Antonioni are aesthetically complex€”critically stimulating though elusive in meaning. They are ambiguous works that pose difficult questions and resist simple conclusions.

Classical narrative causalities are dissolved in favour of expressive abstraction. Displaced dramatic action leads to the creation of a stasis occupied by vague feelings, moods and ideas. Confronted with hesitancy, the spectator is compelled to respond imaginatively and independent of the film. The frustration of this experience reflects that felt in the lives of Antonioni€™s characters: unable to solve their own personal mysteries they often disappear, leave, submit or die.

Antonioni€™s greatest achievement in film is L€™Avventura (1960) .Part of what makes L€™Avventura so impressive is that Antonioni developed a cohesion of narrative and stylistic devices that had only haphazardly surfaced in his earlier films.

It might not be too ridiculous to suggest that analogous to some of his characters, Antonioni was searching for something, a method of communication, which he finally "found" with L€™Avventura. That he wouldn€™t let go until he had explored the approach a couple of films further, is retrospectively understandable. The other two in loose trilogy are La Notte (1961), and Eclipse (1962), both equally as profound.


2. Japan €” Yasujir Ozu

The films of Yasujir Ozu examine the basic struggles that we all face in life: the cycles of birth and death, the transition from childhood to adulthood, and the tension between tradition and modernity. Their titles often emphasise the changing of seasons, a symbolic backdrop for the evolving transitions of human experience.

Seen together, Ozu€™s oeuvre amounts to one of the most profound visions of family life in the history of cinema. It is said that his films portray a uniquely contemplative style so rigorously simplistic that it renounces almost all known film grammar.

Frankly, I don€™t know what else to say. So to avoid being tedious, I will say this: I find it absurd that there are supposed cinema lovers out there who have never seen an Ozu film. He is one of the handful of artists€”the others include De Sica, Ray, Bresson, Bergman€”who have the ability to capture the world on film.


1. United States €” Orson Welles

Orson Welles

It€™s strange: of all the cinemas in the world, and despite the fact that of the numerous films I€™ve seen more than half have come from America, this was the easiest decision of the bunch. Yes, you can label me a classicist; you can yak on about Stanley Kubrick or Quentin Tarantino deserving to be there instead; you can even go as far to say I€™m a perverse idiot. Fact is, Orson Welles is America€™s greatest ever director. Heck, I€™m sure even if he made Citizen Kane and gave it up he would head this list.

But he didn€™t, and after Kane Welles gave us five more masterpieces: The Magnificent Ambersons (1942), Touch of Evil (1958), The Trial (1962), Chimes at Midnight (1966), and F for Fake (1974). Now I€™m not going to explain why each of these films deserve such praise, for what I will say about them, collectively, remains much more unnerving.

As a moviegoer, I have to say that Kane is no longer my favourite Orson Welles film (I'd take Ambersons, Chimes at Midnight, or Touch of Evil), but it is still the best place I know of to start thinking about Welles€”or for that matter about movies in general.

It€™s common knowledge that what Griffith created€”The Birth of a Nation (1915), Intolerance (1916), The Love Flower (1920), Orphans of the Storm (1921), et al€”Welles perfected. It€™s even more known, know, that Citizen Kane is the film that has done more to reshape cinema than any other. (As critic Trevor Johnston put it, "seeing it for the first or umpteenth time remains a revelation.") Clearly, no single film is the greatest ever made. But if there were one, for me Kane would now be the strongest contender, bar none.

I digress. To say why Welles is one of the greatest of all directors is actually quite simple. All you have to do is skew Ingmar Bergman€™s quote about Luis Buñuel a little and it becomes clear: "Orson Welles always made Orson Welles films." What I mean by this is that, although Welles encountered tightened studio control after Kane, all his films are, to some extent, just as propelling as one other.

You can definitely call Kane better than Ambersons, or Touch of Evil better than The Trial, but if you evaluate Welles€™ films based on the artistic freedom granted, you can see just how good he really was. I like to think of him as a modern-day version of Atlas.

Are we wrong? Who is the best of the bunch? Let us know in the comments below?


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Godard and Bresson > Spielberg and Tarantino