5 Joaquin Phoenix Films That Are Better Than Joker
Mr J is nowhere near his best...
One of the most divisive films of 2019, Joker’s polarising reputation didn’t stop it from being nominated for 11 Academy Awards, the most for any film at the 2020 Oscars. While few would argue that Joaquin Phoenix doesn’t deserve his first nomination since he played a lonely World War II veteran in 2013 classic The Master, Joker itself is far from a masterpiece.
Although the look of Joker is memorable and the cinematography is lush, the story is told in broad strokes. Subtlety is not Todd Philips forté as the late ‘here’s confirmation that he was imagining it the whole time’ flashback montage reminded everyone watching. Phoenix carried the film on his bony, twisted back - but we would argue that he’s given better performances.
That’s not to take away from Phoenix’s performance in any way, only to say that you have to work with the material that you’re given. Joker isn’t a great movie and Phoenix has been in plenty better. Here’s five that are better pictures than the clown origin story.
5. The Sisters Brothers (2018)
An underrated western that failed at the box office while winning praise from critics, The Sisters Brothers saw Phoenix play the more impetuous of the eponymous hitmen siblings. Set in the wild American West in the mid-19th century, it tells the tale of bounty hunter brothers tasked with tracking down Hermann Kermit Warm, played by Riz Ahmed, for reasons unknown.
Sharing the screen with Reilly, Ahmed, and Jake Gyllenhaal, Phoenix shone in his role as the complex Charlie. Jacques Audiard’s direction ensured that a steady pace is kept for what is part chase movie and part (dark) buddy comedy. It manages to be funny, touching and eye-opening, confronting viewers with the realities of life in this time period.
Reilly steals the show in a trademark cuddly bear role. Despite playing a hired killer, he has higher ideals and wants to better himself, exemplified in the hilarious scene where he acquires a toothbrush and doesn’t quite understand how to use it. Dig out this movie.
4. Gladiator (2000)
Wild historical inaccuracies aside, Ridley Scott’s Gladiator is a stone-cold classic. A Roman epic charting the fall and rise of Russell Crowe’s Maximus Decimus Meridius, it rightly won Best Picture at the Oscars in 2000 (admittedly in a weak year). One of the best things about the film was that it gave Joaquin Phoenix his breakout role, as terrible Roman emperor Commodus.
For any Game of Thrones fans wishing to see what King Joffrey would have been like if he was played by Phoenix, this is as close as you’re going to get. His Oscar-nominated turn as Commodus shares the same violent urges and immature failings, leading him towards a showdown with Crowe’s gladiator slave.
Thor Ragnarok aside, Gladiator was the last truly great gladiator movie. It was full of tremendous scenes of war and the kind of betrayals that make ancient Rome a no-go area when your best friend and you finally complete that time machine project you’ve been working on. Plus, there’s that scene where Maximus says his name, which is a lot cooler than it sounds.
3. You Were Never Really Here (2017)
Another recent gem for this list shows that Joaquin Phoenix is going through another hot streak in his career. You Were Never Really Here sees him playing Joe, a gun for hire who specialises in rescuing trafficked girls from their captors. A man who is prepared to go to brutally violent means to complete his job, Joe bites off more than he can chew when he’s discreetly hired by a New York State Senator to recover his daughter without alerting the media.
Another wonderful psychological thriller by Lynne Ramsey, You Were Never Really Here is a gripping high-stakes venture into a seedy underworld that is the stuff of nightmares. A film that silently asks conspiratorial questions and quietly chews on them, what it lacks in dialogue it makes up for in pulsating action with Phoenix at the heart of every swing of a hammer.
It’s another role that Phoenix allows himself to be immersed. He gained a hefty amount of weight as he felt the character, who is a military veteran, would have let himself go as middle age crept in. While the physical transformation is eye-catching, the way Phoenix uses his physicality in more impressive, making Joe look like a skulking avenger.
2. Her (2013)
One of the best films of 2013, Her reminded people that they didn’t have to be in love with their operating system to find a movie about a man falling in love with his OS romantic. Phoenix has rarely played as sweet a character as the wonderfully-named Theodore Twombly. A vulnerable divorcee in future LA, Theodore finds love again when he gets a virtual assistant, Samantha, bolstered with artificial intelligence, voiced to charming perfection by Scarlett Johansson.
A visionary work by Spike Jones, Her showcases his best directorial qualities. It takes an absurd premise and makes it seem plausible and compelling. It’s impossible not to become emotionally invested in Theodore’s new relationship with Samantha. The idea of a man falling in love with a computer sounds like a horror plot, instead, it’s a sweet romantic-drama that touches your heart.
It’s a shame that we haven’t seen Phoenix in a similar role since. Her demonstrates his ability to play a convincing romantic lead when unburdened of his usually psychological baggage.
1. The Master (2012)
The best movie of Phoenix’s career featured his best performance to date.
The Master saw Phoenix star as veteran Freddy Quell who becomes indoctrinated in the "teachings" of cult leader named Lancaster Dodd (played by the late Philip Seymour Hoffman) and dangerously committed to The Cause.
Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson, the film offers a parallel to the real world and it’s not hard to guess that Dodd’s character is based on Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard.
Hoffman is incredible as the scarily convincing conman who bullsh*ts with enough conviction to win over almost any doubter. It’s a tour de force of acting with Phoenix’s perma-sneering paranoid Quell being a wonderful counterpoint to the outwardly composed preying false deity that Hoffman claims to be.
A film that features Phoenix’s most grounded lunatic, The Master is a superb portrait of the mechanics of a cult and how it can exploit the most at-risk members of society. For all that Joker has to offer, nothing in it comes close to the ‘processing’ scene in The Master. But, to be fair to Todd Philips, not many films can compete with one of the 21st century’s great films.