5 Justice League Problems Aquaman's First Trailer DIDN'T Fix

WAHOOOOOOOOOO. Stop it.

AQUAMAN Stop
Warner Bros.

Let's just get one thing straight immediately, the Comic Con trailer for Aquaman did a lot to turn the hype dial up. It looks epic and weird and entertaining - owing a lot more to Wonder Woman than to the comparatively disastrous Justice League. Or at least we can hope so, anyway.

But that doesn't mean there aren't some niggling issues with it that might raise some red flags for fans who wantr nothing more than for it to succeed. Perhaps it's because of the fact that it's still part of the DCEU, but Aquaman still does feel like it's tied to Justice League a little more than we should be comfortable with.

And while there's something to be said for creative continuity, if you're anchoring something to a bad thing, you're not giving it the best head start. So it's well worth exploring the ways that first trailer suggests Aquaman might not have quite got over the issues presented by Justice League...

5. The Colour Palette

Aquaman Trench
Warner Bros.

Seriously, what is it with Warner Bros, the DCEU and the colour red at the moment? Justice League's finale was ruined aesthetically by the incredibly stupid idea to paint the sky red and it looks like they're still banging that same artistic drum on that front, particularly in the battle sequences.

As if we couldn't figure out the baddies for ourselves, James Wan seems to have gone with the same Justice League convention of highlighting villains with red, and punctuating dangerous moments with it too. It's like he (and Snyder and Whedon before him) are trying to pull an M Night Shyamalan, only with far less subtlety than he did in The Sixth Sense.

You'd think Wan would resist anything that drew immediate comparisons to Justice League, but here we are.


4. The Jarring Jokes

Aquaman Goat
Warner Bros.

Justice League might have NEEDED a little levity to drag the entire DCEU out of the grumpy doldrums that Man Of Steel and (particularly) Batman v Superman had dumped it in, but it was a particularly divisive element for some fans. And it really didn't help that some of the jokes stuck out like a sore thumb as having been added later by Joss Whedon to lighten things up.

Jokes are fine and levity is fine when it's organically built into the script and isn't cynically designed for cheap thrills, but when it's not built in properly, it feels poorly conceived. Like Aquaman and Bruce Wayne's exchange in Justice League, for instance...

Arthur Curry: "Strong man is strongest alone." You ever heard of that?Bruce Wayne: That's not a saying. That's the opposite of what the saying is.

And unfortunately, it looks like it's happening again. That "that was the worst pep talk, like EVER" line is very much from the same school of writing, and while some will have been delighted by it, the goat reaction shot from the very end of the trailer is just awfully jarring.


3. SOME Ropey Effects Work

Aquaman Shark
Warner Bros.

There's no suggestion that the effects build in the trailer will end up being the final version released with the film (in fact, that would be incredibly odd and entirely against tradition), but considering Justice League had such big issues with CGI, you'd think that Warner Bros would have been SUPER cautious about showing too much that might attract criticism.

And yet, some of the sequences in there definitely look incomplete and the ropey CGI has already been brought up by commenters. It's forgivable to a certain extent, because lots of people will be happy to accept that it's early effects work, but without that disclaimer, more casual audience members wouldn't know. And they're running the risk of that impression being a lasting one with those fans.

Why not just be more artful and hide it for now?


2. It's Still Too Dark At Times

Aquaman Sea
Warner Bros.

For most of the action scenes - the same ones that have too much red in them - it looks like James Wan has gone with the prevailing DCEU aesthetic of turning all of the lights off.

This might make things more dramatic (which seems to be the logic of the franchise's approach), and it might at least fit with the idea of the shared universe being tied together by artistic decisions, but it's just unnecessary.

Look at how stunning the Atlantis introduction in the trailer looks - it has the same immediate impact as Pandora's first appearance in Avatar - and there are enough organic light sources to suggest it should still be lit up at night. So why when there's a battle has everything suddenly gone all grim and grubby? Let's hope it's not just a cynical ploy to hide all the CGI...


1. The Screaming Dude-Bro

Aquaman Arthur
Warner Bros.

Why does Aquaman have to scream like a hollering banshee? Why does he have to shout "bad-ass" like an action figure you pull the string of? What's with the a-whooping and a-hollering just generally? It's incredibly annoying and suggests things about Arthur that simply don't fit his backstory.

He's supposed to have chosen to look after Amnesty Bay because nobody else would and because it suited his desire for anonymity (presumably) and yet he walks around shrieking like the douchebag captain of the LaCrosse team. It's not right and it's not welcome.

Luckily, Warner Bros still have a lot to count on for this to work, because Jason Momoa is incredibly charismatic and he looks the part. If there's anyone who will help the issues be a little more forgivable, it's him.

What did you think of the Aquaman trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.

Read Next: Aquaman Trailer Reactions: 6 Ups & 3 Downs


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.