5 Mistakes That Will Burst Marvel Cinematic Properties' Bubble

We list the pitfalls that could lead to the potential failure of Hollywood's biggest success of the 21st Century, the super-hero movie.

It's no secret that since the success of Marvel's The Avengers studios are looking to rollout intricate schemes to be more like Disney's cash cow. DC made headlines by signing up Batfleck to play alongside Superman in their next film, X-Men: Days of Future Past looks to rally all of the Marvel characters that 20th Century Fox legally owns together, and Sony's Spider-Man movies are going to be paired with movies detailing the Sinister Six and Venom. And let's face it, audiences by and large are asking for it. The Avengers made $1.5 billion, and the widespread enthusiasm surrounding Days of Future Past adds fuel to the fire that franchise tie-ins sparked. With the increased prevalence of these "tent-pole" pictures, and with seemingly thousands of $100 million-plus films coming out in 2015, the success of one film is going to be connected to the success of the other closely connected films in the respective franchises. There are obviously savvy people working at Marvel, and they have had their fingers firmly on the pulse of the general public, but their more recently announced strategies seem to be leading them on a crash-course to market failure. This list is ultimately speculative because none of the movies or TV shows discussed in this article have come out yet. But Marvel and Marvel property-holders have come to rely on fan speculation in order to keep excitement high, so why not examine what could lead to the potential failure of Hollywood's biggest success of the 21st Century, the super-hero movie.

5. Marvel's Netflix Showsnetflix-vpncreative

For those who haven't caught up on the news, Netflix will be releasing four series based on characters on Marvel's roster: Daredevil (the first show starting in 2015), Jessica Jones, Iron Fist, and Luke Cage. There will also be a miniseries on The Defenders to run alongside the already hectic roster of small-screen vigilantes. Getting more under-appreciated yet loved characters out there can't be that bad of an idea, right? Drew Goddard, who co-wrote and directed the Whedon-branded film Cabin in the Woods, is even signed on to helm the Daredevil series. So why are these series a mistake for Marvel? Well, have you seen Marvel's Agents of Shield? What could have been a fun, Gotham Central-esque exploration of the non-super goings on of a superhero universe ultimately lacks the zip of the movies not only because it isn't written very well but also because it doesn't have the production values audiences have come to expect. We love to complain about the overuse of CGI and 3D, but a movie like Thor couldn't have even been made twenty years ago. Sure, Daredevil and Luke Cage aren't going to need the same special effects that it takes to make Iron Man fly or Hulk smash, but limited budgets and superheroes don't mix. Seeing clumsy choreography in a fight scene between Matt Murdock and the Masked Marauder is going to limit our enjoyment of the show, even if it is accompanied by witty dialogue. Furthermore, it seems the plan is to use Netflix as a sort of farm system for Marvel properties. If Daredevil does well on the internet, they might expand him into the cinematic universe and get him to team up with the Avengers in the big leagues. The problem with this strategy is that it makes it essential that viewers participate in every facet of their ever-expanding list of media. While a certain amount of people are going to watch the show simply because it includes Daredevil (i.e. true blue Marvel fanboys) the aforementioned limited budget is also going to limit its audience. The reliance on constantly digging deeper for more and more characters makes the now palatable experience of being familiar with each of the core players of the films an essentially untenable prospect for any casual viewer, the people that Disney needs the most to pay for movie tickets.

4. Sony's Spider-Man Plan

As I mentioned in the opening, Sony (the company that owns the cinematic rights to Spider-Man) is focusing on making multiple movies in the franchise, even if Peter Parker isn't the main character in them. Movies on the Sinister Six and Venom are coming because Sony doesn't have the expansive character roster that Marvel/Disney, Warner Bros./DC, or even 20th Century Fox/X-Men have. And like Marvel's Netflix plan, this isn't just going to cause superhero over-saturation, it is going to hurt the product. Peter Parker became one of the most beloved superheroes precisely because he was an average kid in extraordinary circumstances. Sure, he could fight and climb up walls, but what drew audiences to him was that he is relatable. The best parts of The Amazing Spider-Man (which I really enjoyed) weren't when he was spraying New York with anti-lizard (actual plot) but when he was traversing the dangerous realm of high school relationships with Gwen Stacy. Like I said, audiences have come to expect top-notch production values with superhero movies, but they also want something more. And shoving every villain imaginable into each movie, each with their own backstory, draws away from poor Peter Parker, a.k.a why we watch in the first place. As much as Venom needs a reboot after Spider-Man 3, ignoring what makes Spider-Man interesting in favor of laying out a business plan makes the direction Sony is heading in unsettling.

3. High-Risk Business Means Low-Risk Filmmaking

Movie-making is complicated. Seeing any credit scroll, particularly credits for a big-budget, include a wide array of trained professionals working together to make a movie. When Marvel connected their respective franchises together, they took a complicated process of producing a movie/product and made it significantly more complicated. And in Phase One, as it is called now, this complication added to the fun of actually watching the movies. When you saw The Avengers, you had probably seen at least a couple of Marvel's previous efforts, and watching them team up was exciting in and of itself. But now we know that this crazy idea can work. So what is going to keep the idea of rallying superheroes together fun and new? The rest of this section includes SPOILERS for both Thor: The Dark World (which you probably should have seen by now) and The Avengers (which you definitely should have seen by now) so if you haven't gotten that far yet just skip to the next section. When Tony Stark crosses back through the wormhole in The Avengers, he is supposed to be dead. We get the scene where the rest of the team rallies around their leader and briefly mourns his death, but the audience knows better. Robert Downey Jr. and Iron Man were going to be back for Iron Man 3 the following year. What is supposed to be a dramatic (and theoretically surprising) scene is ultimately made absurd by the predictability of the moment: Tony Stark is going to come back to life. That being said, the movie handles the situation humorously, with the Hulk literally scaring Iron Man back to life, but it hints at the central problem Marvel faces from a narrative standpoint: how can you keep the stakes high if you know every central character has multi-picture deals? Thor 2 skirts around this issue on multiple occasions. When I watched Thor get his hand taken off by Loki I initially thought, "Wow, they're going full Empire Strikes Back here. This is interesting, I wonder what's going to happen to Thor from here on out." But that feeling of actual surprise was shot almost immediately when it was revealed that it was all a hologram, or something like it. When Loki appears to die shortly thereafter, it was plain to see that the audience was being tricked yet again. Of course they're not going to get rid of their most appealing villain, why would they? But repeatedly putting characters in danger without any real chance of peril has diminishing returns. Say what you will about The Dark Knight Rises, but fans could be legitimately concerned about the Caped Crusader's fate in that film. But Chris Hemsworth and Tom Hiddleston are going to be around in Marvel movies for a long time, they are proven to be bankable. So the question becomes: How can characters progress if they are contractually obligated to stay the same to appeal to audiences?

2. Go Big Or Go BiggerMarvel-Cinematic-Universe-P

In order to keep audiences interested, sequels are usually touted as being bigger and with higher stakes. How many commercials have you seen with the tagline being "Character X faces his/her biggest challenge yet..."? Marvel has averted this problem so far by keeping the antagonists of each film specific to a particular character's backstory. But after the world has been placed in danger in each of the films (and after The Avengers destroyed most of New York City), they've run out of real estate to threaten. Marvel has decided to go big in other ways, by introducing more and more characters into the fold and by making the universe even more sprawling and unwieldy. This makes sense in a way, if each team-up includes new members the dynamic will change slightly and there will potentially be more tension to exploit. However, after a certain point, too many protagonists means the same thing as too many villains, and Spiderman 3 proves that there is definitely such a thing as too many villains. This ties back to Sony's plan to have a movie based on the Sinister Six, it's like they haven't even watched the movies they just rebooted. Having the Avengers team up in comic books allows their respective storylines to ebb and flow over the course of several issues, putting all of that together in Avengers 3 and beyond is going to be exceedingly difficult. Having an expanded universe also throws a wrench into any individual storyline, as in "Why didn't Tony just call Bruce Banner to get him to punch Aldrich Killian in the face?" If each stand-alone story is supposed to carry the same weight as the team-ups, why don't they always team up for their big adventures? It's a question that has been plaguing comic books for years, and the absence of this idea is also largely what made Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight series so fresh. If this seems nit-picky it's because it is, but when everyone picks at the same scab it's only going to get worse. The casual movie-goer is going to think that Captain America could really use a helping hand from a certain billionaire playboy philanthropist until he finds the strength to save the day all by himself. Making the movies stakes high from the get-go means that Marvel has backed itself into a creative corner.

1. One Weak Link Can Break the Chain

This is undoubtedly the biggest problem that Marvel's strategy poses. Since all of the movies are inherently tied together, if one movie or superhero fails the entire franchise can be brought down. Its possible that one of their pre-existing franchises stops working for whatever reason, but the more likely outcome is that one of the new heroes spoils the brand for everyone else. Fans can point out that X-Men Origins: Wolverine didn't foil 20th Century Fox's plans for a full-on press of X-Men films, including more Wolverine films, but Wolverine was already an iconic character at the time. Disappointing returns for Superman Returns wasn't going to stop Warner Bros. from rebooting Superman, but if Gal Godot doesn't work out as Wonder Woman in Batman vs. Superman (title pending), fans could be waiting a long time for that character to reappear. This could easily happen with one of the new Marvel properties. I don't think Ant-Man is going to be the straw that breaks the camel's back, Edgar Wright has a very strong track record and this appears to be the rare combination of big-budget production and passion project, but Guardians of the Galaxy could prove to be disappointing. We already know that the MacGuffin for Marvel's next phase is going to be found in that film, and if it fails to connect with audiences that could mean that most of the people interested in seeing the second Avengers film would go in blind. When you build a franchise around several $200 million plus films, you need every possible person to buy a ticket to your movie in order to be successful. And if less people decide to keep coming back because they were soured off the brand by the previous film, it makes the entire process difficult to navigate. Look, Marvel has had an incredibly good track record up to this point. All of their movies have been entertaining, and some have even been great. But their insistence on embarking (and then proceeding to double-down) on one of the boldest business strategies from a franchising perspective in film history is going to have an adverse impact on their films. If they don't produce great films, they are in serious trouble.

Contributor

Bryan Hickman is a WhatCulture contributor residing in Vancouver, British Columbia. Bryan's passions include film, television, basketball, and writing about himself in the third person.