Movies about teachers are a dime a dozen. Every year the moviegoing public is treated to some flick or another about a hard-nosed educator that is just trying to reach these kids. They can range anywhere from academically astute to criminally incompetent, though we are often meant to be inspired by the courageous actions of these (mostly) fictional characters regardless. Today, well examine the lives of five educators who, within the world of their respective scripts, are considered outstanding contributors to the development of Americas youth. Unfortunately, the outlooks of Americas brightest seem a bit dimmer with these teachers at the helm. NOTE: Any criticism listed in this article only pertains to the fictional characters represented in their respective films.
5. LouAnne Johnson - Dangerous Minds
What makes her a good educator? Former U.S. Marine LouAnne Johnson, armed with a masters degree in English, fought her toughest battles in the classroom. It was no easy task to teach the academy classes at Parkmont High School. The task was all the more unenviable when Johnson accepted the position, her first, during the middle of a school year. Despite an overwhelming sense of apathy brooding at Parkmont, Johnsons tenaciousness and dedication to her students outside the classroom would eventually lead to their respect, trust, and love inside of the classroom. What makes her an awful educator? The film depicts several scenes from a spring semester in the mid-90s. The only academic content covered during that time was poetry. In fact, the students only ever seem to dissect either Bob Dylan or Dylan Thomas, and at no point are they ever asked to move beyond oral recitation and commentary. Johnsons questions are mostly answered by Emilio, Raul, or Callie, with the other students falling into agreement soon after. She never even attempted to appeal to different modalities of teaching. Visual, kinesthetic, and tactile learners were marginalized in her classroom. It would be impossible to talk about Dangerous Minds without mentioning the scene where Johnson took her entire class to a theme park during school hours. This was supposed to make us admire the heart of Johnson, though any member of the schools administration must have come to the conclusion that she essentially committed 30 acts of kidnapping. On top of that little problem, one cannot help but wonder what became of her other classes that day? The students of Parkmont clearly articulate abandonment issues at various points of the film. How did those other periods feel being left alone while their teacher illegally took her favorite class out for cotton candy?
4. Jaime Escalante - Stand And Deliver
What makes him a good educator? Jaime Escalante was a dedicated teacher of mathematics at Garfield High School in East Los Angeles. With Escalantes determination and guidance, Garfield went from a school on the brink of losing its accreditation to representing 27 percent of all Mexican Americans who scored a 3 or higher on the AP calculus exam. His students demonstrated such tremendous development that an investigation by the Educational Testing Service was called to ensure Escalantes classes werent cheating. The students were asked to retake the exam and again succeeded, giving Escalante and his students both respect and renown. What makes him an awful educator? At the beginning of the film, Escalante challenged his students to participate in showy lessons that resembled theatre as much as remedial mathematics. When one student, a young girl, replied with a correct answer, Escalante whispered, Is it true intelligent people make better lovers? Sexual harassment, especially followed by a wink and a smile, isnt exactly what I expect in a movie about an inspirational teacher. When he wasnt whispering inappropriate things to young girls in his class, you could be assured that Escalante was walking around somewhere with his hands down his pants. The fact that nobody ever commented on it in the film is a testament to how little attention was paid in the day-to-day happenings at Garfield. It is no wonder the school was in such poor shape to begin with. If that wasnt enough, Escalantes first interaction with a challenging student, Angel, ended with Escalante threatening to snap the boys neck like a tooth pick. With all of his machismo posturing, Escalante is lucky that he didnt escalate the verbal confrontation to a physical altercation. Real Teacher of the Year material.
3. Joe Clark - Lean On Me
What made him a good educator? Classrooms are at their most effective when intelligent discourse is occurring and all parties are actively involved. At the opening of Lean on Me, Joe Clarks classroom was depicted as the model for student involvement and active learning. Students participated in a relay race; first to ring the bell at the front of the room could answer a U.S. government question for +10 points. Clarks jovial attitude and frantic game-style review created a palpable sense of fun and spontaneity that kept every student engaged. Students and fellow faculty couldnt help but beam admiration from their faces. What made him a bad educator? Joe Clarks move from teacher to principal felt more like a hostile takeover than a promotion. In his first day as head administrator of Eastside High School, Clark expelled over 100 students on stage at a school assembly. Not content with his first show of power, Clark then threatened to expel any student who did not meet the Basic Skills Test requirements by the end of the term. This method of clearing the books in order to juke a schools stats is hardly new. It isnt solving a problem, simply renegotiating the terms. Clarks worst offenses occurred when he dragged freshman Thomas Sams to the roof the school in an attempt to scare him straight. He proceeded to jam his finger into the side of Sams head repeatedly, shouted swears in his face, and then insisted that the boy jump off the roof and kill himself. The behavior is cruel and borderline sociopathic. It should come as no surprise when, toward the end of the film, Clark was arrested for literally chaining all of the doors in the school shut to prevent ditching. When Clark inquires about the charge of his arrest, the Chief of Police replied that it was definitely a fire code violation, but also mostly for being an a$$hole.
2. John Keating - Dead Poets Society
What made him a good educator? It is no small miracle that John Keating made it past the interview process before reporting for assignment at Welton Academy. It would be easy to imagine that Keating had been duplicitous during the hiring process if he werent so damned honest. Keatings teaching method largely depended on transparency. He was open and honest with his students, and he expected the same of them. Through a series of trust-building exercises, Keating was able to free many of his students from emotional barriers that had stunted them in the past, particularly with regards to poetry. Over the course of the film, Keatings lyrical explorations of Whitman, Thoreau, and Tennyson encourage the boys to seize the day. What made him a bad educator? John Keating is, in part, responsible for the suicide of star-student Neil Perry. Many viewers are too quick to absolve Keating for his involvement in the tragedy. Its true that Neils father deserves the brunt of blame for his constant bullying, but Keating gives Neil imperfect advice on how to deal with the problem in the first place. Keating insists that the only way to solve Neils domestic issue is to meet it head on. This might be fine advice for a boy with more chutzpah, but Neil is a meek and insecure fellow that often feels paralyzed when confronted by choice. When Neil was unable to articulate his feelings directly to his father, he surely remembered Keetings insistence that that had been the only way to solve his problem. To Neils overwhelmed teenage mind, suicide was the only remaining alternative. Perhaps Mr. Keating should have conveyed the full breadth of Neils options. Neil was less than a year away from graduating. Keating could have advised him to apply to arts colleges without his fathers knowing, or sought to help him find a job that might allow him to gain financial independence from his father. In a matter of weeks he would have been legally free from his parents influence. Keating telling Neil that his only option was to confront his domineering father or live with an unbearable pain wasnt just an incorrect assessment of the situation, it was fatal.
1. Jim McAllister - Election
What makes him a good educator? Jim McAllister was the paragon of excellence at George Washington Carver High School in Omaha, Nebraska. He was regularly involved in school demonstrations, dutifully attended every football game, and was quick to lend a hand when any student needed counseling. For his contributions to the development of the student body, Mr. McAllister had been awarded Teacher of the Year a record three times. In his own words, What I do remember is that I loved my job. I was a teacher. An educator. And I think I made a difference. What makes him an awful educator? Jim McAllister knew that his best friend and fellow teacher, Dave Novotny, was having a sexual relationship with junior Tracy Flick. The average high school junior is around 16 years old, which makes their relationship not just immoral, but illegal. As a mandated reporter of child abuse and neglect, Jim McAllister was well aware of proper protocol, and instead chose to ignore the statutory rape of Tracy Flick. In Nebraska, such negligence can result jail time, fines, and the loss of both his job and teaching credential. How, exactly, could a teacher of law and ethics have ignored such a crime? It is tough to say, as the movie doesnt seem to be particularly concerned with McAllisters negligence. The overall story more or less follows his descent into poor decision-making, but the revelation about Novotny and Flick occurs at the beginning of the film when we still view McAllister as a good, upstanding teacher. His decision to ignore the misconduct committed by Novotny calls into question his moral ability to be an educator, as well as his understanding of the very academic content he is expected to teach.