5 Movie Flops That Blamed Piracy

Was piracy really to blame?

Expendables 3 The Expendables 3 leaked online prior to its blockbuster release and the studio is blaming the film opening $10 million lower than expected on piracy. While that's debatable, it's not the first time studios have used the bogeyman that is piracy as a scapegoat for a film's poor performance. Want to know what movies have used this excuse for their weak openings or overall box office failure? Read on. Piracy isn't new - it's not even close to new. Video game piracy dates back to the 70s, when games were traded by mail and at disk swapping parties, then the 80s and 90s allowed this to be done remotely, first via BBS systems and then by the internet. The creation of the MP3 format in 1998 spawned online music piracy and sparked birth of file sharing networks - something the record industry continually blames for decreased sales, rather than tepid modern acts who fail to capture audience's attention the way artists of old did. The then came movie piracy. Long considered impractical due to the size of video file formats, better codecs and faster broadband internet speeds resulted in just about anyone being able to download a movie anywhere. Movie studios soon started to sing the same tune as the music industry, blaming piracy for its woes. Is piracy to blame for lost profits in Hollywood? That's a tough question. Worldwide, this is yet another year that is looking to be a stellar one for tinsel town, though profits are down a little in the U.S. without a franchise like The Avengers around this season to boost ticket sales. Nevertheless, globally, and in the U.S. as well, business is booming. Lets take a look, however, at five movies that blamed piracy for their woes, right or wrong.

5. Zombieland

Disclaimer: Zombieland cannot be considered a flop. However, despite the fact that the surprise cult hit Zombieland (2009) made back over four times its budget during its initial run alone, its studio still griped about piracy impacting its bottom line, and its director pointed at its popularity on file sharing sites as a reason a sequel wouldn't be greenlit. Here's what director Rhett Reese had to say about the matter on Twitter back when the film came out: "Zombieland currently the most pirated movie on bit torrent. Over one million downloads and counting. Beyond depressing. This greatly affects the likelihood of a Zombieland 2." Lets be extremely clear here: Piracy had zero to do with a sequel to Zombieland not happening. The movie made back its budget and then some. Worldwide, Zombieland grossed $102 million dollars U.S. on a $23 million dollar budget. Even accounting for its advertising campaign, it was a very profitable little movie for Columbia Pictures/Sony (who distributed the film). That does not count DVD/Blu-Ray sales, legitimate downloadable copies of the movie purchased from online stores, VOD and Pay-per-View revenue, and merchandise - Zombieland toys, t-shirts, and the like. Realistically all that probably doubled the film's total revenue. So why didn't a sequel happen if it wasn't piracy? The careers of all those involved took off. Emma Stone wound up part of the Spider-Man franchise and became Hollywood's "it" girl of the last few years. Abigail Breslin got busy doing movies like Rango and Ender's Game (plus, she grew up, and her window of playing a young girl was pretty much over after Zombieland anyway). Jesse Eisenberg wound up a big star thanks to The Social Network and has since joined Batman vs. Superman, and Woody Harrelson joined the heir apparent to the Twilight franchise in tween blockbusters, The Hunger Games. Zombieland was a perfect storm of the right actors all coming together at a right time, but everyone has just been too busy in the past five years to make another go of it. The property was shopped around as a TV series and picked up as a pilot by Amazon, but they opted not to greenlight it as a full series (thankfully, as the show had the same characters as the movie recast, and had fans in an uproar).

4. The Hulk

Ang Lee's version of The Hulk (2003) saw an incomplete workprint of the movie leak online - a copy of the film that featured unfinished special effects including the Hulk not being fully finished, and missing pants in some scenes. So of course, piracy was to blame for the film flopping, right? And despite a worldwide take of over $200 million dollars, make no mistake - this film was a bomb. Until recent years, that leak - which took place weeks before the film's intended release - was considered the biggest film leak in Hollywood history. A couple of important facts: one, given it was an unfinished copy of the movie, it was clearly leaked by someone inside the production. A mole, if you will. Groups that specialize in piracy (who generally do it for bragging rights, as there's no money involved in most cases) love insiders like this. So to some extent, Hollywood had themselves to blame (this is not the only time this has happened). Second, the movie just wasn't very good. And there's the real problem. When movie studios decried the piracy of The Hulk and the industry blamed its perceived failure as a result of its leak online, they were right - for all the wrong reasons. It wasn't that people were downloading The Hulk instead of going to see it in theatres, it's that due to poor reviews from nearly everyone who had seen the film, most notably comic book fans who watched the leaked copy early, the word of mouth for the film was terrible, and no one wanted to spend the money to see it. Ain't It Cool News, at the time the be-all and end-all of movie news sites, slammed the film, with Moriaty (Drew McWeeny, who now runs HitFlix) stating that the Hulk in that print of the film simply wasn't believable. Major publications such as People Magazine then picked up the story, quoting the AICN story. Had Ang Lee made the movie comic book fans wanted, things might have ended different. What was so bad about The Hulk? For one, there was very little smashing in the movie; it focused on the human elements of the character, something that shouldn't have been surprising given it was directed by Ang Lee. It was dull in places, and while it wasn't particularly bad, when it did try to go comic-y it too often got it wrong (think about the Hulked out dogs, for example). Even without the piracy of the movie, this likely would have been the case. The Hulk just wasn't the movie fans wanted. Take this tidbit posted on StraightDope back in 2003 before the movie leaked: "The Hulk himself looks like someone took a bag of jello and beat it against a ceiling fan." - skaterboarder87 A quick Google search of the film back then will lead you to plenty of fans hemming and hawing about the flick leading up to its release, and after word got out - well it was just a disaster. The movie had a $60 million opening, but died off quickly in subsequent weeks.

3. The Expendables 3

The third film in the franchise had the lowest opening weekend of the series to date, $15 million dollars, and the studio and Hollywood insiders have broken out the piracy excuse - but is that really the case? This example is a little tricky because The Expendables 3 leaked online weeks in advance of its release, and in high quality. Which meant that anyone who wanted to watch the film could, in the comfort of their own homes without having to worry about inflated ticket prices and theatres crowded with ignorant cell phone users and chit-chatters. As a result, the studio blaming it on piracy isn't all that far-fetched, however, there are a couple of points to consider: One, The Expendables 2 simply wasn't as good as the first one, and the franchise opted not to release an instalment last year, meaning the last memory we have of the franchise was a luke-warm outing (aside from Jean-Claude Van Damme who was fantastic). Second, the movie was released too close to Guardians of the Galaxy and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. To make a simple comparison, in 2012 The Expendables 2 was released against the animated kids flick ParaNorman, the music drama Sparkle, and The Odd Life of Timothy Green - not films that would remotely eat into its revenue. And The Expendables 2 had already dropped from the first movie, profit-wise - meaning it wasn't a franchise on the rise. Third, the inclusion of "new" expendables in the movie didn't do much for anyone, at least on paper (in the film, they're just sort of there as a plot device, and none but Ronda Rousey even stand out). So here's where we are at: The Expendables 3 is actually arguably the best in the series. Wesley Snipes, Harrison Ford, Kelsey Grammer, Antonion Bandaras, and Mel Gibson are all fantastic additions to the cast, and the film is a much more watchable movie than the second one. It holds up to the first, and is one of the best action movies in the last couple of years - and no one is seeing it. Because of piracy? That's the company line, but poor scheduling is just as much to blame.

2. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

Bad buzz due to the early leak of X-Men Origins: Wolverine not doubt hurt the film's bottom line - but the leak of the film could easily have had the opposite effect. X-Men Origins: Wolverine is possibly the worst film in the X-Men franchise, and that's saying a lot when you have a movie as bad as the Brett "For the Love of God Don't Let Him Anywhere Near a Movie Ever Again" Ratner-directed X-Men: Last Stand (a.k.a. X-Men 3, the one where they kill off a bunch of major characters for no good reason and screwed up comic book continuity). Origins is the movie that destroyed the character of Deadpool, for starters, and was so bad that was basically forgotten about in The Wolverine and retconned out of existence in X-Men: Days of Future Past. Studios blamed piracy for the film bombing of course - but the bad word of mouth hurt it more than anything. The workprint of the film that leaked had some unfinished effects, different fonts on the titles and credits, and alternate sound effects (generally temp stuff), but was not significantly different from the finished product, despite the studio's claim that it would be. The fact that the movie was downright terrible spread like wildfire, and the leak of the film came out a full month before the film hit U.S. cinemas. Imagine how, had Gavin Hood produced a good Wolverine movie, things might have been different. Imagine if good word of mouth got around. The producers of Game of Thrones on TV have acknowledged that piracy doesn't even really both them, because they show is such a critical success that people order the Blu-Ray sets and tune to HBO in droves to watch it anyway. Had X-Men Origins: Wolverine been any good, FOX would have saved itself a lot of embarrassment. The film leaking had nothing to do with the fact that it sucked.

1. The Hurt Locker

hurtlocker (1) The absolute poster boy for how not to conduct business in Hollywood, and how to alienate fans, The Hurt Locker is a title that was critically acclaimed yet is now publicly reviled in some circles for the way in which the studio behind it conducted its business. First off, the history. Though released in some territories in 2008, by 2009 the film hadn't touched the U.S. market, and upon its release there that year, it became eligible for the 82 annual Academy Awards. Starring Jeremy Renner, and telling the story of a bomb disposal unit in Iraq, by the time the awards rolled around, it hadn't even made back its budget. Frankly, no one was really interested in the movie. Critics gave it strong reviews, but it was panned by those with actual military experience for the most part. Not making money back theatrically is not unusual for smaller movies. They're looking for home video sales to make the difference, plus award nominations. The boost in ticket sales from being nominated by the Oscar's can be huge, and the Hurt Locker lucked out in that regard, so the film was looking at an up-tick in sales once the nominations came out. The fact that it went on to win Best Director, Best Picture, and Best Original Screenplay greatly boosted its profile - but it was still far from a box office smash. In the end, it would make back more than triple its $15 million budget - an admirable take for a small film. On top of that, it would pull in another $30 million in home video sales. However, producers weren't satisfied. They blamed piracy for the failure of a movie with limited appeal (American-made war movies don't draw overseas, and in 2009 the U.S. was already weary of anything to do with the Iraq war). Clearly, they argued, it wasn't the quality of the film - look how many awards it had won! And so piracy was once again to blame, and Voltage Pictures, forever damning their name in the eyes of movie geeks, decided to sue people who had downloaded the movie - by the thousands. These sorts of bulk cases had been primarily the domain of music companies in the past, and feature strong arm tactics and "settlement hotlines" - in essence, a firm representing the studio contacts an alleged copyright infringer, scares them with big numbers (movie and music companies have been known to ask for hundreds of thousands of dollars in damages against defendants accused of downloading a single work), then directs them to call a settlement hotline where they can agree to pay a much smaller fee (usually in the thousands). In the U.S. this is somehow legal, though it would be considered blackmail in other nations, and either way is an abuse of the legal system. In the case of Voltage Pictures, they demanded $1,500 from each of 5,000 bit torrent users accused of downloading the movie, and when they met resistance, they expanded their campaign to other countries, including Canada, where their demand to uncover subscriber information from ISPs actually led to changes in Canadian copyright law (downloading movies, and making them available to download, had for a long time been kosher given a legal loophole in the country due to taxes paid on blank media that are turned over to the entertainment industry to offset the perceived costs of piracy). It got messier. The problem with these sorts of lawsuits are that innocent people often get caught in the crossfire and are scared into paying - after all, generally speaking all that studios have in the way of evidence is an IP address. Happen to have open Wifi, or a weak security implementation on your router? Well, you might just find yourself sued. Nicolas Chartier, head of Voltage Pictures, who had actually been banned by the Oscars for trying to petition for votes (a big no-no), made things much worse for himself: after fans began threatening to boycott the company's offerings (we know of several examples of this), and one particular fan e-mailed Chartier to say he'd boycott Voltage til the campaign was dropped, Chartier replied calling the fan a moron, and stating that he hoped his family and kids (Chartier, not the brightest, appeared to be unaware that one's family usually includes their kids) wound up in jail. And that he was stupid. Amongst other insults. Chartier had created a public relations nightmare, and his company's image has never recovered. Voltage did have success thanks to Dallas Buyer's Club last year, but little else in their repertoire really stands out outside The Hurt Locker. As recently as this Spring they were still attempting to make a buck via copyright lawsuits, though in 2013 they had 615 of their cases thrown out of court in a single fell swoop. They've changed tactics as a result, suing smaller numbers of people (six, in a recent example in Oregon) but going after more money from each. Like many copyright trolls before them, their effort to turn a profit by taking advantage of the legal system simply tarnished their image permanently (we're looking at you, Metallica).

Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.