5 Movie Mistakes Caused By CGI
Computer Effects have always been a staple of cinema. In the 60s, several independent films gave a shot at producing realistic monsters and effects. When Star Wars came about in the 70s people were spellbound by the Lasers and Lightsabers and all the other goodies George Lucas and Industrial Light and Magic brought us. Since then CGI has taken cinema to new worlds and shown us new events that we could only dream of. Perhaps the greatest advancement in the world of film in recent years has been the improvements made to Computer Generated Images. Michael Bay has stood atop the box office with a money net almost entirely on the basis that he can bring an extravaganza of special effects to his films. James Cameron gave grace and nightmarish detail to the sinking of the Titanic and lush and spellbinding beauty to the world of Pandora in Avatar. George Lucas himself crafted hectic space dogfights and battles within ruined cities when he returned to the Star Wars universe. The last ten years have hosted some of the greatest CGI achievements imaginable, and the world of film would be a lot worse off without it. However, despite all of this, there are moments where CGI has left us dumbstruck by how unconvincing it is, or how it recklessly ignores physics or biology in an attempt to include something massively above budget or belief. There are a few trends emerging with CGI that need to be put to rest. Admittedly some of these are down to technology not being up to the speed demanded by the filmmakers, but in these cases surely an alternate method could be employed? Perhaps replace the jerky 2D monster with a good old fashioned prop? When CGI is high quality and believable, it is remarkable; when it isnt, it drags you right out of the movie you are watching. Perhaps future big budget endeavours will learn from these lessons.
5. The Human Body Is As Flexible As Cooked Spaghetti
Culprits Catwoman, the Matrix Reloaded, Lord of the Rings: Return of the King This is a very common error of judgement. Filmmakers can pour hours of time and piles of production cash into their epic climactic fight scene, but Rule #1 should always be to make your subject physically plausible. Take the most glaring example: The Matrix Reloaded. Fans of the first film flooded cinemas to see the epic second part to one of the greatest action films of the last two decades. Not only was the overall result quite lacking, but the climactic Burly Brawl was ruined by the horrific CGI Smiths. Watching their almost shapeless masses being repelled by a pole, wielded by a Keanu Reeves action figure, was a disturbing, disappointing event. Catwoman birthed similar monstrosities, as the titular cat burglar leapt from wall to wall like a rectangle only to morph back into a terrible Halle Berry render. Coupled with Berrys terrible performance in the shots where she wasnt a human noodle, the film was simply dire. When you are filming a fight scene there should only be one guideline: Dont get in over your head. Otherwise youll find yourself spawning in more enemies than a video game (with similar graphics, coincidentally) or trying to pull off unfeasible moves that only a dose of expensive CGI can make truly realistic. X2s fantastic opening scene with Nightcrawler storming the White House showed how this sort of thing should have been handled with as little computer modelling as possible. Put simply humans have bones. There is a limit to how far these bones will move and flex. If you overstep this limit, youll break something. Computer models should be no exception.
4. Flying Incurs Zero Physics
Culprits: Iron Man, The Avengers, Spiderman The act of flight is rather tricky. There are a thousand million variables to consider, and a thousand things that could go wrong. Jumping onto an inflight vehicle is not advisable; the forces at play will almost definitely rip your arms out their sockets. This is a rule that Marvel especially loves to ignore. Spider-Man leaps from building to building and smashes headfirst into trains and skyscrapers. He may have the abilities of a spider, but if youve ever seen a spider collide with concrete at terminal velocity youll learn which comes off worst. Ten years onwards and they havent learnt, because The Avengers treated us to a spectacular display of incoming alien invaders, which, while truly wonderful to watch, somehow defied all laws of physics imaginable. The most obvious example in the aforementioned idea of grabbing a speeding vehicle. Yet Black Widow doesnt get turned into a Michonne walker, rather she leaps marvellously onto the ship and proceeds to traverse and pilot it, while shrugging off the intense G-forces an open top vehicle must have been surging through her body. The Avengers is packed full of great effects but they lose their magic when they get applied to impossible situations If we suddenly found ourselves invaded by the creatures of The Avengers, then, after actually coping with our new overlords of course, somebody needs to attach a dont try this at home message to the film, because if anyone was to try and pull any of those stunts theyd find themselves losing a limb or four.
3. Destroying Buildings Will Kill Nobody
Culprits: Transformers, The Avengers, most Big Budget Action films In movie worlds, it would appear that certain materials arent nearly as deadly as we think they are. But in the real world, they are. Raining glass will shred your skin, falling blocks of concrete, thick wood or metal will certainly break limbs and shrapnel works as frag grenades intend them to very fatally. Shia LaBeouf's character in Michael Bays SFX-fest Transformers really should have died in any one of the battle scenes that made up the runtimes majority. But that is just because he was really, really annoying. Apply some real world logic, however, and he physically shouldnt have survived. Bays love of explosions gets way too danger-close for any of the human characters to have realistically survived without major injury, and even the Transformers themselves probably went through several explosions that were too extreme, even for them. So next time you find yourself in a city overwhelmed by giant robots or aliens, make sure to find suitable cover from practicably everything, including your cover. Because chances are, it will all get blown up and, unlike the movies, shred you in an instant.
2. Provoked Animals Move Like A Video Game Glitch
Culprits The Ring, Lake Placid (and other monster films), Life of Pi, The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King Weve all seen a deer get scared of the mere presence of a person and scarper. I have never seen a deer get scared and turn into a shapeless, 2D glitch. Animals, even when startled, do seem to remain ordinary in terms of Physics. This isnt the case with movies, it seems. As soon as scene calls for an animal to do something wild, unnatural or just plain ridiculous, producers will quite rightly turn to CGI to avoid mowing down that actual herd of deer. But could they please do it better, or not at all? Ring 2 featured a scene that so drastically ruined the suspension of disbelief for the film through its terrible CGI animals that most people I talk to about the film agree it is one of the worst applications of CGI in recent history. Lake Placid, Life of Pi, SyFys countless killer animal films and many other creature features suffer the same fate, replacing the convincing models, machines and puppetry that made the likes of Jaws and Jurassic Park successful with bland, rendered failures. Take a look at the picture above to see how it can hit rock bottom.