5 Reasons Ben Affleck As Batman Is A Good Idea

Batmanaffleck

August 22, 2013 will forever be known as the day the internet exploded. After announcing the Man of Steel sequel would include Batman in a surprise announcement at Comic-Con, geek speculation began: Who would portray the Caped Crusader in said film? Would Christian Bale accept a small island as payment and return? Would it be an unknown? An established name? Well-known Bat-film mainstay, Batman-On-Film.com, broke the news that the studio was looking for an actor in their forties. This fueled the flames even more so and, for a moment, it seemed as though Josh Brolin was the man to beat. Brolin seemed to be a solid choice. He certainly has the acting chops and the blockbuster experience as well as fitting the older mold that the studio was looking for. However, speculation on the negative press that his recent divorce from returning Man of Steel cast member, Diane Lane, began to circulate. Whether that had an effect on his casting in the film or not, we may never know, but I'm certain that no one would enjoy traveling the world answering questions from the press with their recently divorced spouse. That side of things is all purely speculation, of course. What we do know now is that, for whatever reason, Brolin was not the man who got the part. August 22, 2013, we found out who did... and then the internet exploded. Ben Affleck, a man whose Hollywood reputation has seen unbelievable highs and depressing lows, has been cast as Batman in the upcoming Batman/Superman film across from returning Henry Cavill as Superman and returning Man of Steel director, Zack Snyder. Had Affleck been cast as Batman in Batman Begins back in 2005, I honestly believe that the negative reaction would have been huge. You have to remember, 2005 was before Hollywoodland. It was before Gone Baby Gone. The mainstream opinion of Affleck in 2005 was that of Matt Damon's less talented friend. I would argue that that opinion was unwarranted given that, when given a meaty role as he was in 2002's Changing Lanes, he proved more than capable as a three-dimensional actor. However, there's little doubt that the American movie-going public didn't think much of him outside of considering him a halfway decent heartthrob type. Capable of headlining a special-effects film, sure, but not a serious actor. In 2013 though? Ben Affleck is a much different name. Ben Affleck has since proven himself to be a legitimate talent in the eyes of the mainstream. Not only has he improved his image greatly as an actor, his status as a top-name director is indisputable. With critical darlings in both categories (in more than one instance, in the same film), Affleck has positioned himself to the point to where putting his name in the same conversation as one Clint Eastwood would not be a stretch. Suffice to say, Gigli is far in his rear-view... and that is why the internet exploded. Despite all that he's accomplished, there is still an identifiable group of fans that do not accept this decision in the least. To them, Affleck is still that guy from Armageddon who isn't tough enough to be Batman. He's still just a pretty boy actor on par with any other male actor from a late nineties teen drama. The stigma still exists, just as it did in 2005. Only now, given his obvious success, there's just as large a group there to decry such claims. So, now, we have something of a Batman Civil War on our hands. One that will only intensify right up until actual footage of Affleck as the Dark Knight surfaces to quell-or qualify-any doubts. Seeing as actual footage isn't likely to surface until late next year, I believe we are looking towards a long, heated debate that will stretch across the comic fan landscape far and wide. It is in the spirit of this debate that I felt the need to provide five solid reasons why we who are lifelong Bat-fans have no reason to worry about the once-Daredevil taking on a different masked hero. While Affleck honestly wasn't my first choice for the role, I find the vocal denouncing of his casting completely ignorant of his development as an actor and very short sighted as to what it could potentially accomplish. Therefore, I present the top five reasons that Ben Affleck as Batman is a good idea.

5. Name Recognition

2371652 Orig

This is where the anti-Affleck camp will immediately disagree, but they clearly haven't been paying attention. Ben Affleck is a big name star. Anyone who doubts that needs to have their head examined. He's bigger than anyone that's been cast as a superhero in any Marvel movie sans Robert Downey, Jr. and even RDJ wasn't that big a star prior to Iron Man. Why is this important? Because Batman is not in the same place he was in back in 2005. In 2005, Batman was eight years removed from Batman & Robin, quite possibly the most infamous superhero film ever. As big a star as George Clooney was in 1997, even he couldn't save that movie. In fact, his star power may have been a hindrance as evidence that the studio was only interested in selling Batman on a superficial level, scooping up a hot name star to sell toys. So, when time came to cast Batman in 2005, it wasn't as important to cast a big name. Christian Bale was not cast for his mainstream appeal as much as he was for his dedication as an actor. This was needed in order to reestablish the character as the serious literary figure he was always meant to be. Thanks to Bale and a little-known director named Christopher Nolan, three films later and Batman is now back to being a serious character that big stars want to play; the kind of stars that get their names above the movie titles on posters. This is important because of the nature of the film we are about to be presented. Henry Cavill's Superman has had a film all to himself to establish his character. It was quite a successful film as well. This puts our new Batman at a bit of a disadvantage. One could argue that Warner Brothers could produce a single, solo Batman outing to give this new Batman a new origin in order to even things out between the two heroes, but who in their right mind wants to make another Batman origin film after Christopher Nolan? Enter Ben Affleck, an actor with the experience and marketability to instantly give this new Batman credibility in the eyes of the public. You don't need an origin when you've got a guy like Affleck. He's not someone who needs to be introduced to the public. Whatever advantage Cavill had as Superman is nonexistent. In fact, I would say that it's Cavill who's at a disadvantage in this case. He's nowhere near the same star level that Affleck is at this point in his career. There's no risk of an inexperienced actor folding under high expectations (and, let's face it, expectations will be at an all time high). Affleck will walk into the role confident and as well-known as anyone playing a new Batman against an established Superman would have to be. That leads us to the next reason Ben Affleck as Batman is a good idea...

4. Ben Affleck As Bruce Wayne Is A Good Idea

Ben Affleck Batman Elite Daily 600x300

Look at any picture of Ben Affleck from an awards ceremony. Take your time. Go ahead, I'll wait... Finished? Is there anything about the guy that doesn't say Bruce Wayne? He's tall. He has that younger look that means he'll probably still look twenty when he's sixty-three. He's comfortable in a suit. He always has his hair combed in a very neat way. I'm not trying to turn this into a hetero-Ben Affleck lovefest, but if we all agree that one of Bruce Wayne's defining characteristics is his boyish looks and playboy appearance, there's no way anyone can argue with Ben Affleck as Batman's alter-ego. With the money he has, the guy could be Batman in real life for all we know. Beyond the superficial connection though, I believe there's another, subliminal reason that Ben Affleck as Bruce Wayne is a good idea. If we're operating under the conceit that this Batman is a well-established crime-fighter and that Cavill's Superman is still learning his craft, then casting Affleck, a more established, more recognizable actor than Cavill in every way to play a more established, more recognizable Bruce Wayne makes perfect sense. Clark Kent is a nobody. Bruce Wayne is known by all. Cavill is most well-known for being Superman. Affleck is well-known for many things. Clark Kent is most well-known for being Superman. Bruce Wayne is well-known for many things. In a very meta way, it makes complete sense to put someone like Affleck in the role. For this film and its context, it's a perfect fit. Plus, if they want to save some money, he may bring his own suits.

3. Fan-Casting Has Been Proven Wrong Too Many Times

B41fc64ddf99cef69bf9ec72fc7ba0

This reason is sort of a cheat as it doesn't have as much to with Affleck as it does with fans in general, but has Heath Ledger taught us nothing? When Heath Ledger was cast as the Joker in The Dark Knight (greatest superhero film ever made), hissy-fits were thrown by the millions. There were the obvious, simple-minded bigots who didn't want their beloved Joker portrayed by the same man who was nominated for an Oscar for playing a gay cowboy. There were those who only thought of him as a heartthrob type much as many did (and still do in certain cases) Affleck. There were those who had there own ideas of who should play the Clown Prince of Crime (looking your way, Hugo Weaving). There were those who didn't dig the first promo shot of Ledger almost deliberately not smiling, as if he wouldn't be smiling in the film, as if someone smiling was all that was required to play the character. Every single one of those objections were written down, thrown in the dumpster, and set on fire once the first, real trailer for the film was released. Once actual footage of Ledger as the Joker was seen by the public, everyone who objected immediately shut up. Why? Because once again, the fan community jumped to conclusions that were based entirely on conjecture and nonsense. Being an Academy Award nominee wasn't enough to get Ledger at least a "we'll see". They had to actually see it and when they did, do you know what the Ledger defenders asked? "Did Michael Keaton teach us nothing?" Listen, Zack Snyder cast Henry Cavill as Superman. That seemed to work out okay, right? So, can we give the two-time Academy Award winning, experienced actor who was cast by the same guy who cast Man of Steel full of great actors at least a "we'll see"? Obviously, you can have your doubts, but given the history of knee-jerk reactions to superhero film casting in the past, is it too much to reserve judgement until actual footage is released? I fear, for many, it is.

2. Affleck As Batman Could Mean Bryan Cranston As Luthor

Cranston Bb

Follow me on this: Bryan Cranston has recently shown interest in playing Lex Luthor. Bryan Cranston has recently finished filming a television show that will be remembered for decades. Bryan Cranston recently starred in a film with Ben Affleck. That same film won an Oscar for Best Picture. That same film was distributed by Warner Brothers. Ben Affleck was just cast as Batman in a Batman/Superman film to be released by Warner Brothers. You realize what all this means? Mark Strong is obviously a lock to play Lex Luthor. Or, you know, maybe, just maybe, we've got a real shot here at Walter White himself taking on another bald, larger-than-life character. I mean, honestly, how could anyone object to a character actor with the charisma of Cranston taking on one of the most charismatic characters in all of comics (there's a lot of alliteration in this section, I'll admit)? Personally, for the part of Luthor, I would want a guy who can play layers. I don't want a "super-villain" Lex Luthor who exudes evil. I also don't want a half-buffoon as we've seen previously. I want a Luthor with depth. I also want a Luthor who can entertain. Bryan Cranston is capable of doing both of those things in spades. There might be some who think that this part is too close to his role on Breaking Bad, but I don't think they could be more different. Walter White is a desperate man, trying to be the man that Luthor is naturally. One can't compare the suburban, morality tale of Breaking Bad to the global, sci-fi world of Superman. Not that one is inherently better than the other, but they are different beasts entirely and rooting against Cranston for the role based on the comparison does as much a disservice to his acting abilities as rooting against Affleck ignores the great work he's done. I'm not saying that Affleck as Batman necessitates that Cranston will be Luthor, but if casting Affleck gets us a little closer to a three-time Emmy-winner as Luthor, I'd say that's a tally in the "pro" side of the Affleck-as-Batman argument as much as anything is.

1. Affleck Playing Batman Gives Hope Of Affleck Directing Batman

Benaffleckdirector600

Anyone who was already on my side probably figured this for number one from the start. Affleck has directed critically acclaimed crime dramas. We know from experience that Batman is best received when he is presented in this form. If Affleck is willing, at this point in his career, to play Batman, who's to say he's not willing to direct Batman as well? From what little we know, there's no guarantee that this version of the character will ever see solo films. This Batman could be confined merely to team-ups. However, I believe that is a great waste of talent on Affleck's part. Affleck's sensibilities as a director fit perfectly within the world of Batman. To sign such a great director up to play Batman and not at least consider the possibility that he might one day direct the character as well would be foolish on Warner Brothers' part. This has the potential to be the perfect situation. The fear that came from the initial announcement that the new Batman would be introduced in the Man of Steel sequel was that any future solo director would be forced to confide his vision of Batman to Zack Snyder's. If Ben Affleck, critically acclaimed director, is playing Batman, however, I think there's a good chance he'll get his fair say into how the character is presented and if the possibility of a solo film presents itself, he won't have to worry about fitting anything into his Batman that he doesn't want to because he will have already had that conversation. The burden of the first post-Bale Batman was always going to be more on the actor that portrayed him than it was any one director. Said actor, depending on his success in the role, may have been called to play Batman in different films for different directors. It would be up to that actor to carry the weight of the role completely. How nice is it then, that the actor playing him is an accomplished director himself, fully capable of directing his own solo franchise if need be? Also, how unique and attention-getting that would be to have an actor playing and directing himself in a superhero film, especially an actor and director of Affleck's pedigree? This, essentially, solves the potential problem of another director having to play catch up if they decide to break this Batman off on his own. Affleck won't have to play catch up, he'll be in on the ground floor. While some may still not be convinced that he can play Batman, I defy anyone to say he can't direct Batman. All of the films he's directed thus far would differ. He's shown the ability to present the nuances of crime. He's shown the ability to direct action. He's shown the ability to get gritty. He knows how to get great performances. He's the perfect guy to direct Batman post-Nolan. The fact that he's playing the character as well isn't a negative in the slightest because he's proven he can direct a film and give a gritty, solid performance as an actor as well. As far as I'm concerned, Affleck's proven he's as versatile as the Dark Knight himself. Any reasons I missed? Any arguments against? Let me know in the comment section.

Contributor
Contributor

Josh has no concept of reality. He has spent more time with fake people then real ones and finds the fake ones to be more real. He believes Batman will one day be the basis of a religion. His imaginary friends include wrestlers, serial anti-heroes, and various jedi. Warning: Object may go from sincere to sarcastic without notice. Handle with care.