5 Reasons Why Dredd Sucked
Dredd has finally arrived and it is an incredibly boring and empty film. Here's why...
Judge Dredd is far from the cultural icon many, particularly the devout readers of the 2000AD comic book he stars in, believe he is. Ask the wrong person and you could easily be led to believe hes a creation on par with Darth Vader or Sherlock Holmes. Step out of the comic bubble and the only trace of him on popular culture is that terrible 1995 Sylvester Stallone version. I can guarantee that when your standard movie goer sees a poster for the new adaptation of the character, they dont go At long last, a worthy film adaptation of that great icon that we all know and love. Theyre much more likely to go Who? Hopefully thatll be enough to keep them from the cinema because Dredd is a god awful film. It's a boring experience that drags, despite the swift 95 minute running time. It doesn't seem to know who its audience is. On the one hand, it doesn't appear extremely faithful to its source material the plot is entirely new and the basic set up aside a lot of the more interesting sounding elements of the Dredd universe aren't present but on the other theres little present to appeal to the regular public. It may have been met with mostly favourable reviews, with review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes giving it an amazing 91% score, but its worth noting the average rating is a much lower 6.5/10; most reviews place it just above average. There is admittedly something refreshing about a British action film that has high ambitions despite its small budget and you can appreciate the toned down plot is a way to accommodate more violence and the added 3D; there will be no comparison to The Raid here. Although there is one recent film that Dredd bares a startling resemblance to, if not in direct plot, but in a stylised nature, with a solitary character and sudden explosions of extreme violence. Dredd is Drive for adolescents. But just what made Dredd suck so badly? Click next to find out. Light Spoilers, with major ones highlighted.
5. The 3D
3D has outstayed its welcome by over three years and Dredd only continues its banal existence. I thankfully caught one of the few 2D showings available, but that it is itself an achievement to do so says it all. Dredd may have been shot in 3D, but thats no reason to say there cant be a 2D showing. It seems distributor Entertainment disagree; my local Cineworld had seven showings a day in 3D and only one 2D showing placed too late to be in the daytime, but too early for people whove been working all day. This is forcing people to go for the 3D option, which was fine in the early days, but now with the ridiculous ticket surcharge its just plain greedy. In a couple of months time, when Dredds performance at the box office is used as a case for why 3D is far from dead, just remember they forced you to see it in the expensive, colour reducing format. As for whether the 3D itself is effective, there has been little discussion in reviews as to its quality; a sure sign that it has little impact. There were a few moments in the film where you can imagine the effect attempting to dazzle you, but the only thing that stood out was (SPOILER) when MaMas face splattered over the screen. This struck me as a pointless feature; use a medium designed to pull the audience in to create a barrier between the audience and the film.
4. Lack Of Satire
What really intrigued me about Dredd was its satirical nature. The comic strip had initially been a response to the Thatcher government and evolved to pass comment on many other elements of society as the world it was published in evolved. This made an adaptation produced in such an interesting period as our own a delicious concept. Think of all the interesting comments that could be made about the modern state of the world; the banks, the reliance on technology and of course, police bureaucracy. There is not even a semblance of satire in Dredd. How is that even possible? The film is about a law enforcer who judges the criminals and often executes them on the spot. That is all set-up in a brief introduction that plays up the coolness of it all, not even pausing to muse its implications. Throughout the film the Judges are presented as brave heroes and nothing else; no attempt at questioning the ethics of this society. The film excises any semblance of smarts and replaces it with dumb and repetitive action (more on that later). I watched the reboot of The Sweeney just before Dredd. That film, from the director of numerous Danny Dyer gangsta flicks, said more about the attitudes of the public and the police than a film based on series famed for its satire.
3. Slo-Mo
To a low budget filmmaker theres nothing more badass than slow motion. But it sure is pesky having to justify putting it in a film. Dredd avoids this annoyance by having slow motion a major plot point. The drug that villain MaMa is peddling is called, with the most imaginative name since Unobtanium, slo-mo and makes everything appear, well, slower. Slo-Mo is a terribly unimaginative idea shoehorned in as a key plot device. Was there nothing in Dredds twenty year history that could have been used over a gimmick that got tired by the second Matrix film? Slow motion is an incredibly overused device that purports to make things look cooler, but is used with such frequency that it is more refreshing and cool to have a film without it. If you need to slow the action down to make it comprehensible, maybe you shouldn't be directing action at all? Like 3D, it is admittedly quite cool the first time you see the effect. As well as slowing things down, it creates a sort of hyper enhanced colour pallet, making everything look bright, vibrant and, best of all, interesting. Its a shame the rest of the film is stuck with drab and dirty greys. We get at least three uses before the plot proper kicks off, followed by a couple in early action sequences (by which point its getting a bit tired). Then, about halfway through the drug is mostly forgotten. Its almost as if it was put in there just to create the sense of style and not for the benefit of the plot at all!
2. Tensionless Action
In film that is first and foremost an action spectacle, it is surprising how flat the action feels. Theres plenty of gun play, but very little of it sticks in the mind. There is one standout sequence early on involving a drug bust, shocking because of the explicit violence and the sudden nature of it all. After that, the film devolves into minor set pieces all lacking in tension. There are so many small action sequences someone is shot in a corridor, someone is shot in a stairwell, someone is shot in a room, someone is shot in a room by someone in a corridor that quickly there is no threat from the countless goons attacking the Judges. Each kill just happens to a faceless character with no sense of impact or violence. It ends up with the heroes feeling too indestructible to ever be in any peril. (SPOLIERS in following paragraph) When a group of rouge Judges show up it looks like things could get interesting. But instead it gets even more banal. The stupidity of these new adversaries is unbelievable; three of them all die from taking the time to talk to the people they are being paid to kill. And in a bizarre casting choice, the lead rouge has a very similar jaw line to Karl Urban and thus it is painfully hard to tell who is actually fighting who. It all ends up like watching someone else play a video game on an easy setting.
1. No Relatable Characters
It must be one of the first things that is taught in Screenwriting 101; create characters your audience can relate to. They dont have to be someone who the audience literally feel exactly the same as, like Luke Skywalker, Frodo Baggins or other heroes from the same batch. But there needs to be something that the audience can latch on to. In fact I cant think of any great film that doesnt have at least one relatable character. By the end of Psycho, weve been at points directly following four different characters (Marion, Norman, Arbogast and Lila). One is stealing a vast sum of money from her boss and another is hiding the dead body of the woman who up until three minutes ago was the audiences viewpoints. And yet we still feel for the characters, understanding their motives and allowing them to bring us into their world. Judge Dredd is by his very nature an unlikable and unrelatable character. He is a literally faceless lawgiver working for a oppressive government with has no human characteristics who just kills people on the spot. He may work as the driving force of a short comic strip, but for 95 minutes (and a long 95 minutes at that) it doesnt work. You can imagine that was why Anderson was written into the script. A rookie training with Dredd, shes an orphan struggling to make the pass grade to become a Judge; typical empathy character. But Olivia Thirlby plays her so closed and the character's psychic ability only further distances her from the audience. To make things worse, as the film develops she looses all semblance of an emphatic role; after a brief moment of worrying over killing she is happy to gun down as many thugs as it takes. The lack of empathy with the characters is by far the worst thing in the film. We as an audience have no way in to the story and thus it all washes over us, highlighting just how poor the film actually is.