50 Greatest Performances In Marvel Movies
35. Tobey Maguire - Spider-Man
Tobey Maguire is still the best Spider-Man. Granted, he had to portray that awful Venom-influenced side of the character in his third outing, but apart from that he was pretty much brilliant.
His nerdiness and vulnerable side were far more convincing than Garfield's - and that's more typically what Peter Parker is about - and, while his chemistry with Kirsten Dunst's wasn't quite as good as Garfield's with Stone, it was still convincing.