6 Hollywood Mysteries That Were Never Solved

Just like the movies, only in real-life.

There's no business like show business, and there's no place quite like Hollywood. The movie business set up shop there back in 1910, meaning there is over a century of history about the place, and it is as storied as the movies themselves. There are countless tales to be told, from the Oscars to Orson Welles, Chaplin to Cruise, and the silent films to summer blockbusters. Almost every aspiring actor, writer, or director wants to make it to Tinseltown; it's the place where dreams - and careers - are made. However, look beyond that cinematic sheen, past the stars the on Walk of Fame and the handprints outside of Grauman's Chinese Theatre, and you'll find something a little less glamourous. Buried beneath the red carpet premieres and A-list events, there is a dark and murky underworld to Hollywood. It's one that belies its image of being all champagne and caviar, but is just a much a part of this world as the movie stars we're presented with on-screen and in glossy magazines. Murder and mystery may be common themes for the movies, but there's been a number of them in real-life that even Hitchcock would've struggled to come up with. These are some of the biggest that still haven't been solved to this day...

6. The Black Dahlia

There's a good chance you've heard of The Black Dahlia, even if you're not completely aware of the story behind it. That's partly because it's a rather interesting sounding nickname, the sort that gets stuck in the memory, and it was also the inspiration for a book of the same name by acclaimed Los Angeles crime writer James Ellroy. The actual person it refers to is Elizabeth Short, a 22-year-old who was found back in 1947 having had her body sliced in half at the waist. The corners of her mouth had been slit up to her ears, and she had numerous other cuts all over her body. She was found in a LA parking lot completely drained of blood, and the gruesome story attracted a host of sensationalised tabloid headlines, which led to the infamous nickname. The Los Angeles Examiner went as far to contact her mother reporting that her daughter had won a beauty contest, and only after interviewing her did they reveal the truth about what had actually happened. However, despite the huge amount of coverage, the police were unable to find a single lead on the case. They interviewed a host of people from Short's past, but there was no evidence to connect any of them to her brutal murder. Later, a man started contacting the Examiner, worried that coverage of the case was dropping off. He mailed a number of items belonging to Short, including her birth certificate, business cards, and photographs. Dozens have come forward to falsely confess to the case, which happens whenever it reappears in popular culture. However, no one has ever actually been arrested, and given it has now been almost 70 years it's extremely unlikely it will ever be solved.

5. The Murder Of Thelma Todd

Thelma Todd appeared in a huge number of films in her career, gaining a reputation as a talented comedy actress for her roles opposite the Marx Brothers in Monkey Business and Horse Feathers, and with Buster Keaton in Speak Easily. All told she appeared in well over 100 movies between 1926 and 1935. One of her last roles, in Laurel and Hardy film The Bohemien Girl, was in the process of filming when she was found dead, aged just 30. She was discovered in a car parked a block away from her home, and the cause of death was said to be carbon monoxide poisoning. The official police ruling was that it had been an accident, with possible suicidal tendencies. However, her friends argued that she was a happy person and would never have committed suicide, and no motive nor note was ever discovered. Furthermore, when she was found she had a bloody lip, and there were spots of blood in the car. The coroners found no signs of violence on the body though, apart from the lip, and after a grand jury probe there was no evidence of a murder. Her body was cremated, meaning there was no chance of a second autopsy, and the official cause of death stands at accidental but possible suicide. Author Andy Edmonds wrote a book on the subject, Hot Toddy: The True Story of Hollywood's Most Sensational Murder, arguing that gangster 'Lucky' Luciano was responsible for her murder, though no case has successfully been brought against him or anyone else.

4. The Death Of Superman

The Superman Curse is the name given to the series of misfortune suffered by people who have worked on various Superman movies, in particular those playing the titular hero. For example, Christopher Reeve was paralysed after falling from a horse, and passed away a few years later. Bud Collyer was the first man to voice Superman, from 1941-43, but after returning to the role in 1966 he died just three years later. Lee Quigley, who only played Superman as a baby, died due to solvent abuse aged just 14. Brandon Routh and Henry Cavill, well, they had the bad luck to be in Superman Returns and Man of Steel respectively. It's mostly attributed, however, to George Reeves, who played Superman back in the 1950s. He was found dead of a gunshot wound in his home back in 1959, and the official ruling was that he had committed suicide. However, there were four other people in the house at the time (his fiancee Leonore Lemmon, and three guests) who waited a suspiciously long time before calling the police. Furthermore, stray bullet cases were found next to the body, and no fingerprints were found on the gun. Many believe that Reeves was instead killed by Toni Mannox, with whom he was having an affair, while others believe it was Lemmon who murdered him. These possibilities were explored in the Ben Affleck film Hollywoodland, however despite the doubt and controversy the official cause remains as suicide.

3. Marilyn Monroe's Death

Some 50 years after her death, Norma Jeane Mortenson remains one of the most iconic and well-loved movie stars ever to have graced the big screen. However, while her legacy with live on thanks to her roles in the likes of the Seven-Year Itch and Some Like it Hot, the fact she was one of the biggest stars of her time, and her status as a beauty icon, there's also another reason she remains a popular figure for discussion: her death, back in 1962, at just 36-years-of-age. She was found dead in her California home, in bed with an empty bottle of sleeping pills in her hand, so it seemed a foregone conclusion that she had committed suicide, and indeed that was the official ruling. She'd allegedly been suffering from depression, so it seemed to fit that was what happened. There are many who refuse to believe that was the case though, and have pointed to some mysterious circumstances before her death. A number of items were apparently taken from her apartment, including a personal diary and a note that could have major implications for the White House. Theories have included that she was murdered by the mafia, or that her death was a government-ordered assassination due to her supposed affairs with John F. and Robert Kennedy. It was later discovered that FBI files on the case had gone missing, and still haven't been recovered to this day, further fuelling speculation she was killed.

2. Jean Spangler's Disappearance

Jean Spangler was a model and an aspiring actress, having bit-part roles in the likes of musical When My Baby Smiles at Me and comedy Chicken Every Sunday. However, she is best known for being at the centre of one of the biggest mysteries in Hollywood's history. In 1949, just as she was starting to break into the movies, the 26-year-old disappeared. She left her daughter with her sister-in-law, claiming she was going to see her ex-husband, and then on to a film shoot., however, the ex claims that he never saw her, and there were no shoots scheduled that day. A couple of days later her purse was found in Griffith Park, LA, and had been torn at the strap. Inside was a seemingly unfinished note, which read: "Kirk, Can€™t wait any longer. Going to see Dr. Scott. It will work best this way while mother is away€. She had been filming a small part in the Kirk Douglas film Young Man with a Horn at the time of her disappearance, however Douglas contacted police before he was even a suspect to state he had no involvement in her disappearance. Few other clues were found, although it was mooted that she'd been pregnant, and Dr Scott was a man who carried out abortions (then illegal) for money. She was also allegedly spotted with gangster David Ogul, an associate of LA crime boss Mickey Cohen, some time after she went missing. However, to this day she hasn't been found, and the case remains open.

1. Fatty Arbuckle And Virginia Rappe

Roscoe 'Fatty' Arbuckle was one of the first movie stars, a hugely popular figure of the silents films during the 1910s, a mentor to Charlie Chaplin and discovered Buster Keaton, and in 1921 became one of the best paid actors in the world, signing a $1m contract with Paramount. After that though his career was dogged by controversy, and it's for that he is now best remembered. At a Labor Day party with Arbuckle, aspiring actress Virginia Rappe fell ill in his room. He found her when he went to change clothes, and called for a doctor who concluded she was simply drunk. After contuining to be ill for a further three days she eventually went to hospital, where she died from having her bladder ruptured. One guest blamed Arbuckle for the death, claiming Rappe had said he'd hurt her, and he was subsequently arrested. One theory held that he raped her, and his sheer weight caused the injuries, while others suggest he violently attacked her with a bottle. He was forced to stand through three trials, with two hung juries and constant attacks from the media, but was never convicted, and no evidence was found to actually connect him to her death. Despite being found not guilty it ruined his career, while the exact cause of Rappe's injuries remain shrouded in mystery. Which other mysteries still haunt Hollywood? Share your own most compelling examples below in the comments thread.

In this post: 
Hollywood
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.