6 Reasons Why The Dark Knight Rises Complaints Should Be Put To Rest

Michael Caine In the world where praise and hate are consistently butting heads, one always seem to have more prevalence over the other. In one instance, a big box office mammoth like The Avengers receives well-deserved praise for its various working elements and balances. Another instance is The Dark Knight Rises, another box office mammoth, which receives a generous amount of praise - and also congruous amounts of hate. What makes it even more noticeable is when writers start a hate war over something that shouldn't even be the focus of so much unnecessary criticism. The Dark Knight Rises happens to be one of those actual tragedies. Whenever the chance is available, writers look at all the little problems that reveal themselves in the film and find the chance to bash the hell out of it up until things no longer make sense. The same problems are discussed over and over again, from Bruce Wayne finding his way back into Gotham City, to the nuclear blast that would have killed Batman and possibly destroyed part of the city in the process. It's all about the flaws, errors, and making sure the writers knew when they screwed up, mainly because people are looking for a reason to cause controversy and spark attention. As seen ever since its July 2012 release, fans have found every opportunity imaginable to make sure the film lives in the image of mediocrity instead of simply leaving it alone and moving on. Still, there are a ton of others who just want to see an end to all the hate, myself included. So I've taken it upon myself to gather 6 definitive reasons that should (hopefully) put most of the bashers and backlash to rest. Because all they really complain about is how pitiful the paint job is on the outside, instead of opening the hood to check out the engine. Please note: there are MAJOR spoilers ahead that give away important plot points for The Dark Knight Rises (along with analysis on certain points for the whole trilogy, too).

6. The Plot Holes Are "Part Of The Plan"

the-dark-knight-rises-ending Probably the most talked about aspect of TDKR is its massive plot holes. I say "massive" because they do leave behind giants gaps of information that make it difficult to comprehend some aspects of the story. Plot holes like Batman escaping a nuclear blast with only so little time to escape, or everyone's favorite: Bruce Wayne mysteriously returning to Gotham City with no funds or a private jet to get him there. These major examples may be some of the film's most talked about and disputed subjects, but let's play devil's advocate here for a little bit: What if these plot holes, so to speak, were purposefully put in the film to tease at our minds, with us having to ask the obvious questions like how, when, where, and what? As bothersome as they might be, I believe, as unbiased as I can possibly be, that these plot holes are all "part of the plan," as the Joker would narrowly put it. And there's two certain elements to this "plan," and they're Nolan's intellect and our interpretation of the matter. Nolan has a significant style when directing his films. He explores every detail he can find and give it enough reason to make sense within the context of his narrative, as mysterious as they can be sometimes. With said plot holes being a cumbersome part of the experience to some viewers, they must consider Nolan's analytical approach to filmmaking and how he accomplishes wonders behind the lens of a camera (and storyboard, mind you). In my mind, they're simple gaps in the narrative disguised as plot holes so that we can think about the answers ourselves, instead of having Nolan add more running time to a movie that's already almost pushing 3 hours. This couldn't be more prevalent than Bruce's grand return to Gotham: with his funds all but wiped clean in the film's first act, Bruce really didn't have anything left but his damaged career as Batman. So after escaping the Pit in a location we can presume is only far, far away from Gotham or any known source of travel, and with no funds to back up his return, his sudden and shockingly grand return left a lot of people scratching their heads. But the truth is, it was done that way on purpose. What if that was Nolan's intention?

5. More Bruce Wayne Than Batman Is Good

bruce wayne the dark knight rises Nolan's Batman trilogy really brought to focus the story of Bruce Wayne and his journey from Princeton University student to hard-edged vigilante. That journey manifested itself with Batman Begins, giving us a Bruce Wayne that felt grounded and full of moral intrigue. His evolution into becoming Batman was lifted with such deft hands that by the end of the film we were left with a great first chapter that had plenty of Bruce Wayne and plenty of Batman, a perfect balance. With TDK, we were given more of a special treatment of the same journey, this time with much more of the Caped Crusader and less Bruce Wayne. Bruce was still a centrepiece in the story, becoming a political ally to Harvey Dent and a resurfacing love interest with Rachel Dawes. But in the end TDK was more a Batman story rather than Bruce Wayne's. With TDKR we were given yet another special treatment into Bruce's journey. With this film being the epic culmination of Bruce's story, Christopher Nolan and David S. Goyer (lead writer for the trilogy) opted to make it more a Bruce Wayne story than the prior two films, with much less Batman and more of the eccentric billionaire playboy looking to become something more than what he already is now: an eccentric billionaire playboy. After taking the fall for Harvey Dent and being branded an outlaw, Bruce must use Batman to save Gotham City from Bane, which ultimately ends with Bruce faking his own death and retiring. This led to one of the chief reasons why some fans tore into TDKR with such hate: they didn't get enough of Batman, but instead more Bruce Wayne. Like all trilogies, the beginning act needs to set the stage with motivation and goals, the middle act needs to balance out those motives and fulfill and add on to those goals, and the final act needs to bring everything full circle. To do that, everything must rest on the shoulders of one character. In this case, Bruce Wayne. In this trilogy it's his journey, his motives, his goals that matter. Gotham City itself and the rest of the supporting cast have their own motives and goals, but it's Bruce's that we want to see brought to fruition. Batman Begins really gave us a young Bruce Wayne that was ready to tackle the troubles of Gotham City and set the stage for things to come. TDK continued that trend and added a huge gap in his morals and brought interesting quandaries thanks to the Joker and Harvey Dent. Finally, TDKR showed his motivations come to a halt and his goals tarnished thanks to the physical damage he brought upon himself, but he pulls through to do what he set out to do: give people hope in times that seem the darkest, and reveal to them that anybody can rise up and be a hero. Thus he retires, his motivations and goals untroubled.

4. Remember The Other Bane?

Batman And Robin

There came a time back in the late 1990s where some wise-ass director by the name of Joel Schumacher decided to completely tarnish Batman's reputation and history to the point where everything registered with a nasty, terrible aftertaste. His last blood-curdling attempt came with Batman & Robin (1997), which sealed Schumacher's fate and brought the legacy of Batman films to an utter standstill. One of its biggest mishaps was the very unsettling and bizarre rendition of one of the film's villains, Bane. Played by the late Robert "Jeep" Swenson, and baring the name Antonio Diego before becoming the Venom-induced Bane, Schumacher took the absolute cartoon treatment for Bane, making him as goofy and one-dimensional as possible. Where he was a legitimate threat and adversary to Batman in the comics, he's just a standard henchman/enforcer for Mr. Freeze and Poison Ivy's plot to take over Gotham City and the world. Even worse, he was hardly a challenge for the Dark Knight or the Boy Wonder in the actual film, therefore sticking to his henchman role. Simply put, it was an embarrassment. Fact check: Schumacher's Bane did nothing to advance the film; he was just there and stood in the corner until Schumacher decided he should look tough. Also, he not once spoke a coherent sentence. Nothing but mumbles and groans, with the occasional simple word coming from his over-exaggerated self. Now, on the other hand, Nolan's Bane managed to put all of Gotham City under duress and formulate a plot to have a nuclear device primed to incinerate the city at a moment's notice, but not before giving Gotham's citizens the chance to declare anarchy on the rich and wealthy and reclaim it in the name of inhuman justice and tyranny. Now for all those naysayers that continue to brand Nolan's Bane as not living up to the hype and not a great villain, just remember that someone far less talented created a far more devastating tragedy of the character.

3. No Joker Is Also A Good Thing

Joker1 I'm going to keep this distinct reason brief and simple, for I see it as a no-argument-needed type of scenario (despite all the previous and upcoming reasons). Everyone who reads this list no doubt holds TDK up there with the best. Christopher Nolan not only delivered one of the finest films of all time, but casted the perfect Joker in Heath Ledger. His transcending talent and need to push the character farther than ever before really drove home the film for a lot of people, and due to his unfortunate death fans were scared a third film would never be made - or that TDK wouldn't be released. But Nolan went for a third film against his own wishes, for he saw a way to end it all and bring a worthy conclusion to the story. One of the bullets he wanted to dodge was not mentioning or referencing Heath's Joker out of respect. Although rumours circulated that unused footage from TDK would be added to crowbar the Joker into the film, Nolan was persistent on keeping the Joker out of the big picture, laying Heath's legacy to rest in the process. I've seen and heard people complain about this decision, and I'm surprised that they don't see the logic behind it all. We all know Heath put in the performance of a lifetime and how much we'd all love to see it again, but leaving no stone unturned with TDKR honors the actor in more ways than people might be considering.

2. "Death Does Not Wait For You To Be Ready..."

Bane Batman This is perhaps one of the more philosophical reasons that go beyond just simple inclusions and nitpicks, but rather into the very fabric of the trilogy itself. By now, everyone has seen or heard of Bane's death scene. It's been made a parody of several times on YouTube, been mocked for its ridiculousness, and criticized for its lack of finalisation between both Bane and Batman, instead having Catwoman deliver the killing blow with Batman's own Batpod. How ironic that Batman doesn't kill, but instead the technology he uses does the job and then some. Bane's death can be seen as one of the film's most chastising and irrefutable moments, but as much as some would think. Let me explain: The whole trilogy has done a marvelous job at foreshadowing key events and laying the road for future plot points thanks to a fresh abundance of symbolism. From Bruce falling inside the hole to being literally and metaphorically put back inside it in TDKR, to Harvey Dent's take on becoming a villain, all the way to the blunt symbolism of the Joker's card at the end of Batman Begins, foreshadowing goes a long way in terms of storytelling. But sometimes the most cleverest examples of foreshadowing and symbolism aren't put out in the open, but rather hidden within the context of the character's dialogue. Ra's al Ghul, the progenitor of the trilogy's many themes and League of Shadows, happens to hold one of the most remarkable pieces of foreshadowing in the entire trilogy, one that I'm willing to bet many people glanced right over. After meeting Bruce in a Bhutanese prison and giving him purpose to serve justice, and after arriving at his own fortress in the snowy mountains, Ra's al Ghul gives Bruce a nice monologue before knocking Bruce's teeth in. He says:
"Death does not wait for you to be ready. Death is not considerate or fair. And make no mistake, here you face death."
A simple yet effective piece of dialogue is all it takes to lay the foundation for foreshadowing taking place two movies later with the result of Bane's death. Considering what we were told from Ra's al Ghul about death and how it's such an absolute when things unfold, we're revealed a few things about Bane's death from both a fan and thematic perspective. As fans, we would expect Catwoman to be the last person to end Bane's rampage and save Batman's rear. From a thematic angle, it rings Ra's al Ghul's words true that death itself can come from anywhere, when we least expect it and under the most unruly of circumstances.

1. The Final Product Will Never Be How We Imagine It

Dark Knight Rises As with the Joker reasoning, I'm going to be very blunt and straight to the point with the final point of this article. This final reason is something we all can relate to, I think, given that there isn't one person alive who awaited the release of their most anticipated film and got exactly what they thought they were going to get. Whether they visualized the entire film in their heads or just a assumed a few things, there's no way it came out as they imagined entirely. With TDKR, I presumed a lot of things myself. For one, I assumed Batman would get his back broken by Ban, that - somehow - Ra's al Ghul would come back from the dead, and that Batman would have to sit the rest of the film out while Joseph Gordon-Levitt played Jean-Paul Valley and became Azrael, taking down Bane until Bruce Wayne healed up, after which he would then try to stop Azrael. I really wanted Jean-Paul Valley to be in the film. When I discovered he wouldn't appear, I wasn't upset. Looking at the end product, I'm glad I was wrong. But having my hopes dashed at seeing an almost direct tred of Knightfall, Knightquest, and KnightsEnd really didn't pain me as much as I thought it would. Because I knew, in the end, that the final product could never have been how I imagined it would. I understand there are fans out there who felt the repercussions of not seeing their direct vision for the film emphasised in the final product, and I understand why they might upset about it, but we must all come to fathom the horrible yet honest truth: we can't judge something merely because our imaginations have been turned down. Let's hear it: what do you guys think? Do all these reasons do TDKR justice? Do you disagree or agree? Are there other reasons that you feel should have been included? I'm eager to hear to the responses. Feel free to discuss it below in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Ryan Glenn is an amateur writer in pursuit of a career in both the writing and graphic design fields. He currently attends the Art Institutes of Illinois and looks to go back for a degree in journalism. A reader of an exhaustive library of books and an adept music and video game lover, there's no outlet of media that he isn't involved in or doesn't love.