6 Reasons Why Jaws Is Secretly A Western
You're gonna need a bigger... horse!?
Let's talk about Jaws, Steven Spielberg's tale of a rampaging, rogue shark terrorising an island community. Upon release in the Summer of 1975, the film became an instant classic and almost single handedly invented the summer blockbuster.
Is Jaws an adventure movie, an action blockbuster or a horror movie? All these descriptions are apt, however, search deeper within the celluloid and you will uncover undeniable evidence that in fact Jaws is Steven Spielberg's first, and to date, only...Western.
Call it far fetched, call it over reaching, but all the tropes are there. It's well known that Spielberg is a big fan of John Ford's The Searchers and as legend has it (okay, that's dramatic) according to interviews Spielberg has given over the years, he screens it to his cast and crew before embarking on creating a new moving picture.
So saddle up, here's why Jaws is actually a Western...
6. Amity Island
Amity Island (Amity, as you know, means friendship) is isolated, surrounded by ocean, naturally, and cut off from the mainland. Replace the ocean with desert and you could have any number of frontier towns in any number of westerns.
The islanders are a close knit community who don't take well to outsiders as evidenced when Ellen Brody is informed that she will never be an islander; their complaints about out of town car number plates; and barely sealed frustration at Chief Brody not understanding the town's economics and their reliance on 'summer dollars'.
Even when Richard Dreyfuss' Hooper turns up to help he is looked upon with suspicion by Robert Shaw's Quint, with his city ways and city hands.
5. The Shark
The Shark (do we call it Jaws?) is depicted mostly through John Williams' chillingly simple score...duh dum duh dum, is this the shark's heart beat, is it our heart beat!? This pure force of nature terrorises a small island community, picking off its citizens, slinking back into the ocean depths, silent, unchallenged.
Take the opening seen of Jaws; during the terrifying, brutal assault on poor Chrissie Watkins the audience are barely given even a glimpse of the terror beneath the waves. Indeed it seems incomprehensible to some that this could be a shark attack, even if others are in denial. All that is known for sure is that a young woman is snatched away in the most frightening of circumstances.
Let's compare this with The Searchers (a film Jaws shares D.N.A. with at an almost primal level). The attack on the Edwards home is equally as horrifying, the Native Americans (often depicted in troubling fashion, particularity in early examples of the genre) are, like the shark, unseen, silent, their presence portrayed through the flashing of mirrors and suggestion of smoke in the distance. The result of the attack is just as devastating, in this case two young girls snatched from their homes.
The most effective element of both scenes is that the true terror is left to the imaginations of the audience. Women and Children being slaughtered, fear spreading through the town, the community looking to the law to save them...it's adding up.
4. The Main Trio
Quint, Brody, Hooper - the grizzled old timer, the Sheriff and the young gunslinger. Characters that could be straight out of Rio Bravo. Quint has been there, done that and harpooned the t-shirt; Brody is the Sheriff out to save his town; and Hooper the cocky youngster out to prove his worth.
Three men, far from home, out on the frontier...sounds like a Howard Hawks picture.
3. Chief/Sheriff Brody
The new Sheriff in town! From the first moments we meet Chief Brody it's clear he's not from these parts, with his New York accent and his faltering attempts at an Amity Island accent (pahking the cah in the yahd). Brody isn't disliked by the townsfolk as such, but they aren't quite ready to embrace him. Mayor Vaughn runs the show and Brody, as evidenced when he doesn't close the beaches after the death of Alex Kintner, is trying to not ruffle the town's feathers (the corrupt Mayor, the righteous Sheriff, another Western trope).
There are similarities between Brody and Gary Cooper's Marshall Will Kane in High Noon, in that the community doesn't quite trust him, they don't rally around him and he can't rely on their support. In fact until Richard Dreyfus's Hooper shows up, he's very much on his own.
It could be argued that Brody doesn't take the threat of the shark seriously until his son Michael has a close encounter. The shot of Brody staring out to sea, with the vast blue framed by the pier, is pure John Ford.
2. Quint's Obsession
Quint's obsession with finding and killing the shark is both personal and dangerous and has huge similarities to Ethan Edwards in The Searchers (we're back there again). They are both determined to kill their quarry and their single mindedness drives their character's actions. Sure Quint could be based on Captain Ahab, but think of the ruthlessness displayed by Wayne's Edwards. He's frightening; he's uncompromising; he clashes with Jeffrey Hunter's Marty, who's idealism and naivete grate at him.
The moment Quint destroys the Orca's radio it's clear there is no going back; it's him or the shark. Similarly Ethan Edwards had no intention of turning back, as sure as the turning of the earth he's determined to find his prey. Neither character has a place in their respective societies. Quint is happiest on his battered fishing boat, even if he surely needs a bigger one and Edward's on his horse - living off the land; sleeping under the stars; always in pursuit.
Both men are defined by the hunt, unrelenting, purposeful, with no care for the impact their actions have on others. In this they could be interchangeable.
1. Gunfight On The Orca
After all of Quint's tricks and all of Hooper's technology have failed, the final showdown between man and beast comes down to a shootout. Who will blink first? Brody perched upon the mast of the sinking Orca or the shark charging him, chewing on the air canister which was stuffed into it's mouth moments before; reminiscent of Clint Eastwood chewing on a cigar in a classic spaghetti western.
The shark with no name versus the sheriff. It's classic western territory, this could be The Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, A Fist Full of Dollars, Shane, take your pick.
We all know who wins, the Sheriff rides (swims) back to his town victorious, the shark sinks to the depths. This ocean wasn't big enough for the both of them.