6 Reasons Why Zach Braff Shouldn't Be On Kickstarter

Kickstarter

If a celebrity asked me for money to make a film without a profit sharing scheme in place and with no hope of ever getting my money back, I€™d probably tell them to stick a boom mic somewhere rather painful. But if you starred in Scrubs and do it over the internet, people you€™ve never met will throw up to thousands of dollars at you. In the past few weeks, a lot has been said (including a very fair defence on this site) about Scrubs star Zach Braff using crowd-funding website Kickstarter to fund his film Wish I Was Here, a comedy he is directing and starring in. Over 39,000 people have given him money, even more couldn€™t care less, and a small number of people including Screen Junkies think that him asking people to donate money for his film is a load of bull. I€™m one of that second lot of people, so here are 6 reasons why Zach Braff shouldn€™t be on Kickstarter...

6. He Asked For A Ridiculous Amount

Zach Braff Kickstarter

The goals of people on Kickstarter are sometimes a bit pie in the sky. I€™ve seen people looking for $50,000 worth of funding before now and I€™m sure there are some people who have asked for more. But Zach Braff has taken that to a whole new level with his Kickstarter request for Wish I Was Here: $2 million. Asking for $2 million from total strangers for what sounds like a vanity project is just taking the mick. If it was a Kickstarter for some kind of charity project with a more modest budget, I€™d personally be more than happy to kick in a few quid. Wish I Was Here, on the other hand, is a way for Zach Braff to make money with a ridiculous financial goal that donors are expected to help reach without ever seeing a penny of the film€™s profits. What€™s even more astonishing that he€™s making requests for up to $10,000 from individual people. Kickstarter€™s not there to raise millions of dollars. You€™d be hard pressed to find someone on there whose project deserves millions of dollars, to be honest. But if you are asking for that kind of money, the rewards you offer had better be pretty damn spectacular. Which brings me to my next point...

5. His Perks Don€™t Really Seem Worth it

Zach Braff Kickstarter Perks What makes Kickstarter donations worth it is that nine times out of ten, you€™ll get something in return like a t-shirt or one of the products that you€™ve helped to fund. It€™s a nice feature of the scheme that not only stops you feeling short-changed, but allows the beneficiary to show their gratitude to the benefactors. But when it comes to choosing perks, you€™ve got to make them worth the money you get for them. Something that Zach Braff didn€™t really succeed in doing. For example, a perk in exchange for a $10,000 donation is having a role with a single line in the film. Braff is expecting a person to pay a ridiculous amount to appear in the film and for them to pay for their own travel and accommodation. That is not how filmmaking works. People don€™t pay to be in films and even if your actors are working for free, you pay their expenses. It€™s common courtesy and builds a better relationship between actor and director. And $10,000 for a single line an indie film goes beyond insulting and borders on insane. But I digress. What Braff is offering people as perks are nowhere near worth what they€™re expected to pay. You don€™t even get the film on DVD unless you put in at least $150. Even with Braff€™s autograph on the DVD and a few other bits and pieces such as an invite to an advance screening that carries over from lesser donations, the donation far outstrips the reward. Kickstarter is about communal support and, in some ways, the donations could be considered as charitable. But if you€™re providing a perk, you€™ve got to make it worth it.

4. He Seems Unwilling To Compromise His Vision

Wish I Was Here Concept Art

As much as I respect filmmakers who want to retain creative integrity, the fact of the matter is that filmmaking will always require compromise. Whether it€™s compromise with other people on creative matters or having to change things because of budget, it€™s going to happen at some point. Because this isn€™t a magical fantasy land where everything you want will come true, and in filmmaking more than any other business, you can€™t always have what you want. For example, the project I am currently working on is pretty ambitious and because I€™ll be making it on a shoestring budget and it€™s being used as my university final year project, some scenes or concepts will have to go to make the film possible and to get the best possible grade. But I€™m fine with that. Not being able to fully realise your vision is a sad reality of filmmaking. If I, a nineteen year old with an ego the size of Essex, can realise this and work around these constraints, a professional filmmaker like Zach Braff should be able to. Because when things aren€™t working out the way you hoped, you€™ve got to make do and try your best to not make the compromises hurt your film.

3. He€™s Rich And Well Connected

Jim Parsons Kickstarter Video Still

The figure of $22 million has been bandied about as Braff€™s estimated net worth. Whether or not this is accurate, the point remains that he€™s a popular actor who was reportedly earning $350,000 for every episode of Scrubs he starred in at its peak. All the evidence points towards him being completely minted. With his kind of money and connections, he should be able to find some other way of funding his film rather than asking the public for money. For example, he wants to cast Jim Parsons (The Big Bang Theory) in one of the lead roles and give Donald Faison (Scrubs) a cameo. Parsons and Faison both appear his panhandling video that€™s on the Kickstarter page so the question is if he can either pay them to appear in that video or get them to do it for free, why can he not either negotiate with them to appear in the film at a low rate or even ask them to help him fund the film. In the 1970s, African-American director Melvin Van Peebles was refused studio financing for his film Sweet Sweetback€™s Badaasssss Song but managed to get a $50,000 loan from comedian Bill Cosby that funded the bulk of it. That€™s the kind of thing Braff should be doing to fund his film given that he€™s been a high profile celebrity for at least a decade now. He€™s got money and connections. For a man in his position, a little initiative can yield big results.

2. He Had Already Been Offered Funding

Zach Braff Kickstarter Video Still

If Braff€™s film was a well-established franchise with a wide fanbase that really didn€™t have any other hope of financial backing like the Veronica Mars film was, the use of Kickstarter might be acceptable. Wish I Was Here does not fit that category. It€™s a quirky indie film that Braff is directing and starring in. And at least one studio had already seen its potential and agreed to front the money that Braff was after. But because he worried that the lack of creative control he€™d have would negatively affect the film and he wouldn€™t be given the film€™s final cut, he turned them down. Like I€™ve said before, if it comes to a point where you have to compromise in order to make your film, knuckle under and make the best of it. Or alternatively, find a studio that will give you the control you want or look for different ways of funding that aren€™t Kickstarter.

1. It Sets A Worrying Precedent

Zach Braff Kickstarter Video Still 2

As an aspiring filmmaker hoping to partly fund my first project through Kickstarter, I consider this to be a worrying development. Kickstarter is there for people who can€™t afford their small projects and have practically no hope of getting any notable financial backing. What it most definitely is not there for is to act as a platform for celebrities to use for their vanity projects after having a tantrum and refusing studio backing.

The fact that Braff raised just over 125% of what he asked for is the most worrying thing. Because it means that celebrities using Kickstarter is feasible. And if Kickstarter becomes filled with celebrities asking for money, it means attention that will be diverted away from the little man. The people who only want a few thousand pounds or perhaps even less and who don€™t really have many other avenues of funding will slowly be squeezed out of Kickstarter and similar schemes, and replaced by sitcom stars who want to make films but don€™t want to risk a lot of their own assets or give too much control to a financial backer. Braff himself says in his promotional video that he thinks this could start a paradigm where more people (and by people he really means celebrities) can use the website to fund their smaller personal films. This is completely contrary to the spirit of Kickstarter and the reason it was created. To quote Hal Rudnick of Screen Junkies, "Kickstarter is for the penniless dreamer." I can€™t speak for anyone but myself but it€™s my firm belief that unless they€™re donating money or raising funds for a charity scheme, the rich and famous should stay the hell away from Kickstarter since its entire point is being an avenue of funding for people who don't have their wealth or connections. What do you think of Zach Braff using Kickstarter? Let us know in the comments section below.

In this post: 
Kickstarter
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

JG Moore is a writer and filmmaker from the south of England. He also works as an editor and VFX artist, and has a BA in Media Production from the University Of Winchester.