3. James Roday
I'm no huge fan of
Psych, but I can't deny Roday's obvious comedic chops. That's something that could really translate well in a role like Electro, and like Aaron Paul, I'd like to see Roday at his most unrestrained. He's got the look for Dillon and could pretty convincingly play both sides of manic and depressive. And I don't see Electro jumping into the third part of this new trilogy, so having him around for one film wouldn't exhaust his presence (as a character like Electro
can get very exhausting when overdone). Roday works and deserves a shot. He's already carrying a show on his back (with help from Dule Hill), so tackling this role shouldn't be too much of a challenge.