7 Actors Who Beat Their Star Persona

Mifune_zps177f616d When it comes to cinematic performance, there are two common types of modern actors. There are the method actors and those with a star persona. There are also theatrical actors, but these are practically extinct in the film and television world of today. Method actors are what are often labeled as chameleons. They are actors who are capable of inhabiting any role by being a character rather than pretending to be one. This is achieved through the method of isolating personal experiences, memories, and psychology and personifying it onto their role. Actors like these include Robert De Niro, Marlon Brando, Montgomery Clift, James Dean, Eli Wallach, Viggo Mortensen, Daniel Day Lewis, and the list continues. A common misconception is that method actors are ones who are unidentifiable from one role to the next. Daniel Day Lewis€™ Daniel Plainview from There Will Be Blood is nearly the antithesis of his Abraham Lincoln. However, this is merely an extension of the method, even if differences between the characters they play is a common indication. There are several non-method actors who achieve the same result through their own process and skill. Peter Sellers, for example, is one who changes drastically from one role to the next, but he is no method actor in €˜Stanivlaskian€™ definition. He is simply talented, gifted, and imaginative at pretending to be a German, an Englishman, and an American in Dr. Strangelove. Method actor, though? No. Star persona, on the other hand, is a type of actor who is successful at playing a typecast role. Chances are that whenever an actor like Arnold Schwarzenegger, for instance, plays a non-action role, the film will tank. If either Hugh or Cary Grant ever tried to not play a charming, smooth man, then the film would drown in heartbroken fans€™ tears. Success is only assured to actors like these when they continuously perform in the genre to which they most conform. As long as Arnold Schwarzenegger acts in an action flick, people will watch it. It is a matter of expecting rather than accepting when watching their films. But what about those with a cemented star persona who manage to escape it? There are countless examples of actors who crash and burn when they attempt this, but every once in a while, some actors parachute their way against the flow. This article will focus on seven actors who managed to escape their star persona and tumble-dried audiences with the unprecedented success in their trial. Be warned that spoilers lie ahead!

7. Leonardo DiCaprio in Django Unchained

django-unchained-2 DiCaprio has always been a talented actor unafraid of accepting challenging roles, so his stance in this article is not meant as target practice against his reputable filmography. And, yes, this includes Titanic. Nevertheless, his performance as Calvin Candie in Tarantino€™s Django Unchained stands out in comparison to his other roles for one broad reason €“ it is against everything that the man represents. DiCaprio became a household name after Titanic, due to his attractive and boyish look, charm, and his heartthrob popularity. As a result, he became a leading man and typecast as the hero of every storyline. His versatility as an actor is rarely ever questioned, since he has proven himself in much darker tones and atmospheres. Danny Archer in Blood Diamond, Frank Wheeler in Revolutionary Road, Billy in The Departed, Teddy Daniels in Shutter Island, and many other roles demonstrated that even though he is the one with which the viewers are meant to sympathize, DiCaprio has never feared getting his hands dirty with riskier zones. When Tarantino came along, though, audiences met an unexplored side of his €“ one that will not return any time soon, unfortunately. Despite playing darker roles throughout his career €“ especially under Martin Scorsese€™s wing €“ Tarantino morphed his talent into a fist clenching, vile villain. His charm is ever present as he sways viewers with his suave, Southern accent, but his character€™s intentions forces us to regurgitate our original impressions. Racist, a murderer, ignorant, unrepentant, and egotistically evil, Calvin Candie is Leonardo DiCaprio raising the bar once more. Why is it that the charming villains are always the scariest yet the ones who prevent you from looking away? Out of all his deaths on screen, none brought more relief than this one. Should have been nominated for an Oscar, folks.

6. Brad Pitt in Burn After Reading

Alike DiCaprio, Brad Pitt is a humanitarian heartthrob unafraid of exploring the potential of his craft. Many also doubt his talent merely because it is hard to accept that someone as handsome can also possess as much talent. In short, folks, he does €“ if he always has is another question entirely. Before he became a household name, Brad Pitt already started experimenting and made it perfectly clear that he had no intention of becoming a typecast pretty boy a la Channing Tatum. His performances in Se7eN, 12 Monkeys, and Fight Club asserted that the man aimed to stand the test of time, and we are pretty sure that he has by now. As soon as the noughties came along, however, one can tell that he grew severely comfortable with his celebrity lifestyle and personality. He still appeared in commercial hits like the Ocean€™s trilogy, Mr. & Mrs. Smith, and Troy, but he discontinued his delivery of demanding performances. The man played himself and succumbed to the star persona that the global media labeled him as €“ a charismatic sex symbol €“ which personifies the kind of career path by which DiCaprio was unwilling to cruise. He unbuckled his seat belt once more in 2006 with Babel, thankfully, and viewers rekindled to the profound actor that was thought to be long gone. The Assassination of Jesse James and the Coward Robert Ford cemented his return, but his performance in Burn After Reading caused various jaws to hang like sails on a ship unraveling as soon as the wind pops by. This sharply dressed, handsome, magnetic, emotionally deep celebrity morphed into a doofus. A jester. A joke. A member of the frat pack. And a bloody hilarious one. Never will you see someone with Brad Pitt€™s star power achieve this more than once. Otherwise, the trend and expectancy would develop into one that could hinder his future roles. That is something that only auteurs like the Coen Brothers could ever come up with: €œlet€™s pay the most famous and sexiest actor on the planet €“ man that countless of people look up to €“ millions of dollars to play a man with a cow€™s IQ€. Brad Pitt received a BAFTA nomination for his performance, and it verifies that a pinch of the Brad Pitt from the 90s remained. Can you really believe that the man who played Jesse James and Benjamin Button managed to squeeze a role like Chad Feldheimer€™s right in between them? The role may not be his most challenging, but definitely his most unique.

5. Jerry Lewis in The King of Comedy

TheKingofComedy_zps6e67207b Jerry Lewis may not be along the all time greats like Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton in regards to slapstick humor, but his imprint is hardly ever going to fade away. His screwball faces when he orchestrated his slippery, clumsy routine on stage would transfer to the screen and provide thunderous laughter to many. He may have never achieved critical acclaim film-wise nor pieces that would be regarded amongst the greatest of all time, but people did not buy tickets for his films for the sake of cinematic integrity. They solely attended to slap their foreheads whenever something inexplicable would tumble towards them. Martin Scorsese noticed his acting potential, somehow, and it will astonish many that the King of Comedy is nothing to laugh about. Lewis plays Jerry Langford, a successful comedian stalked by De Niro€™s Rupert Pupkin. Pupkin pursuits his happiness by becoming a celebrity comedian like his idol and pressures the man into a professional meeting in order to kickstar his stand up career. Unfortunately for Pupkin, nothing ever comes easily in life. Lewis€™ role may not be memorable, but this is perhaps what shocks audiences. One expects a wacky, indescribable buffoon, but we are granted a straightforward, off-camera, and boring persona. If anything, he is a grouch irritated by Pupkin€™s persistence. To be fair, how else would one react when held hostage? De Niro€™s performance eclipsed Lewis€™ in every way unsurprisingly, so Lewis is rarely ever acknowledged when the film is discussed. Try asking anyone out there if they recognize who €˜the other guy€™ is, though, and I guarantee not many will notice that it is The Nutty Professor. He triumphs in this aspect, at least.

4. Toshiro Mifune in I Live in Fear

ILiveinFear_zps822cbb30 When one asks what five things pop to mind when one hears €˜Akira Kurosawa€™, it is impossible not to think of Toshiro Mifune. Rashomon, Yojimbo, Seven Samurai, Stray Dog, High and Low, and many, many other collaborations mark this pair as probably the biggest in cinema history, edging the likes of Belmondo and Godard or De Niro and Scorsese in my book. A film of his that is not as renowned is I Live in Fear, one of the many post-war world cinema achievements that slowly asserted that film was evolving into a sociological art form. It is shameful that this, according to IMDB, is Kurosawa€™s first film to not break its budget even upon release. The Second World War and the bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki were everything but forgotten in Japan, and I Live in Fear developed into an analysis of the national €“ and global €“ concern from a country that already tasted biochemical warfare. Normally, Mifune permeates his dominance on screen. Once he fills the frame, your eyes will always be glued onto him. He owns the room, and as Kurosawa said himself, €œhe could convey in only three feet of film an emotion for which the average Japanese actor would require ten feet€. This was no different in Kurosawa€™s post-war drama, but confidence, wisdom, integrity, courage, and honor are few words that defined Mifune€™s star persona. His role in I Live in Fear is an exception. Mifune plays a paranoid, nervous, fragile and frightened old man whose only solution to evading imminent pulverization was the migration to Brazil. His entire family opposes, since he would sacrifice the family business in doing so, but fear forces even the strongest of men to succumb to insecurity. Not only is his performance singular, but his make-up also hides the very face that enchanted many cinema-goers. Perhaps this may be the reason of the film€™s failure in the Japanese box office.

3. Humphrey Bogart in The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

TreasureoftheSierraMadre_zps6c58aaee Humphrey Bogart is one of the most iconic faces in American cinema. He appeared in several films prior to the 1940s, and his most memorable was probably the backstabbing George Hally in The Roaring Twenties, starring James Cagney. His roles in High Sierra and The Maltese Falcon, though, caught the eyes of cinema-goers, but Casablanca propelled him into Hollywood stardom, and he would never be forgotten from then onwards. His droning, choppy delivery, his deadpan expressions, his chain smoking, and €“ most significantly €“ his noble intentions (despite appearing to not care less) towards others turned into his trademark. He became a symbol of the film noir era, and it unsurprised viewers to see him as a hard-boiled detective and wounded antihero. In other words, he became the Bruce Wayne of the generation, before Batman ever transcended the €˜legend radar€™. When he re-teamed up with John Huston for The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, on the other hand, nobody expected the outcome. Humphrey Bogart, naturally top billed and with the largest face and name on the film€™s poster, played a bohemian beggar stuck in Tampico, Mexico. With rags as attire and sporting a beard that could polish a diamond, he looked different albeit not alien. He was an actor after all, and everybody expected that everything would go his way by the ending. It almost did, and not in a way one could imagine. Bogart€™s Fred Dobbs was a carnivorous leech injected with lethal doses of greed, and it perplexed viewers how somebody like Bogart could convince us of wearing dollar-signed shades despite representing the heart of Hollywood cinema for almost a decade. A scene that stands out is when he kills and digs Curtin€™s body in order to hide the corpse. His insanity is palpable as he questions whether or not he did so without leaving a shred of evidence, and viewers notice how his rationality and decadence wrestle against one another. The winner is clear when he keeps Curtin€™s portion of gold. It comes as no shock how Paul Thomas Anderson used The Treasure of the Sierra Madre as inspiration for There Will Be Blood. Humphrey Bogart€™s performance is also criminally ignored, especially when one considers how Walter Huston ended up with the Best Supporting Actor Oscar and Bogart did not even score a nomination.

2. James Stewart in any Alfred Hitchcock film

JimmyStewart_zps98532828€œAww, shucks.€ Those two words alone label James Stewart. He was America€™s sweetheart. Who cannot find his performances in films like Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, It€™s a Wonderful Life, Harvey, and The Shop Around the Corner as adorable expressions withdrawn from the heart? James Stewart was an American symbol due to his lighthearted delivery. He usually played the shy, incorruptible, and innocent man who provided smiles even to those parched from a doses of passion and sentiment. He was a hero who stood by ideals and gifted even the most undeserved with the benefit of the doubt €“ at least until the master of suspense came along. Hitchcock is amongst the most famous directors of all time. Not a single thriller out there can claim to not be indebted to his influence. Few praise the magnificent performances that he managed to squeeze out of his actors, and Stewart remains a prime example. Jimmy Stewart is a stranger in films like Rope, Rear Window, The Man Who Knew Too Much, and most importantly, Vertigo. How can the Stewart revered in the United States fit within these storylines, then? How can you have a Hitchcock thriller and mystery with a man incapable of sharing a shadow of a doubt? No pun intended. Hitchcock turned Stewart into a self-assured and macabre critical thinker. The beauty of this transformation is that his distrust, obsession, and ego culminated the narratives of each film; without Stewart€™s newfound investigative nature, the films would not conclude in the ways they did. Phillip and Brandon would get away with murder in Rope; Madeleine would have always been dead in Vertigo; his neighbor would succeed in hiding the corpse in Rear Window. A normal James Stewart would probably be dumbfounded and refuse to incriminate another for murder; he struggled enough denouncing his nature with politics in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. How could he possibly pull through in a Hitchcock film when something as sanguine as death was involved? He did - and in incredible fashion.

1. Jean Claude Van Damme in JCVD

JCVD_zps6d571030 If you have yet to see JCVD, then this is your homework assignment for tonight. The Muscles from Brussels, a critically acclaimed and unfathomably deep actor? The guy from Bloodsport and Street Fighter? No way. Jean Claude Van Damme is one of the quintessential action stars in cinema€™s history. The 80s and 90s marked a time where action films starred men like Steven Seagal, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Sylvester Stallone, Dolph Lundgren, among others, and they refused to hide behind CGI. With assistance of stunt doubles or not, everything they did was real. Some even fought professionally at some point, and Jean Claude Van Damme was no different. As a result, nobody ever expected the man the exchange his fists for his heart when JCVD was out. The film received a lot of buzz, and €“ unless you read reviews or watched the trailer beforehand €“ nobody really could calculate why, especially when remembering all the tripe defecated by Van Damme the last few years. Was it revolutionary action scenes? No, the budget was too low. Could it be the rise of a new, endowed director, then? Yes, partially. But it was mostly Van Damme, and I instantly forgave him. His acting peaks with a surreal and touching confession most likely occurring within the shadiest areas of his mind. His chair elevates him to the ceiling, and this shatters the fourth wall as camera shooting lights are suddenly visible. This signifies that the audience is no longer a member of a fictional story; this is the real JCVD pouring his soul and his past sins upon us, his entrusted witnesses. Everything else is a movie. Not this. This will be the closest Van Damme will ever be to embracing Stanivlaski€™s method, and it feels like a public apology regarding his former drug abuse, his failed love life, and his regretful celebrity lifestyle. Remarkable, Jean Claude. Simply remarkable. What do you guys think? Is anybody missing? Please let us know in the comments!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm currently enrolled in the Film Studies program at the University of Copenhagen in Denmark. If you haven't guessed by now, movies and media are as a big of a passion for me as they are for you and would love to hear what you've gotta say as well!