7 Comedies That Should Have Been Great (But Weren't)

4787young adult

There are some comedies that look terrible from the start. You see who's in 'em, what they're about and decide to keep your money in your pocket. And then there are those comedies that emerge only once every few years. Not for them the lazy sequel, the last, spluttering breath of an exhausted franchise; no, these are actual funny jokes and well-rounded characters. And so, having watched the trailer a few hundred times, you excitedly tell your friends that this, this is the film that will restore their faith in cinema. They're not convinced, so you throw around words like 'edgy' and 'self-referential' and tell them to stop rolling their eyes. This must have worked because, the next thing you know, there's a ticket stub in your hand. You find your seat, slap a big, expectant grin on your face and prepare for the time of your life. But something isn't quite right. Yeah,you've smirked a couple of times and maybe the odd line has raised a half-hearted chuckle...but is this really it? Where did all the funny go? Maybe they squandered the perfect ensemble cast. Maybe they used up all their best lines in the trailer. Or maybe that much-hyped surprise cameo really wasn't all that. Sure, you've been stung countless times in the past but for one reason or another, the seven examples below had duped you into thinking they were different. They're by no means failures, just disappointments. Put simply, these are the films that sounded better in your head than they did on the screen. Contains spoilers

7. Casa De Mi Padre

casa-de-mi-padre-still-1

Why It Should Have Been Great: Will Ferrell in a spoof of Latin American telenovelas, complete with melodramatic love scenes, deliberately shoddy effects and gloriously over the top shoot-outs? Sí, por favor! Following a stylish title sequence, Casa de mi Padre begins as a pitch-perfect parody. As the dim-witted 'ranchero' Armando Alvarez, Ferrell confounds expectations by leaving his shouty man-child schtick north of the border. Here, he's surprisingly restrained. He's even speaking Spanish. Why It Wasn't: Sadly, this wasn't enough to distract us from the fact that, for all its B-movie affectations (continuity errors, terrible dialogue), the film was apparently more fun to write than it was to watch. As Armando sets out to rescue his brother's girlfriend (Génesis Rodriguez) from a group of drug barons, we brace ourselves for a barrage of Mexploitation gags that never quite take shape. Instead, the film eschews jokes for a straightforward action story, meaning that the biggest laughs are mostly confined to the opening ten minutes. An early highlight sees gunmen lay waste to a wedding, sparking a showdown practically dripping with symbolism; yet such chaos cannot compete with the rival network melee in Anchorman, still Ferrell's finest work. Teetering somewhere between a spaghetti western and a swooning romance, the point doesn€™t really stretch to eighty minutes and a strong start soon leads to an extended (and typically inconsistent) €˜Funny or Die€™ sketch. Gael García Bernal seems to enjoy playing against type - looking every inch the Mexican Tony Montana- but, in constantly reaching for his pistol, he inadvertently reflects the film's tendency to miss more often than it hits.

6. The League Of Gentlemen's Apocalypse

league of gentlemen's apocalypseWhy It Should Have Been Great: With the groundwork already set by a radio programme, three series and a Christmas special, we knew that the show could be dark. And funny. And so a feature-length spin-off could be darker and funnier still. Although an extended episode would suit some followers just fine, the transition from small screen to big requires the stakes to be raised considerably higher. After all, it is the end of the world... Why It Wasn't: Our beloved characters and catchphrases may be intact- but they're swamped under ninety minutes of self-indulgence. Just get a load of the synopsis: After the show's writers decide to kill off their creations in favour of writing a historical horror feature called The King's Evil, they are shocked to find that their characters - Tubbs, Edward, Hilary and all- have escaped their universe and stumbled into ours. And so we have the writers (Steve Pemberton, Reece Shearsmith and Mark Gatiss) playing not only themselves and their LoG characters but also those from The King's Evil. Simultaneously. All, that is, except writer Jeremy Dyson, who doesn't want to end the show and, for the purposes of this film, is being played by Martin Sheen. Such meta-fictional razzle-dazzle bears the mark of Charlie Kaufman but none of the wit. Instead, it feels as though the film has decided it would rather be clever than comic; swirling together the three storylines in the hope that something funny will suddenly- miraculously - fly out. If you're a fan of the show, you'll have already seen better sketches. If you're new to the League, this isn't the most promising place to start.

5. The Dictator the-dictator-review

Why It Should Have Been Great: After striking comedy gold not once but twice with Borat and Brüno (we'll just ignore Ali G Indahouse for now, shall we?), the fearlessly funny Sacha Baron Cohen took on a more foreboding disguise: playing the intolerant but all-powerful leader of a fictional North African republic, currently on a state visit to the US. But, you know, for laughs. Why It Wasn't: The trailers had made it crystal clear. This was not to be a mockumentary, a format that had fit Cohen and director Larry Charles' previous collaborations like a glove, but instead a scripted comedy. Immediately, this robbed the film of its volatility - a characteristic that, until now, had unquestionably been part of the fun. And so no matter how jaw-droppingly offensive General Admiral Aladeen may be, he's not out to provoke the man on the (New York) street; here, he's cocooned in the comfort of other actors: kidnapped by John C. Reilly and then hired by Anna Faris. Had Cohen kept the hidden camera routine and simply wandered around America claiming to be a real political leader, then perhaps this film would have made more of an impact.

4. Be Kind Rewind

be kind rewindWhy It Should Have Been Great: With Michel Gondry in the director's chair, and Jack Black and Mos Def frantically (but affectionately) re-enacting your favourite film scenes, what's not to love? Why It Wasn't: Despite a brilliant premise, the film reaches a crossroads around the halfway point; unsure whether it should be a quirky comedy or sappy drama. So instead it tries for both. Def plays the New Jersey video-store clerk left in charge for a few days, and Black his clumsy friend who, after becoming 'magnetized', accidentally erases the shop's entire stock. Together, they set about recreating ,or 'sweding', as many movies as possible and passing them off to the public. Rather than bring the store to the brink of bankruptcy, these videos actually prove more popular than the originals, and so it isn't long before the entire town finds themselves on either side of a camera. The 'sweded' films are excellent- yet again showcasing Gondry's flair for lo-tech flights of fancy- so it's a shame that we barely see more than fifteen minutes' worth. Instead, too much is made of the subplot: bringing the community together to save the store from closure, as well as protecting its status as the (alleged) birthplace of jazz musician Fats Waller. You can't deny that the film has heart; you just wish it wouldn't nosedive into schmaltz so soon and for so long.

3. Young Adult

87young adult

Why It Should Have Been Great: Charlize Theron as Mavis, a self-centred author who wants to steal her ex, Buddy (Patrick Wilson), away from his loving family? Sold! Why It Wasn't: Written by Diablo Cody and directed by Jason Reitman, Young Adult was marketed, somewhat erroneously, as a dark comedy. And so we expected a new benchmark for the bunny boiler; a protagonist we really shouldn't root for, someone as downright despicable as Billy Bob Thornton in Bad Santa. Yet the nastiest Mavis ever gets is when she tells someone to f**k off. The rest of the film is spent following her as she plans to lure Buddy away from his wife, and then moaning to Matt (Patton Oswalt), a former classmate who she barely remembers, when these schemes don't come to fruition. The 'joke' being, of course, that Mavis is too busy complaining about her perfectly privileged life to realise that others have it much worse. For example, Matt has been left disabled from a gang attack and is, understandably, still bitter about it. But, y'know, maybe the pair can share life lessons and help each other to become better people? And so it is with a belated sense of humility that Mavis, having undergone an obligatory Scrooge-like transformation, starts to see the world from a brighter perspective. Which, all things considered, is a bit of a shame.

2. Semi-Pro

semi pro

Why It Should Have Been Great: Yes, a Will Ferrell sports comedy has practically become a genre unto itself but, c'mon, this one's about basketball! And it's set in the Seventies! Why It Wasn't: Clearly humour was invented sometime around 1980. As Jackie Moon, owner, coach and star player of the floundering Flint Tropics, Ferrell has little to do but shout and pout. And as much as we'd like to squint and pretend it's really Ron Burgundy in those basketball shorts, the dialogue just isn't quite the same. Ferrell may thrive on playing these larger-than-life types, but he's best when bouncing off a slightly-less-bonkers supporting cast. Here, however, the rest of the bench, including Woody Harrelson and Andre Benjamin, is reduced to dead wood. In fact, aside from the occasional, incongruous setpieces (such as Moon wrestling a bear) you'll be surprised at how quickly you can forget it's supposed to be a comedy. Indeed, in the plucky underdog finale that you've seen a thousand times before, you're not willing the team to victory-you're counting down the seconds on the clock until it's game over.

1. Ted

120629012941-ted-mark-wahlberg-story-topWhy It Should Have Been Great: Seth MacFarlane's foray into live-action features Mark Wahlberg, Mila Kunis and Ted, a cuddly teddy bear that comes to life thanks to a wish made on a shooting star. Sounds sickly, but make no mistake - it's definitely not a Disney film. MacFarlane's tar-black humour, peppered with a near-endless supply of pop culture references, puts this toy strictly out of children's reach. Why It Wasn't: With credits as director, co-writer, co-producer and leading (voice) actor, it€™s easy to dismiss Ted as simply the latest of MacFarlane€™s vanity projects. Certainly, in rounding up members of his 'Family Guy' cast (Mila Kunis plays the love interest while Alex Borstein and Patrick Warburton have bit parts) and anthropomorphising yet another animal with the very worst of human behaviour, originality is one of the first things noticeable by its absence. Wahlberg plays John Bennett, a man who has taken his childhood friend, a real-life, tough-talking, pot-smoking teddy bear, into his thirties but now has to decide whether he should sacrifice it all for his girlfriend, Lori (Kunis). Needless to say, it's another buddy movie in which the main female character is shown in a less than flattering light. Here Lori is a humourless spoilsport who exists solely to remind our slacker hero about growing up and accepting responsibility. Still, it could be worse: practically every other female character is a prostitute. With his gruff Beantown accent, potty mouth and insatiable appetite for most earthly pleasures, Ted is a character you'll either fall in love with for ever or grow tired of in the opening ten minutes. After the novelty of hearing such filth come from such a cute face wears off, chances are you'll pick the latter. For the film is essentially a substandard rom-com seldom elevated by its scattergun approach to humour (namely, throw enough mud€) and Wahlberg€™s comic timing; the latter impressively showcased in his reeling off of forty €˜white trash€™ girls€™ names without taking a breath. With a nostalgic (masked as ironic) eye to the Eighties, talk of the buddies€™ favourite film, Flash Gordon, inexplicably leads to an over-long running joke (another MacFarlane trait) about its star, Sam J. Jones, demolishing a house party; a scene offensive not for its rather racist denouement but for how weakly it limps to such a finish.Ultimately, for all the shock tactics, Ted is a significantly sweeter film than any amount of four- letter words spat from a stuffed toy would have you believe. It just has a hard time admitting it, that's all.

Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshireman (hence the surname). Often spotted sacrificing sleep and sanity for the annual Leeds International Film Festival. For a sample of (fairly) recent film reviews, please visit whatsnottoblog.wordpress.com.