7 Dumb Films Based On The Titanic You Won’t Believe Got Made
The sinking of the Titanic is a event that, with its horrific, escalating sequence of mistakes and massive loss of life, has captured the imagination of pretty much everyone whos lived in the 101 years since it sank. Dramatisations, on the large and small screen, have played a big part in this, turning the tragedy into an emotionally unifying melodrama, without losing any of the tragic effect. Obviously James Camerons epic (and in many ways definitive) film version that swept the Oscars and the box office played a big part in that, but even before then, particularly in the decades directly following the disaster, theres been a multitude of movies that have looked at Titanic in one way or another. And why not? With the obvious class divide, present in both the ships design and pushed to the fore in its sinking, and Titanic herself serving as a symbol of Empire driven opulence theres a myriad of subtexts to be mined. And once it became convention to have a fictional romance on board the ship be the main attraction (a notion introduced incredibly early on), screenplays began to write themselves. Some, notably Camerons incredible effort and the meticulously researched A Night To Remember (Walter Lord spent 20 years collecting information for the book on which its based), ended up brilliant, but most fall in the category of interesting to fanatics, but vapid to general audiences. And then beyond them theres the films on this list; the movies based around the Titanic tragedy so stupid they'd be written off as a joke if it wasn't for the evidence sitting right in front of you. Strap yourselves in; this is going to be a bumpy one. Honourable Mention - That Disrespectful Red Bull Advert
A couple of months ago Red Bull aired another in their series of crudely drawn, logically skewed adverts, this time claiming that the only reason so many of the passengers of the crew died when the Titanic went down was because there was no Red Bull on board and therefore no one had their wiiings. If you think it sounds too stupid to be true, check the video out below. While theres certainly an a argument that 101 years is enough time for most jokes to be acceptable, that doesn't really stretch to the trivialisation of a catastrophic loss of life. It subsequently received 110 complaints from disgusted viewers, including descendants of those who died, but the ad remained on the air. But hey, at least it understood that Captain Smith was ignorant of the dangers of sea travel, so it did do a bit better than some entries on this list.
7. Saved From The Titanic Comes Out Less Than A Month After The Sinking
The Titanic sank on 15th April 1912. On 14th May 1912 the first film adaptation of the tragedy was released. In less than a month the sinking had gone from actual event happening right now to mass entertainment. The phrase too soon doesn't even come close. Capitalising on actress Dorothy Gibsons presence on the maiden voyage, it has her reliving her experiences, retelling the sinking in the blandest way possible; Gibson was on the first lifeboat released, meaning the story is little more than her feeling the impact, going to the deck and waiting for the Carpathia to pick her up. Theres what sounds like some interesting elements, with lingerie used to plug a leak in the boat and a creative use of archive footage (including the Olympic standing in for its sister ship), although nowadays its mainly remembered for the quick production turnaround. Oddly enough the reaction at the time was rather positive. Of course there were some critics (one called the whole project revolting), but for the most part people were impressed the film managed to show the personal side of the disaster. That really stands out now in a world where the release of The Impossible or United 93 has people tense (heck, even Doctor Who came under fire for its space liner Titanic being disrespectful). The sinking and subsequent media storm proved too much for Gibson. She retired after the emotional strain of that night (and subsequently reliving it) took its toll, while the film was lost in a fire at clair studios a couple of years later. An odd, sensitive (if by modern standards disrespectful) curio that no modern Titanic fanatic will get to see.
6. Titanic II Tries To Trick You Into Thinking James Cameron Made A Sequel
You probably heard a couple of years ago that schlock factory Asylum turned their eyes away from sharks and tornados to make the misleadingly titled Titanic II. Misunderstood by many (probably the same people who mistook the devious Transmorphers for Michael Bays higher in budget, equal in quality Transformers) as a sequel to James Camerons smash hit (people even mused interest if Leonardo DiCaprio was involved), it is a disgusting mess of film that got a lot of flack for its disrespect to both the tragedy and the Oscar winning classic, in many cases sidestepping the fact its just an awful movie. Ignoring how cheap it looks and how terrible the acting is, Titanic II is really more of a straight up disaster movie that conjures up memories of The Poseidon Adventure. Its a survival tale where a group of passengers have to deal with various nautical problems, such as raining icebergs and tsunamis travelling faster than the speed of sound. Suddenly Sharknado isn't too much of a stretch. So yeah, its not really about the Titanic, but the general plot (as well as the tacky advertising) relies entirely on its memory.
5. Joseph Goebbels Retells The Sinking As German Propaganda
The Titanic was going too fast; thats an accepted fact. Its also popular opinion that Bruce Ismay was a key driving force behind the move to break the record to cross the Atlantic. That he was solely motivated in a move to double dip the stocks is borderline conspiracy. And that a German First Officer was the only good man on the ship trying to get his greedy superiors to slow down is a flat out lie. Yet all these elements are melded together in a World War II propaganda film commissioned by Reich Minister of Propaganda Joseph Goebbels that presents the disaster as a folly of British capitalism. Placing all the well meaning Germans in steerage and painting Brits as devious corpse-climbers, it takes so many liberties with the story (there were no German officers on the boat) you wonder why it wasn't simply decided to retell the whole thing as the famous hoax gone wrong myth. Never shown in Germany due to a high loss of German life feeling unsuitable during continued Allied bombings and only receiving a limited release elsewhere, Goebbels eventually hoped it would fade into the same obscurity that welcomed Saved From The Titanic. No such luck; prints somehow survived and it eventually received an uncut release on DVD in 2005. The whole saga is chronicled in the History Channel documentary; Nazi Titanic.
4. Titanic: The Legend Goes On Rips Off James Cameron And Rewrites History So Everyone Survives
If youre ever searching for a list of the worst films of all time, odds are a Titanic animation will pop up at one point or another. A couple of others Ill touch on later, but for now lets look at the one that at least seemed like it tried to do something. That that thing was kidify Camerons billion dollar busting epic is neither here nor there. The story sets itself us as the typical rich meets poor story, with one key difference; its the guy whos first class this time, successfully cutting out any of the social differences all other Titanic dramas use for some reason (maybe because it lends drama). The Heart Of The Oceans tackier cousin also makes an appearance, only with much nicer connotations as Angelicas (poor Rose) only remaining gift from her estranged mother (who surprise, surprise is on the boat too). With the story simplified and no time spent on the actual sinking itself theres surprisingly a lot of time left to fill out the run time. Thankfully a bunch of talking animals who fit snuggly into broad stereotypes are on hand to rap and poorly slapstick their way through that remaining hour. And rapping over half a century before its invention isn't the worst historical accuracy present. That award has to go to the Inglourious Basterds-esque ending where everyone survives; even William (rich Jack) comes out of the sub-freezing water as fresh as a daisy.
3. Raise The Titanic Is So Dumb It Becomes The (Then) Biggest Flop Of All Time
The Titanic wreck was discovered in 1985. Before that we knew very little about what state the ship was in, leading to many outlandish methods being suggested how to save it from the sea floor (my favourite is filling it with ping pong balls). Amidst the hysteria of all these (sadly serious) ideas, things reached fever pitch with the release of Raise The Titanic. Coming amidst Cold War paranoia, the film retcons history to have the Titanic be carrying a Macguffin essential to blah...blah...blah...nuclear weapons, leading to a desperate race to bring the ship back to the surface and plunder her depths. Yeah, its really dumb. Based off the adventure book (part of an ongoing series, rather than a standalone Titanic story) of the same name, albeit lacking the novels out of place exclamation mark (and sense of fun), dont be fooled into thinking its only stupid in hindsight. Critics hated the film, which made back only a fraction of its $40,000,000 budget, making it then one of the biggest flops of all time. Funnily enough, the Cold War did play a part in the discovery of the wreck; the submersibles used to discover it were funded by the US Navy on the condition they could be used on highly classified missions.
2. The Legend Of The Titanic Has The Ship Sunk By An Octopus Tricked By A Gang Of Sharks Driven By Whaling Rights. No, Seriously.
The correct description in the films title really should be Myth, because beyond having the ship existing and coming into contact with an iceberg theres pretty much nothing based on the actual story here. Key story elements (its told in a flashback from the present day and features a rich girl forced to wed against her will who falls in love with a man below her class) suggest that as with The Legend Goes On this is meant to be riding the success of James Camerons film. Yet while that story runs through and travels towards a predictable end, the film really seems much more interested with the events of the sinking. You know the one; a despicable whaler plots a fake marriage to steal rights to new territory, but once magic dolphins blow his cover he has to enlist a gang of sharks to sink the ship, who in turn trick a giant octopus to move an iceberg in the Titanics path. But dont worry - the octopus realises the error of his ways and holds the ship up until everyone has time to get off. Phew. And that summary doesn't even fully highlight how outlandish the whole thing is, nor even scratch the surface of what the producers were smoking when creating the straight-to-VHS movie. Unbelievably, this is the film whose success led to the earlier offender, but quite why this made a dramatic departure from the truth seem like a good idea Ill never know.
1. The Sequel, In Search For The Titanic, Throws In Atlantis Because... I'm Sorry... I Just Cant Do This Any More...
Beating the Asylum to the punch by a good few years, a sequel to The Legend Of Titanic came a couple of years later, despite no one ever asking for it. Intriguingly named In Search For Titanic (somehow translated from the original Italian title Tentacolino), the film doesn't actually spending much time searching for the Titanic instead using the titular mission as a jumping off point so we can revisit the characters from the original film. Because they were such a joy to be around after all. Not finished with milking the iconography of the Titanic, but also keen to capitalise on Disneys recent hit Atlantis, visionary, yet for some reason Wikipedia-entry-less, director Kim J. Ok decided to do both in the same movie. Seemingly merging everything wrong with every film on this list into one horrendously unpalatable mess, its as if the writers mistook Camerons movie as a fiction free for reinterpretation, rather than the tragic mass loss of human life it actually was. Red Bull's beginning to look quite good now. Do you know of any more stupid Titanic films? Which of these have you had the misfortune of seeing? Let us know down in the comments.