7 Early Signs Of The McConaissance

Right now McConaughey's playing for the World Series (of acting) but it's just as exhilarating to see how he qualified.

The other day I saw a denizen of our grand internet ask an apposite question: If it was 5 years ago and I told you that Matthew McConaughey won an Oscar for Best Actor and may win an Emmy for Best Actor in a Drama series in the same year, what would you have said? The smug-faced arse (as opposed to arse-faced smug, or smug-arsed face) of such cinematic travesties as Failure to Launch, Ghosts of Girlfriends Past and Fool's Gold is near-unrecognisable as the recent winner of an Academy Award for Dallas Buyers Club (and not just because he lost what we in the industry call a "Bale-tonne" of weight). It's as if all of a sudden he remembered how to act. And lucky us, because McConaughey 2.0's powerhouse performances have been the standout in films like Mud, Killer Joe, Magic Mike, he had a memorable cameo in Wolf of Wall Street (a movie not short of memorable performances), plus there's his turn as nihilistic homicide detective in HBO series True Detective. That's a level of career rehabilitation that the likes of The Priory can only dream of offering. For most of us, this sudden turn in McConaughey's choice of films and his performances in them seemed to come out of nowhere. The McConaissance, however - much like the renaissance - has been slowly taking place over a period of years, and we've only just begun to appreciate it. Here's a few of the early warning signs that the star of Sahara might have had more to him than pecs and a slappable smirk.

7. Lone Star

The young Texan booked his first big role in John Sayles' crime drama, although his appearance in it isn't much more than a cameo. His character's shadow looms large over the proceedings, however, appearing in flashback as the father of Chris Cooper's reluctant police officer working on the US/Mexico border. Lone Star opens with the discovery of...well, not exactly a body, but a skeleton. With a sheriff's badge. Said sheriff is himself played in the flashbacks by Kris Kristofferson as a nasty little sumbitch who takes bribes, extorts money from local business, and is generally an awful person to the majority black and Hispanic population of his town. Local legend tells that his young deputy, Buddy Deeds (McConaughey) was the only one to ever step up to him, and chased him out of town, never to be seen again. When his bones turn up, that story is called into question. Rather than being a straight crime thriller, the film is really a drama that focuses on the way history plays on the lives of people living today. Most of the heavy lifting is left to Cooper, a young officer who never bought the folk tale depiction of his distant, philandering father, but McConaughey really shines in his few flashback scenes. Near-unrecognisable not because of dropping the pounds but because he's so fresh-faced, he holds his own against Kristofferson at his bonkers best, showing potential that no doubt lead to his first starring role that same year.

6. A Time To Kill

McConaughey's second film of 1996 allowed him a little more screen time (and, weirdly, has Chris Cooper in a small supporting role). A Time to Kill is a courtroom drama from a time when you couldn't swing a Grisham without hitting a courtroom drama, but it stands out from its legion of contemporaries with a complex plot and a particularly striking set of performances, headlined by McConaughey himself as defense lawyer Jake Tyler Brigance. In fact, playing a lawyer seems to bookend the McConaughey wilderness years, but we'll get to that soon enough. It's a film that's never knowingly understated - which, from the director of Batman and Robin, from a book by the author of The Firm, isn't surprising - but the fablestic story matches the bombastic tone. Brigance takes it upon himself to defend Samuel L Jackson's Carl Lee Hailey, accused of murdering the two men who sexually assaulted his 10-year-old daughter. Strong stuff, and the themes of race, justice and revenge allow it to rise above the standard of Grisham's other potboilers. Everyone in the cast is as the top of their game, from the righteously angry and grieving Jackson to hungry, upcoming legal aid Sandra Bullock, to Kevin Spacey as the arrogant attorney for the prosecution who takes on the highly publicised case to help his campaign for District Attorney. McConaughey, though, steals the show not just as the protagonist but as a three-dimensional character whose motivations for representing Hailey may be just as selfish as Spacey's. He is charismatic without being smug, conflicted without being cliched, and his closing monologue might not match Jackson's famous line (later used to sell beer) for intensity, but certainly does for sheer grandstanding acting.

5. The Newton Boys

His second role in a Richard Linklater film may not be as well remembered (or quoted) as his first, but McConaughey's follow up to Dazed and Confused gives him a lot more to work with. Taking the lead in this based-on-true story, McConaughey's Willis Newton ropes his brothers (Ethan Hawke, Vincent D'Onofrio and Skeet Ulrich) into thinking a little bigger than the small-town country life they're used to. The life of the bank robber awaits them. Where Hawke is hampered by a dodgy fake moustache and Ulrich by being Skeet Ulrich in something other than Scream, McConaughey strikes the perfect balance he never managed in the like of The Wedding Planner. Instead of being simply smarmy and self-satisfied and some sort therefore a romantic lead, the confidence and easy charm he imbues the character with makes it easy to believe he was such a successful criminal - and so adept at getting out of sticky situations. "You don't look like any criminal I've ever seen," a character tells McConaughey's Willis Newton at one point. And they've got a point. His character, and the film as a whole, has a lot more charm and humour than recent films of similar Prohibition-era criminals - like Public Enemies or Lawless - and McConaughey in particular makes his character feel like a real person rather than simply an impeachable historical figure, especially as his best laid plans begin to go awry.

4. Frailty

The opening scene of Bill "Game over man! Game over!" Paxton's directorial debut makes sure it has its talons in you good and proper. An FBI agent (Powers Boothe!) is called to his office in the middle of the night because there's a young man (McConaughey) there who knows the identity of the serial killer he's been hunting. He knows them pretty well, too: it's his brother. Most of the film is then told in flashback as the young man narrates his tumultuous childhood growing up with a father (Paxton again) who was as nuttier than a KP factory, and an extremely impressionable little brother (who is clearly crazy; he'd prefer to see Meatballs over the Warriors?!). Whenever McConaughey's on screen he has an eerie calm about him, and his southern drawl is perfect for the sun-baked horror of his recollections. Frailty didn't bother the Academy in the same way that our hero's recent films have, understandably: save for a few neat flourishes (a Brazil-esque hallucination of an angel by the mad dad; creepy use of children's Christian claymation series Davy and Goliath; a camera hovering over an ad-hoc burial ala The Evil Dead), Paxton's direction is pretty pedestrian, and there's more than a few unintentionally hilarious lines as dad and sons alike give into homicidal religious fervour, plus the premise is pretty out there. It's a neat little horror flick, though, with some above-average child acting (the kid playing young McConaughey mastered his contemplative squint), and a creepy premise that earned it praise from no less authorities on the genre than Stephen King, Sam Raimi and James Cameron. No doubt McConaughey's electric performance helped.

3. Eastbound And Down

Formerly disgraced baseball player Kenny Powers completed his journey back to the top of his game in the fourth and final season of Eastbound and Down last year, and our man McConaughey helped him get there. First appearing as "Texas Scout" and later as the much more reasonable (but less literally) named Roy McDaniel, the actor got to show off some stronger comedic chops than usual, no doubt helped by getting to act opposite Danny McBride rather than Sarah Jessica Parker. In fact he was a perfect fit as he turned over some of the show's trademark profane turns of phrase in his smooth Texas tones. As the man who helped Kenny Powers out of exile in Mexico, back into American baseball and then up further into the big leagues, McDaniel was both a pivotal part of the story that built over four seasons and one of its highlights. From his first appearance, urging Powers to "suck his dream's cock" whilst he had the chance, to his scene-stealing monologue in the third season finale as he leads a locker room prayer reprising and riffing on that line in fantastically filthy fashion, McConaughey really grabbed ahold of this meaty role and just went to town on it. Kind of like in...

2. Tropic Thunder

In a film that's not exactly wanting for incredibly famous dramatic actors being very silly indeed, McConaughey's larger-than-life, Tango-tanned Hollywood agent Rick Peck still manages to cut a manic figure amongst Robert Downey Jr as the ultimate method actor, Nick Nolte as a handless Vietnam vet, and Tom Cruise doing his best to distract from his various PR disasters by putting on a bald cap - not to mention Ben Stiller going "full retard". Whilst Stiller's out-of-his-depth action star Tugg Speedman enters increasingly desperate situations as the war-movie-within-a-movie (also confusingly called Tropic Thunder) gives way to actual jungle warfare, McConaughey channels presumably every asshole agent he's ever come across in the California hills as the curly-coiffed, pastel-polo-shirted, bluetooth-headset-toting hero who manages to put down his Wiimote long enough to make sure that his client...gets TiVO. No matter what.

1. The Lincoln Lawyer

Here we are, full circle! As Bryan Cranston's cop asks the titular character towards the end, "whose side are you on anyway?" It's a clunky bit of expositional dialogue which takes away from Matthew McConaughey's complex second round as a struggling lawyer. This time he swaps the fiery tension (and fiery temperatures) of Mississippi for California as Mickey Haller - whose nickname comes from the Lincoln Town Car he uses as an office - who acts as the defence for a similarly controversial crime to A Time To Kill. Is the heir to a lucrative real estate fortune (played to douchey perfection by Ryan Phillipe) guilty of beating a prostitute to within an inch of her life? It seems like a set up but, as the story unfolds, things start to get a bit more complicated than that. For one thing, Haller begins noticing similarities to an earlier case of his... Watching this film in comparison to A Time To Kill, it's clear to see that McConaughey had come on leaps and bounds as an actor. His performance in the Grisham adaptation was damn fine, but this film version of a Michael Connelly book gives him even more to do. The good fifteen years of work between the two of them is obvious as he knocks it out of the park as an attorney with even shakier morales than his media-chasing Jake Brigance, with a look behind the eyes that comes only with age (or possibly special contact lenses). The film's an enjoyable bit of hokum - like A Time To Kill, it's fairly average in its direction and plot twists - but it has possibly the clearest evidence that the McConaissance has been a long time coming. Right on the cusp of that recent run of home runs, this is the first pitch; not quite as clean, but still a doozy. Right now McConaughey's playing for the World Series (of acting) (that's a baseball thing, right?) but it's just as exhilarating to see how he qualified.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/