7 Movies That Didn't Learn Their Own Lesson

Paul Giamatti Shoot Em Up Occasionally, films come with a message, a certain lesson they wish to give. That message can be all kinds of things, and not all necessarily draped around conventional ideas of being morality or something else halfway positive. No, film is a complex medium, and you can portray all sorts of ideologies and messages onscreen. Hell, that's part of the medium's power, and why it's been sought out by any propaganda arm worth its salt. What I'm trying to get at is this €“films are open-ended by nature, and can give you all sorts of life advice. For example, Forrest Gump taught you not to under-estimate anyone, Titanic taught us that love never dies and From Dusk Til Dawn taught us that you probably shouldn't attend strangely active Mexican strip joints in the middle of nowhere. Everything's got a point, regardless of how trivial that point might be. Yet occasionally some films don't abide by this, and instead fall over their own feet in attempting moralising. It might be due to thematic confusion, it could be to do with an attempt to have their cake and eat it, and occasionally, it might just be the product of ill-thought-out silliness, but once in a blue moon, a film comes along that's so at odds with its own message, you can't help but sit back and admire the ensuing thematic catastrophe. Please understand, I'm not talking about those films that shoot themselves in the foot on purpose €“ if that were the case, this list would be a hell of a lot longer. No, I'm talking about that special club of films, those films who seem contradictory in spirit and just confuse the audience with their message. It's to these films that this article €“ replete with SPOILER WARNINGS €“ is dedicated.

7. The Great Gatsby

Gatsby If you've read The Great Gatsby, you'll know that F. Scott Fitzgerald isn't exactly a fan of all the excess in which his titular character indulges. Indeed, it's quite the opposite. He's very scathing of all the decadence Gatsby lives in, making it very clear that he's just compensating for the real lack of emotional depth in his life. Everything's distant, far-away and cold, exacerbating the problem of Gatsby's riches €“ because while he knows he's rich, it still won't fill any sort of hole in his life. Yet when it came time for the 21st century movie, a very different message was at hand, and this was all made possible by the catastrophically crazy choice of director. I'll explain. Baz Luhrmann is an excellent director, but only if he's directing certain things. Simply put, he's not the best at subtlety, so it's a bit of a shock to see him helming material which is supposed to mock the central subject and surrounding characters for their lavish ways. But the way Luhrmann stages his sets, you can't help but be enraptured by just how goddamned beautiful everything is. The tragedy is that this shouldn't be the point, that you're supposed to hate everything that Gatsby stands for, all his hedonism and emptiness. But by choosing a director whose main talent is making even the mundane look like a roller disco set in a tart's boudoir, this apparently empty excess instead seems like a damn awesome possibility. After all, where else are you going to get champagne pyramids, if not from cinema's most exuberant director? By making the whole thing seem impossibly glamorous, he's missed the point completely in favour of dressing up a more part of Gatsby's nihilism as a pretty awesome source of extravagance, and that's a shame.

6. Limitless

Limitless The inspiration from this piece came from an earlier article, when I was claiming that Limitless made drug addiction look awesome. I've come back to it here because I loved the main lesson it teaches the audience €“ drug addiction is bad, but occasionally the only way out is through more drugs. Limitless is a B-plus film that rattles along at a slick pace and is expertly put together, but more than anything else, it was the character arc that stuck with me. It follows the plot beats of any other cautionary tale €“ man finds drugs, finds drugs awesome but then comes to see them as a horrible hindrance. But it's at Eddie's nadir that the whole thing changes somewhat. Rather than realising the error of his ways and swearing off those awesome clear pills €“ a lesson surely relevant after you've drunk someone's blood for a boost €“ he gets straight back on the horse and abuses it further. This shows one clear message €“ Bradley Cooper's Eddie Mora doesn't learn a damn thing from his escapades with NZT, except how bleeding awesome it is. For him, it doesn't matter how bad things get, because the way out always involves more drugs. It's a bit of a wacky, ballsy message and entirely at odds with the desperate actions the pills inspires €“ remember, this is the film where Abbie Cornish wields an actual human child as a weapon to fend off a drug-related attacker, yet all this awfulness get swept under the carpet for Eddie's continued adventures on the now much less harmful drugs.

5. A Knight's Tale

A Knights Tale If ever you want a pitch-perfect example of a film which kicked its own message hard in the balls, you needn't go much further than A Knight's Tale. The premise of the film is pretty bog-standard €“ it's about a man who wants to overturn the system which has kept him down. Such a blueprint has been used time and time again, except in this case, the man's a peasant who decides to go around jousting knights in his master's stead after he suddenly kicks the bucket. This is all done to the soundtrack of Queen, and it's brilliant in an entirely awful way. The film makes a big show of a man hoping to reach beyond his station, and to its credit, it makes a pretty compelling case €“ Will Thatcher is able to knock all sorts of landed gentry off their horses, showing that despite his lowly origins, talent is in fact the great leveller. Yet eventually, a nadir has to come in a heroic film, and it comes for Will in spadefuls. Namely, the nobility €“ helped by his curious night-time travel habits €“ learn that he's in fact a thatcher, and one of the lowest order. He's stripped of his position as the pornographically named Ulrich Von Lichtenstein, and he's pelted with fruit in the stocks. You're left wondering key questions €“ how's he going to get out of this, especially considering his dire societal situation? Whatever it is, you know it's going to be suitably absurd. Except, it kind of isn't. William is saved by The Black Prince, who claims that his historians have found that this lowly bloke is descended from ancient knights. Granted, it's a cool way to end a film €“ William's able to waltz into the sunset with the girl of his dreams and his status intact, but for us, it gives off a mixed message. Basically, we learn that despite William's desires to subvert the system, he's actually part of it, and that's the reason why he can do the things he's done. He can act noble because he his noble €“ his ancient bloodline points to it. Yet apparently, there's no such luck for medieval Mark Addy or Alan Tudyk, or even for silver-tongued Paul Bettany, who've missed out on a similar, unascended social mobility by a few hundred years. Still, at least Heath got the girl, and that's what counts.. ...Right?

4. V For Vendetta

V For Vendetta The government in V For Vendetta are hardly good folk. They murder and oppress their way across British society with precious little subtlety, backed by the intense fizzog and no-nonsense oratory of Chancellor Sutler, leader of the Norsefire party and all-out dictatorial leader of post-apocalypse Great Britain. In the movie world, Sutler's party aren't the most tolerant bunch €“ they'll lock you up for anything from the wrong nationality to the wrong faith, and they're not exactly tolerant about differing sexualities or political ideologies either. It's a bit of a hellhole, and into this hellhole strides V, Guy Fawkes mask-wearer and anarchist extraordinaire. V's plan is to overthrow the entire rotten system, but he can't really do it himself €“ as the former subject of heinous medical tests, he's pretty damn conspicuous. To this end, he recruits Natalie Portman's Evie, a much more normal-looking person who can help him advance his ends. Yet how does he convince her? Why, in the same manner as the government, of course! He re-enacts every single aspect of a close-monitored government torture, from the inhospitable accommodation to the probing question-and-answer sessions and the emotional and physical abuse which come as part and parcel of Norsefire's and V's philosophy. I suppose you can understand why he did it €“ he needed to create people he could trust. Yet to me, there's something troubling about an anti-oppression unit which begins with oppression, because it's only from there that fanaticism and troubling ideologies can develop. Frankly, even if desperate times call for desperate measures, it still seems like hypocrisy to me.

3. Shoot 'Em Up

Shoot Em Up I love Shoot 'Em Up. There, I said it. I know it's not everyone's cup of tea, but I've always had a soft spot for films which left sanity at the door and spent the rest of its run-time whistling Dixie and letting all sorts of insanity happen. To it's credit, Shoot 'Em Up does this with the sort of enthusiasm reserved for the circus €“ everything is ramped up to 11, and it's all the more glorious for it. After all, this is the film which let you see Clive Owen's Smith perform the equivalent of bullet ballet, cutting his way through hordes of hired goons before murdering a crack squad of murderers while having sex with Monica Bellucci. If that's not worth you high-fiving the cinema screen, I don't know what is. But still, all films come with a message, and Shoot 'Em Up's was particularly heavy-handed. Effectively, it was arguing how nefarious the gun manufacturers were for attempting to turn America into murderers for a profit. Paul Giamatti's hit-man was hired by the arms lobby to tie up the loose ends of their preferred Presidential candidate, who will back the repealing of second amendment legislation. It's driving a (not subtle) message that guns are bad, and that those who want to keep violence available to all will resort to cartoonish measures to keep such an avenue available. You're meant to go boo and hiss, but there's one thing stopping you €“ Smith himself. Namely, Smith makes guns look awesome to the extent that you're actually enraptured by the possibilities of what one man could do with them. For a film which has this strange anti-violence agenda, it chose a spectacularly inappropriate protagonist €“ the fact of the matter is that throughout this film, guns looks so awesome that you'd consider it a crying shame to ban them. The awkward fact is that this is the view of the film's villains too, making for a strange paradox.

2. The Condemned

The Condemned Remember Battle Royale? Wasn't that whole thing cool and meaningful, showing how society can fall into a horrible demise incredibly quickly if we're presented with a violent, neck-blowing-up external force? Remember the salient points it raised about the brutality of society, simply by having the victims be schoolchildren? Ok, now take all those lessons, throw them out the window and replace them with Vinnie Jones, Steve Austin and other similar roid-heads. If you do this, you'll have The Condemned, a film which abandons any sort of prescient point-making for the sake of seeing terrible people go boom. You know what? I don't mind this. Jason Statham's made a career out of these simplistic constructs, and by taking the Battle Royale formula of letting us witness brutal battles and diluting the over-arching message for the excuse of letting us watch ultraviolence with few strings attached, we're left with a perfectly serviceable film. Sure, we still had the idea of people watching this battle for survival, but it's nothing we haven't seen before in similar no-brainers like Death Race, and that was nothing if not mindlessly entertaining. Yet despite enjoying Austin and Jones wade through a pile of corpses to make merry hell on each other, we're still confronted with something beyond the mere comprehension of a WWE film. Simply put, the film attempts a f**k you, arguing in its coda whether you're in fact the condemned for watching a violent piece of trash by giving the faintest cap-doff to self-awareness which utterly jarred in the gleeful carnage it had reveled in up 'til now. Frankly, I refuse to be judged for watching a WWE production where a wooden Stone Cold murdered the blue hell out of everything, and in the most meat-headed way possible, This is the worst sort of clever ending, the last resort of an obviously dumb film to reach above itself and become something more cerebral. It's a colossal failure, and a poor attempt to have its ultraviolent cake and eat it, hiding behind the fig-leaf of poignancy. It proved that occasionally, perhaps going dumb is the way forward, rather than this slapdash, heavy-handed, contrary moralizing.

1. Daybreakers

Daybreakers At its heart, Daybreakers is pretty bloody (no pun intended) good film. It's an unabashed high-concept horror, the sort of film which takes a premise and runs with it to the nth degree. For what it's worth, I really love it. It's refreshing to see a flick which treats schlock with a perverse integrity and letting it play out in logical fashion. To that end, we get to see precisely what happens when the vampires win. Namely, everything become blood-centric, but we've got to keep the fossil fuel €“ damn, I hit the analogy to dead on the nose €“ going, so there's always a need to harvest humans. Unfortunately for the communities of Daybreakers, their supply of meatbags are dwindling €“ again, got to love the analogy €“ so they need to find an alternative. Rattling along in the background to this thinly-veiled ecology lecture is Ethan Hawke and Willem Dafoe, the former a human-sympathising vampire and the latter an Elvis-loving, muscle car-riding nutcase with a penchant for heavy weaponry. These guys effectively derail the vampire society by making humanity contagious. To make that more specific, if you take a bite out of a vampire whose become a human, you become human yourself. Taken by itself, this viral spread could be considered a good thing €“ despite the development of a blood alternative, the higher-ups want to keep farming humans for profit, so surely, you can get the impression that this is a better solution to unethical murder. However, it really, totally isn't. Hell, it could be, but the problem is that by the end of the film when the solution is perfected, vampire society is so far diminished by the scarcity of blood supplies that your average bloodsucker on the street would vault over his own mother to take a human apart. Can you see where I'm going with this? The problem is that to make everyone human again is a laudable task, but in practical terms it'll cause an outrageous amount of exponential human death (just look at the soldier lobby scene) on a possibly society-ruining scale. I know you can't make an omelette without breaking eggs, but killing at least three quarters of the world's population €“ just when they've turned human €“ must seem a bit counter-productive to the human cause, right. Again, I get the need for sacrifice, but it's just when you've spent a film serving up the vampires as the bad guys but then throw a ton of humans into the meat-grinder, any attempt at a moral can fly out the window with the rest of the gore.

Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.