8 Commandments All Movies Must Follow
Each film is different, and each filmgoer desires different things from the experience. Some define themselves by the art in which they engage in, whilst others desire only a momentary distraction from the real world, something to pass the time and occupy the mind before the rigors of jobs, families, school, etc. etc. That said, there are certain aspects of movies that we can probably come to consensus on. There are recurring problems and annoyances that crop up again and again that we, as a film-going public, can point to and request improvement. Asking for a few guiding principles to hold Hollywood to as it churns out product doesnt seem to be too out of line. But who to come up with these guidelines, these rules? Who would suppose themselves wise enough to command power over all tastes and beliefs? Who has such a colossal ego, such an inflated opinion of themselves and their own intellect, that they would dare impose their beliefs and ideas on other people? Lets do this. 8. A Movie MustTell A Complete Story
Movie-going, its a time and money-consuming affair, no? You need to clear time to do it, an ordeal thats difficulty is multiplied five or six times over once you start factoring in kids, work, appointments, schedules and all the other hassles that the modern world pummels each individual with. And if you do get out to the movie theater theres no guarantee that you wont be subjected to seat kickers, cell-phone talkers, talking-to-the-screeners, or crying babies. So if youve gone through all that to get yourself into the theater, in your seat, money paid up front, its safe to say that youve earned the right for a complete theatrical experience, right? So why, time after time after time, do we get movies that feel like extended prologues for larger stories? Why are we forking our money over to be subjected to two hour long pilot episodes of theoretical franchises? This especially strikes films in the fantasy genre, where the entire film will be jam-packed with naked exposition and plot-mechanics, leaving no room for drama or actual story. The film is so busy setting up the players for The Next One, that they forget to give the audience a reason to give half a crap about anything they are seeing on screen. It is easy to see why. Everyone is chasing the Harry Potter model, trying to create the self-perpetuating machine that was that franchise. But what all these pretenders to the throne forget is that the first two Harry Potter movies are completely self-contained. They tell complete, open-and-closed stories that are fully resolved by the end of the loooooong run times. Leaving plot threads dangling, ending on cliffhangers, all of that began in the third movie, by which time it had become abundantly clear that the audience wasnt going anywhere. I can hear the keyboards tapping as someone writes a comment protesting about how Harry Potters story involved prophecies and Horcruxes and epic battles and a complex mythology that began in those first two books/movies. While thats true, all those details came up later. JK Rowling expanded on the mythology of the story as it went along, refining upon the established details to layer in much more complex explanations for what was happening in those first stories. But those first two books/movies didnt need more detail to work as stories. Rowling is just a gifted enough writer that both the fairy tale logic and the complex explanations worked perfectly and in tangent with each other. So basically, if for some reason Britain got blipped off the face of the Earth, if like Dr. Who got hit by a truck and couldnt stop that weeks alien invasion, those first two stories would still be complete stories. Thats where everyone else keeps screwing up. And the reason it is so frustrating is because the setting-up of future installments (that almost never actually come) only detracts from any potential enjoyment of the actual film. You know, the one you paid all that money and went through all that hassle to see. Please filmmakers, just tell a damn story. A beginning, a middle, an end. Tell a good, compelling, complete story and your audience will happily come back again and again to see those characters in new situations.
7. A Movie Must Have a Point
A movie should have to be about something. Nowadays, movie after movie comes out and doesnt leave the slightest impression beyond That one actor was really good or The effects were pretty good or other micro-concerns like that. Blockbusters seem to be laminated from the exact same press, and even our indie dramas fall into several obvious pre-determined shapes. If youve seen one movie about a depressed guy in his mid-30s falling in love with a quirky girl who teaches him to enjoy life The problem is, so many movies exist just to, well, exist for the sake of existing. Its like movies are grown in labs or, more likely, planned out in boardrooms before a single actual artistic person looks at it and has their say. Executives decide the look, tone and subject matter of the films before theyre released and people like writers and directors are employed to execute that plan on time and on schedule and on budget. Because of this, movies just follow the trends of whatever is popular, without any attempt to understand WHY those trends have merged in the first place. Take the ongoing Nolan-ization of superhero and fantasy films. Nolans brilliant idea was to take Batman out of the heavily-stylized soundstage cityscape that Burton had so carefully built in the 80s and plop him into the real world (or close to it) and examine what would actually make the Dark Knight tick. It worked because Batman is the perfect character to try this approach with (dark enough that the real world stuff made sense, silly enough that you could still have him drive a rocket-powered tank and no one would blink) and because the themes that Nolan and his team brought to the fore with this approach (power of symbols, power of fear, terrorism, spread of chaos) were pulled directly from our own post-9/11 daily lives. But making movies is hard and it takes a while and Jersey Shore was having a marathon that day I guess, and so subsequent creative teams have tried to nakedly ape Nolans dark approach but without any of the larger thematic elements that actually made his vision make sense. They were just doing it to do it. Thats why, in a perfect world, every movie would have a thematic reason to exist. Every film would have to be ABOUT something. That doesnt mean that every film would have to have deep socio-economic underpinnings, because thats not necessarily what a theme is. A theme can be as simple as Family and the writer can find dozens of permutations upon that to build a story around. If every movie had a clear thematic core to guide the decisions made concerning things like look, tone, pacing and characterization, it would cut down on the feeling that the paying audience is seeing endless copies over and over again. At least it would cut down on all the damn GRITTY fairy tales that come out every couple of months.
6. A Movie Must Hold The Camera Still
This seems like it should be self-explanatory, but lets explain it anyway. Movies are a predominantly visual medium, right? Even before films had the ability to utilize SOUND they were still able to portray complete/complex stories, not to mention the various relationships and actions of characters. Even with that huge asset taken away, films could still communicate everything important. Such is the power of the well-used visual frame. Modern action scenes take that power, wrap it in a garbage bag, hit it with a cudgel a few times and then toss it off a cliff like the crate in that section of CREEPSHOW. The camera will shake and spin around constantly, vibrating ceaselessly while the people on screen shout and flail, trying desperately to return the audiences attention to them, the main characters of the film. This visual style is not helped at all by the rapid-fire editing that so many directors use, and thats not even bringing up the washed-out grey-on-black-on-brown that every action movie insists on using to convey grit and seriousness. Like so many stupid things done by stupid people, the shakycam style to action has a decent idea at its core. The style can be used to great effect to communicate the kinetic energy of an action sequence and to immerse the viewer in the mindset of the character as they are beset by bullets and explosion. Shaking the camera can be used to recall the footage taking from the nightly news, creating another layer of immersion. When used properly by someone like Steven Spielberg or Paul Greengrass, the shakycam style can result in never-before-realized intensity in action sequences. But getting that intensity requires an extreme amount of care and intent. The filmmaker needs to know EXACTLY what response he/she wants to illicit from the audience, and to design the sequence in question in such a way as to wring the maximum amount of tension out of the audience. It can be done, but it requires an extraordinary amount of effort and care. You begin to see the problem. Most action filmmakers try to trade the shaking camera and rapid editing as a replacement for actual, you know, action. Its not just bad on the micro-level of a particular sequence or film, its actually kind of offensive to the medium as a whole. Film draws its power from the images it creates, and by reducing on-screen imagery to blurry blobs of washed out light going BOOM, the filmmakers are spitting in the face of the foundational craft of the artform. This is why it always drives me nuts when people defend Michael Bays movies as Its not about the plot, just enjoy the action! Sure, thatd be great. Plenty of great action movies are narratively weak but make up for it with stand-up-and-cheer great action sequences. The problem with Bays films are that they are aggressively stooped AND when you get to the action scenes, he whips the camera around here, there and everywhere, so you cant tell who is where or what they are doing or where they are spatially compared to the huge fireball. Basically, Michael Bay makes action movies that deny the viewer the ability to think that Shia Labeoufs character died in a huge fireball. Thats just unfair.
5. A Movie Must Try New Things
This is the one that is hardest to qualify. There are schools of thought that say that nothing is original, that all art is essentially a catalog of influences that the artist is synthesizing into a new shape to reflect their own interests. Every lauded film and filmmaker has deep influences that are nakedly visible on screen, whether its Tarantinos non-stop homaging of his favorite films or Lucas and Spielberg aping the look, tone and sometimes set-pieces of old serials. All art is a pastiche in some form or another, and all anyone can hope to do is to try and do something new with it. Thats the key. Its the attempt, the intention, of trying to do your own thing with your work and establish your own voice that makes art so compelling. After all, millions upon millions of children grew up watching those serials, but how many made STAR WARS? Just the one. Lucas mixed-and-matched parts from every type of film he loved and then created something totally unique from it. Its that unique part that gets left out, more often than not. Producers and directors dont try to create bold new visions, theyre just trying to ride whatever wave happens to be getting traction at the moment. We get films that are identical to each other on every level except for search-and-replace plot points. The reluctant hero chases the magical doo-dad, cracking jokes while the hot chick rolls her eyes but secretly smiles. Big fight. CGI. Alt-rock song on the end credits. The audience is complicit in this. Theyre the ones who reward the same-old, same-old by handing money over for it. And its understandable. No one wants to get burned by paying money to see something that winds up being absolute crap. A movie doesnt even need to tell a wildly original story to have its own identity. This year, a very small movie had a blink-and-you-miss-it theatrical release. GOON, starring Seann William Scott, follows every beat in the underdog sports movie book. But GOON takes its characters seriously and works hard to give each major character genuine nuance and pathos. The audience comes to love the characters and care about them, which means that they wind up investing deeply in the story, familiar though it may be. The audience may have seen this kind of story, and these kind of characters, but they have never meet these characters and seen how they deal with the ups-and-downs of an underdog sports movie. GOON didnt get much of a release, but it arrive don home video with a cult audience already fully formed. Most movies cant be bothered with the nuance aspect. The makers are content to do a perfunctory job, hitting each beat in a professional, indistinct manner. But, speaking only for myself, I find that watching interesting directors swing for the fences, even when they whiff, to be infinitely more engaging than watching the latest Xerox blockbuster roll off the assembly line. Look at something like Sucker Punch, a movie that ends up failing on just about every level. Narratively, thematically, dramatically, etc., the film collapses in on itself. It just doesnt work. But its still fascinating to watch and there are isolated moments in the film that work perfectly. Writer/Director Zack Snyder used the film to deal with notions such as escapism, fetishization, repression, the changing values of generations, and the sexual aspect of geek culture. Also dragons. To me, watching someone use all of the tools of modern filmmaking in service of something weird and personal, epic but introspective in equal measure, that is the really rewarding part of being a film fan. Not every thing that gets tried will be successful. And thats OK. Its the effort, the struggle to take the old and build something new that is truly valuable. That is what the film industry should foster and support. That is what every movie should strive to contain. Also dragons.4. All Movies MustHave a Female Lead Who is Neither the Love Interest or Mother Figure
This rule should be passed just to see what Hollywood does with it. The results would be FASCINATING as hundreds of lazy screenwriters, suddenly deprived of the easy route of just making the girl character The Girl and leaving it at that, would be forced to actually develop female characters that exist on their own terms, not just to lust after/mentor/all of the above with the true hero of the film, The Guy. Because thats what 99% of the female leads in Hollywood movies are reduced to. They have no agency or will of their own, existing entirely as a reaction to the arc of the hero. Even if a woman is introduced as being intelligent or resourceful, the plot will engineer a scenario in which the female character is placed on the sideline or otherwise incapacitated so that the hero can do the actual work of resolving the plot. Its not enough to just hand the only girl around a sword or a gun and have her running around in the final battle, you have to make the effort to create an actual CHARACTER who has a reason to be there besides The Hero told me to. Look. This is not hard. Movies and TV have been desperately aping Joss Whedons use of strong female characters for well over a decade now and James Camerons before that. Yet they still somehow missing the entire freaking point of what made those characters work. The reason Whedons writing for women is considered so important and seminal is not because he was the first guy to have a tiny girl beat the crap out of a big burly guy. Thats just a simplistic visual approximation of what he was after thematically. No, the reason fans adored (and continue to adore) Buffy, Willow, Tara, Codelia, Fred, Zoe, et. Al. is because they were multi-faceted, layered people. They had strengths, weaknesses, fears, specialties, goals and ambitions and inner pains. Romances were a part of that personality but they were never the DEFINING aspect of those women. Whedon carried that over into this past summers AVENGERS with the character of Black Widow. While she spends much of the film concerned about Hawkeye, she is also taking part in interactions and events which have nothing to do with him. And even after Hawkeye had been rescued and redeemed, Black Widow is still an active part of the group, fighting on the front lines and serving a crucial, vital role in the outcome of the film. The romantic relationship is a part of the character, but it is not what defines Black Widow. You could have changed or removed the romance from her section of the film, and the core of Black Widow would still have been present. Compare that to, say, Carol Ferris of Green Lantern or even Elizabeth in the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, and youll see characters who make gestures towards completeness, who hint at deeper personalities, but are in the end reliant on the more dominating male characters to give them definition. Elizabeth Swann is defined by her romantic relationships and reactions to Jack Sparrow and Will Turner, and Carol Ferris is defined by her evolving relationship with Green Lantern. Enough of this. There is no reason in this day and age why female characters in movies should have to exist as echo chambers of the male heros own greatness. That Black Widows strong characterization was considered a breath of fresh air (if not a total surprise by people who dont know Whedons work) speaks more to how shameful most movies are in this regard than to anything revolutionary that Whedon did.
3. All Movies Must Ignore Awards Season
There is a bigger and more exhaustive discussion to be had about whether or not awards season is good for film culture (it probably is) or whether or not awards are valuable in gauging the quality of a film (they most certainly are not) but this isnt about that so much as it is about the way that awards season intrudes upon the actual content of movies. Oscar-bait. What an ugly, cheap term that also pretty correctly sums up a huge portion of the movies that get made today. You know the ones. The ones that take the Have A Point mandate and turn it into a 100-foot high neon billboard that is then used to bludgeon the audience over the head. Famous people get naked! Famous people lose weight! Do accents! Put on weight! Get naked after losing weight WHILE doing an accent! Ugh. Its so ugly because its so obvious. And its infuriating because those films, those stupid histrionic films, are the only ones that ever seem to tackle real, adult issues. We should absolutely have a film industry that creates and rewards films that deal with sexuality, aging, race, poverty and institutional woes. But the only films that DO that are chasing the monetary reward attached to Oscar buzz, which means that if you want to make a film dealing with that subject matter and get distribution, you need to incorporate de-glammed movie stars bawling their eyes out, a triumphant redemptive arc (because Hollywood only likes movies about sad things if everything works out OK. Please see the list of Oscars Spike Lees direction has been nominated for as an example of what happens when films DONT do that) and all of it tied up in the sort of pat resolution that makes the industry people feel better about themselves and their politics, as opposed to, you know, making a challenging film about challenging subject matter. If films were forbidden from acknowledging the awards season at any point in their production, films would be in a healthier place. People both behind and in front of the camera would have to choose material based on what truly inspires and moves them, not because they assume theres a gold statue waiting at the end of the road. At the very least, a Hollywood that did not incorporate awards season into the process would be spared scenes like Robert Downey Jr. explaining Full Retard.
2. All Movies Must Have Respect For Their Audience
And really, thats what this all comes down to, no? At the end of the day, me, you and everyone we know could fill out a hundred thousand entries on a list like this, explaining in agonizing detail every nit that we have to pick with the movies industry and how we wish it would be better. But at the bottom line, all I ask from a movie (and its makers) is that it extend the basic effort of respecting my intelligence and the intelligence of the collective human race that will be spending the money that executives will later turn into houses, couches, cars, boats and gadgets (not to mention the piles of cocaine that all those things will be made out of). I want to see movies that try to do new things, that try to capture something true and honest about being alive in this world right now, that treat my time and money like things that have value and should be rewarded with an experience that I cant get anywhere BUT at the movies. I want to see movies that act like people, all people across genders and nationalities, are intelligent and deserve to be represented as just that: As people. Its easy to be cynical about movies these days. I spend an exhaustive amount of time reading and reports and opinion pieces that paint the whole town as a hive of idiocy, devoid of any creative drive or artistic interest. Its easy to look at the endless rehashing of whatever style is popular and assume that the whole place is stupid and that any quality that leaks out must be some kind of accident. Easy, maybe, to think that. But I dont buy it. Because, speaking only for myself, I know how truly transporting a good movie is. There is no experience like being in a darkened movie theater, being engrossed in the action on-screen. The movies allow you to love, fear for, and mourn the lives of people who have never been and never will be. They show you lands that have never existed and creatures that have never walked the earth, and makes you as familiar with them as you are your own house or pets. Movies absorb you in such a way as to become an essential part of your thoughts and dreams, this despite being built entirely out of falsities and illusions. That aint no fluke. No, movies are something else. Something special. They are magic. And as long as a movie really tries, really makes the effort to engage with the audience and make that magic come alive, well, I can guarantee theyll always have this writer as a customer. Oh, and one more thing
1. All Movies Must Give a Role to Harry Dean Stanton
Because cmon.