8 Directors Who Hate Superhero Movies
"Batman V Superman? It's a piece of s**t!"
“Everywhere you go,” wrote Tom Shone in 2004, “you will meet filmmakers who will cheerfully opine that there are way too many comic book adaptations/sequels/merchandising cash-ins before turning back to their mixing desks to put the finishing touches to Daredevil II: Double Dare or whatever else it is they are working on.”
Plus ca change plus ca meme chose, because over a decade later the only thing that has changed is the sheer volume of superhero movies being made and the number of filmmakers who express their distaste for them. So while DC develops its shared universe with Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, Steven Spielberg predicts the genre will eventually go the way of the western, despite the movie’s $872 million box office haul.
From Joel Schumacher to Josh Trank, directors of superhero movies have poured scorn on their own films when the results failed to enthuse audiences, but far more insightful are the thoughts of directors who wouldn’t touch a comic book property for all the gold in Fort Knox. After all, doesn't everyone want a piece of a good thing?
Whatever their motivations, here are eight people with no ambition to be the next Zack Snyder.
8. John McTiernan
Prior to his indictment in a criminal wiretapping case, John McTiernan was one of Hollywood’s best action directors with two Die Hard movies under his belt as well as Predator, The Hunt For Red October and Last Action Hero. But if you think he’s be the go-to guy for a superhero movie you’re sadly mistaken.
Interviewed for the French edition of Premiere, the filmmaker had some harsh words for the genre as a whole and Captain America in particular.
“These are films made by fascists. Comic book heroes are for businesses,” he said. “The cult of American masculinity is one of the worst things that has happened in the world during the last fifty years. Hundreds of thousands of people died because of this stupid illusion. So how is it possible to watch a movie called Captain America?”
While we eagerly await Mr McTiernan’s first movie in nearly fifteen years, it’s safe to assume his phone won’t be ringing off the hook with job offers from Marvel Studios.
7. Ridley Scott
Ridley Scott gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Thelma & Louise and Gladiator, so when he opines that, “Cinema mainly is pretty bad”, you sit up and take notice. What type of blockbuster will he never turn his hand to? Take a wild guess.
“Superhero movies are not my kind of thing,” he claims. “I can’t believe in the thin, gossamer tightrope of the non-reality of the situation of the superhero.”
The closest he’s ever come to making a comic book movie, he maintains, is his celebrated adaptation of Philip K Dick’s Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep?
“Blade Runner really is a comic strip when you think about it: it’s a dark story told in an unreal world. You could almost put Batman or Superman in that world, that atmosphere, except I’d have a f**king good story as opposed to no story.”
We’ll hold him to that when Alien: Covenant opens in May 2017.
6. Alejandro Inarritu
Nominated for 9 Oscars, of which it won 4, Alejandro Inarritu’s Birdman tells the story of a former actor in superhero movies (Michael Keaton) struggling to establish himself on Broadway, so you’d expect the director to have an opinion on the superhero genre.
Nobody expected him to brand them as “cultural genocide”, though.
“The audience is so overexposed to plot and situations and poop that doesn’t mean nothing about the experience of being human,” the filmmaker stated in 2014. “Superheroes – just the word hero bothers me. What the £$%& does that mean? It’s a false, misleading conception, the superhero. Then, the way they apply violence to it, it’s absolutely right wing.”
Inarritu won Best Director for Birdman, a trick he repeated the following year with The Revenant, so his words must’ve struck a chord in liberal Hollywood.
5. William Friedkin
Best known for The French Connection and The Exorcist, William Friedkin is no stranger to commenting on popcorn movies, having previously likened Star Wars’ massive success to the franchising of McDonalds. “The taste for good food just disappeared,” he said. “Everything has gone back towards a big sucking hole.”
At the Champs Elysees Film Festival in Paris 2015, the filmmaker kept on the offensive, informing the audience that modern cinema “is all about Batman, Superman, Iron Man, Avengers….all kinds of stuff that I have no interest in seeing at all.”
He added: “Films used to be rooted in gravity. They used to be about things.”
Don’t bother asking if he’s seen any of the current crop of superhero movies – he won’t even sit through the sequels to The Exorcist. “I’ve seen none of them, nor do I want to or intend to.”
4. Terry Gilliam
You’d expect the director of Brazil and The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen, who once described Lara Croft: Tomb Raider as “just crap”, to take a sledgehammer to superhero movies, but in fact he enjoyed Ant-Man. Well, some of it.
“Technically, it’s brilliant,” the filmmaker said in 2015. “But it’s also predictable, ultimately. We know where it’s gonna go, so the structure and the shape is all there…That’s my problem – I don’t get the surprise I used to get. I want to go and be more surprised.”
Eventually, he says, superhero movies will be done in by their repetitiveness.
“Now we’ve got to get all the Marvel Universe dancing with each other, so Superman has now got to make love to Batman or something….The Bible is more interesting, and the stories are more surprising and actually more human.”
3. Mel Gibson
He’s said some unfortunate things in the past, but Mel Gibson probably won some new fans in 2016 when he criticized the superhero genre, with Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice getting both barrels.
Promoting Hacksaw Ridge, Mel admitted that the success of superhero movies left him scratching his head.
“I’m really baffled by it. I think there’s a lot of waste but maybe if I did one of those things with the green screens I’d find out different. I don’t know. It seems to me you could do it for less. If you’re spending outrageous amounts of money, $180 million or more, I don’t know how you get it back after the taxman gets you and after you give half to the exhibitors.”
Delivering the coup de grace, he added: “How much did they spend on Batman V Superman that they’re admitting to? And it’s a piece of s**t.”
2. David Cronenberg
As one of Hollywood’s most cerebral directors (and the only filmmaker to have successfully brought William Boroughs to the screen), you’d expect David Cronenberg to have a problem with a genre not known for its perspicacity and in 2012 he ripped into superhero movies with a vengeance.
“A superhero movie, by definition, you know, it’s comic book. It’s for kids,” he said. “This has always been its appeal, and I think people who are saying The Dark Knight Rises is, you know, supreme art cinema, I don’t think they know what the f**k they’re talking about.”
He went on: “Christopher Nolan’s best movie is Memento and that is an interesting movie. I don’t think his Batman movies are half as interesting, though they’re twenty million times the expense.”
Given that Cronenberg’s last feature, Maps To The Stars, was a low-budget drama about a dysfunctional Hollywood family, you can rule him out from taking the helm of Iron Man IV.
1. Roland Emmerich
1068466Courtesy of Independence Day, Godzilla, The Day After Tomorrow et al, Roland Emmerich is no stranger to demolition, so when he sees superheroes trashing landmarks, he feels a sense of déjà vu. Is someone stealing his shtick?
“I felt that when I saw some of these Marvel movies or DC from Warners. I felt, Oh my God, that looks familiar to me. Why is Superman bashing so many buildings? I was actually warned already by Steven Spielberg that this will happen. He said Independence Day will be the most imitated film of the next 20 years – and he was right.”
However, the filmmaker claims there’s a big difference between his brand of destruction and superhero movies.
“When you look at my movies it’s always the regular Joe Schmo that’s the unlikely hero. A lot of Marvel movies, they show people in funny suits running around. I don’t like people in capes. I find it silly when someone dons a superhero suit and flies. I don’t understand it. I’m from Germany, that’s probably why.”