8 Directors Who Have The Worst Takes About Their Own Movie Endings

Just because they were the minds behind a movie, doesn't mean their ending takes were golden.

Whiplash movie
Sony Pictures Classics

It's undoubtedly never been easier to unleash an unfiltered and sometimes controversial take onto the masses, with fans seemingly taking to the likes of Twitter by the hour to fantasise or theorise over what the ending of a much-discussed recent flick actually means.

For the most part, though, no matter how intentionally ambiguous or confusing a feature's final moments may appear at first, the director behind said movie can usually be counted on to deliver a definitive answer as to how their story rides off into the sunset, ultimately settling all debate on the matter so fans can happily move onto the next project to fiercely discuss.

However, in the following cases, not only did a director go out of their way to offer an explanation for their movie's ending that many would be quick to brand as downright laughable if it tumbled out of the average moviegoer's mouth, but they may have actually been responsible for perhaps the poorest take ever sent their big-screen baby's way.

From making matters even more confusing than they already were, to some of the strangest explanations for undeniably bizarre developments you're ever likely to hear, maybe these directors should've just kept their traps shut upon being nudged over the true meaning behind their film's closing stages.

8. George Lucas' Odd Reason For Bringing Back Hayden Christensen - Return Of The Jedi

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Hayden Christensen
Disney

While many have been quick to call out George Lucas for his decision to repeatedly tinker with his Original Trilogy in the years since the trio of beloved features initially burst onto the scene, it must be noted that not every alteration was as jarring as the sight of pointless CGI being stuffed into every frame possible.

Take the decision to lace Ian McDiarmid's version of Emperor Palpatine into The Empire Strikes Back, for example, papering over the sight of Marjorie Eaton initially playing the Dark Lord of the Sith with superimposed chimpanzee eyes and effectively linking the Prequels with the OG trilogy of flicks.

The same cannot be said for the decision to bring Hayden Christensen back into the fold in the closing stages of Return of the Jedi, however, with many quick to question why Lucas opted to revert back to the younger version Anakin Skywalker after the fallen Jedi ultimately became a Force Ghost in the wake of dying much later on in his life.

Lucas' explanation for the jarring shift? Well, the director felt that after Anakin was redeemed by saving his son's life, his "inner person would go back to where we left it off", suggesting that the Jedi metaphorically died after becoming Vader.

In reality, though, Sebastian Shaw's version of Skywalker/Vader was likely cut out as way of jarringly connecting the two trilogies more than anything else.


7. Zack Snyder Wanted Bruce Kent To Take Up The Bat-Mantle - Zack Snyder's Justice League

Lois Lane Bed Justice League
Warner Bros.

Not content with completely tearing up the first attempt at bringing the DCEU's Justice League into being with his own 242-minute monster of a director's cut in 2021, Zack Snyder decided to eventually explain what the future would've looked like had the rest of his super-vision been followed through on.

Snyder would've had Ben Affleck's Batman ultimately sacrifice himself in order to save a pregnant Lois Lane from an incoming Darkseid, an event that would create a timeline that didn't actually see Supes fall under the control of the big bad entity; as seen in the Snyder Cut's Knightmare sequence.

Said sacrifice would've then have paved the way for yet another "reboot" of sorts later down the road, with Snyder noting to GQ that a future Justice League story would've involved Superman and Lane's son taking up the Bat mantle:

"Then the end is this epilogue where it's 20 years later, where Superman's son has no powers. He's born without the powers of a god, but then in the end, he would have become the new Batman... Then it would have been a reboot after that. You can just go back to the beginning again, where you could do a small movie with the new Batman or something."

Had this reality come to pass, there's a strong chance fans would've never been treated to Matt Reeves' recent critically acclaimed take on all things Gotham. So, it's probably for the best that Snyder's planned never-ending Bat-saga was nixed in the end.


6. Christopher Nolan Thinks Cobb Is In His Own Subjective Reality - Inception

Inception Leo Walking
Warner Bros. Pictures

Easily ranking as one of the most fiercely debated closing sequences in modern movie history, the final shot of Christopher Nolan's mind-bending Inception epic has fans still wondering whether Leonardo DiCaprio's Cobb is still in a dream as the film finally cuts to black.

The final scene, involving Cobb spinning his trusty totem and rushing off to see his children before his last reality test is fully completed, has been intensely analysed ever since its debut in 2010, with Nolan's take on the matter only muddying the waters even more.

In a speech the director gave at Princeton University in 2015, instead of outright revealing whether or not the final moment of the totem appearing to wobble after spinning for an age meant that the emotional climax was going down within a dream or in reality, Nolan offered up this explanation:

"The way the end of that film worked, Leonardo DiCaprio’s character Cobb — he was off with his kids, he was in his own subjective reality. He didn’t really care anymore, and that makes a statement: perhaps, all levels of reality are valid."

Contradicting this hint at Cobbs' final moments actually being nothing more the reality he is choosing to believe in, however, Michael Cane would also reveal at a screening for the flick in 2018 that he was told by Nolan, "Well when you're in the scene it's reality." And Cane is very much present during that closing sequence, of course.

Simply put, Nolan has done little to clear up this ending in any way, shape, or form.


5. Mary Harron Doesn't Think It Was All In Bateman's Head - American Psycho

American Psycho Christian Bale
Lionsgate

For the longest time, a great many fans found themselves coming away from Mary Harron's unsettling American Psycho slice of horror feeling as though the acts they'd just witness being performed by the chilling Patrick Bateman may have actually been a figment of the New York investment banker's imagination all along.

This theory certainly adds a new dimension to the horrific murders Bateman is seen executing throughout the 2000 flick's run-time. But the ambiguity of the film's closing scene, which sees the apparent serial killer told that a colleague recently had dinner with a Paul Allen he was sure he'd murdered, wasn't actually designed to leave audiences believing these many horrendous acts could've been in Bateman's head all along.

As the film's director Harron would explain when discussing her frustration at folks walking away from the experience convinced that they'd just been delivered a twist "it was all a dream" conclusion:

"One thing I think is a failure on my part is people keep coming out of the film thinking that it's all a dream, and I never intended that. All I wanted was to be ambiguous in the way that the book was. I think it's a failure of mine in the final scene because I just got the emphasis wrong. I should have left it more open ended. It makes it look like it was all in his head, and as far as I'm concerned, it's not."

Much to the annoyance of those who have spent many hours debating the contrary then, in Harron's mind, Christian Bale's unsettling Bateman is very much the serial killer her flick portrays him to be.


4. Damien Chazelle Doesn't Think Andrew Makes It Out Of His 30s Alive - Whiplash

Whiplash Miles Teller
Sony Pictures Classics

After spending an entire movie at each other's throats, with J.K. Simmons' Fletcher in particular making Mile Teller's Andrew's life somewhat of a misery as he pursues drumming greatness throughout Whiplash's run-time, Damien Chazelle appeared to offer a flicker of hope in the form of the feature's final beats.

The sight of Fletcher and Andrew seemingly being on the same page during the latter stages of the feature's triumphant climactic drum solo, however, isn't enough to guarantee an all-round happy ending for the tortured up-and-coming drummer.

That's at least what the director behind the movie itself believes, with Chazelle noting to Screen Crush how he believes the pair's positive connection late in the day was merely a "fleeting thing" and a dark future lay ahead for Andrew down the road:

"I think it’s definitely a fleeting thing. I think there’s a certain amount of damage that will always have been done. Fletcher will always think he won and Andrew will be a sad, empty shell of a person and will die in his 30s of a drug overdose. I have a very dark view of where it goes."

Chazelle isn't the only person involved in the flick to share this rather depressing take either, with Teller himself also revealing, "I think (Andrew) lives a pretty lonely existence, just working on his craft and becoming one of the greatest drummers of all time, but being pretty miserable (and) alone."

Who'd be a drummer, eh?


3. J.J. Abrams Thinks Being A Palpatine Is Worse Than Being A Nobody - The Rise Of Skywalker

Star Wars The Rise Of Skywalker Rey
Lucasfilm

For all of the divisive reviews that were sent Rian Johnson's The Last Jedi's way in the wake of its 2017 release, the decision to have Daisy Ridley's Rey be revealed as little more than a "nobody" during the middle-entry of the Sequels was one that many felt acted as perhaps the most inspired plot twist the franchise had introduced in years.

But then, in what felt like little more than a lazy attempt to appeal to those who had been theorising over Rey's heritage since The Force Awakens blasted off into theatres in 2015, J.J. Abrams decided to bizarrely undo Johnson's work from the film prior and have Rey be actually revealed to have been a Palpatine all along.

Stripping away the idea that any average human could find it within themselves to make a difference, Abrams eventually explained that he felt the "you're nobody" direction simply wasn't as painful as his Palpatine development:

"Though I completely understand 'you're nobody' is a devastating thing, to me the more painful, the more shocking thing was the idea that you're actually from the worst possible place."

And it was because of this decision to lazily lean into what came before instead of heading into the unexplored waters that were teased in Episode VIII that fans were ultimately exposed to Rey duking it out with her granddaddy in Rise of Skywalker's climax.

Whatever way you slice it, the Force was not strong with this particular take and Episode IX suffered the consequences as a result.


2. Richard Kelly Goes Too Far With His Unfiltered Cut - Donnie Darko

Donnie Darko Copy
Flower Films

In a rare case of a director's cut actually somehow finding a way to undo the brilliant theatrical work that came before it, Richard Kelly's unfiltered take on Donnie Darko released a few years after the film's commercially unsuccessful 2001 cinema bow pretty much murdered any and all mystique the Jake Gyllenhaal-starring cult hit once possessed.

Despite initially being received quite well by fans and critics alike, the addition of twenty minutes worth of once-deleted scenes and a boatload of superimposed text from the fictional Philosophy of Time Travel book shed unwanted light on a number of ambiguous plot points (such as the existence of Tangent and Primary Universes) that had once been a source of many a fan theory and compelling post-flick discussion.

Sure, Kelly's need to explain each and every potential loose-end once prevalent in the theatrical entry made the film a touch more accessible. But at what cost?

A great many who had originally been captivated by the mystery and limitless potential of their own imaginations upon taking Darko in a few years earlier were left wondering why the director felt the need to painfully spoon-feed an already compelling tale to his audience.


1. Stanley Kubrick Thinks Dave Was Turned Into A "Super Being" - 2001: A Space Odyssey

2001 A Space Odyssey Star Child
MGM

And finishing off with another flick that once spawned countless different theories over what in the hell it all meant by the time the credits rolled, Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey provided audiences with one of the most confusing yet intriguing conclusions in movie history.

Yet, while many have spent hours trying to unpack the finale of David Bowman seemingly going from decrepit old man to baby floating towards Earth, Kubrick himself actually revealed the true meaning behind this enigmatic ending many moons ago.

According to the legendary director in a rare interview many years back, upon discovering another monolith, Dave "is taken in by god-like entities, creatures of pure energy and intelligence with no shape or form." Then, after being studied in "a human zoo" of sorts, "his whole life passes from that point on in that room."

And if that wasn't enough, Kubrick would then surreally add:

"Anyway, when they get finished with him, as happens in so many myths of all cultures in the world, he is transformed into some kind of super being and sent back to Earth, transformed and made into some sort of superman."

So for those eternally searching for some deeper meaning in the closing stretch of this 1968 classic, it turns out Kubrick was simply on the cusp of forging his own brand of super-verse. How thrilling.


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!