8 Exact Decisions That Doomed Horror Movie Protagonists

Decisions, decisions, decisions. Are they bad? Yes. Do we love them? Also yes.

Midsommar movie
A24

Some of them done with good intent, and some done out of pure stupidity, but there's no denying that the decisions made by some horror movie protagonists leave much to be desired either way.

Choices are a big part of how a plot can unfold within a movie, and in no genre is this more apparent than within horror. One small wrong decision can lead to a cascade of other events that, more often than not, are catalysts for a particular character's downfall.

Most of these decisions are made to further the plot, so in almost all cases they were necessary to a certain degree. From characters who are doomed from the get-go and whose decisions only solidify their gory demises, all the way to those who just happened to make the wrong decision at the wrong time, all of the following made huge errors in their decision making.

We can judge all we want, but in the end it all ultimately begs the question of: what would you have done in that situation?

8. Urinating On The Tree - Mark "Midsommar"

Midsommar Will Poulter
A24

Many, many mistakes can be identified in Midsommar. But the most stupid decision that solidified the fate of Will Poulter's character, Mark, is that of urinating on a sacred tree.

Midsommar is a folk-horror film by Ari Aster that came a year after his directorial debut Hereditary. He took a different angle with Midsommar, deciding to use overexposure and bright lighting to create discomfort and horror. We are invited along on a trip with a group of college friends who are writing their thesis on this particular Swedish community, and immediately a few of the characters are shown to have questionable levels of intelligence.

Mark, the most arrogant and of the group, decides to urinate on a tree on the very first day of the friends being in the community. This angers multiple people, but most specifically one gentleman that later on in the film takes much pleasure in Mark's death.

Of course, Mark and the rest of the group were very much brought to Sweden by their Swedish friends to be sacrifices so their fate was predestined to a certain degree anyway. However, this very much solidified his fate!


7. Saving The Children - Lee "A Quiet Place"

A Quiet Place Lee
Paramount Pictures

A Quiet Place was a fantastic break into the genre for dynamic duo Emily Blunt and John Krasinski, and they certainly did not disappoint with their creative aptitude! A story centred around familial relations and the importance of these, the audience follows the Abbott family who have recently lost their young son Beau to the creatures that now dominate this post-apocalyptic world who hunt purely based off of sound.

It's clear just how much this family love one another, and in no point in the film is this more apparent than in the film's final few moments that sees Lee (Krasinski) sacrifice himself in order to save his remaining children from being killed. He lets out a gut wrenching scream that, after 90 minutes of very minimal dialogue and the dialogue that is present being extremely quiet, comes as a harrowing shock to the audience.

Moments after doing this, the creatures descend upon Lee and we have to watch as his children witness their father being killed and knowing that the end of his life was caused by them.


6. Shaming Ganush - Christine "Drag Me To Hell"

Drag Me To Hell
Universal Pictures

Sam Raimi's Drag Me To Hell was a fun addition to the supernatural horror sub-genre, and although lacking in actual scariness, it did manage to provide a relatively well-rounded plot and twist in its final few moments.

Protagonist Christine finds herself head-to-head with a fellow colleague for a big promotion at her place of work as a bank loan officer. She meets Ganush, an Eastern European Roma lady who is looking for another extension on her mortgage to stop her house being repossessed, however moments earlier we learn that Christine has been told by her boss that in order to be in the running for the promotion she is going to need to prove that she can make difficult decisions.

This particular difficult decision comes in the form of rejecting Ganush's mortgage extension request, which results in Christine being ambushed by Ganush in the parking lot shortly after and the old woman cursing one of Christine's buttons that she rips from her coat.

As you can imagine, the remainder of the film is Christine trying to find ways to lift the curse that was put on her, and serves as a lesson to those who act in their own self interest.


5. Stranger Danger - Lorna "Hostel: Part 2"

Hostel 2
Screen Gems

The Hostel franchise leaves very little to the imagination in terms of gore, hence its role in moulding what is now known as the subgenre of 'torture-porn' horror. After the slow start and trajectory of the first movie, audiences hoped for a more fast paced and to-the-point plot that relied more on gore than actual storyline substance, and Eli Roth very much delivered!

Following a similar plot to its predecessor, Hostel Part 2 sees trio of friends Lorna, Whitney and Beth all go to Slovakia with friend Axelle who tells them of a fantastic spa retreat. The audience are returned to the hostel from the previous movie, and soon enough odd things begin to happen. During a party that the four women go to, Lorna is seduced by a gentleman who claims to have good intentions with her. Despite being in a foreign country, drunk, and just not seeming very bright in general, she decides to go with the man against her friends' better judgement.

Unsurprisingly, the man indeed does not have Lorna's best interest at heart and not before long she is hung upside down in a chamber before being slit open from navel to throat!


4. Taking A Shortcut - Hutch "The Ritual"

The Ritual Rafe Spall
E1

The Ritual is a fantastic addition to Britain's repertoire of "every five years or so coming out with a half decent horror film"! It follows the holiday of friends Phil, Hutch, Luke and Dom who all go hiking in the Swedish mountains to honour the memory of their late friend, Rob, whom Luke blames himself for the death of.

Of course there are tensions within the group as the audience comes to learn that Luke was present at the moment of Rob's murder in a robbery-turned murder at an off-license. The rest of the group try their hardest to not blame Luke for Rob's death, but it's clear that some of them still do. One friend which seems to blame Luke more than any of the others is Dom, who sprains his ankle very soon into the hike.

This simple injury when paired with being in the depths of a Swedish forest spells trouble for the group, however it is only when Hutch suggests that the friends take a 'short-cut' through the dense undergrowth that the trouble really begins. One main take away of this film would be: do not stray from the path you know is safest!


3. Breaking The Rules - Amanda Saw 3

Saw III Amanda
Lionsgate

The Saw movies are well known for their tricks and intricate games, and in no film within the franchise is this more apparent than in the third instalment, Saw III. By the end of this film, it is a well known fact that John Kramer is a gentleman with a devious brain and a hankering for players of his games to stick strictly to the rules laid out in front of them.

Despite knowing this, Jigsaw's apprentice Amanda seems to believe that she is exempt from this rule. After battling for the entire movie to keep Kramer alive by kidnapping a surgeon, Amanda apparently forgets that she too is being tested by Kramer, despite him actively telling her this. Her death is brought on by her own recklessness and unwillingness to abide by the rules of her predecessor. We can hardly say that seeing her death on screen was not at least a little bit satisfying, as by this point in the franchise Amanda has made her presence known in the worst possible way.

Overall, Amanda's downfall comes from not doing the one thing that Kramer warned her of months earlier: play by the rules.


2. The Handcuffs - Vaines The Descent Part 2

The Descent Part 2
Warner Bros.

The Descent part 2 divided fans of its predecessor as to whether or not it was A) good and B) necessary. However, one thing that fans could agree on was that it was refreshing to see a sequel that wasn't based around an entirely new group of people and new plot. This sequel created the perfect synthesis of old and new, which fans everywhere could at least acknowledge was a good start.

Not so much a protagonist but still a very relevant member of the cast is that of Vaines, played by Gavan O'Herlihy. Vaines is a police officer assigned to the missing persons case of the group of female cave explorers from the first film, yet we soon discover that he believes the sole survivor of the expedition (Sarah) is the reason behind the women's disappearances.

Due to this belief, Vaines actually handcuffs himself to Sarah while down in the caves in an attempt to stop her from running away. This decision is quite obviously an awful one as, soon after, the two find themselves in a life threatening situation that results in Vaines' arm having to be chopped off so that Sarah can survive, leaving the officer to plummet to his death off a cliff.


1. Benefit Of The Doubt - Aaron "Creep"

Creep 2014
Blumhouse Productions

This found footage flick is an immaculately crafted film from start to finish, and what makes it even more impressive is Mark Duplass' and Patrick Brice's ability to hold the attention of the audience despite only having the two men onscreen for the entire movie and never introducing any more characters.

This onscreen dynamic is to die for and reaches a true precipice in the film's final act. It is abundantly clear that Mark Duplass' character Joseph is a strange individual, and that he has an unhealthy obsession with Aaron (Brice). Joseph gives Aaron multiple reasons not to trust him, and this is only further solidified by his increasingly unnerving behaviour even after Aaron leaves Joseph's house, which should have spelled the end of the filmmaker's discomforting ordeal.

After receiving threatening items in the mail from Joseph, for some reason Aaron still decides to give his odd counterpart benefit of the doubt and entertains him when Joseph asks for the two to meet in a public place, which in theory should have secured Aaron's safety. However, this decision of Aaron to still go and see Joseph is fatal, and ends with an axe being struck firmly through his head as the audience can do nothing but watch in horror from a camera Aaron sets up from inside of his car.


Watch Next


Contributor

Amy James hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.