8 Films Disowned By Their Directors Before They Were Released
That Alan Smithee's Rotten Tomatoes average is absolutely atrocious...
In the age of Sharknado and Movie 43, it might seem strange to some that a film director might want to distance themselves from a theatrical disaster and miss out on all that lucrative "so bad it's good" money. Yet in the early days of cinema, directors had to build their entire careers on churning out successful, profitable films one after another in quick succession.
Back then, you didn't get to mess up as many films as directors like M Night Shyamalan have and still keep your job. If you screwed up too much, your name and your entire career would be cast aside for the next hottest talent. Early Hollywood was a cutthroat business, and very few directors managed to build a career out of purposefully producing terrible films.
But before we invented this internet-thing, people could just straight up lie and get away with it. As a result of this loophole, the pseudonym Allen Smithee was created by the Directors Guild of America. Make a rubbish film? No worries! Just pretend it never happened and have another crack at the whole film-making malarkey instead mate.
That isn't to say directors don't still engage in the practice of disowning their films. Of course nowadays discrediting your own work is more of a spiteful, power move rather than a crafty one. Whether you like it or not that stuff is still gonna show up on your IMDb - and on lists like this one...
8. Death Of A Gunfighter (1969)
Death of a Gunfighter, unlike most of the films on this list, has the rare distinction of not being completely awful. It's garnered decent reviews and, due to its place in film history, has a small cult following.
The film itself is actually what birthed the Alan Smithee pseudonym, as the original director Robert Totten (of Gunsmoke fame) clashed with the film's star, Richard Widmark, and was dropped by the studio. He was then replaced by Don Siegel, director of Dirty Harry, who completed filming.
Once the film was completed Siegel protested his own directors credit, attributing too much of the work to Totten. With neither director wanting to take credit, the Director's Guild of America invented the pseudonym "Allen Smithee", and the rest is history.
The studio behind the film neglected to inform the press or reviewers of this fact however, so once the film was released to the public people began raving about this new up-and-comer. Robert Ebert himself said in his 3.5/4 review of the film that "director Allen Smithee, a name I'm not familiar with, allows his story to unfold naturally."
7. Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983)
To say Twilight Zone: The Movie had a troubled production process is putting things lightly. The film assembled four directorial behemoths, bringing together Spielberg, John Landis, Joe Dante and George Miller for the anthology picture, none of which pulled their director's credit from the film.
In fact, the only person to do so was second assistant director Andy House. House is kind of a "always the bridesmaid, never the bride" sort of director, more recently producing or writing television instead of helping to direct blockbuster movies.
So why would an assistant director ask to have their credit removed from a film? Well, House personally took umbrage with a notorious on-set disaster that occurred during the film's shooting. During the filming of a helicopter stunt, the pilot of the helicopter lost control when pyrotechnics were ignited too close to the vehicle.
The resulting crash ending up killing two child actors, who were being paid illegally in a bid to circumvent California's child labour laws, as well as one of the film's lead actors, Vic Morrow. House, sickened by the studio's role in their deaths, chose to remove his directorial credit from the film before the film's release.
6. Supernova (2000)
Ho boy, where to start with this one? Supernova is (apparently) a science-fiction horror, but if you were to watch the trailer for the film you might instead assume it's some kind of... space rom-com? I feel confident in saying it may be one of the worst trailers ever seen.
The project went through four different directors before filming finished, starting with Geoffrey Wright in 1997 and ending with Ford Francis Coppola in 1999. Whilst Wright quit before filming even began, Jack Sholder came on-board to re-shoot what the second director, Walter Hill, had started.
Eventually, when both Sholder's and Hill's cuts of the film failed to impress the producers, Coppola was brought on to finish the job and provide a final edit of the film. Coppola, you know the guy who directed The Godfather, struggled to work the film into anything even remotely decent and it subsequently released to terrible, awful reviews.
In the end, none of the three of the directors that actually worked on the film ended up receiving a directorial credit. As the name Alan Smithee had become too recognizable by the time the film was released, the studio instead opted for the name "Thomas Lee".
5. Accidental Love (2015)
Accidental Love, also known as Nailed during it's production, started production sometime in 2008. Now for anyone who might have seen this film (maybe one of the three of you happens to read this) that should set some alarm bells ringing, as Accidental Love's final product definitely didn't warrant seven whole years of development.
The film actually finished primary filming in early 2010, and by "finished" I mean the entire production team got sick of not being paid and quit. Supposedly production on the project was halted no less than 14 times over this two year period, and the film's producers Douglas Wick and Lucy Fisher refused to film a scene pivotal to the film's plot until after all the production team had been paid.
The film's director, David O. Russell, refused to return for re-shoots after quitting the production. After the original production company, Capitol Productions, went bankrupt in 2010, the film was purchased by Millennium Entertainment in 2014 and completed.
David O. Russell subsequently removed both his directorial and co-writing credits from the film, instead going under the pseudonym Stephen Greene. Then, to nobody's surprise, the film was released to awful, awful reviews. Definitely worth the seven years of production hell.
4. Solar Crisis (1990)
Solar Crisis is a pretty unexceptional entry in this list. The film itself isn't good, but honestly it's not terrible either. It's not aged very well over the past couple of decades, but it's not offensively bad by any stretch of the imagination. It also didn't have a troubled production schedule, instead completing its production in well under a year.
What is significant however is that it's the only entry in the list to feature two separate discredits. After the film under-performed in Japan (where it was first released) the production company behind the film optioned to reshoot some footage, which the director of the project, Richard C. Sarafian, felt uncomfortable putting his name to.
The weird thing is Sarafian's son, Tedi, was the one who helped rewrite the script to accommodate these reshoots. After helping reshoot his father's work, Tedi then decided he didn't want his name on the project either and opted for the pseudonym "Crispan Bolt" in place of the already taken Alan Smithee.
Also it's worth noting that the film's technical adviser went on record saying that landing on the sun was impossible, but the producers ignored him because they thought it'd be cool. Never change, Hollywood.
3. Gunhed (1989)
Gunhed, a Japanese sci-fi about a huge robot tank with more guns attached to it than I've had hot dinners, was directed by Masato Harada and released in Japan in 1989. Much like Death of a Gunfighter, Gunhed is actually kind of a great film. There is an incredible amount of detail to be found in the model work, with the titular robot itself looking rad as hell, and it's mostly just about the aforementioned tank-robot blowing stuff up.
So, what's not to love? Well, the English dub of the film is uh... not good. It's near impossible to find it online, most likely due to how truly awful it is, so you'll just have to take my word for it.
Harada hated the dub so much that he refused to have his name associated with the project, instead going under Alan Smithee for it's US release. It suffered critically and financially as a result.
Honestly though, give the subbed version a watch if you've never seen it. Provided you find a high quality version of the film, you'll probably have a blast. It's about a tank with legs blowing stuff up, how can you not enjoy that?
2. An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn (1998)
Strap yourselves in folks, because we're about to go full meta. An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn, released in 1998, stars Eric Idle of Monty Python fame as the unfortunately named Alan Smithee; a director who nobody will take seriously because of his infamous name.
The film itself was actually directed by Arthur Hiller, director of See No Evil, Hear No Evil. Coming off the back of a successful and lauded career that started in the late 50's, Hiller found himself releasing several critical and commercial flops in the 1990's. The last of these, An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn, was panned across the board by critics and currently holds an 8% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
However, this wasn't why Hiller discredited himself as the film's director. Hiller publicly stated that he distanced himself from the film after seeing Joe Eszterhas's cut of the film, taking issue with the final product.
Eszterhas rebuked this in his biography, stating that Hiller actually sat with him in the editing room whilst he cut the film and offered advice. So, it's more than likely that it was simply just a stupid marketing ploy, or maybe an extra-meta joke Hiller played on his audience.
1. Exposed (2016)
Exposed, formerly known as Daughter of God, is a 2016 cop-thriller starring Keanu Reeves. Originally, before studio interference, the film had Ana de Armas as it's lead with Keanu Reeves as a supporting character.
When Lionsgate bought the rights to the film, they assumed (as you naturally do when spending several million dollars purchasing a film) that Keanu was meant to be the film's lead. So, instead of simply misleading their audience and putting Keanu's face in all the posters or editing the trailers to make it look like he was the lead - like a real studio would - Lionsgate just decided to massacre the film on the cutting room floor and edit it to forcibly make Keanu the lead.
Naturally, this annoyed director Gee Malik Linton, who'd shot a bi-lingual drama focused on police brutality and violence against women, only to get a nonsensical thriller instead. Linton rescinded his directorial credit and instead the film was released under the pseudonym "Declan Dale".
The film got awful reviews and made barely any money. Hopefully, Lionsgate will re-release the film with a proper edit, as what we were originally promised seemed genuinely innovative and interesting. Also, maybe pigs will grow wings and fly.