8 "Great" Movies You Actually Only Remember For The Plot Twist

How much of Shutter Island can you even really recall?

Shutter Island
Paramount Pictures

Audiences love plot twists - so much so, in fact, that they often end up giving a movie way more credit than it actually deserves if it culminates on a crazy or unpredictable twist. After all, it's the element they end up thinking about when they leave the theatre; it's the part they'll remember when somebody asks them about the film.

But a truly great film is made up of dozens of great scenes, and a plot twist can often dupe us into forgetting that. Not that it isn't possible to have a great film that also relies on a plot twist; Se7en, Fight Club and Oldboy are all films made endlessly rewatchable because they don't need their associated twists to be awesome - they're made up of one great scene after another, regardless of the final denouement.

There are some "great" films, however (and, yes, notice the quotation marks), that lack the relentless brilliance of the aforementioned films because they are so very reliant on their plot twists. In retrospect, these twists are likely to be the one aspect you remember about each film, whilst the rest of the narrative lingers hazily in your mind as an unfamiliar blur of forgettable, somewhat interchangeable scenes.

You have to ask yourself: how great can a film be if all you can really remember about it a few months later is its plot twist?

8. Shutter Island (2010)

Shutter Island Leonardo DiCaprio
Paramount Pictures

What People Remember About The Movie: "Well, it starts off on a boat, doesn't it? Then they meet Ben Kingsley, who's the bad guy. Or the good guy, I don't recall. Then some seriously weird stuff happens in the middle and it turns out Leo is actually a patient at the mental hospital."

There's no denying that Shutter Island is a well-made film, because Martin Scorsese rarely delivers anything else. The problem is that, unlike Scorsese's best pictures, this adaptation lacks both punch and depth and relies squarely on its shocking ending to leave audiences feeling stunned and awed.

You remember bits and pieces of Shutter Island, of course, like the boat scene at the beginning and the ending in the lighthouse; trying to map out the story or track the narrative of the film is more difficult, though. Much of the film is played as a red herring, so watching Leo racing around the island trying to solve the central mystery doesn't wind up being all that memorable because it doesn't mean anything.

The dark, murky aesthetic doesn't help matters, either - it makes differentiating the events of the movie near impossible. Alas, you come away with Shutter Island's big reveal lingering in your mind... and not much else.


7. What Lies Beneath (2002)

What Lies Beneath
Dreamworks

What People Remember About The Movie: "That's the one where Harrison Ford is the bad guy, right? He's married to Michelle Pfeiffer! The plot? Uh, gimme a minute."

If What Lies Beneath lacked its famous twist, in which the typical nice guy character played by Harrison Ford, Dr. Norman Spencer, turns out to be a murderer, chances are that nobody would remember this film even existed. That's kind of surprising, given that it was helmed by Robert Zemeckis, who has given us some of the most entertaining flicks of the past few decades.

What Lies Beneath has a reputation for being a good, efficient thriller, which in retrospect feels entirely unearned: save for the twist, nothing about Zemeckis' film sticks with you in the aftermath. What's the story? What was Norman's motive?Chances are that, if you haven't seen this one in years, you're struggling to recall literally a single detail about the plot.

Zemeckis tried for a Hitchcockian thriller, but ultimately he came up short; Hitchcock knew that there needed to be more than a twist to make a movie - you needed memorable moments along the way. What Lies Beneath could and should have been more than the sum of its twist, instead of merely serviceable.


6. The Game (1997)

The Game Michael Douglas
PolyGram Filmed Entertainment

What People Remember About The Movie: "Oh, yeah, so this was Fincher's first film after Se7en and, like, nowhere near as good. Michael Douglas plays an as*hole in this, that I do recall. Weird stuff starts happening to him, and then we find out that it was all a game to make him less of an as*hole. Right?"

David Fincher followed what is perhaps his greatest film, Se7en, with The Game, a paranoid thriller that is so clinical in its execution that a trip to a fridge shop would prove to be a less chilling experience.

The Game's big plot twist tells us that everything that happens is the result of an elaborate, pre-planned scheme designed to make Michael Douglas's jerky millionaire more appreciative of his existence. But what actually happens across the film's whopping 128 minute runtime, before Douglas arrives at his birthday party at the end and discovers that his brother - played by Sean Penn - was responsible?

The vague and puzzle-like nature of The Game doesn't make it memorable; it simply ensures that you don't recall any of what occurs. There's a love interest character in this film, played by Deborah Kara Unger, but trying to remember what purpose she serves or how she fits into the story... well, good luck with that.


5. The Sixth Sense (1999)

The Sixth Sense Bruce Willis
Buena Vista Pictures

What People Remember About The Movie: "This one's easy: Haley Joel Osment can see ghosts. Bruce Willis is a ghost. What else? Um, well, Haley Joel Osment has a mom and there's a young, scary Mischa Barton. That's it. That's the film."

The Sixth Sense is probably the most famous "movie with a twist" ever made, and it's generally regarded to be a great film - M. Night Shyamalan's best movie, at least, and the one that tricked the world into thinking that we had another Steven Spielberg on our hands. That wasn't the case, obviously, as The Village confirmed that.

To deride The Sixth Sense might seem like cinematic blasphemy, then, but here's a film with a reputation that far exceeds the contents of what's actually in the movie. Not only does the twist itself not make much sense (that's an argument for another time, though), but very little of the movie is as memorable as the final denouement. As a narrative, The Sixth Sense kind of blurs into a hazy collection of scenes.

That's not to say there's nothing to like: there is a level of craftsmanship inherent to Shyamalan's film that is admirable. It's just that, narratively, nothing really stands out about The Sixth Sense and the story beats don't linger. Imagine trying to describe what happens in this film to a friend, beat by beat: it's harder than you think.


4. The Secret In Their Eyes (2009)

The Secret In Their Eyes
Sony Pictures Classics

What People Remember About The Movie: "There's that scene with the stadium, isn't there? That was cool. The twist at the end... well, it turns out the guy they've been looking for has been locked up for years. Can't remember the rest, though."

Recently remade into an unnecessary Hollywood flop starring Nicole Kidman, Julia Roberts and Chiwetel Ejiofor, the original Argentine version of The Secrets in Their Eyes is considered by many to be a modern classic of world cinema. And coming away from the film for the first time, that is sure to feel like an appropriate declaration, so powerful and unexpected is the final plot twist.

But that doesn't excuse the fact that the majority of The Secrets in Their Eyes, save for one awesome scene set at a stadium during a football game, shot in what appears to be one take, has all the durability of an episode of Law & Order. In the moment, it might seem thrilling, but none of the procedural aspects have any staying power: compare them to those in a film like Zodiac, and you get the point.

In this case, the revelation - that Irene has been keeping the guy who murdered her daughter in a makeshift cell all along - is such a shock that Juan José Campanella's film feels weightier than it is. But, really, what can you recall, save for its ending?


3. Gone Baby Gone (2007)

Casey Affleck Gone Baby Gone Patrick Kenzie
Miramax

What People Remember About The Movie: "Uh... they drove out to that house and Morgan Freeman had the girl and he was bad?"

Ask anybody whether they think Gone Baby Gone is a good film and their answer is likely to be: "Yes, of course it is." Ask them to outline the plot and the only thing they'll probably be able to tell you is: "Morgan Freeman was the bad guy all along!"

Gone Baby Gone has a reputation for being a great thriller, and in the moment - just like the Dennis Lehane novel it's based upon - it's certainly a compulsive and entertaining ride. Get into the specifics, though, and there's something about Gone Baby Gone that renders it utterly forgettable. Seriously: if you saw it more than a year ago, can you recall a single solitary scene apart from the bit with the twist?

The film's plot, which follows a private detective's relentless pursuit to locate a missing girl, is made wholly memorable by the shocking reveal, when it turns out that a supposedly trustworthy police captain (played by Morgan Freeman) has been hiding her away the entire time. But it stands to reckon that the relatively "flat" nature of the film's tone results in a flick that's actually quite hard to recall.

Well-made and competently written, Gone Baby Gone fails to leave a true mark because most of its procedural aspects aren't easily differentiated.


2. The Illusionist (2006)

Ed Norton The Illusionist.jpg
Yari Film Group

What People Remember About The Film: "He's a twin! Oh, wait, no, that's a different film about magicians, isn't it? The Illusionist? Oh, yeah.... the girl was alive the entire time, and Ed Norton, like, framed Paul Giamatti!"

The Illusionist is the other movie about magicians that came out at around the same time as The Prestige in that weird, serendipitous Antz/A Bug's Way - a Hollywood coincidence that has since led to people getting these movies confused roughly four times a day. Whilst The Prestige is packed full of memorable scenes and happenings, however, the story behind The Illusionist simply escapes the memory.

This is a pretty highly regarded film we're talking about, and one featuring fine performances from most of its cast - especially Ed Norton, who plays a magician named Eisenheim, and Paul Giamatti, who plays the cop who's out to get him.

The basic story is based around a romance (Jessica Biel is love interest Sophie), but you'd be pressed to recall any of Norton's interactions with his beau. The plot unravels in such a vague, mysterious way that it's difficult to absorb the scenes, so focused are you on trying to decode what's happening. This essentially renders everything else - save for the final reveal in which we discover Sophie has faked her death all along and the whole thing was a scheme - kind of forgettable.

As Roger Ebert said in his admittedly positive review of the film, "the screenplay and direction aren't that strong," and that pretty much sums it up - you need more than a twist for a film to stay with you longer than the time it takes to drive home.


1. Buried (2010)

ryan reynolds buried
Lionsgate

What People Remember About The Film: "He gets buried with a phone and a snake, and then at the end - just when you think Ryan Reynolds has been saved and it's gonna be fine - they dig up the wrong guy. Proper depressing, this one."

Of all the movies featured on this list, perhaps, Buried makes the most sense: it's incredibly difficult to recall what happens in any detail in a movie that is set in such a small location with such limited perspective. Ryan Reynolds' Middle East-based truck driver is confined to a coffin for the sum of the film, after all; he doesn't move.

In essence, then, trying to remember what happens in Buried means you have to recall the conversations that take place over the cell phone - which is very unlikely. As such, it's really, really easy to forget what actually occurs across the span of this film, aside from "guy gets stuck in coffin" and "guy doesn't get out of said coffin."

You remember the ending with a horrific vividness, of course, because it's plainly disturbing. Just when we think Paul Conroy is about to be rescued, the film hits us with a nasty plot twist. To quote Sallah from Raiders of the Lost Ark: "They're digging in the wrong place." The film ends on the bum note of guaranteed death.

What literally happens for the other 90 minutes of this supposedly great film, though? It almost certainly escapes one's memory.

What other films that over-relied on their twists belong on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.