8 Horror Movies Built On A Lie
The truth is overrated.
Films lie to us all the time. And considering we sit down to watch anything from dragon slaying adventures to planet hopping space dramas when it comes to settling on a story, the truth really isn't all that important if having a good time with a grand story is on the cards instead.
Whether that's a marketing campaign that buries the real movie so deep you have no idea what you're watching when you finally get to the cinema, or a plot that celebrates the endless possibilities of twisting a narrative to the point of no return - there are all sorts of mistruths that go to making an exciting movie along the way. It's true that horror in particular has capitalised on some of the best lies out there to make endlessly terrifying movies - and whilst not every film that bends the truth does so well, the result is always one well worth talking about.
From doomed simulations, to sequels that shouldn't exist, to straight up filmic trolling in its purest form - if horror movies could wear pants: these ones would definitely be on fire.
9. Honourable Mention: At The Mountains Of Madness
A short deviation from the films that used lies to their advantage, here's the one case where a film absolutely SHOULD have been built on a lie - but wholesome, pure, good-hearted Guillermo Del Toro couldn't bring himself to bend the truth for his passion project to come to life. God bless that man.
At the Mountains of Madness was Del Toro's envisioned adaptation of H.P. Lovecraft's work of the same name, and would have been a deliciously dark fantasy slathered in his iconic style. The only reason it hasn't already been made - as it was in the capable hands of Universal studios at one point - is because it was designed with a hard R rating in mind.
Apparently, Del Toro knew a PG-13 could have gotten the green light, but didn't want to tell porkies about his project. It's only when the thing got canned that he realised his mistake.
He said himself in an interview with Collider: "I’m too much of a Boy Scout, I should have lied, but I didn’t.”
You should have Mr. Del Toro, you should have.
8. The Fourth Kind
The most audacious liar of them all, The Fourth Kind takes things to the extreme with its fictitious story presented as cold hard truth. A mockumentary that goes to great lengths to appear as if the 'mock' has nothing to do with it, this tale of alien abductions in Nome, Alaska claims to be based on a true story. And it is! Only... it's a true story that has nothing to do with alien abductions.
Going so far as to construct fake 'true' footage with 'real' actors to go alongside dramatic recreations, The Fourth Kind really hammers home its bafflingly convincing premise of extraterrestrial terror. It's just a shame that it's been plastered over actual accounts of missing and dead citizens of Nome in the process - using real tragedies as a canvas to paint in alien tales that seem wildly inappropriate when looked at in context.
Producers even went as far as to create fake news stories from real papers in the area for marketing. The whole thing earned them a hefty lawsuit in the process, and the film was critically panned for its offensive manipulation of the truth. Ouch.
7. Jacob's Ladder
A story woven around a narrative lie, this one is a big old spoiler if you haven't seen the movie. Jacob's Ladder is the story of a man coming to terms with PTSD after the Vietnam war, seeing nightmarish hallucinations around the city after returning home from his deployment.
Or at least that's what you're lead to believe until the end of the film. Actually a whole representation of purgatory - or at least, some space between life and death that Jacob finds himself stuck in - Jacob's Ladder is really a rumination on moving on into the afterlife, with Jacob himself succumbing to his battle wounds after desperately fighting to live for most of the film's runtime.
Much like The Sixth Sense, this is a film that focusses its lie on viewer experience - pulling the rug out at the last moment to change the movie into an entirely new beast by the time the credits roll. It's the most common type of horror movie lie there is, but Jacob's Ladder is a great one to use as a blanket example for the concept here.
6. Resident Evil: Retribution
Perhaps bending this concept a little more than most, Resident Evil: Retribution is making this list as perhaps the most underseen and underloved fifth sequel in a film series. A very specific accolade, but one I'm handing out all the same.
Whilst the whole Resident Evil series is based on the lie of taking a video game title and spinning out a film series that feels entirely unrelated, Retribution comes top of the pile for creating a world comprised of simulations. Alice and her zombie-busting pals find themselves stuck in an underground facility designed to play out the effects of the T-Virus in public spaces, with grand imaginings of infected cities like Tokyo and Moscow standing between them and their escape.
This is a film that celebrates its fakery and visual lies at every turn, and dives into all sorts of strange subplots to throw viewers off before revelling in the batsh*t insane concept to the fullest degree.
Perhaps the biggest lie this film is built on is that it's just a big dumb action horror movie with very little to offer. Questions of identity, facsimile, and reality all colliding with Milla Jovovich in bondage gear? Why not!?
5. The Gift
Quite the literal movie built on a lie, The Gift wouldn't exist at all had central character and grade A d*ck Simon not toyed with the truth when he was younger. A psychological thriller that uses a new, subtler shade of horror, The Gift's premise revolves around a man haunted by his mistakes - but so desperate to not admit them that he loses everything in the process.
Late on in The Gift, we learn that Simon lied about Gordo - a boy attending the same school as he was - for no real reason other than spite. Telling everyone he was molested by another boy, Gordo was relentlessly bullied and attacked by his own bigot father, resulting in the rest of his life spiralling out of control.
The Gift is Gordo's revenge for the pain he didn't deserve, and at each turn Simon tries to hide the truth of his actions to preserve the comfortable life he's built up. That's the thing with a web of lies though, it's all too easy to get tangled up in it...
4. Scary Movie 2
If you've seen Scary Movie - or more specifically, Scary Movie's promotional posters - you'll already know why its sequel is dropping in for an appearance on this list. And if not, then let me regale you with a tagline that reveals all in but six words:
No Mercy. No Shame. No Sequel.
Well, there's our lie then.
Of course, the whole thing is some extended spoof on the Scary Movie franchise's part that recognises the horror movie sequel disease in all its corny glory. We never need a sequel. We often never want a sequel. But it always comes all the same, hurtling through production to capitalise on a box-office hit that will never quite be replicated in the same way no matter how many follow ups are spat out in the process.
Thanks Scary Movie 2 for being just a bit TOO real by existing at all.
3. It Comes At Night
Mucha few of its other 'elevated horror' chums, It Comes At Night decided to play a dangerous game by advertising a film that doesn't actually exist. Manipulating its marketing to seem as if some inescapable monster would be preying on the remnants of humanity, what actually came out when the film finally dropped was a rumination on human emotion instead.
People didn't like paying to see a rumination on human emotion.
The whole misleading marketing gimmick is one that divides audiences at the best of times - with some desperate to get a full sense of a film before committing their hard earned cash to seeing it, and others wanting to go in totally blind to preserve the cinematic experience. At the end of the day though, It Comes At Night built its whole prospective audience up on trailers for a different film to what actually screened, and many called out the process as an undesirable industry tactic they didn't want to see again.
Good thing Hereditary didn't do anything of the sort then, eh?
2. Troll 2
I didn't say the movies on this list were going to be GOOD horror movies built on lies, so here we are at the bottom of the barrel for the so bad its brilliant level of film in Troll 2. The lie only feels appropriate for this whole mess of a movie though, to be honest, and maybe even enhances it a teensy tiny bit. Never mind the truth, make it interesting, eh?
Troll 2, despite its title directly saying otherwise, is not a sequel. Much like Open Water 2: Adrift, the title was taken from another movie and a sequel digit slapped on the end to help its chances at the box office. Apparently 'Goblins' wasn't as much of a sell, even if the whole movie centres on those creatures rather than the titular troll it's emblazoned with. I mean, Troll wasn't even that great of a movie either, so quite what they were thinking with this one no one can be sure.
Either way, famed for its ridiculous acting and dire storytelling, Troll 2 is an absolute treat if you go in with an open mind and some serious beef with vegetarians. Just go with it. It's worth it.
1. The Haunting In Connecticut 2: Ghosts Of Georgia
Where to start with this film series? The first film is an absolute mess in its construction from concept to execution, with the so-called 'true story' it's based on barely being true in the first place.
The haunting of the Snedeker family is believed to be largely a work of fiction, written by an author hired by paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. They wanted something a little spicier for their infamous tales of supernatural terror, and weren't above making things up to fit their profitable narrative.
So we've already got a first movie that's taken liberties with its source material, and said source material isn't even accurate in the first place. AND THEN we have a sequel to a falsified story turned into sensational Hollywood fodder.
The Haunting in Connecticut 2 makes exactly the same mistakes in basing itself, very loosely, on a true story once again. Also, as a nice little cherry on this big old crappy cake, Connecticut and Georgia are two different states. Talk about one mess of a title.