8 Horror Remakes That Became Classics In Their Own Right

Remakes that aren't terrifyingly bad. Just terrifying.

Dawn Of The Dead 2004
Universal

Our cinemas are inundated with horror remakes, and most of them - it has to be said - are pretty bad. If a film had any commercial success, it’s likely it’s been a victim of a poor reimagining, or will be in the near future. These days it’s even happening whilst the corpse of the original is still warm, with the likes of Let Me In and We Are What We Are being released within five years of the original versions.

However, it’s not ALL doom and gloom. Occasionally, a rare remake pops up that defies the trend, and actually proves its worth as a solid horror offering regardless of its damning 'remake' status.

The following is not necessarily a list of films that are better than the originals, although in some cases that could certainly be said. Instead, this is a list of films that have stood on their own as a staple of the genre, and are an exception to the rule that remakes always suck.

8. Evil Dead (2013)

Evil Dead Mia
TriStar Pictures

The first thing to understand about Evil Dead 2013 is that it really isn’t trying to be Sam Raimi’s The Evil Dead. This is not the humorous, tongue-in-cheek spatter-fest that first introduced us to the Book of the Dead back in 1981. This is a different beast entirely; intense, brutal, unrelenting and at times genuinely uncomfortable. Evil Dead leaves you thinking a joke here or there wouldn’t have gone a miss in order to catch your breath.

The criticism that it takes itself too seriously, and ignores the humour of the original in favour of out-right intensity is fair one. However, regardless of whether you question its loyalty to the 'video nasty' version, one thing can’t be argued, horror films like this are rarely, if ever, seen in our cinemas these days.

It may be a bit too early to refer to the 2013 Evil Dead as a genre classic, and it certainly hasn’t established a similar cult status as the original, but it is one of the best horror films released in the past 10 years and one that is endlessly re-watchable. Even if at times it's hard to watch!


7. The Grudge (2004)

The Grudge
Lions Gate

Hollywood continued its fascination with Japanese chillers following the success of The Ring with this genuinely frightening ghost story based on Ju-on. The Grudge has managed to set itself apart from the majority of forgettable J-Horror remakes that were churned out around the same time due to its brilliantly choreographed creepy set pieces and opting for a tone of impending dread over clichéd genre jump scares. Although there’s plenty of those on offer too!

The Grudge uses the same director as the original in Takashi Shimizu, leading to the film not really being a Hollywood remake per say. The location isn’t changed from Japan to L.A, a chunk of dialogue is still in Japanese, and most importantly it is handled by someone who truly cares and knows the source material better than any other director would.

Aside from a tepid performance by Sarah Michelle Gellar, the film is still as chilling watched today as when released. Despite not being as good as the original, it wasn’t too far off, with The Grudge becoming one of only two J-Horror remakes that stand on their own as being great films.


6. Dawn Of The Dead (2004)

Dawn of the Dead remake 2004
Universal

Zack Snyder took George A. Romero’s consumerist social commentary disguised as a zombie movie and turned it into something a bit more accessible. Although once again taking place in a shopping mall, Snyder doesn’t lay the themes on quite so thick. Instead, he opts for an entertaining thrill ride that is as much blockbuster as it grindhouse. With such an approach, Snyder managed to target an entirely different and significantly wider audience than that of Romero’s version.

The zombie apocalypse sub-genre had not been an ‘event’ movie until Snyder’s film was released. Whether for better or for worse, since 2004, they have been common place on the summer blockbuster schedule, with films such as I Am Legend, World War Z, and Zombieland having the commercial and even critical success of Dawn of the Dead to thank for their 'lifeless' existence.


5. Cape Fear (1991)

robert de niro cape fear
Universal Pictures

Although not a horror film in the traditional sense, the terrifying performance from Robert De Niro is as scary as any movie monster you’ll ever see. De Niro plays an ex-con stalking an average American family, in a more grounded scenario than we’re used to seeing in the genre, which as a result, hits home a lot harder.

Martin Scorsese directs outside his comfort zone in his first foray into horror, but handles the material with restraint, employing a slow burn approach that makes the exhilarating finale on Cape Fear all the more explosive.

Despite not being considered one of his best films (understandable with Taxi Driver and Goodfellas on his resume), it is still one of the best remakes ever with some scenes becoming so iconic that they’re regularly referenced in pop culture: never more brilliantly than in The Simpsons episode ‘Cape Feare’.


4. The Ring (2002)

Samara Morgan Returns In The Latest Film From The Ring Saga
DreamWorks

This is the film that kick-started Hollywood’s heavy-handed obsession with J-horror in the early naughties that included English language remakes of The Grudge, Dark Water, Pulse, One Missed Call, The Eye, Shutter, Mirrors, and The Uninvited. The Ring, however, is the best of the lot.

Subtle, creepy and atmospheric, The Ring relies on suggestion rather than gore, capturing the essence of J-Horror perfectly. Released in a time when the genre was becoming post-modern with the likes of the Scream trilogy, The Ring was not afraid to go back to basics with its campfire ghost story tone.

The film has stood the test of time largely thanks to a committed performance from Naomi Watts who sells the far-fetched premise as if it were an Oscar season drama. Unfortunately, The Ring’s legacy has been tainted by some sub-par sequels which prevented it from developing into the horror franchise it might have become.


3. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978)

Invasion of the Body Snatchers
United Artists

This reimagining of Don Siegel’s 1956 classic, which itself was an adaptation of a 1954 novel by Jack Finney, is multiple films in one. It is a noir mystery, a paranoid thriller, an invasion sci-fi and a body horror. All interwoven genres are balanced perfectly to create one of the best remakes of all time.

Donald Sutherland's health inspector discovers that alien plant seed pods are transforming people into dead-eyed replicas, leading to the distrusting of everyone and everything, from neighbours to the environment itself. What seems like a silly idea is executed seriously and with belief by a host of fantastic performances including Sutherland himself and a young Jeff Goldblum.

Director Philip Kaufman generates a creepy tone throughout with minimal special effects, relying on the ‘are they human?’ enigma to create its horror; a plot device that remains compelling right up until the final bleak scene in which we realise there may be no hope for the community or anyone in it.


2. The Fly (1986)

Jeff Goldblum The Fly
20th Century Studios

David Cronenberg took the B-Movie material of the 1958 original and carved from it a dark, gory, body horror that is still as potent today as it was when released in 1986. Exploring themes such as aging, illness and masculinity, Cronenberg, like in his other work, creates images and moments that will haunt your mind long after the credits have rolled.

Slow burning, and doing away with genre conventions, The Fly is as much a character study as it is a sci-fi horror. Jeff Goldblum plays protagonist and antagonist, creating a similar empathy for him as people had towards Frankenstein’s Monster as he endures a sense of helpless at what he is becoming.

The film won an Oscar for it’s make up effects and rightly so. Goldblum’s slow transfiguration into the fly is as disgustingly realistic as it is fascinating, and even at times heartbreaking, as his girlfriend played by Geena Davis, becomes repelled by his appearance.

Just be warned, The Fly isn’t for the faint-hearted; the vomit scene: case and point.


1. The Thing (1982)

The Thing Cosmic Horror
The Turman-Foster Company

John Carpenter’s The Thing is nothing if not brave. Released the same year as friendly-alien blockbuster E.T, it sports a full male cast, takes place in one location, is based on a cheesy B-movie popcorn flick, and then there’s that title. The box office failure should not have come as a surprise. Yet, some 36 years later and it’s hard to imagine the horror or sci-fi genre without this masterpiece.

Carpenter takes the alien invasion sub-genre and turns it on its head by tapping into cabin in the woods paranoia and seclusion opposed to large scale set-pieces. Similar to Invasion of the Body Snatchers, much of the tension is driven by low key scenes in which we question who is actually human. No scene is better in conveying this than the blood sampling scene, which is one of the most nail-bitingly intense scenes in horror cinema history.

Watched today and it's still as terrifying and thrilling as ever with many of the (non-CGI) effects still holding up, most of which were unlike anything seen before, or since, in any sci-fi or horror film. Bizarrely, it was completely ignored by the Academy, with the film's groundbreaking visuals receiving no nominations for make up or special effects.

The Thing was remade again in 2011, but this latest venture to the Antarctic failed to capture any of the originality, or nastiness of the 1982 version which is not only one of the greatest remakes of all time, but also one of the best horror films ever made.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm pretty good at writing screenplays, news articles, film & TV lists, short stories and reviews. Terrible at writing bios.