8 Miscast Movie Roles That Received A Bizarre Amount Of Praise

Even those these folk were clearly miscast in their roles, people heaped 'em with praise and showered 'em with awards anyway. What gives, World?

A good ol' fashioned miscasting usually goes down one of two ways: either an actor is genuinely miscast in a role and the entire movie crumbles under the weight of their performance, or an actor is miscast and somehow manages to transcend the role entirely and nobody gives a crap, 'cause man weren't they awesome? But there is a third option - one which occurs far less frequently: that of the bonafide, clear as day miscasting that ends up getting mostly praised anyway. How does that differ from option two, you ask? Well, in option two, an actor who originally appears to be miscast on the surface reveals themselves to be perfect for the part (Tom Cruise in Interview with the Vampire springs to mind). But with this third option, an actor who is so clearly wrong for the part ends up getting praised or lavished with awards, despite the fact that - even after the picture is over - you can't escape the lingering feeling that they were miscast. Here we take a look at some movie miscastings that were - rather surprisingly - lavished with respect and praise. Once again, we'll reiterate that these performances weren't necessarily terrible, but remain notably ill-conceived. Is it merely a case of jumping on the bandwagon?

8. Brad Pitt - Inglourious Basterds

Brad Pitt's casting in Quentin Tarantino's bloody World War II fantasy Inglourious Basterds - as Lt. Aldo Raine - isn't really something that gets brought up all that often, almost as if it's of absolutely no consequence, or simply because there's nothing much to say about it. On paper, of course, the idea of Pitt playing the leader of a band of Apache-like Nazi killers sounds like the stuff that cinematic dreams are made of: and yet the actor proved to be surprisingly awkward in the role - the one actor in the film who failed to gel naturally with the rest of the cast. So Brad Pitt sticks out like a sore thumb in Inglourious Basterds. You can't help but feel as though Tarantino's first choice for the role, Michael Madsen, might have been more comfortable delivering the lines that Pitt makes such chewy work of getting through. No, he isn't entirely terrible, and no, he doesn't unhinge the picture, but he's the only actor in the movie that doesn't feel 100% Tarantino-esque (perhaps with the exception of B.J. Novak). It's surprising that so many people came out thinking Brad Pitt was "awesome." Awesomely miscast, more like. The Praise: Numerous Best Ensemble Cast Awards, but no major ones, hence why he makes the tail end of the list. Still, nobody ever seems to mark this out for what it is: a clumsy miscasting that we should strive to mention every single day from here on in.

7. Gwyneth Paltrow - Shakespeare In Love

Shakespeare In Love is best remembered nowadays as one of the less deserving Best Picture winners in Academy Awards history - a notion that isn't helped by Gwyneth Paltrow's frankly dull and retrospectively mediocre performance as Viola de Lesseps, the daughter of a wealthily merchant who has to pretend to be a boy so that she can hang out with Shakespeare and perform in his plays. She won an Oscar, and yet... shouldn't all Best Actress-winning performances remain - above all - memorable? Hardly anybody recalls this one. So presumably the Academy got caught up in the fact that an American Paltrow was talking in a British accent, because that's the only remotely interesting thing going on here (and it's not quite as convincing now as it seemed at the time). People genuinely remember Paltrow's frankly awkward Oscar acceptance speech over her oddly flat performance here, though, which kind of sums the whole thing up: if she was that forgettable as Viola, she was obviously miscast. The Praise: She won an Oscar for Best Actress, yes, and a Golden Globe, too. Not sure the words "Oscar-Winner" and "Gwyneth Paltrow" go together, though.

6. Mel Gibson - Braveheart

There's no denying the fact that Mel Gibson is incredibly likeable and charismatic as wild Scot turned English-killer William Wallace, but he was hardly the right man for the job, was he? Be it simply down to the fact that he doesn't look Scottish at all, or that his attempt at a local accent was bordering the "Kevin Costner," and there are numerous reasons as to why his turn here might be branded as a "miscasting of extreme proportions." And though many critics came to attack Gibson's portrayal of William Wallace in their reviews, the majority of people settled for the: "Oh, well... don't worry about it" approach. Now, don't get us wrong: it's nice that the population were able to overcome the surface level issues with Mel's performance here, but since when has humanity been so forgiving of Hollywood actors (especially Mel Gibson)? Did we all find the final scene of the movie so heart-wrenching that this miscasting was overlooked? Apparently so: Braveheart took Best Picture. The Praise: Well, ol' Mel was gifted with a MTV Movie Award nomination for Best Actor, alongside various other Best Actor Awards for that year. Why was he nominated again? Uh, FREEDOM?!

5. Mark Hamill - Star Wars

It's entirely understandable that some people will be irked by Mark Hamill's inclusion on this list, but think about it for a moment. Mark Hamill is an icon - amongst movie fans, he probably has one of the most recognisable faces in the industry. This stems, of course, from the fact that he's Luke Skywalker, the character who serves as pretty much an audience surrogate within the Star Wars universe - we envision that we're Luke. Thing is, Luke Skywalker is a massive dork. And yet the magic of the Star Wars movies has allowed Luke (and Hamill) to rise above all that, though. And let's face it: Hamill isn't really an actor. Sure, he's okay and he does the job, but when you actually think about the fact that Luke Skywalker is the main character of the series - boring, whiny, personality-less Luke Skywalker - you realise that we're letting the character off the hook. Because there's so much stuff to enjoy about Star Wars, we don't really notice that Luke's a total drip (besides, we have Han, too). Mark Hamill is, fundamentally, miscast in his role as Luke Skywalker - not in the first movie, perhaps, but as he learns to become a Jedi... absolutely. Hamill can't play heroic and stoic - he's forever stuck as the whiny kid forever. It's a problem. The Praise: Well, nobody really ever says anything bad about Mark Hamill or Luke Skywalker purely because of their association with the classic trilogy. He also won two Saturn Awards for his performances in both The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi.

4. Roberto Benigni - Life Is Beautiful

Robert Benigni's performance in the audacious and frankly bizarre Life Is Beautiful is "okay." No more, no less. Playing a Jewish father who attempts to transform a Nazi concentration camp into a nice place for his son to live during World War II through some carefully deployed lies, the subject matter was bound to both trouble and challenge all those who saw it. And yet Benigni's performance was thought to be noteworthy. Why, though? Fact is, Benigni was best left out of Life Is Beautiful in the same way that Robin Williams, no matter how sincere a performance have might have given, was best left out of Schindler's List: the association is just wrong (to our knowledge, Robin Williams was never considered for that movie - which is the point). Miscasting aside, then, the script for Life Is Beautiful was written by Benigni himself, which is part of the problem. Does the movie trivialise the holocaust? Perhaps. But the miscasting here goes back to the script stages: maybe the whole thing was a bad idea. The Praise: Roberto Benigni won an Oscar for Best Actor for his role here, as well as numerous other awards - strange, considering his performance is noticeably one-note.

3. Leonardo DiCaprio - The Aviator

Watching Leonardo DiCaprio dominating the screen in the recent The Wolf of Wall Street only serves to remind us that this guy can really, really act when he's given the right part - talented though he is, however, finding a part that suits him often proves more difficult than one might imagine. That's to say, you could certainly argue that DiCaprio has been miscast in absolutely every Martin Scorsese picture up until The Wolf of Wall Street. Though he feels at odds with his character in Gangs of New York, it's in The Aviator that he feels even more out of place. Which is to say, DiCaprio was wrong for The Aviator and for Howard Hughes in so many ways: despite the fact that the age difference felt iffy as the movie carried across the years, DiCaprio spends much of the movie in a sort of whiny haze that he presumably perfected whilst shooting The Beach. Looking back on The Aviator, it's clear that the movie is one of Martin Scorsese's weaker and more flabby efforts - in a lot of ways it's an unremarkable picture masquerading as a remarkable one. A description that works, too, for DiCaprio's performance, in fact. The Praise: A Golden Globe win, and an Oscar nomination for Best Actor? Both felt somewhat forced - almost as if the subject matter automatically warranted their existence.

2. Jennifer Lawrence - American Hustle

There is something undeniably mesmerising about Jennifer Lawrence's turn in American Hustle, whereupon she plays Christian Bale's frenzied wife Rosalyn, a character who spends much of her screentime being drunk, saying the wrong things, and generally being a pain in the ass. Lawrence injects everything she has into the role, of course, but that's a given with Jennifer Lawrence, anyway - she's hardly the type to "phone it in." The fact remains, though: there's something inherently wrong with her casting in the movie. A certain aspect feels "off." It might be her age. Yes, the character required here needed to be much, much older - somebody we can genuinely believe would have shacked up with a near-on fifty (and balding) Christian Bale. Lawrence is a talent unto herself, but she feels out of place - like a teenager trying to sneak into the adult's party: though her performance is probably one of the most interesting things about American Hustle, she was wrong for Rosalyn (somebody like The Wolf of Wall Street's Margo Robbie, though similar in age, might have been better suited). The Praise: A Golden Globe win? An Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actress? It all seems like way too much acclaim for what was essentially a good performance in the wrong movie.

1. Almost Everybody - Les Miserables

When director Tom Hooper (The King's Speech) decided to adapt infamous musical Les Miserables to the big screen, he also decided that it would be a good idea to have his actors sing live on set, as to inject the motion picture with a bit of added authenticity. What he presumably did not stop to ask himself, however, was: "Why do we need authenticity?" And that's the inherent problem: Les Miserables is a musical, a fantasy - its plot relies on moments of bizarre coincidence that can only be forgiven in a world that resembles that of a fake stage musical. Making it "real" and gritty didn't work - and neither did getting a variety of Hollywood actors to strain their voices, attempting to sing their way through all three hours of the production. So Russell Crowe was miscast, yes, but he didn't receive all that much praise. It was Hugh Jackman who found himself pegged as the perfect Jean Valjean, but the truth is that he's far from it: on paper, it sounded like a perfect match, and yet Jackman fails to make Valjean feel like a person - he's just a vessel for forcing out every sung line in the same, repetitive fashion. And then there's Anne Hathaway, who is good when she's singing "I Dreamed A Dream," and then all right when she's not. Point is, she still doesn't make a convincing Fantine - there's an emotional core inherent to her portrait of the character, yes, but the history feels absent. There's no sense that this women has really gone through what she's telling us she's gone through. And you could make a case for the rest of the actors as victims of miscasting, too (Helena Bonham Carter; there for the sake of it/Amanda Seyfried; to be fair, she had the worst character). The Praise: Oscar nominations! Oscar nominations as far as the eye could see! One for Best Picture, of course. Jackman didn't deserve the acclaim that was heaped on his bland Jean Valjean (he was given an nomination for Best Actor) - and Anne Hathaway wasn't enough of a presence to end up with that Oscar for Best Supporting Actress. Les Miserables was "okay," but you'd think the way people talk about it now that it was a gift from God. Like this article? Anyone to add? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.