8 Moments That Almost Killed Star Wars
From the loss of LucasArts to Solo forcing Disney to change their plans...
When Star Wars was released in 1977, it was a cultural phenomenon that went on to become one of the most profitable franchises in history. Every Sci-Fi movie that came after it owes George Lucas’ creation some thanks for paving the way and the franchise remains a Force to be reckoned with — pun definitely intended.
Of course, no franchise can exist for more than four decades and not hit a stumbling block along the way. In an effort to profit off of his creation, Lucas cashed in on his IP, and who could blame him? Anyone who watched a certain Holiday Special might have something to say, but that’s hardly the only time Star Wars released something terrible.
Over the years, attempts at introducing new video games, concepts, characters, and more have upset and outraged the fandom, and while there are plenty of things about the galaxy far, far away that are up for debate, one thing that definitely isn't is that the Star Wars fandom is not an easy group to please.
As a result, there have been a few moments in Star Wars’ history that could have gone very differently and might have even led to killing off the franchise altogether.
While that has yet to happen, there have been times when the fandom was ready to walk away. Still, there were some bad moments and these 10 were some the franchise somehow survived.
8. A New Hope Nearly Died During Production
Most people look back on A New Hope with fond memories of seeing it for the first time. That's all well and good for fans, but making the movie was something of a nightmare for the people who created it. Sure, it made them rich and famous, but that doesn't mean it was easy.
Star Wars' production was anything but easy, and it nearly died several times before and during the cameras started to roll. Firstly, it was rejected twice before it managed to find a distributor, which didn't help it get the budget it truly needed. After that, the filming in Tunisia was just terrible.
Ironically, Tatooine was meant to be a jungle planet, but filming in that environment seemed problematic, so it became a desert. That locale was no better, and prop breakdowns, serious cast injuries, electrical problems and a rare Tunisian rainstorm drove costs up, caused schedules to be chucked in the bin, and production to become strained.
Add to that the fact that the movie's first cut was unwatchable, and nobody seemed to care about the project other than George Lucas. It truly did defy the odds.
7. The Star Wars Holiday Special
You probably knew this was coming even if you've never sat down to watch the Star Wars Holiday Special. It's something that is so hated by fans, it's become the stuff of legend. Imagine it's 1978, and you're desperately awaiting anything new from Star Wars (which wasn't a franchise... yet).
What you get is a mess so disturbingly awful, Carrie Fisher used to play it at the end of her parties to get people to leave. It was directed by Steve Binder, and George Lucas had very little to do with it. That said, it included Luke Skywalker, Han Solo, Darth Vader, Princess Leia, Chewbacca, and the Droids.
The main story followed Chewie and Han's attempt to visit Kashyyyk to celebrate "Life Day" with Chewbacca's family. It introduced his father, Itchy, his wife Malla, and his son Lumpy. They also looked terrible and were little more than cheap knock-offs of the Wookie design/costume.
It's hard to properly describe how bad this thing actually was — you really have to experience the horror of watching it for yourself. Though, you should never do that. The Holiday Special didn't kill Star Wars, but it certainly didn't do it any favors either.
6. Harrison Ford Didn't Want To Reprise The Role Of Han Solo For Return Of The Jedi
By now, you've probably heard the story about Harrison Ford's dislike of Han Solo. The actor never really clicked with the character — certainly not in the same way fans have embraced him. When Ford signed on to play him, he didn't sign up for two sequels (like Hamill & Fisher).
His obligation was over and done with when Empire Strikes Back was finished, which presented a problem for the franchise. Han Solo was a core member of what made the franchise so appealing to a plethora of fans, but his refusal to sign on meant Han had to go into the Carbonite.
Had he not returned, it wouldn't have been a huge problem, seeing as the character was already on ice. Still, it was one of those moments that nearly made the whole franchise come crashing down. Think back to Return of the Jedi for a moment, and imagine it without Han Solo.
It's almost inconceivable, but for a while, that's precisely how Richard Marquand, George Lucas, and Lawrence Kasdan had to proceed. It's anyone's guess what would have happened with a Harrison Ford-less ROTJ, but it's doubtful it would've been nearly half as iconic as what the final film ended up being.
5. The Special Edition
While Star Wars had incredible special effects at the time of its release in 1977, the artistry and technical wizardry that went into those effects weren't enough for George Lucas. As technology improved, Lucas' desire to go back and fix what wasn't broken grew, and thus came the Special Editions.
In 1997, Lucas released Special Edition versions of the original trilogy to movie theaters to celebrate the 20th anniversary of Star Wars. It wasn't long before people could own their favorite movies in another newer, flashier format on VHS and later DVD. While the tweaks "polished" the look, a lot of fans hated the new versions.
CGI creatures and numerous changes were made to make the movies appear grander than they did in the 1970s. The new version did this, but not in a great way. For example, the practical effects of the seventies still look amazing to this day, but the dated CGI from 1997 looks disturbing, cartoonish, and awful.
Add to that the ridiculous notion that Han Solo fired his blaster only after his head impossibly moved half a foot to the left, and the whole "Han shot first" controversy came to a head.
The Special Edition may not have killed Star Wars, but it certainly made it much harder for fans to be able to watch the original theatrical cuts.
4. Star Wars: Underworld
For decades before John Favreau came along to save the franchise with The Mandalorian, talk of a live-action Star Wars series made it seem like there was one in development all of the time. A live-action Star Wars show was something fans wanted, but it's a good thing they had to wait until 2020.
Star Wars: Underworld was the working title of a series that was planned to have 100 episodes (of the 400 that were proposed). Fifty hours of footage was shot, but it never came to fruition.
The series was set to take place between Episode III and IV, and it was first announced at 2005's Celebration III by George Lucas. Here's how he described it to Total Film magazine (via Gizmodo) in 2008:
"It's kind of like Episode IV — it's funny, and there's action, but it's [a] lot more talky. It's more of what I would call a soap opera with a bunch of personal dramas in it. It's not really based on action-adventure films from the '30s — it's actually more based on film noir movies from the '40s!"
The show was going to have familiar characters like Palpatine, who would've been more of a "sympathetic figure". Ultimately, it never managed to come to life due to the cost of producing it.
3. The End Of LucasArts
For many Star Wars fans LucasArts was home to some of the best video games ever made. This was not only the production company responsible for creating Star Wars games - it was also home to some of the best games produced in the late-1990s and beyond.
LucasArts produced some incredible games outside the franchise, including Maniac Mansion, The Secret of Monkey Island, and Grim Fandango, to name a few. For Star Wars, the studio and publisher churned out massive hits, including Rebel Assault, X-Wing, Knights of the Old Republic, Star Wars Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy, and many more.
When Disney bought Lucasfilm in 2012, the deal included its subsidiaries, and LucasArts was one of them. Unfortunately, an injection of cash wasn't on the horizon, and instead, the studio was closed in 2013. Did this kill Star Wars? No, but it destroyed one of the gaming industry's most beloved studios and set Star Wars down a path of mediocrity for much of the 2010s as far as gaming was concerned.
Fortunately, an announcement in 2021 confirmed the reestablishment of the Lucasfilm Games brand, but only time will tell if it will rekindle the company's past glory.
2. Star Wars Battlefront II
The Battlefront games have long been celebrated and enjoyed by fans, so the announcement of Star Wars: Battlefront II elicited a great deal of excitement from gamers around the world. EA and DICE's 2015 reboot of the series released to lukewarm reviews but showed a great deal of promise, so all the signs were there that a sequel could finally deliver the potential of a truly next gen Battlefront.
Then it was released to widespread criticism. The game could have been amazing, but Electronic Arts were less interested in producing a quality game as they were cramming as many microtransactions as they could into it. Progression was initially locked behind random lootbox drops, which could of course be bought to bypass the grind completely.
Battlefront II hurt the Star Wars franchise as well as Electronic Arts' reputation. Ultimately, it didn't help build a lot of trust in the franchise's licensed games, even though DICE were able to redesign its progression system and ensure that Battlefront II ended up being a truly great Star Wars title.
1. Solo Singlehandedly Killed "A Star Wars Story"
Events or films that nearly brought about the end of Star Wars also include projects that completely upended the franchise. Solo: A Star Wars Story is a perfect example of this because while it didn't kill the franchise, it definitely altered its path forward.
Solo was meant to kickstart a series of films that would make the Star Wars franchise the equivalent of another Disney property: the MCU. Marvel movies have been making the House of Mouse billions, and the studio wanted to replicate that success with Star Wars, beginning with Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.
The plan was to launch a brand new anthology series that would follow a similar format to Rogue One and Solo - with spin-off films centred on Boba Fett and Obi-Wan in production - but the latter's performance at the box office as well as the behind-the-scenes trouble surrounding the film derailed the plan. All talk of anthology films came to a screeching halt.
Since the conclusion of the Sequel Trilogy, Star Wars is taking a different path going forward, with greater emphasis on TV and Disney+. Future Star Wars efforts are in the works, but plans for a Solo sequel are long gone.
Watch Next
Star Wars Quiz: True Or False?