8 Most Criminally Unloved Slasher Movie Sequels
These shunned horror successors deserve way more...
Let's rewind back to that one great scene in Scream 2 when a class full of film students debate how often a sequel is superiorly better than the original. In the class, Randy claims that, "by definition alone they're inferior films." And for the most part, he's correct - a succeeding superior sequel is a pretty rare gem to find...especially within the horror genre.
How many horror sequels out there actually manage to surpass the excitement, innovation, and shock-horror of the first? What's more, how many of these sequels are known as actually being a great watch?
Most of all, it’s the slasher sub-genre that notoriously churns out sequel after sequel, and as a result, there’s a huge collection of incredible franchises full of duds with bad reputations and even worse IMDb scores - particularly within the holy trinity of horror (Jason, Michael, Freddy, and the rest of the top-tier blood brothers). So how many of these sequels have you truly taken to your heart? How many do you consider to be a well-crafted and highly entertaining instalment?
Ultimately, it’s not just the second sequel that's usually underrated, there's also the third instalment, the fourth, the fifth, and beyond that are wrongly labelled as pointless or repetitively stupid. But the truth is, if we skip past the typical horror triumphs of the original, there’s actually numerous under-appreciated sequels that haven’t been given the respect and attention they deserve.
So let’s give a long-awaited round of applause to these follow-ups that have unfortunately become the most misunderstood and unloved underdogs of their horror movie franchises.
8. Scream 3
Out of all the slasher franchises, the Scream series is the one story that falters the least - from the first’s ground-breaking rule-setting, all the way to Scream 4’s exuberant reboot of the original trio Sidney, Gale, and Dewey in a new smartphone-obsessed world. But somewhere in between, we have Scream 3, which in a lot of people’s eyes is the worst instalment by a long-stretch. And mostly, these criticisms are not entirely wrong.
By this third film, Wes Craven had taken all the right things about Scream being a somewhat light-hearted parody, and wrongfully made it far too goofy and corny. There’s some strange outfit choices, some cheesy sound effects in moments where they shouldn’t be, and the plot is centred around Stab 3 - the new movie adaptation of the Woodsboro murders that stars a bunch of thinly-developed lookalike actors.
Saying all that, despite all of its flaws, it’s still a greatly loveable watch, and that’s down to the genius craft of Wes Craven who once again proved that even when he’s not on best form he still knows how to take audiences on an amusing horror ride. There’s a lot of brilliant iconic moments that fans of the franchise won’t forget - including a bunch of funny cameos and a dramatic ending that’s executed just as finely as its two predecessors.
So despite its dodgy reputation, there’s nothing major in the end-product that is totally unforgivable. Actually, crap that... Courtney Cox’s short bangs…
7. Friday The 13th: Part 3
In part three, we head back to Crystal Lake for a third round of Voorhees’s teen-slaying violence, and this time around, the camera crew bought along a new state-of-the-art 3D camera to work with. Sadly, it’s because of these cinematic attempts that part three doesn’t hold up as well as it should against the others.
However, what you have is still a wholly loveable addition to the franchise in its own right - and arguably, there’s one big reason why it should be considered the most important sequel of them all. Why? Well, it’s the first time we see Jason ditch the one-eyed potato sack and instead pick up his hockey mask. Still to this day, the producers of this sequel argue about whose idea this was, and considering how ionic the mask has become, it really is no surprise why they all want to claim ownership of such a great decision.
As part of the biggest, most exciting slasher franchise of all time, Friday the 13th’s third instalment is truly where it all begins. And as one of the most punchy, action-packed movies in the series, part three is the start of what you’d recognise as a bad-ass Jason Voorhees movie.
The distracting 3D angles of the original footage may now be shamefully dated, but overall, it’s still an entertaining fun-time that introduces Jason's playful tongue-in-cheek humour that kept devoted fans coming back time and time again.
6. Halloween 2
Commencing just seconds after the first film finishes, this Michael Myers killing spree continues into the same blood-drenched night on October 31, 1978. Because of this, for those who ever sit down to enjoy John Carpenter’s Halloween, it’s important you know that this direct sequel released three years later in 1981 could and should always be watched straight after. It’s basically a part-two continuation of the first film’s events, brilliantly concluding Laurie Strode’s Halloween night in Haddonfield town hospital.
Like the original, Halloween 2 has that stripped-back, atmospheric-type feel to its story-telling, and the shadow-lurking Michael Myers is just as hauntingly sinister. With this sequel being so directly linked to the original premise, it’s an utter travesty part two never gets the recognition it deserves as an integral part of such a beloved slasher franchise.
As it is with most slasher sequels, there is, of course, still some flaws that were ultimately avoidable - firstly, Michael’s stretched-out and yellowing mask is frustratingly not quite the same, and there’s some pretty dodgy camera work in some of the chase scenes - but because John Carpenter and Debra Hill returned as its screenplay writers, there’s still so much joyous suspense that keeps your heart nervously pounding. Jamie Lee-Curtis is just as charming in her symbolic final girl role too.
5. Final Destination 2
The supernatural-slasher franchise of Final Destination is, in a lot of ways, one of the most innovative and thrilling concepts to come out of horror this side of the millennium. Despite the so-called ‘final’ instalment being released back in 2011, there’s now new talks of a reboot by Warner Bros. This is no surprise considering how wildly entertaining all (but one) of the movies have been…Final Destination 4 is the true skippable dud.
Out of all of them, it’s usually the original or the third iconic roller-coaster instalment that gets the most amount of love and attention from fans, unfortunately meaning that the second sequel gets left behind away from all the fun. However, it is actually the second film that crafted the inclusion of such good-time entertainment in the first place. After the first film’s try at sobering eeriness, the second realised that the premise shouldn’t try to be any more serious-minded than it needed to be. Unadulterated cinematic amusement was clearly the correct way to go.
And that’s exactly what Final Destination 2 is - a pure popcorn-wielding horror romp that requires you to watch it with friends so you can wince, scream, and squirm in harmony. There's still some of the original's devilish terror still lurking too, especially after the opening’s impressively brutal highway pile up sequence that sets up a story packed full of relentless thrills and unbearable edge-of-your-seat tension.
What's more, the one-by-one formula also delivers brilliantly climatic red herring-filled death scenes - including being decapitated by an elevator and being trisected by a flying fence. Is there anything else you could need?
4. Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2
Believe it or not, but director and producer Tobe Hooper originally aimed for the first Texas Chainsaw Massacre to be a far more light-hearted affair, but for anyone who’s seen it in all its grotesque glory, you’ll know that is certainly not how it turned out. But then 12 years later in 1986, Hooper decided he finally wanted to bring his intended vision of a sadistic black-comedy to the screen, and the results are, well, pretty insane.
If you re-watch the original Texas Chainsaw, you’ll notice that there’s a strange lack of explicit blood and gore that you actually see on screen, but in number two, Hooper brings the splatter in full force. There’s also more nerve-racking jump-scares, but this time, he’s got less of an intention to truly upset and disturb audiences with the family’s heinous crimes. Instead, the overall mood is outrageously and strangely playful - especially Bill Mosley’s Chop Top which to this day still stands as one of the best performances of any slasher villain.
Because of this, if you’re willing and mentally ready to give this ludicrous sequel a go, it’s so strangely engrossing that by the time you feel you can’t take anymore you’ll probably have made it to the very end anyway. What you have is an oddly comical absurdity that frustratingly gets a bad time with fans - so watch at your own peril. You have been warned.
3. Saw IV
As each instalment of the Saw series came along, the franchise became increasingly known as having a confusing and unnecessarily knotty plot line. Is Jigsaw still alive? Or is he dead and long gone? Honestly, no one knows. However, there’s one huge draw at the centre of its films that keeps blood-thirsty audiences buying their cinema tickets, and that is, of course, the impressively elaborate torture sequences that Saw has become infamously known for.
This importance of the audience having a fun-packed gore-fest is why Saw IV is known as one of the (if not the definitive) worst sequel of the lot. Instead of a focus on blood-curdling torture inventions, this is the sequel that shifts the series into a sort-of melodramatic character-study of Jigsaw himself and the legacy he’s left behind. We see another huge winding and twisting backstory introduced, and the time-lines that once fitted and slotted nicely now throw you off your game.
Saw IV is undeniably drawn-out and convoluted, but it’s often suggested that each Saw movie should be watched in direct succession like a TV series - as you would if you’re staying up all night to binge the latest Netflix hit. This way, you might follow the plot line a little easier and start to notice the small things to be thrilled by.
After all, the bold scope of its complex narrative is impressive alone, especially in this fourth sequel that seemingly oils up Jigsaw’s game-playing machinery more so than any of the others. Plus, the cold and clinical palette of its cinematography make this instalment the most unnerving of them all. Give it another go - just this time pay full attention.
2. Child's Play 3
Ironically so, the Child’s Play franchise is quite literally the most playfully juvenile of the top-tier slasher franchises. Of course they are in no way PG films, but there’s something so purely light-hearted about the story-telling, especially considering how gruesomely violent some of the death scenes actually are. Then in Child's Play 3, Chucky even saw himself as an armed and dangerous toy solider when the plot followed him to a reprimanding military camp where a teenaged Andy was forced to face his wrath once again.
Unfortunately, this storyline is often labelled as dull, ineffective, and unlikeable, especially seeing as nothing overly exciting really happens in the first half at all. Plus, with it released just 9 months after Child's Play 2, it ultimately falls victim to the hype-riding production company pushing out another rushed instalment far too quickly - resulting in what most cinema-goers described as a half-assed disappointment that simply doesn't live up to its close-knit predecessor.
But hold on a second, let's give Chucky a break. The finale act of Child's Play 3 saves the entire film, all thanks to the spurge of gun-wielding, camo-wearing action and Chucky’s witty one-liners that only grow even more outrageously silly as the film progresses. Justin Whalin as Andy finishes off with a sturdy performance too.
In fact, the film as a whole evolves into a well-rounded and well-acted ending to the original trilogy. It's just a shame the rushed release came at a bad time during the early 90s when the slasher genre generally felt washed out and tiresome.
Luckily, there's one thing that an absurd film about a miniature serial killer naturally is not...and that's boring.
1. Nightmare On Elm Street 4: The Dream Master
After the kick-ass power of A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors, the fourth instalment to the Nightmare franchise had a pretty tough gig to follow. Whilst the offices of New Line Cinema toyed with their options of where to take Freddy on his next outing, in walked a confident and ambitious up and coming director Renny Harlin. According to Harlin himself, he visited the office five times in the hope of inspiring them with his ideas, so despite having their reputations at stake, New Line finally shook his hand and made a deal.
With the magnitude of the franchise’s commercial audience expanding far beyond expectations, the motto for Harlin was, of course, bigger is better. However, despite there being a $5 million budget and a promising script including the return of Dream Warriors’s fan favourites Kristen, Kincaid, and Joey, there was one major issue at hand - Patricia Arquette who originally played Kristen turned the reprisal down. This alone, was unfortunately the film’s major downfall, which as a result meant a competent but far less charming Tuesday Knight took over as Kristen and the returning trio met their demise far too soon in the film’s first half. It all felt rather wasteful.
But that’s not to say Dream Master doesn’t have some of the franchise’s greatest moments. It’s a big, bold and blockbusting slasher with Harlin taking on the story with a ballsy go-big-or-go-home attitude. With his untameable ambition, he took over the audience’s love of Freddy Krueger with vigorous energy and made this fourth screenplay more adventurous than ever. The set pieces of the dream sequences are elaborate and exciting, and he imagined up some of Krueger’s best death scenes that we've ever seen - the iconic cockroach transformation still to this day looks superbly impressive.
Let’s also not forget that Harlin took the reins just at the right moment of peak Freddy popularity in 1988, and as a result, Dream Master still stands as the highest-grossing Nightmare sequel - raking in a whopping $49.4 million. At the time, it was a hugely impactful addition to the franchise, but nowadays it sadly stands as the sequel that doesn’t get the credit it deserves for being Freddy’s biggest and most daring cinematic venture.