8 REAL Failed Movie Pitches Just Revealed
Ever wanted to see the Hulk fight John Carpenter's The Thing? Well you're going to want to now...
Everyone knows that filmmaking is a precarious business. Hundreds of pitches go through Hollywood each year, but only a select few ever make it to cinemas, either because they were immediately rejected, or some behind-the-scenes troubles derailed pre-production.
Failed movie pitches have captivated film fans for decades, thanks in part to the fact that what could've been almost always sounds more exciting than what eventually ended up on the big screen in a given year.
However, while rejected pitches and cancelled projects have been part and parcel of the filmmaking industry since its inception, talk of failed projects has ballooned over the last decade, Superman Lives and Star Wars: Duel of the Fates the two biggest examples.
For every high-profile cancellation though, there are about a dozen more that sneak beneath the radar, mainly because they didn't make it far in the production process. These are the pitches that were met with rejection near-enough from the off, but that doesn't make them any less interesting, as screenwriting duo Mark Swift and Damian Shannon illustrated when they took to Twitter this month, asking for the weirdest pitches writers had come up with, and why they never got made.
Needless to say, there were some REALLY interesting examples thrown up in the thread - as you can tell from the Se7en pitch Shannon & Swift mention there. There's more though, featuring cancelled sequels, clever reboots, and some really fascinating crossovers...
8. A Rocketeer Sequel Starring Alison Brie
Joe Johnston's The Rocketeer is an absolute gem of a film that way too many people have slept on. The film drew praise from critics upon its release but sadly didn't manage to pull in a big enough haul at the box office to justify any sequels. Even so, The Rocketeer has amassed a cult following in the years since its release, with a TV spin-off even releasing on Disney Junior in 2019, while a reboot/sequel is set to debut on Disney+ at some point in the next few years.
All fine and dandy, yes, but what about the other sequels that have been pitched over the last couple of decades? Not too much is really known about them, but thankfully screenwriter Kevin Biegel decided to do us all a solid and answer Shannon & Swift's Tweet detailing his failed Rocketeer pitch. Tragically, it sounds kind of incredible.
Biegel's idea to take the Rocketeer's pulpy sensibilities and apply them to the sixties is a genius idea, effectively enabling the film to mirror the actual evolution of superheroes from the Golden Age of Comics to the Silver Age that emerged after the Second World War. As he elaborates in the thread, this Rocketeer sequel would've also poked fun at sixties spy capers, with multiple elite agents turning up to lecture the new lead before dying all sorts of horrible deaths.
Also, if everything had gone according to plan, it would've had Community's Alison Brie as the granddaughter of Cliff Seccord! Why didn't this get made again?
7. Planet Of The Apes Vs The Nazis
The Planet of the Apes franchise has been through a lot over the years. First, there were five films of varying quality released during the sixties and seventies; there's been a TV show and an animated series, a failed relaunch, a doomed remake featuring Mark Wahlberg in the lead, before finally settling on a brilliant reboot series helmed by Matt Reeves.
Reeves' trilogy, released from 2011-2017, worked as a superb reimagining of the franchise and as a great precursor to the original film. However, while Reeves' films were admittedly fantastic, Daniel Kunka's pitch below might just beat them out solely on account of the fact the premise is genuinely bananas.
That... wasn't intentional.
Anyway, as you can see, Kunka's idea would've been set during World War II and would've seen American soldiers team up with the apes to fight the Nazis.
Kunka goes on to say that the film would've been set in Africa, with the Americans and Nazis vying for control of an important mineral. The twist would be that the mineral in question - sought out by the Allies for use in the construction of the first atomic bomb - was also what made the apes hyper-intelligent.
It's a bit out there, but could anyone possibly turn down the opportunity to see Caesar going to town on Hitler's thugs? Probably not.
6. Hulk Vs. John Carpenter's The Thing
It may be hard to believe today, but the Incredible Hulk was initially conceived by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby as a horror comic. The Jekyll and Hyde influence is plain for all to see, but gradually, over time, the Hulk lost touch with his horror roots, being rebranded more as an action character than as the menacing figure he started out as.
Those who've been keeping up with Marvel's comics will know that perception of the Jade Giant is beginning to change once again. Al Ewing and Joe Bennett's Immortal Hulk series has brought the character back to his horror roots, pitting Bruce Banner and his alter-ego against a manner of terrifying creatures since debuting in 2017, with some looking as though they could've been ripped straight from John Carpenter's The Thing.
It's not just Ewing and Bennett who love Hulk best when he's in the horror genre though. No, replying to Shannon & Swift's thread, Dick Grunert shared a frankly incredible pitch for an animated Hulk project, which would've seen Banner's other half fight what was effectively the same creature from Carpenter's 1982 classic.
It sounds almost like it could've been a storyline from Immortal Hulk, but it never happened. Disappointed doesn't even cut it.
5. The Stealth Se7en Prequel
Believe it or not, this isn't the first we've heard of a failed Se7en spin-off. I say 'failed' in the sense that the only other one that went ahead was Solace, an unofficial sequel to David Fincher's 1995 thriller that featured Anthony Hopkins and Colin Farrell in the leading roles. Now, though, we know of at least one other Se7en project that never get off the ground, this time from Shannon & Swift, the writers behind 2003's Freddy Vs. Jason and the 2009 Friday the 13th remake.
According to the duo, theirs would've been a stealth prequel to the original Se7en, with the huge shock ending being that we were watching John Doe all along.
In their own words, "it was how John Doe became John Doe", with the conceit being that the audience wouldn't know it was him until the final scene, which would've been the character going shopping before entering the apartment where the first victim would be tied up.
That's a bombshell of a climax no matter how you look at it, but the project was just never meant to be, with Shannon & Swift admitting that it was "probably a bad idea" to even try following Fincher's classic.
4. The Last Of Sheila Remake
Switching from one of the most high profile thrillers of all time now to one of the more overlooked mystery films released, screenwriter Jonathan WC Mills replied to Shannon & Swift's thread stating that he'd pitched a remake of The Last of Sheila to Warner Bros. The project sadly never got off the ground but, as Mills notes in his tweet, the success of Knives Out last year may invite the studio to give the project another shot - even if it's not his original pitch.
Remakes are rarely ever not divisive, but there's a lot working in favour of a Last of Sheila reimagining. It's relatively overlooked for starters, and, given the right treatment, it wouldn't be difficult to see how it could work in a post-Knives Out climate.
The basic premise of the film revolves around a movie producer inviting his friends onto his yacht the year after his wife's passing in a hit-and-run incident. A tense mystery then ensues, as all the members of the yacht come to realise that the person who killed the titular Sheila is also onboard the vessel with them.
It's a great film if you can track it down, and one we can probably expect to see grace the big screen again in the future.
3. Oregon Trail: The Movie
The Oregon Trail is one of the most notorious video game series of all time, thanks in part because it possesses an equally infamous game over screen where the player dies of dysentery - by far the most dramatic of all the deaths you could suffer in the Old West.
Playing to the legend surrounding the franchise, Ian Shorr's pitch for a failed Oregon Trail film would've seen a city slicker stuck in the worst version of Groundhog Day ever. As the character tried to complete the Oregon Trail, he'd die repeatedly in various circumstances - sort of like Live, Die, Repeat, but y'know, with more infectious diarrhoea.
Sadly, the studio Shorr pitched the idea to weren't fans, and ultimately the project never went ahead.
2. The Lost Aliens Vs Predator Film
The first Aliens vs Predator film released in 2004, at long last pitting together two of the most successful sci-fi/horror franchises against each other after a long line of comics spin-offs. It was... okay - and the 2007 sequel wasn't exactly anything to write home about either - but what's important is that the first film was in the works for a long time.
The first AVP comic debuted in 1989, about a year before the release of Predator 2, which featured a xenomorph skull in the Predator's trophy cabinet. Development commenced on a movie crossover shortly afterwards, with multiple scripts being submitted before the studios settled on one from Paul W. S. Anderson.
However, while Anderson had been working on his script, John Turman had also started formulating his own pitch for a crossover. It would've been set in the present day, and would've featured US and Russian special forces teaming up to find an energy source stemming from a crashed spaceship, only for them to discover both Predators and Aliens at the crash site. The film would've also ended with the creation of Weyland Industries, effectively explaining their reason for wanting to capture alien life.
This is where things start to get a little awkward though. You see, as Turman explains in his tweet, he pitched this story September 10, 2001 - a day before the September 11 attacks that pre-empted the US invasion of Afghanistan and later Iraq, which was also where the bulk of the story was set.
With these events in mind, this pitch didn't stand a chance.
1. The Blade Runner Prequel About Roy Batty's Origin
Blade Runner is one of the all-time great science-fiction films, so anything threatening to touch it has to be amazing. Although it took a good 35 years, audiences got that amazing sequel in Blade Runner 2049, a project headed up Denis Villeneuve, about six years after it was announced that Ridley Scott would be returning to the franchise.
However, during this time, it's likely that a number of Blade Runner sequels, prequels and spin-offs were pitched. One such concept was developed by Sean Keller, who responded to Shannon & Swift's thread briefly detailing their concept for a Blade Runner prequel revolving around Roy Batty, who was portrayed by Rutger Hauer.
Keller's story would've depicted Batty before he realises he's a replicant. He's sent to quell an uprising, but effectively becomes a "synthetic Spartacus" when he rebels against humanity.
Some will be happy we never got to see this story due to how revered the original was, but it's certainly a clever way of realising a Blade Runner prequel, seeing as Roy was always the hero of his own story.
Watch Next
Guess The Films From These 80s Horror Movie Taglines