8 Reasons Ben Affleck Should Retire From Batman
It's not you Ben, it's me...
Another week, another report emerging from 'inside sources' that Warner Bros. and Ben Affleck aren't quite seeing eye-to-eye on this whole Batman thing anymore.
Rumors have swirled for months now as to whether or not the actor would be reprising his role in the DCEU franchise, with various confusing statements and contradictions. One week Ben says he loves the role and will answer the call anytime he's needed; the next week he's looking for a 'cool' way to transition out of it.
One week Warner Bros. loves him and couldn't ask for a better actor to play the role. The next week they're upset that he hasn't become their own personal 'RDJ' or face of the franchise and they want Jake Gyllenhaal. It's all terribly confusing.
Now, a report has emerged from inside Warner Bros., claiming that the studio is looking to make set plans for the future but that Affleck is non-committal. He seemingly has no interest in officially signing on for or vacating from the role. With Matt Reeve's Batman solo film and several other DCEU films apparently looming on the horizon, a decision will need to be reached sooner rather than later.
And frankly, for several reasons, it is time for Affleck to leave the franchise...
8. Avoiding Confusion
One of the other possibilities that have been hinted at, at various points over the last few months, is that Affleck may very well be replaced in Matt Reeve's standalone film but continue to appear in other DCEU films, such as Suicide Squad 2 or Flashpoint.
This would be a terrible idea.
As much as some comic book fans may be excited about DC's apparent plan to dip their toes into their infamous 'elseworld' stories with Todd Phillips' upcoming Joker film, general audiences will be entirely confused by this.
The general public has a hard enough time as it is keeping up with the sprawling narratives of the multiple cinematic universes in play. Introducing the concept of two actors playing the same role but being completely unrelated will be hard enough with Joker but imagine for a moment a world in which the main DCEU films have Batman being played by two different leading men within the same story.
It is ludicrous. If Affleck bows out of the role now, it is a clear line in the sand and a single actor can continue to play Batman from this point forward, maintaining some semblance of coherency.
7. Free It Up
A mere two years removed from his initial performance as the caped crusader, Affleck's version of the character feels incredibly worn down and saddled with the weight of past disappointments. He's too busy trying to compensate, one way or the other, to make up former transgressions that it's become nigh impossible to feel like we're actually seeing Batman on screen. Instead, it's simply Ben Affleck playing Batman and that is a huge distinction.
Actors such as Keaton, Bale, and Conroy were able to fully embody the character and make it feel as though Batman was truly alive on the screen. A new generation of Bat-fans deserves to feel that way again. Recasting the role would remove the inherent baggage of Affleck and give the character a chance to actually be worth something again.
A new actor would give the DCEU Batman a fresh start and allow the creatives to repurpose him to better suit their needs. When Affleck went from a full-blown murderous psychopath to a fast-talking quipper in just one film, audiences the world over found it hard to swallow.
Had it been a new actor in Justice League, it could have been an entirely different story. Mark Ruffalo has had immense freedom to play the role of Banner in Marvel's films the way he sees fit, rather than being held to what Edward Norton did before him. A new face goes a long way towards lending the character some serious creative liberty.
6. No Hard Feelings
For a long time, Affleck was about as committed to Batman as one could possibly be. He was signed on to not only portray the character in multiple appearances but also to write and direct his own standalone Batman film. For months after the release of BvS, it seemed that all any interviewer wanted to ask Affleck about was the status of his script and when the film would be going into production.
Thanks to this, we got a whole lot of footage of Affleck talking about either how excited he was about his script or downplaying the certainty of said film in the first place. After months of back-and-forth, the news was officially broken that Affleck would not be helming or writing the Batman solo film. Instead, acclaimed Apes director, Matt Reeves, would be stepping in to direct and write his own script for the film.
Since then, Affleck has put on a good face for the crowds and spoken here and there about how excited he is to work with Reeves but he's also mentioned how much he regrets not being able to deliver his version of the script. Having Affleck and Reeves both on the set of that film sounds like a tension-filled nightmare just waiting to happen.
If Affleck leaves the role now, it will surely be better for both Reeves and himself in the long-run. At the very least, they won't kill each other on-set.
5. His Press Tour Composure
As you may have garnered by now, a lot of the issues revolving around all of this stems from the sheer publicity of it. Disputes such as this between an actor and studio relating to a franchise are not at all uncommon and happen all of the time. The only reason this particular issue gets so much coverage is that Affleck apparently has no idea how to keep any semblance of composure after he's been on a press tour for a few weeks.
Whether he's doing press for a DCEU film or one of his other ventures, Affleck is constantly asked about this franchise and the role he plays in it. That is completely understandable. The issue arises from the fact that he can't ever seem to give a consistent answer. During the Justice League press tour he was literally giving contradicting answers, as to his return to the role, from one day to the next.
Things later got even worse during that press tour, when amidst the Time's Up campaign's accusations coming out, Affleck attempted to make light of the matter with some exceedingly ill-conceived jokes.
It isn't entirely Affleck's fault (he is, by far, the DCEU star in the spotlight when it comes to interviewing) but his fellow DCEU stars seem quite capable of not running into these issues. They nod, give polite, general answers and are on their way. A new actor would alleviate the pressure from the press and take a whole lot of stress off of Affleck.
4. Cut Ties With The Snyder-Verse
If one thing has been made abundantly clear from the way WB and DC have handled the Justice League reshoots issue, its that the studios are actively stepping away from Snyder's initial vision for this franchise.
While Snyder may have given the films their start, with Man of Steel and BvS, his distinctive dour tone left a bad taste in many filmgoers mouths. Then, when the extremely against-the-current Wonder Woman became such a beloved and huge hit for the studios, the message was sent loud and clear. Thus, when Snyder stepped down from directorial duties on Justice League, they opted to reshoot huge portions of the film, insert humor, and do some serious redos on the color grading.
Rather than being a conclusion to Snyder's prior films, Justice League was a distinct attempt to get away from them. Everything coming out of DC ever since has been about making things happier, brighter, and more fun. As a part of this rebranding, the studios will undoubtedly be looking for clear ways to signify to casual audiences that things are different now. Of course, the easiest way to do this is to recast the actors who appeared most consistently in Snyder's films.
But whereas Cavill's Superman essentially got a reboot already in Justice League and Gadot's Wonder Woman was turned into an inspiring cultural icon in her solo film, Affleck's Batman has little going for him. Getting rid of Affleck moves the franchise further away from its roots and vies the DCEU a chance to properly earn back some fans and the general movie-going public.
3. His Laziness
Remember when Affleck was initially cast in BvS? Sure, the internet exploded decrying it immediately, but the man himself got down to business. He got in the best shape of his career, he made sure to get hair implants to give himself a comics-accurate widow's peak, and spoke at length about how passionate he was about doing the character justice. Regardless of your opinion of his performance in that film, it's hard to deny that the man was well and truly committed to the role.
Fast forward a few years and that same man is practically unrecognizable in the role.
Not just physically but emotionally, Affleck's performance in Justice League showed that his heart was clearly not in it. He spent the vast majority of the film staring vacantly into the midground without even vaguely attempting to emote. Whereas he perhaps felt he had something to prove in BvS, given his prior Daredevil failure and the internet's reaction, its follow-up showed that he had lost any and all of whatever had been such a strong motivator before.
He fell out of shape, his widow's peak was an exceedingly noticeably bad wig, and every time he opened his mouth to talk about the role it sounded like a downtrodden speaker at an AA meeting.
2. Other Actors Actually Care
Batman is not just some gig. It's not just a paycheck and its certainly not just some guy in tights and a cape. The role of Batman is one of the most prestigious roles our generation has to offer. It is, essentially, our Hamlet. It has been played by fantastic actors across generations who have been able to dive into the tragedy and humanity at the core of his character and deliver truly iconic performances.
It has also been played by Val Kilmer, but I digress.
Great actors have been begging for this part for years. It inspires true passion in the hearts of many A-listers who would love to take a crack at it, which is exactly why it is just not fair for a clearly bored and tired Ben Affleck to cling to the part. Performers such as Gyllenhaal or Hamm are masterclass actors who are chomping at the bit to play this part. They are inspired and ready to go, just as Affleck once was.
Perhaps Affleck has simply been overexposed to the part and has failed to cherish the experience amidst the near-constant backlashes but that's hardly an excuse. Fans, creators, actors, they deeply and passionately care about Batman. And to have someone in the role who has made it painfully obvious through his actions that he does not is to fail the character and everything he stands for.
1. For His Own Sake
Despite what has been said here, Ben Affleck is an incredibly talented guy. He's a great actor and an even better director. Hell, he came into this franchise fresh off of directing and starring in Argo, a film that won Best Picture. Which, though it may be easy to forget now, was the culmination of a long-and-winding road to redemption that Affleck had been trekking for years.
He clawed his own way out of the multiple failures that befell his career in the mid-'00s and started directing his own films. After successes like Gone Baby Gone and The Town earning widespread acclaim, Argo was the film that put him right back on top of Tinsel Town and cemented his credibility as a true auteur.
Then, of course, he threw it all away.
Even his non-DC films have suffered ever since he has taken on the role. His acting in The Accountant wasn't anything to write home about but where the real evidence of the toll this had taken on his personal career was in Live By Night.
It was a film that Affleck had been attempting to write and direct for years, which was finally released in late 2016. What was pitched as his triumphant return to directing was instead a bona fide box office and critical bomb. All of this to say that Ben is clearly not at his creative best when he's in DCEU films, nor is he happy partaking in them and their respective backlashes.
Leave the role behind, Ben. If for nothing else, do it yourself.