8 Reasons Why The Terminator Franchise Is Dead

Hasta la vista, Arnie.

23 years ago, Terminator 2, James Cameron's sequel to his unexpectedly popular The Terminator, grossed an almost-unprecedented $520 million at the worldwide box office. Cut to today, and Alan Taylor's Terminator Genisys stands at less than $300 million after three weeks on release, struggling to even make back the total of its production and marketing costs. It's quite a fall from grace for what was once one of the pre-eminent science fiction movie franchises; what's more, Genisys has also prompted the worst critical evaluation of any Terminator film to date. After five films, including two attempted reboots (Salvation and Genisys), the future of the series appears more dire than ever. It's now up to Paramount and Skydance Productions to decide how they'll proceed with those proposed sequels to Genisys. Pitched as the first in a new trilogy, and with an ending left wide open for follow-ups, Genisys is primed as a franchise kick-starter, with producers no doubt hoping they'll hit better pay dirt with those planned Terminator movies scheduled for 2017 and 2018. At this point, however, whether the saga will even be allowed to continue and keep haemorrhaging money at all seems highly doubtful. Here are eight reasons why the Terminator franchise is basically already dead.


8. Its Reputation As A Quality Series Died 12 Years Ago

It makes sense that producers responsible for the Terminator movies want to keep making sequels. James Cameron's originals, The Terminator and Terminator 2, weren't just financially successful, they were a hit with both critics and audiences, ensuring a longevity that kept fans coming back. With Terminator 3, however, that short quality streak ended. That film, an instantly forgettable cash-in, may not have reached the lows that the franchise would come to wallow in, but it marked the point at which the Terminator films stopped being about quality and started being about making money (even Schwarzenegger didn't want to do T3, until they paid him astronomical sums to reappear). Since then, the Terminator series' reputation has only gotten worse, with the critically-maligned pairing of Salvation and now Genisys. With the gross for these films going down all the time, it seems like the gig is up: audiences know what they're getting with a Terminator movie now, and it isn't something necessarily worth their time and money.

7. The Right Directors Won't Touch The Films

Did you know that Ridley Scott and John McTiernan were offered the job of directing Terminator 3? Terminator Genisys, similarly, could have had Ang Lee, Rian Johnson or Denis Villeneuve at the helm, but all passed to cover more prestigious projects like Sicario and Star Wars Episode VIII. Instead, you ended up with Jonathan Mostow, whose career has plummeted since Terminator 3, or Salvation's McG, someone who - and there probably aren't many who'll argue with this - qualifies as one of the worst working directors of today. Terminator Genisys at least had someone more competent in the director's seat with Alan Taylor, but only slightly. Genisys's director isn't even a moviemaker by trade - Taylor made Thor 2, one of the weaker, more anonymous Marvel films, but has otherwise spent most of his career hacking away in television. When the really great, or even the merely good directors won't work on Terminator movies, what hope is there for the films ever getting back on track?

6. Neither Will The Right Actors

Christian Bale aside (though even he gave arguably his blandest performance to date in Salvation), this generation's great actors aren't exactly flocking to make Terminator movies. Where James Cameron had the pick of just about every male and female star in Hollywood when he made The Terminator, it doesn't seem like there's much interest from the acting community anymore. It's been getting progressively worse, starting with Terminator 3: Nick Stahl and a pre-Homeland Claire Danes didn't show off much but a general blah-ness in that movie, while Terminator Salvation squandered talents like Anton Yelchin and Bale while giving prominent roles to also-ran thesps like Sam Worthington and Moon Bloodgood. Then you get to Genisys, and realise Hollywood's best and brightest are simply opting to stay away. If Jason Clarke's visible display of potential in Zero Dark Thirty (his breakout movie) is beginning to feel like a very long time ago, at least he showed some - the same can't be said for the absolutely forgettable likes of Genisys's Emilia Clarke, Byung-hun Lee and Jai Courtney.

5. No More Schwarzenegger?

With the real acting talent seemingly unwilling to become part of the Terminator franchise, you have to rely a bit more on the great older cast members that any new movies stand to inherit. Michael Biehn's looking to make his return soon with Neill Blomkamp's Aliens movie, so he's shown willingness to tread old ground should a future Terminator movie come calling. However, easily the franchise's biggest asset - Arnold Schwarzenegger - isn't going to be around forever, and at 67-years-old there's no point counting on Austria's greatest import to keep playing action hero. Neither is Schwarzenegger going to waste time on further critical and box office bombs when he's still looking to make a real movie comeback. Future Terminator movies should be realistic: Arnold Schwarzenegger is going to need replacing, and soon, preferably before he hits his eighth decade. Whether producers can find a compelling alternative remains to be seen - Arnie is the Terminator, so what use would the Terminator franchise be without him?

4. Two Bombs Too Many

One major reason why another Terminator movie probably won't happen: simple Hollywood economics. Though Terminator 3 under-performed, grossing less than predecessor Terminator 2, Salvation, and now Genisys, were out-and-out commercial failures. And that, in Hollywood, is the ultimate no-no. A Hollywood blockbuster can offend its audience, have critics to declare it the worst film ever made and cause viewers to leave in droves before the halfway point - but as long as those people went to the cinema in the first place and paid for their tickets, then there's absolutely no problem, and you should probably expect a sequel. If a blockbuster fails to break the bank, however, then that's a different story altogether; when a film fails to make the cash it was expected to make, in Hollywood that's called an outright disaster. The Terminator franchise has two strikes already - whether studios will take a punt and risk strike three is uncertain, but the numbers for Genisys (on track to becoming the lowest-grossing Terminator sequel) definitely don't look good.

3. The Studios Appear To Have Run Out Of Ideas

With Genisys, the Terminator franchise was literally taken back to square one, to the same year and setting as the original, and featuring the old familiar characters for a 'different' take on James Cameron's 1984 movie. You can only speculate as to why Terminator Genisys bombed, but lazily repeating whole storylines and concepts from the first film certainly can't have helped. Movie sequels always benefit from trying to change the formula, by refusing to be tied down to the original film and attempting to forge their own path. Unfortunately, the Terminator producers don't seem to want to take this approach - they're much happier to keep repeating the same lines and same action beats for each subsequent 'new' package. Salvation could have heralded in a different kind of Terminator movie - there was a whole Future War trilogy planned - but after that film didn't perform as well as was hoped, the studios balked and went back to the drawing board. What they came up with was Terminator Genisys, a reboot with nary an original thought in its head.

2. Audiences Have Moved On

With two bombs under their belt, the Terminator producers are right now going to be counting up the figures and wondering where exactly the audiences have gone, and why the people who loved the original trilogy didn't show up for Genisys. Well, the simple fact is that audiences have changed, along with the cinematic landscape, while the Terminator movies appear stuck firmly in the past. After Salvation failed to drum up much support for a Terminator movie about the Future War, the franchise's producers made a conscious decision to go backwards. Back to 1984, back to the romance between Sarah Connor and Kyle Reese and a Terminator being sent on the same old mission, in the hope they could claw back former fans. Trading on audience nostalgia is a cynical move, but it does often work; not so for the Terminator movies, however, which don't quite have the contemporary cultural cache of, say, Star Wars. Furthermore, making Genisys a nostalgic, '80s-set 12A reboot of the 18-rated Terminator seems nonsensical, especially when the youngest audience members at the time will now be approaching their 50s and likely have no interest in seeing their formerly adult franchise turned into family-friendly spectacle.

1. It's An Over-Crowded Sci-Fi/Fantasy Market

The new Star Wars trilogy and its various spin-offs; the resurgent Jurassic Park and Mad Max franchises; the Marvel and X-Men movies, essentially science fiction and fantasy by another name; Pixar's fantastical tales, and other animation from DreamWorks and Blue Sky Studios; numerous YA movies. These are just some of the big films showing up in a crowded 2015. Terminator Genisys came into a very competitive marketplace for science fiction/fantasy cinema, and lost. The film's level of success would have decided where exactly the Terminator movies now fit in in the blockbuster landscape; seeing as audiences largely stayed away, the future doesn't look rosy at all. Things are only set to become more difficult for any future Terminator films, as the number of big budget sci-fi/fantasy movies and their sequels continues to rocket. After two false starts breaking back into the game with Salvation and Genisys, the Terminator franchise is already lagging so far behind, it might never be able to catch up. What are your thoughts on the future of the Terminator franchise? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film, writer of words, pretentious beyond belief. Thinks Scorsese and Kubrick are the kings of cinema, but PT Anderson and David Fincher are the dashing young princes. Follow Brogan on twitter if you can take shameless self-promotion: @BroganMorris1