8 Recent Incredible Movie Performances That Nobody Expected

These shockingly good recent performances were so unexpected that we never saw them coming.

Borat 2
Amazon Studios

It is a wonderful thing about human nature that we are infinitely unpredictable. Any one person contains multitudes and is capable of things we don’t know, maybe some things even they don’t know.

When it comes to the world of movies, this means that even at the most unexpected times, an actor or director can just really pull it out the bag. Even if they’ve been stagnant or unimpressive for years, there’s always the potential for them to just turn it all around. We’ve seen it happen a million times before and we’ll see it again.

There are plenty of reasons why we might not expect much from a given actor. Potentially they’re inexperienced, have a bad history, have been out of the game for a while and such. Well we all need to stop being so quick to judge because we can be proven wrong in an instant.

Typecasting and pigeonholing may hold some celebrities back, but there’ll always be those who break free and surprise us all with a stunning performance. In this aspect and this aspect alone, I love to be proven wrong.

8. Nicolas Cage - Pig

Pig Nicolas Cage
Neon

I guess it’s rather unfair that over the years Nicolas Cage has become a bit of a joke. It’s an unfortunate side-product of his propensity for goofy over-acting and his participation in a variety of bad films; it’s the Adam Sandler effect, if you will.

He has a range of solid performances under his belt, from performing alongside Cher in 1987’s Moonstruck to his haunting performance in 2018’s Mandy - his range is really quite impressive. This doesn’t make him immune to the effects of his less successful films, however, and it’s always the bad reputation that sticks around longest.

So when we heard of a film about a truffle forager whose pig is stolen with Cage in the main role, we expected the worst. Fortunately for director Michael Sarnoski though, his feature debut has been a hit with pretty much every critic - with Cage being praised for his convincing - and surprisingly subdued - performance as forager Rob Feld.

In Cage terms it’s an understated performance, which critics have praised for the modest humility he brought to the role. With Pig, Cage has reminded us all that he is not to be pigeon-holed.


7. Kristen Stewart - Spencer

Kristen Stewart Spencer
Neon

Even though it has been many years since her Twilight fame, Kristen Stewart is still haunted by her early years in that many people will never see her as a serious actress.

When rumours emerged that she was to play one of the most beloved women to ever come out of Britain, they were met with certain levels of shock and outrage. “That’s the Twilight lass,” the boomers cried, “she can’t play ar’ Di’ that’s an insult!” Well they may find that they have to eat their words, as even before the film is available everywhere it’s tipped that Stewart is pretty much guaranteed an Oscar for her performance.

It’s always going to be difficult to play someone who was so widely loved and seen as public property. People have projected for years their own ideas of who Diana was and who she should’ve been, and when playing her in a Hollywood feature film these are all things Stewart would have to take into account.

From ‘that Twilight lass’ to ‘definite Oscar contender’, she has come a long way. Reviews are already pouring in praising her as “charming,” “uncannily precise”, even “note perfect.” The film’s presentation of Diana may not be for everyone, but Stewart certainly gives it her all.


6. Joel Kinnaman - The Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Rick Flag
Warner Bros.

After the train-wreck that was the first Suicide Squad movie, we were all understandably suspicious when The Suicide Squad came out in 2021. Having removed some characters and replaced some actors, Joel Kinnaman was one of the central cast who remained unchanged.

He was playing Rick Flag, but this time around he wanted to have a bit more fun with it. This could’ve gone two ways: either it was going to be too campy and try-hard-funny, or it was going to work. Luckily for Kinnaman, it was the latter. Overall the film was widely praised and enjoyed, and Kinnaman managed to pull of a strong performance that contributed to that.

Not overshadowed by the failure that was the last film, Kinnaman managed to reinvent his character just enough to bring something new to the table without being completely left-field. As the squad’s leader he had a lot resting on his shoulders, but thankfully they were able to make the movie they wanted to this time, with Kinnaman commenting that this time around it was actually “joy to shoot the film.”


5. Sidney Flanigan - Never Rarely Sometimes Always

Never Rarely Sometimes Always
Focus Features

People had little to expect from Sidney Flanigan as she took on the lead role of 2020’s Never Rarely Sometimes Always, given that shockingly it was her acting debut. You wouldn’t usually think it was a good idea to hinge a whole film on the central performance of a young actress for whom this was her first ever movie. It seems pretty risky if you ask me.

It’s nothing personal then that we weren’t expecting much from her. Some were concerned that she wasn’t going to have strong enough acting abilities to carry the whole film - especially one on such a divisive and difficult topic as abortion.

Well we definitely got proven wrong. For her performance as the pregnant Autumn Callahan, she was nominated for over a dozen awards and won almost ten more. Needless to say, this is incredibly impressive for a newbie.

The film itself also earned its fair share of awards and nominations, thanks in part to Flanigan’s performance. Despite her lack of experience she pulled it out of the bag, and you can bet we won’t hurry to underestimate her again.


4. Agathe Rousselle - Titane

Titane Agathe Rousselle
Neon

Horror as a genre has largely been dismissed by the world of film. Critics and awards bodies alike don’t like horror films and they’ve made that very clear. So for sites like RogerEbert.com to give the film 3.5 stars (out of 4, remember), there must be something special about it.

Performances in horror are rarely praised because of the aforementioned bias, but on the rare occasion that a horror film starts being touted as ‘actually worth watching’ there’s some room made for compliments. Agathe Rousselle, the actress behind Titane’s Alexia, shocked us all by bringing this wacky film to life, and carrying it to the extent that it has received its well-deserved press coverage.

If you’re not a very famous actress in an Ari Aster horror, the chances of you gaining attention are pretty low. Rousselle’s brutal physicality and her absolute dedication to this weird, difficult role however have turned heads, and she has thus forced people to talk about her. She took what she was given with Titane and she ran with it, and oh man did she make it beautiful.


3. Maria Bakalova - Borat Subsequent Moviefilm

Borat Subsequent Moviefilm Tutar
Amazon Studios

It was all fun and games joking about the second Borat film until suddenly Maria Bakalova was nominated for an Academy Award for her role. I’m not saying it wasn’t absolutely deserved but seriously, who could’ve seen that coming?

In what was one of the most stunning nominations in recent years (aside from Hillbilly Elegy being nominated for...literally anything), Bakalova had thousands of people rooting for her to win Best Supporting Actress in 2021’s awards. She didn’t end up winning, of course, but it’s not like she didn’t stand a chance.

Playing Borat’s maladjusted daughter, Tutar, Bakalova dived head-first into a role made so challenging by its own outlandishness. Her performance was equally bizarre as it was endearing, as she somehow managed to make audiences care for her despite the overt humour of her character.

Had Tutar been performed by someone less capable, she could’ve turned into one big joke that lost all meaning. With Bakalova though, the girl was able to help hammer home some serious points about sensitive topics without it all being overshadowed by stupidity. It’s a fine line to toe and nobody was expecting her to pull it off, but we were happily surprised when she did.


2. Bob Wells - Nomadland

Bob Wells Nomadland
Searchlight Pictures

One of Nomadland’s gimmicks, if you didn’t know, was that a huge chunk of the cast weren’t actors at all, but were instead regular people performing as slightly tweaked versions of themselves. One of these people was Bob Wells, the founder of an annual vandweller gathering and real life YouTuber and nomad.

It would be a mistake to think that acting almost as yourself is an easy feat, especially when pitted against the incredible on-screen talent that is Frances McDormand (who played the lead role of Fern). Bob and the rest of the non-professional acting cast took this in their stride, delivering believable and humane portraits of the range of people taking on the nomadic lifestyle.

Bob came across as a genuine, likeable guy who wanted to bring individuals together in a community, much the same as his real life self. Much the same could be said for the other nomads present. There wasn’t a problem of losing immersion or things feeling clearly staged, no awkward stumbling or fumbling. Being on camera is hard when you’re not used to it, but every one of them did a damn good job considering.


1. Will Smith - King Richard

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

The film isn’t even out everywhere yet and already people are claiming Will Smith is in the running for an Oscar for King Richard. Revolving around Richard Williams, the father of global superstar athletes Serena and Venus Williams, the film focuses on all the things Richard did to help his girls become the athletes they are today.

It has been a long while since people had high expectations for Will Smith. Between a number of subpar movies and some weird commercial appearances, he sort of disappeared from our minds as a serious actor.

Now, it seems, he is making an unexpected comeback. It was probably in the 90s that & early 00s that Smith was last at his best, with the public flocking to see films he was leading - meaning that his return to the big-time has been decades in waiting.

Time will tell as to whether his performance lives up to all the hype, and what the public actually thinks of it, but as of now things are looking very good as per critics.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's shortest contributor (probably). Lover of cats, baked goods and Netflix Originals.