8 Superhero Films That Nearly Had Completely Different Directors
These versions are out there somewhere in the multiverse...
Large-scale moviemaking is a messy business. There are so many people's livelihoods at stake, so many competing visions and - crucially - so much money on the table that there's little chance of things running smoothly. Getting a blockbuster made seems like trying to control the weather: giant, unforeseeable forces are at work, making human decisions more or less irrelevant.
There are perhaps no blockbusters bigger at the moment than superhero franchises: six of the top twenty highest-grossing films of all time are Marvel movies made within the last decade. So it's not surprising that these films have especially chequered production histories, crisscrossed with the rising and falling fortunes of various directors, tossed on the capricious tides of the studio system.
As such, some well-known superhero films have suffered from tempestuous behind-the-scenes politics that led directors to leave their projects, even if they had spent years working on them. These would-be movies offer a glimpse into another universe, let's call it Earth 212, in which the world was granted a very different batch of superhero films, at the hands of a very different group of directors.
8. Justice League - George Miller
The Justice League movie may have finally made its underwhelming appearance on the big screen last year but, back in 2008, it looked to be a very different project, entitled Justice League: Mortals and directed by George Miller. This would have meant very different actors playing the heroes, including Adam Brody as The Flash, Common as Green Lantern and Arnie Hammer as Batman.
The Aussie legend came frustratingly close to making his vision a reality. He didn't just write an unproduced script; pre-production had started, with $250 million earmarked for the project and Antipodean wizards Weta Workshop underway building sets and costumes. Had things gone to plan, DC would have had its own ensemble superhero film years before the Avengers reached the big screen.
Unfortunately, drama interfered. Following the writer's strikes of 2007-08, Australia altered its tax laws, deciding that the film did not qualify for a rebate because it was not an Australian film. In their view, it was an American film headed by an Australian.
Adam Brody, however, has suggested that there might have been reluctance on Warner Bros' end too, as Miller's new DC universe potentially stepped on the toes of the forthcoming Dark Knight and Superman Returns films.
7. Spider Man - James Cameron
In one of the weirder chapters in Marvel’s history, the Titanic director wrote an entire 80-page "scriptment" in the early 90s for the latex-clad hero, one that took on a distinctly adult tone.
Cameron seems to have been fixated by the idea that the Spidey powers could be a metaphor for puberty - not a bad idea, really, but one that sits at odds with the kind of lighthearted tone we've come to expect from our friendly neighbourhood Spiderman.
In one scene, Parker wakes up covered in a sticky white substance. In another, he spies on Mary Jane as she gets changed. Later she sleeps with him on a bridge, having been seduced by Parker's description of the mating habits of spiders: "the male will attach strands of silk to the female... tying her limbs." It's hard to imagine Tom Holland's preppy hero saying these lines, to say the least.
Things fell through when a contract dispute led Carolco Pictures (the studio Cameron was working for) losing the rights for the franchise, which went to Sony. It's probably for the best.
6. Wonder Woman - Joss Whedon
Whilst Joss Whedon hasn't had a shortage of opportunities to tackle major superhero franchises (helming both The Avengers and The Justice League), he's had a few slip through his fingers, too. Most notable was his pass at the Wonder Woman script; he spent at least two years in the mid-noughties writing the script and was gearing up to direct the feature when the project fell through.
Unlike the Patty Jenkins version, the bulk of which took place during and after WWI, Whedon's vision entirely takes place contemporaneously in the Gotham-lite city of Gateway. Steve Trevor is no longer a soldier, but a military aid worker delivering supplies to isolated communities. The film's villain is Strife, CEO of a munitions company bent on destroying the city.
As if having a project collapse wasn't humiliating enough, the script leaked in 2017 and was widely derided as sexist, with an underdeveloped and over-sexualised heroine. Ouch.
5. Black Panther - John Singleton
The original Black Panther was another 90s treatment that never came to be. The African superhero might have seen the light of day not as a Ryan Coogler project but one directed by Boyz n the Hood director John Singleton and starring Wesley Snipes.
It was a labour of love for Snipes. The actor (who would go on to star in Marvel's Blade films) was a lifelong fan of the comics and spent much of the decade trying to get the pet project of the ground. It was his belief that T'Challa's story would offer a positive, inspiring view of African culture in the era of L.A riots and the O.J verdict.
Snipes and his potential director Singleton didn't quite see eye to eye, however. The latter reportedly wanted to set the project in the Civil Rights era, giving the title a more literal meaning. In Singleton's version, T'Challa would be struggling to recruit his son to the Black Panther cause - not the most inspiring of plotlines. We can all be glad that Singleton's vision was doomed.
4. Watchmen - Terry Gilliam
Although Zack Snyder's 2009 film wasn't terrible, many felt that it was an underwhelming use of such rich source material. Snyder's heavily-stylised, edgy pretensions often bordered on the adolescent and lacked the subtlety of Alan Moore's groundbreaking graphic novel. Which is why it would have at least been interesting to see the film at the helm another director - namely, surrealist maestro Terry Gilliam.
For over a year in the 90s, Gilliam and Brazil screenwriter Charles McKeown worked on the project. From the titbits teased by producer Joel Silver, their version would have been a far more daring, iconoclastic adaptation, unafraid to make serious departures from the source material where Snyder was overly-respectful.
Like Snyder, Gilliam decides not to include the interdimensional Death Squid of the book. Instead, Doctor Manhattan travels back in time to prevent himself from ever existing, resulting in an alternate reality where Nite Owl, Rorschach et al. were never superheroes. Bold, but kind of brilliant.
3. Doctor Strange - Guillermo Del Toro
Doctor Strange is another superhero who received a solid but not particularly inspired transition to the screen. Whilst Scott Derrickson's 2016 creation was rich with visual artistry, it was slight on, well, strangeness, missing some of the alluring mysticism of the source material.
It stands to reason, then, that legendary fantasists Neil Gaiman and Guillermo Del Toro (with their track records of strange, dark and magical creations) might have better suited the franchise.
And this isn't completely fanciful, as the writer and director pitched their own version of Doctor Strange in 2007, dreamt up on the set of Hellboy. It sounds like their pitch was perhaps a little too odd for Marvel's tastes; Del Toro was drawn to the comic's depiction of the occult and didn't want Strange wearing a suit.
Although the studio did ultimately decline, it's not hard to imagine a director of Del Toro's clout being gifted the franchise. One can only dream...
2. The Wolverine - Darren Aronofsky
The 2013 film, based on Frank Miller’s 1982 “Wolverine” series, was ultimately directed in the safe hands of James Mangold. It could, however, have been helmed by the dark visionary Darren Aronofsky. For a while it looked likely, too; the director only left the project due to a messy and time-consuming divorce.
It's difficult to imagine just how different the project might have been. Of course, 2017's Logan showed off a darker side to Wolverine, but Aronofsky's films tend to offer a more psychological grittiness, full of anxiety and paranoia.
In fact, what we know about the script suggests it could have been even darker than Logan. Writer Christopher McQuarrie (The Usual Suspects), described the first draft as "Kurosawa's Wolverine" and one of the best scripts he'd ever written, saying that it featured no other mutants than Wolverine.
1. Ant-Man - Edgar Wright
One of the MCU’s biggest disappointments in recent years was Edgar Wright’s departure from the Ant-Man project in 2014, the result of his inability to stick to Marvel’s infamously strict formula. Wright had been at work on the film for eight years (amidst other projects) with writing partner and Attack the Block director Joe Cornish.
Although details are murky, it was clearly creative differences, caused by Wright's famously distinctive style, that led to the failure. Wright has diplomatically stated: "I wanted to make a Marvel movie but I don’t think they really wanted to make an Edgar Wright movie".
Ultimately, the film and its upcoming sequel were directed by Peyton Reed. Directors like James Gunn and Taika Waititi have managed to retain their comic sensibilities and tick off the Marvel checklist, so it’s a shame it never worked out for Wright.