8 Things The DCEU Is Doing Better Than The MCU (So Far)

The MCU Vs. DCEU battle isn't as clear cut as you might think...

Captain Marvel Wonder Woman
Marvel Studios/Warner Bros.

The DCEU has had a troubled journey so far. Difficult productions, critical mauling and box office disappointments have been a problem regarding several of its films and it has become something of a critical punching bag, but it's not all bad news. Quite the contrary.

The films are getting better and better, and although the DCEU isn't as good as the Marvel Cinematic Universe, it certainly isn't the weak franchise it once was. In fact, the DCEU has done a fair few things better than the MCU across its eight films so far.

Of course, in terms of writing, acting, box office performance, humour, coherence and overall consistency and quality, the MCU is an immediate winner but in some other areas it's actually been surpassed by this other, less successful superhero cinematic universe.

Judging by both these qualities and the improving fortunes of the DCEU, perhaps this franchise will be just as good as Marvel's cinematic universe one day. Stranger things have happened...

8. The Outsider Hero's Fantasy World

Aquaman Atlantis
Warner Bros.

Aquaman (Jason Momoa) is basically the Justice League equivalent to Thor, since he's another long-haired, god-like member of royalty from an alternative world (sort-of).

Asgard, the world where Thor comes from, is OK. It looks nice and everything but it's ultimately kind-of meh (just like most of the other things in Thor's solo films). It isn't a tenth as awesome or detailed as Atlantis, which is the underwater world where Aquaman's mother comes from and of which Aquaman is now king.

Not only is it an absolutely stunning and gorgeous on a visual level, but Aquaman's solo film took time to flesh out some of the backstory regarding the original seven kingdoms, their differences in appearance and history, and the state the different groups have fallen into.

It's a living, breathing world that pretty much represents some of the best world-building of any kind in any MCU or DCEU film.


7. A More Adult Vibe

Birds of Prey Black Mask Ewan McGregor
Warner Bros.

The DCEU movies are mostly darker and more grown-up than the MCU ones, with even Shazam! being darker in points than many would've expected, and this has mostly worked in the franchise's favour.

It helps the DCEU stand apart from the Marvel films and in the DCEU's better movies this darker tone has allowed for some very powerful, weighty content.

For example, it wasn't until Avengers: Infinity War that the MCU provided a death scene as heart-breaking as that of Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) in Wonder Woman, while Aquaman's unforgettable Trench monsters set-piece had some great horror vibes.

Other highlights include the sobering opening of Batman Vs. Superman (the best part of the film), the sociopath character of Amanda Waller in Suicide Squad and Cyborg's thought-provoking backstory in Justice League.

Notably, the DCEU has now delivered an R-rated film in the form of Birds of Prey, which was a pretty adult movie, and even if it under-performed commercially the R-rating added quite a lot.

It's arguable that the MCU should try an R-rated film soon, since many of the most beloved superhero films of recent times (such as Deadpool, Joker, Logan and The Dark Knight Trilogy) have been more adult, unconventional offerings of the genre.


6. Variety

Shazam Billy
Warner Bros.

With the DCEU, whenever a new instalment is announced, we never know quite what we're getting.

All eight DCEU films so far have been rather different from each other and that's a truly great thing, since it means this cinematic universe hasn't become repetitive at all and isn't likely to the way things are going. Shazam! and Birds of Prey, meanwhile, were rather unlike any other superhero movies we've received in recent times.

The MCU has done a great job overall and most of the films in its line-up are good or above in terms of quality, but they usually feel like they're following the same formula and have a similar vibe to them.

Sure, Guardians of the Galaxy felt like a major departure from the MCU style, but then many of the MCU films since have copied GOTG's tone, so variety still isn't exactly an MCU strength.

Still, some of the Phase 4 films sound more diverse, so that's a step in the right direction.


5. Music

Man of Steel
Warner Bros.

In terms of music, the DCEU has generally been pretty awesome. Sure, Suicide Squad over-used pop music in a very jarring manner and that Pitbull cover of Toto's 'Africa' that featured in Aquaman was questionable to put it mildly, but other than that it's been smooth sailing in this department.

Hans Zimmer provided a fantastic musical score for Man of Steel and he did strong work once again for Batman Vs. Superman.

Rupert Gregson-Williams has also provided two excellent musical scores for Wonder Woman and Aquaman in particular, while Danny Elfman's soundtrack for Justice League was very good too. If you listen closely to that one, there are times when he's evidently calling back to his iconic Batman score.

Shazam! and Birds of Prey also had strong soundtracks that reflected their stories and characters well, and Birds of Prey used pop music in a far, far better way than Suicide Squad did.


4. Female Characters

Harley Quinn Margot Robbie
Warner Bros.

The MCU has some strong female characters, such as Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson), Gamora (Zoe Saldana), Shuri (Letitia Wright), Okoye (Danai Gurira), Valkyrie (Tessa Thompson) and Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell) among others, but the DCEU has a considerably better line-up.

In terms of the main female hero in the two franchises, we all love Scarlett Johansson's Black Widow, but she's not given quite as much focus as DC's Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot). Wonder Woman is not only one of the most lovable superhero characters of recent times, but she had a fantastic hero's journey in her solo movie too.

In the DCEU, there's also Margot Robbie's brilliant, endlessly entertaining and morally complex Harley Quinn and the many bad-ass, beautifully-played women she teamed up with in Birds of Prey.

Meanwhile, we can't forget Lois Lane (Amy Adams) and Martha Kent (Diane Lane), both of whom are miles better than the versions from the Christopher Reeve films.

Additionally, there's a group of very solid female characters in Shazam! and Suicide Squad's Amanda Waller (including a superb Viola Davis, who gave one of the all-time best performances in a terrible movie).


3. The Female-Led Films

Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

Ignoring the pre-release backlash against the movie (which was completely unfair), Captain Marvel is one of the MCU's weaker offerings. It's not bad or anything, it's just mediocre, safe and the less said about its ghastly explanation for how Nick Fury lost his eye, the better. The MCU's first female-led film deserved a lot better.

As it should go without saying, the DCEU's superb Wonder Woman blew it out of the water and did an effortless job of mixing stunning spectacle with heartfelt character development.

The other female-led DCEU film, Birds of Prey, is a more mixed bag. The plot is messy and forgettable, but thanks to the amazing direction, action sequences and performances, as well as the general uniqueness of the whole thing, it's an absolutely fascinating superhero movie.

Ant-Man and the Wasp, the previous MCU film to Captain Marvel, is co-led by a woman, but unfortunately that one is worse than Captain Marvel and once again, it has nothing on Wonder Woman or Birds of Prey. Hopefully the long-awaited Black Widow solo movie will finally give the MCU its first great female-led film.


2. Romances

Wonder Woman Diana Steve Trevor
Warner Bros.

One thing the MCU truly sucks at is romances. Only three of the romances in that franchise have worked - Tony Stark and Pepper Potts, Star-Lord and Gamora and Peter Parker and MJ.

The DCEU is doing a hell of a lot better here. Wonder Woman and Steve Trevor had the best superhero movie love story of all time; they've got amazing chemistry, they're completely adorable and the way in which the romance develops both of them as characters is great.

Aquaman and Mera were a good pairing too and Jason Momoa and Amber Heard worked very well together, while both of them developed in a meaningful way as well.

As for Superman and Lois Lane, they were pretty weak in Man of Steel, but were far better in Batman Vs. Superman and Justice League and you got a real sense of how much they cared about each other. The only romance which hasn't really worked so far is Harley Quinn and the Joker (Jared Leto) and that's only because they've barely been seen together.

Considering how bad most superhero movie romances are, the fact that this franchise has got three out of its four romances right is a minor miracle.


1. Visual Style

Aquaman Trench
Warner Bros.

Finally, one area in which the MCU really can't hold a candle to the DCEU is visual style. Few of the MCU films are that amazing visually (aside from the Guardians of the Galaxy films and Doctor Strange) and it's a less exciting franchise in film-making terms.

As for the DCEU... the visuals are mostly bloody fantastic. Suicide Squad was atrociously directed and Shazam! looked fairly ordinary, but the other six have been great. Crucially, the visual style differs from film to film and this makes them considerably more interesting on a cinematic level than the MCU films, which usually have very similar visuals.

Zack Snyder's films have always been hit-or-miss, but he is an excellent visual stylist and this came through once again in Snyder's three DCEU films, while Patty Jenkins, aside from her over-use of slow-mo, did an excellent job with Wonder Woman.

Cathy Yan's stylish direction of Birds of Prey, especially during the action sequences, was something to behold and made one wonder where the hell this obviously superb director has been hiding. That being said, James Wan's epic, awe-inspiring direction of Aquaman is the stand-out so far.

The MCU is a far better franchise than the DCEU, but the DCEU is still doing more things right than it's often credited for, and these amazing visuals are arguably its biggest asset, as well as the main thing it's doing better than the MCU so far.


Watch Next


DCEU Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Aquaman?

Aquaman Queen Atlanna
Warner Bros/EW

1. Who Is Aquaman's Mother?

In this post: 
DCEU
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.