8 Times Movie Censorship Backfired

From Florence Pugh's CGI dress in Oppenheimer to disastrous TV edits of classic films.

Florence Pugh Oppenheimer
Universal Pictures

Since there have been movies, there has been censorship.

Regulatory bodies and governments the world over have been mandating change in order for films to be released for well over a century now, whether that be the Hays Code from the 1930s or the "Video Nasty"-induced backlash that gripped the UK decades later. Generally speaking, movie censorship is way less intrusive than it used to be. However, it still persists, with films being subjected to jarring edits or even getting outright banned by certain countries.

Understandably, this tends to not always have the desired result. The intent of most film censorship is to guard against depictions deemed "extreme" or provocative - socially, politically, morally, or otherwise. In the case of TV broadcasters, films tend to get censored to avoid sparking complaints from families. More recently, movie studios like Disney have been censoring material for films available on their streaming services.

Guard something too enthusiastically, however, and it tends to have the effect of driving intrigue.

In that context, it's pretty easy to view all cases of censorship as backfiring in one way or another, with viewers either successfully seeking out the banned material or poking fun at the incongruous changes mandated in a released cut. That's certainly the case with the following examples, which all inspired mockery, backlash, or just drove up intrigue.

8. The UK's Horror Bans - Texas Chain Saw Massacre, The Exorcist, & More

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre UK Poster
Legendary Entertainment

While the BBFC is today a largely lenient and liberal classification board, this was infamously not the case for much of the latter half of the 20th century. Intrusive cuts were not uncommon and it's only recently, over the last two decades, that films that were previously censored have seen re-releases with those cuts or changes removed. Local authorities also had the final say over what films could and couldn't be screened, so even while works like The Exorcist were given an X rating by the BBFC (a precursor to the standard 18 certificate UK moviegoers are now accustomed to), it was still banned by many councils - effectively meaning that certain areas of the UK went without it.

The BBFC also refused classification for The Texas Chain Saw Massacre following its initial theatrical run, with the film only being unbanned in 1998 - a full 22 years after its UK premiere.

While films across a wide range of genres were subjected to intrusive cuts or even bans by the BBFC and the Conservative UK governments of the 1970s and '80s, the horror genre was most affected. However, these bans and cuts have arguably only led to these films gaining a more notorious reputation and consequently their enduring popularity. The Exorcist didn't have its UK TV premiere until 2001, by which point its cinematic acclaim had been underlined by years of stories surrounding its controversial initial release.

You can even draw a throughline from the days of old horror and martial arts movies being banned in the UK to the thriving boutique home video label scene that has emerged over the last decade, with labels like Arrow Video, 88 Films, and Indicator - all UK-based companies - largely specialising in those genres.


7. A Gritty Classic Gets Undermined - The French Connection

The French Connection
20th Century Fox

William Friedkin's The French Connection is one of many masterpieces the late, great filmmaker crafted over the 1970s and '80s. A gritty police drama starring Gene Hackman in arguably his most iconic performance, the film took home three Academy Awards and is widely considered one of the defining pictures of the New Hollywood era.

The French Connection was one of many films that got hoovered up by Disney when the Mouse House purchased 20th Century Fox in 2019. There were plenty of anxieties over what would become of Fox's library, mainly due to Disney's seeming lack of commitment to film preservation, among other things. That said, it seemed as if Disney was content to leave well enough alone, with The French Connection one of many Fox movies to find a home on the company's streaming service, Disney+.

Sadly, that doesn't seem to have been the case. Earlier in 2023, viewers based in the U.S. noted that The French Connection had been censored on both The Criterion Channel and Disney+, with digital copies also receiving the change in question. The offending scene? A moment where Popeye (Hackman) uses a racial slur when talking to Cloudy (Roy Scheider) before they head out for the evening. This moment has been jarringly removed for American viewers, but - perhaps bizarrely - has been left undisturbed in the UK and Europe (at least at the time of writing).

Unsurprisingly, the removal of the moment in question sparked a significant backlash, with many rightly (and, some in full crank mode, disingenuously) questioning why the dialogue had been cut. Popeye and Cloudy are not meant to be nice men, and the scene in question emphasises the casual ugliness of their brand of policing. Such a change undermines the original vision of The French Connection, and raises awkward questions that have yet to be answered - namely, who implemented the change, and if it will ever be reversed.

In any case, the removal of the dialogue led to a surge in purchases of The French Connection Blu-ray, with the risk being that new printings may also include the incongruous removal of the aforementioned scene.


6. Daryl Hannah's CGI Hair - Splash

Splash Butt Censorship
Disney

A more open-and-shut example of Disney+ censorship is Splash. This 1984 Ron Howard-directed rom-com starred Tom Hanks opposite Daryl Hannah, the latter of whom plays a mermaid who washes up to the surface. Splash has always been in Disney's catalogue, with the film being produced under the Touchstone banner, making it an obvious candidate for inclusion on Disney+ when it launched in 2019.

Somewhat hilariously, though, the version of Splash that was on Disney+ from 2020 through to 2022 included a bizarre case of censorship. In a scene early in the movie, during the original cut, Hannah's Madison runs towards the ocean fully nude, with her butt exposed to the camera. However, for the version screened on Disney+, CGI hair extensions were added to cover Hannah's bottom half. It's a properly awkward addition, with the CGI hair almost glued in place, and it's no surprise that it received a lot of mocking attention.

What's so funny about the hair change to Splash (apart from the obvious) is that it reinforced some of the biggest stereotypes of the modern Disney brand. You've got prude Disney going out of its way to censor a tame, PG example of on-screen nudity, and you also have evil corporate Disney diving into its back catalogue to retroactively change something without a director's input. It's a bad, frankly hilarious look all around.

As per CBR, Disney did finally reverse its CG Splash antics for the film's 4K update in 2022, removing Hannah's butt-covering locks and restoring the scene as it was originally shot.


5. Fart Noises Removed - Blazing Saddles

Blazing saddles fart joke
Warner Bros.

Probably the funniest and most encountered type of film censorship is the TV edit. Films regularly get cut down for broadcasters to accommodate time slots and to remove potentially offensive content that could be seen by younger audiences. These changes can sometimes even impact films that air after the designated broadcast watershed, which, when taking advert breaks into account as well, can make watching films on TV a less-than-optimal experience.

However, sometimes a TV edit can enter "so bad it's good" territory, which was very much the case for some U.S. viewers who tuned in to watch Blazing Saddles as it first started to make its way to television sets in the 1970s. One of the most iconic scenes in Mel Brooks' rip-roaring comedy Western is also a movie first - where a number of cowboys gather around a campfire, eat some beans, and toot up a storm.

It's one of the film's most abruptly funny moments, but it was also the victim of one of the funniest TV edits. Rather than broadcast Blazing Saddles farts-intact, many stations elected instead to remove the onscreen flatulence altogether. With the farts removed, the cowboys look like they're engaging in some kind of ritualistic dance, which is somehow even weirder than if the stations had cut the scene entirely.


4. Florence Pugh's CGI Dress - Oppenheimer

Oppenheimer Florence Pugh Jean Tatlock
Universal Pictures

Director Christopher Nolan's latest effort, Oppenheimer, marks a number of firsts for the director. It's the first movie where he's recreated a nuclear explosion, the first where he's used Cillian Murphy as a lead, and also his first to feature some full-on nudity. Murphy and Florence Pugh share a number of love scenes in the film as the eponymous physicist and Communist activist Jean Tatlock respectively, with the latter going fully topless for each of them.

Full nudity tends to lead to a film getting an R-rating from the MPAA or a 15 by the BBFC. However, certain countries in the Middle East and Asia can often request that the offending content either be edited or removed in order to be considered for release. For Oppenheimer, securing a release in India and several Middle East countries meant both editing large chunks of the love scenes and for Pugh to be shrouded in a CGI dress for the scene where she and Murphy are sat on opposite chairs following a heated rendezvous.

It didn't take long for said dress to go viral on social media, with the computer-generated garment looking totally unconvincing.

Hilariously though, this isn't even the worst case of animation being used to cover up on-screen nudity.


3. Yippee Ki-Yay, Mister Falcon - Die Hard 2

Die Hard 2 Yippee Ki Yay
20th Century Studios

1988's Die Hard blessed us all with John McClane's immortal one-liner of "Yippee ki yay, motherf**ker", but it was Die Hard 2 that cemented it as a series staple - a pre-kill quip for Bruce Willis' character to utter before he rains all over the bad guys' parade.

And the finale for Die Hard 2 arguably has the best use of the quip, with McClane using his lighter to ignite the trail of aviation fuel and explode the mercenaries that have been terrorising the skies over Washington D.C. It's a great finale, underlined by the return of a beloved bit of dialogue from John McTiernan's original.

But it wasn't presented like this for television. Understandably (or not - the watershed is there for a reason), Die Hard 2 received a TV edit that toned down the violence and profanity. However, this TV edit is arguably one of the most infamous, due mainly to how it changed McClane's catchphrase. Instead of the traditional expletive, for Die Hard 2's TV edit, McClane says "Yippee ki yay, Mr. Falcon", in a tragic case of overdubbing.

The line itself makes about as much sense in context as it does out of it. While there is a Mr. Falcon in Die Hard 2 (Esperanza's call sign), that name is mentioned only very briefly and isn't likely to leave as big an impression as the actual named villains did. Throw in the terrible dub from a guy who sounds nothing like Bruce Willis, and you're left with an all-timer piece of bad television.


2. The Whole Movie Gets Recut - Pulp Fiction

Pulp Fiction Ending
Miramax

One of the weirdest movie beefs has to be the one between Lebanese distributor Italia Film and Quentin Tarantino.

Italia Film has been distributing the writer/director's films in Lebanon for the past three decades and is prone to cutting vast swathes of them before they hit theatres. As per The New Arab, Italia Film cut key portions from The Hateful Eight and Kill Bill - reportedly due to concerns over their length more than anything else.

This is unusual in and of itself - typically, censorship is implemented to remove offending content, rather than because of a subjective critique over length or presentation - but it doesn't even take the cake for the weirdest change implemented by Italia Film for one of Tarantino's movies. That honour goes to Pulp Fiction, which was re-edited in chronological order for its Lebanese release thanks to the company thinking its non-linear presentation was a mistake with the reels.

Less overt censorship than a distributor simply overstepping the mark, the story of Pulp Fiction's mangled linear cut is tragically funny.


1. The Worst, Most Hilariously Bad TV Edit Of All Time - Showgirls

Showgirls Kyle MacLachlan Elizabeth Berkley
United Artists

Paul Verhoeven's Showgirls is one of the most notorious movies from the '90s. Widely panned at release and yet also embraced as "high camp" cinema, the film has seen some enthusiastic reappraisals in recent years - reinforcing it as a cult classic.

Regardless of where you fall on the "Showgirls is good-Showgirls is bad" divide, however, one thing that I'm sure everyone can agree on is the hilariously bad TV edit the film received for VH1 (broken down here by Bustle). So wide were the changes implemented that Verhoeven's name isn't credited - the director is instead listed as "Jan Jansen".

In total, over 45 minutes of footage was excised for the TV broadcast of Showgirls. This includes all the sexual content (which is a lot of the movie!), with the film also receiving extensive overdubbing to remove all the profanity. Those on their own would've made Showgirls' TV edit an all-timer of a broadcast, but it gets better.

Anyone familiar with Showgirls knows that there's nudity. Like, a lot of nudity. So much so that the idea of a TV edit sounds mental. To get around this, VH1 simply pasted digital bras and undergarments onto all the nude actresses, with the clothes themselves seemingly being pinched straight from Toon Town.

It's a complete butcher job - one of those movie events where you can't help but laugh at how anyone thought this was a good idea to begin with. At the same time, it all kind of adds to the narrative of Showgirls, which makes it amazing.


Watch Next


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.