9 Actors Who Almost Played Comic Book Villains

Which characters had two faces?

Jesse Eisenberg Adam Driver
Warner Bros/Lucasfilm

A good hero is nothing without his or her villain to go up against, and a villain is nothing without a great actor portraying them. Nowhere is that fact more evident than in comic book movies.

Heath Ledger's casting as The Joker may have initially caused some outrage online, but his performance transcended the genre and turned The Dark Knight into something truly special. Much the same could be said for Jack Nicholson's take on the Clown Prince of Crime some 29-years prior as well.

Indeed, comic book villains have always held more appeal than their heroic counterparts for Hollywood's top talent. They're more colourful, more twisted, and have darker propositions befitting of serious psychological analysis, and therefore qualify as "proper acting". What's more, villains tend to only stick around for one movie, so they're perfect for serious thesps to cash in on without selling out to Hollywood for extended periods of time.

Oscar-winners like Gene Hackman, Tommy Lee Jones, and Ben Kingsley have taken on comic book villains over the past few decades, but the list of stars who've almost played them is perhaps even more impressive.

9. Robin Williams - The Riddler

Robin Williams Riddler
Deviantart - Elmic-Toboo

Robin Williams was initially approached to play The Joker for Batman (1989), with Jack Nicholson hesitating to commit. It's unclear whether Warner Bros were seriously interested or it was just a negotiating ploy, because Nicholson ended up accepting the role.

Cut to a few years later, and Williams was touted to play The Riddler for Tim Burton opposite Michael Keaton, but sadly the project never happened. Warner Bros were disappointed with the box office of Batman Returns, and blamed the film's violence and dark overtones for the $150m shortfall in revenue compared to 1989's Batman.

Burton agreed to take a step back, and let Joel Schumacher bring a more family friendly vibe to the series. As a result, Keaton parted ways with the character and Jim Carrey was brought in as the Riddler, much to the disappointment of self-proclaimed comic book aficionado Williams and moviegoing fans around the globe.

Years later, during Christopher Nolan's tenure with the franchise, Williams would again pitch for the role of the Joker, before eventually telling Empire:

"Chris, call me, I’ll do anything. I could be a great character — or some weird little man in the background in Arkham Asylum.”

Unfortunately, Williams never made it into a Batman film. He might not have been a fit for Nolan's more grounded approach, but the thought of his singular comedic talent being let loose to improvise as the Riddler opposite Keaton's Batman is one of the genre's greatest what ifs.


8. John Malkovich - Green Goblin/The Vulture

Bird Box John Malkovich
Netflix

John Malkovich has a beguiling, unhinged, and intellectual quality about him that would be perfect for a movie supervillain. Hell, even just looking at him and you can see him playing any number of iconic comic book bad guys.

Hollywood thought so too, and the actor was Sam Raimi's first pick for the role of Green Goblin in the director's box-office guzzling reinvention of Spider-Man in 2002. Only one problem... Malkovich wasn't all that enthusiastic, saying that "it's not really my genre" and "those sort of films aren't art films, they're business propositions."

You'd expect him to have burnt his bridges with comments like those, but Raimi approached Malkovich again during pre-production for the ill-fated Spider-Man 4, with an offer to play the Vulture, before plans for the movie as a whole fell apart.

Two Spider-Man reboots later, and Vulture eventually showed up in the guise of Michael Keaton in 2017's Spider-Man Homecoming. Given just how good he was, it's hard to mourn too much, even though Malkovich too would've been a great pick.


7. Mads Mikkelsen - Malekith

Mads Mikkelsen King Arthur
Buena Vista

Mads Mikkelsen was top choice for one of Marvel's least memorable villains in one of the MCUs very worst movies, Thor 2: The Dark World.

While the Danish actor couldn't play the part of Dark Elf Malekith The Accursed due to a scheduling conflict with NBC's Hannibal series, it would have been interesting to see if a different approach may have elevated this role

Known on the big screen for his villainous role in Casino Royale, his distinctive voice and appearance can be used to create a strange, compelling mix of charm and menace, but it's still hard to imagine his take on the character coming off much better than Christopher Eccleston's, with the actor lost under a sea of prosethtics and bad dialogue.

Marvel chiefs clearly liked the idea though, because Mikkelsen later made his MCU debut as evil sorcerer Kaecilius in 2016's Dr Strange. Thankfully, he was unburdened of many of the issues that plagued Eccleston in The Dark World, making for a better villain overall, although the script still didn't make full use of his considerable talents.


6. Matthew McConaughey - Ego

Dark Tower Matthew McConaughey
Warner Bros.

Matthew McConaughey was offered the role of Ego the living planet in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2. by writer/director James Gunn, and even appeared in concept art for the movie, but ultimately deciding to turn down the part.

Much closer in age to Chris Pratt's Star-Lord, who it later transpires is Ego's son, this wouldn't read quite the same way on screen as Kurt Russell's more fatherly rendition of the character.

McConaughey would've brought a relaxed, charming, and effortlessly cool screen presence, making for a perfect mirror of Chris Pratt's Star-Lord. You can see the appeal, but then few actors embody those qualities, along with being more age-appropriate, than Russell himself.

Instead of Guardians 2, McConaughey took up the role of Randall Flagg in the hugely disappointing Stephen King adaptation Dark Tower, while Russell became one of the MCU's strongest villains as Guardians 2 racked up over $850m at the box-office.


5. Josh Hartnett - Loki

Josh Hartnett Penny Dreadfuls
Sky

Without any real success in a good few years, Josh Hartnett was very much the kind of actor Marvel were looking at when building the MCU, being recognisable but not a household name, and able to mould a character without costing too much.

Hartnett had meetings with director Kenneth Branagh to discuss his involvement in the first Thor movie as Loki, the God of Mischief. To a degree, you can see why the actor would appeal, with his sleek-hair and boyish charm, he has the surface-level qualities for someone like Loki.

Sadly for him, the plum multi-picture deal fell to the relatively unknown (but Olivier Award Winning) Tom Hiddleston, who has crafted a far more fascinating take on the character than Hartnett likely would've, becoming one of the most popular MCU characters in the process and having one of the strongest character arcs too.

Hartnett, meanwhile, has since fallen into relative obscurity despite his rise to stardom at the turn of the century, while Hiddleston is reprising his role as Loki for a big-budget Disney Plus series.


4. Sam Rockwell - The Joker

Sam Rockwell Oscars 2018
ABC

The last couple of years have seen Sam Rockwell finally getting the sort of attention and acclaim he's long deserved, but it all could've happened much earlier. The Oscar-winner was one the final contenders on Christopher Nolan's shortlist of actors to play the Joker in The Dark Knight, coming very close to a role that redefined what an actor could accomplish in superhero cinema.

Rockwell is a lively, unpredictable character with a great ability to completely immerse himself and fully embody a particular role, especially ones of figures that are pretty despicable.

Ledger is iconic as the Joker, in a rare and beautiful meeting of actor and character that none of us saw coming. It's difficult to imagine anyone else having played it, but while Rockwell may not have topped it, you can bet he'd have done something really interesting with the character.

He did eventually make his way into a comic book movie, playing arms dealer Justin Hammer Iron Man 2 (and a single shot in Iron Man 3), but the smaller role couldn't make full use of his abilities, and it'd be great to see him given another crack, whether that's more of Hammer or a different comic book character altogether.


3. Ryan Gosling - The Joker

Ryan Gosling Place Beyond The Pines
Focus Features

David Ayer's Suicide Squad found box-office success in spite of itself, with $746m worldwide flying in the face of its 27% score on Rotten Tomatoes. It's not a well-liked movie, to put it mildly, and Jared Leto's take on the Joker is one of the movie's more objectionable components.

Tattooed where Heath Ledger's take was scarred, Leto plays the Clown Prince of Crime like a neon-coloured pimp, but his peculiar brand of method acting combined with studio interference led to it being more boring then beguilingly bizarre.

It's interesting to note, then, that Ayer's first choice was actually Ryan Gosling. The actor isn't an obvious pick for the role (but then, nor were Ledger and Leto), but there is something intriguing about the idea. Aside from his good looks, Gosling possesses a great innate coolness and charisma, mixed with a slight sense of being intangible and degree of otherness to him. Look at his charm in, say, Crazy Stupid Love, his bottled intensity in Drive, and his searing emotion in Blue Valentine, and you can start to see a pieces of what could be a great take on the character (with the right material, of course).

Following in the footsteps of Ledger's acclaimed performance in the role would be intimidating for any actor, but signing a multi-picture contract is what gave Gosling cold feet, and allowed him to dodge the bullet here. Gosling and Leto later shared the screen in Dennis Villeneuve's Blade Runner 2049, where Gosling would once again come out much better off.


2. Adam Driver - Lex Luthor

Adam Driver This Is Where I Leave you
Warner Bros. Pictures

If not for a scheduling conflict, Zack Synder's Batman V Superman would have brought Adam Driver's considerable acting talents to the role of Metropolis' nefarious business magnate Lex Luthor.

From the torn-apart villain Kylo Ren to the self-absorbed artist Adam in Girls, his intense turn in Silence and his quiet, thoughtful performance in Paterson, Driver has pitched dark and soulful performances in much of his film career thus far. He's an actor of incredible range who can seemingly just about do anything, so you can see why he'd be approached for such an iconic DC villain.

Ultimately the role fell to Jesse Eisenberg, who mined a rich vein in "young narcissistic know it all" as Mark Zuckerberg in The Social Network. The Silicon Valley stylings of LexCorps' headquarters in Snyder's film can leave us in no doubt that, for good or ill, this millennial iteration of Lex was baked into the design of the movie from the get-go, and the movie was savaged by critics, so it's perhaps for the best that Driver wasn't trapped here.


1. Alec Baldwin - Alexander Pierce

Mission Impossible Rogue Nation Alec Baldwin
Paramount

Captain America: The Winter Soldier is a wonderful throwback to 70s conspiracy thrillers, dressed up as a superhero sequel. It's the kind of genre mashup we haven't seen enough of in the MCU, with the exception of Thor Ragnarok's buddy-comedy makeover courtesy of Taika Waititi.

Winter Soldier's old school sensibility is complemented quite nicely by the slightly meta-casting of Robert Redford's as Alexander Pierce, the undercover Hydra operative who has infiltrated the upper echelon's of SHIELD's leadership.

This might be one definitive instance where an actor was replaced by somebody more suited for the role. The Russo brothers, perhaps thinking Redford wouldn't be interested in a comic book movie, pitched straight to Baldwin, who has played many of these corporate types before and has dabbled in big-budget Hollywood tentpoles too.

His wife's pregnancy prompted him to pass on the role however, leaving the door open for Redford, who is a far better fit for the part than Baldwin would've been, helping make The Winter Soldier one of the very best MCU offerings.

Do you wish any of these castings had actually happened? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor

Oliver Smith hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.