9 Actors Who Played Other, Better Actors

The stars who played the stars.

Biopics have been a cinema institution since 1900, when French actress Bleuette Bernon starred as Joan of Arc in George Melies€™ silent film of the same name, but such a role comes with far more pressure than usual for the starring actor. The portrayal needs to remain true to the character as the audience already knows it, and this requires something that even the most talented of actors can struggle to bring to the screen: authenticity. The job, then, becomes even more of a challenge when it comes to biopics of figures who are in the acting profession themselves. For an actor to play an actor requires a level of imitation that encompasses the whole of the character's on-screen and off-screen persona, and this inevitably means being measured up to and compared against the skill and integrity of the very actor being portrayed. Can anybody really capture the elegance and grace of Audrey Hepburn? Can Andy Kaufman's instinctive comic timing be replicated? Can anybody pull off an impression of not just Peter Sellers, but all of his voices and characters too? It€™s a hit-and-miss business which relies on more than just a physical resemblance or a matching wardrobe. The believability of a part can hang solely on the likes of genuine emotion and subtle mannerisms. If it€™s not right, it€™s just a caricature. In a long list of stars playing stars, some stand out far more than others €“ though not always for the right reasons. Here are ten of the most notable instances of Hollywood€™s finest being resurrected by other actors, shining a spotlight on the ones that got it right, and the ones which were shy of the mark.


9. Jennifer Love Hewitt As Audrey Hepburn

No matter who took on the lead role in 2000€™s The Audrey Hepburn Story, there were always going to be the knee-jerk critics complaining about the poor casting and the gall of the actress who dared to impersonate Hollywood's most beloved beauty. With that in mind, one compliment that must be paid to Jennifer Love Hewitt is that she was admirably courageous to attempt the role at all. It isn€™t easy to step into the shoes of an icon. Unfortunately, the compliments don't go much further than that. It€™s not that Hewitt gives an altogether bad performance, but she doesn€™t quite hit the mark as a believable Hepburn. The accent and style is there, and Hepburn's trademark niceness is present in bucket loads, but the portrayal rarely succeeds in surpassing anything more than a half-decent impression. The Audrey Hepburn Story is, however, a good reminder of that important balance between physical likeness and personality that needs to be struck by actors in biopics. Hewitt just about passes superficially, but the character was exaggerated to the point that the performance would seem more at home at a fancy dress party than on a television screen. Unsurprisingly, the aforementioned critics had a field day.

8. James Franco As James Dean

Brad Pitt, Johnny Depp, and Leonardo DiCaprio were all attached to the part of James Dean for this biopic which languished in development hell for around a decade. Any one of them could likely have played the role well, but the authenticity James Franco brings to the table is inarguable. Before filming began, Franco immersed himself completely in Dean€™s world. He researched the character obsessively, met with the actor€™s close friends, and learned how to ride a motorcycle and play guitar. Despite being a non-smoker, he even began smoking two packs of cigarettes a day. The dedication to the role seemingly paid off, as while Franco€™s physical resemblance to Dean is uncanny, the performance itself is absolutely convincing. He went on to win a Golden Globe Award for his performance, though a bigger accomplishment could be that he has since given up smoking.

7. Scarlett Johansson As Janet Leigh

2012's Alfred Hitchcock biopic garnered mixed reviews, and justifiably so. It's a questionable film with a somewhat strained storyline focusing on the director's relationship with his wife, but one thing that the film does have going for it is its cast. It€™s an A-List star-studded production with top-notch performances throughout (though HBO€™s own Hitchcock film The Girl, released only a month earlier, does give it a run for its money). But never mind Hopkins and Mirren in the lead roles, because it€™s Scarlett Johansson who steals every scene she appears in. As Janet Leigh, the lead actress in Hitchock's Psycho, Johansson's part isn't a big one, admittedly, but she plays it with an effortless sexiness throughout, and brings to life a character that, truth be told, could very easily have been a boring one. She later praised the make-up and wardrobe team for helping her to slip into the role so effectively, and given her remarkable likeness on-screen, it€™s easy to see why. Special mention goes to the restaurant scene in which Leigh expresses concern over the upcoming nude shower sequence. Whether they would care to admit it or not, it's the sequence that every man (or woman) in the audience is waiting for. Graciously, Hitchock assures us with a sly grin that it will be positively "titillating".

6. Nicole Kidman As Grace Kelly

On paper, Nicole Kidman being cast as the elegant and ever-classy Grace Kelly (or in this case, Princess Grace of Monaco) seems foolproof. Not only does Kidman bare an uncanny resemblance to Kelly, but she's also shown audiences time and again that she can be every bit as charming. So€ what went wrong? The trouble with 2014's Grace of Monaco lies not so much in the casting, but in the story. The true story of Kelly's later life is interesting enough to have been a tremendous biopic, but Arash Amel's screenplay is about as historically accurate as Terminator 2, leaving the film floundering somewhere between a biographical account and a completely fictionalised fairytale. Looking beyond the questionable storyline, however, Kidman's performance does have a few shining moments. As she stated herself, she considered the role to be a character study, and she does an admirable job of giving the audience an insight into the depths of Kelly's character off-screen. Unfortunately, the performance only leaves us wondering what might have been if Kidman had been given a better script to work from.

5. Jim Carrey As Andy Kaufman

Floating around somewhere on YouTube is Jim Carrey's audition tape for 1999's Man on the Moon. It's perhaps not surprising for somebody so famously skilled in impersonation, but the tape is a masterpiece. Carrey had the role nailed before it was even his. One thing that is apparent throughout the film is that he somehow manages to be more like Kaufman than Kaufman himself. It's at times a bizarre caricature, but a performance so masterfully done that at no point does it seem over-exaggerated or corny. Just like so many of Carrey€™s impressions, it€™s completely believable. So dedicated was Carrey to the role, he refused to be addressed by his own name for the duration of production, instead insisting he be referred to as Andy Kaufman at all times. Perhaps going one step too far, Carrey even harassed ex-wrestler Jerry Lawler relentlessly during filming in an attempt to recreate the Kaufman vs. Lawler feud. Unfortunately for Carrey, Lawler didn't take too kindly and the harassment led to a violent altercation. Even with the wrestler's hand around his throat, Carrey still remained in character. How's that for method acting?

4. Robert Downey Jr. As Charlie Chaplin

Taking on the role of any character requires a good deal of preparation, but even more so when that character is so physically recognisable that any portrayal would be subject to the very harshest of scrutiny. Take Charlie Chaplin for instance, a pioneer of silent era comedy, and a name and face known even to those who have never seen his work. To do the part justice, an imitation of such a character needs to be exacting. Robert Downey Jr., then, was perhaps one of the most perfect casting decisions in Hollywood history. He's a man who takes his profession very seriously, and when he gets it right, he gets it very right. He prepared extensively for the part by watching all of Chaplin's films, employing a personal coach to help him imitate the correct posture, and even going so far as to learn to play the violin and tennis left-handed. The result is an almost exact double of Chaplin, given away only by the colour of his eyes. Although Downey had had a number of significant acting roles before Chaplin, this was one of his first breakout roles. He was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Actor, but lost to Al Pacino in Scent of a Woman. Needless to say, things seem to have worked out pretty well for him anyway.

3. Amanda Seyfried as Linda Lovelace

The role of 70s porn star Linda Lovelace (of Deep Throat fame) was initially to be played by Lindsay Lohan, but when she abandoned the biopic it was offered to her Mean Girls co-star Amanda Seyfried. Understandably, Seyfried was initially cautious, wary of the fact that it was the type of role that could potentially ruin a career. As feared, the film was a commercial failure, despite a stellar lead performance. Lovelace is portrayed as a very real, fragile and naive young girl. She's sexy, of course, but the sex takes a back seat to the tormented character. The role certainly hasn't ruined Seyfried's career either, and despite the lacklustre reviews for the film, her performance has been consistently praised. In regards to the nudity dotted throughout, she described the part as €˜liberating€™. Irrelevant but also worth noting is that in the scenes of simulated oral sex, an ice lolly was used as a substitute for a penis. Definitely irrelevant, but notable.

2. Geoffrey Rush as Peter Sellers

It€™s hard enough for an actor to impersonate another actor, but even more so when required to impersonate all of that actor€™s own performances as well. Such is the case with Peter Sellers, whose entire career was built on a host of finely crafted and diverse characters, each more eccentric than the next. We've all tried our own impression of Inspector Clouseau ("Do you have a rheuum?"), but to take on his entire repertoire would be a daunting task for even the most accomplished actor. In 2004's The Life and Death of Peter Sellers, however, Geoffrey Rush tackles them all, slipping seamlessly into such guises as Doctor Strangelove and Chance, the simpleton gardener from Being There. Such is the accuracy of most of his impressions, that the seemingly endless layers of make-up and latex hardly seem necessary at all. Blake Edwards, director of the Pink Panther film series, himself commented that while watching Rush's performance, he had at times thought he was seeing the real Peter Sellers on screen. Rush was initially apprehensive about playing the part, not believing himself to have the ability to play such a complex character well enough, but felt in the right frame of mind to do it after starring as Captain Barbossa in Pirates of the Caribbean. Unfortunately, this did mean that every now and again throughout the Sellers biopic, the character bizarrely slips into a mannerism or expression that momentarily seems more befitting of the captain of the Black Pearl than anybody else. Despite the overall impressive performance, the film has met harsh criticism from those who knew Sellers, including one of his four wives, Britt Ekland. She reportedly disliked the way in which Sellers was portrayed as an essentially likeable and talented man, but in fact a monster with no saving graces at all.

1. Cate Blanchett as Katharine Hepburn

The final entry on this list acknowledges the first time in cinema history that an actor has garnered an Academy Award for playing an Academy Award-winning actor. 2004€™s The Aviator may have been a biopic about aviation pioneer Howard Hughes (and Leonardo DiCaprio€™s performance is bloody good too), but it is Cate Blanchett in the supporting role of his long-term girlfriend and Hollywood actress Katharine Hepburn that really sets the screen alight. Given Hepburn€™s larger-than-life persona, it would have been easy for Blanchett to have overdone it. Roles like this one very often slip into ill-judged caricature, but she nails the character perfectly. She worked with a speech coach to master the difficult, but instantly recognisable Hartford accent, and reportedly even began taking regular cold showers (as Hepburn did herself). The mannerisms and the wardrobe are spot on, and the strong-willed yet vulnerable values of the character are captured wonderfully, resulting in a performance that is difficult to criticise. In fact, one of the only downsides is that as a supporting character, she isn€™t on screen nearly often enough. Have we missed any other notable actors playing actors? Let us know in the comment section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Lover of Audrey Hepburn, Clint Eastwood and Steve McQueen. Also writes things. Went to university. Learned lots.