9 Actors Who Quit Major Film Roles
Cut loose before action.
As the end-users in the film industry, it's easy to see the polished final products as the result of a similarly smooth production process. The truth is anything but, and there's often a number of maladies that beset the development of a film. Sometimes, problems present themselves before shooting even begins - such as a cast member deciding it's just not for them.
While it's true that any actor leaving any production at any point can be a traumatic, disruptive event for the resulting film, it happens more often than you think. Nary a year goes by without a few stories of people being ejected from a cast because they don't like the material, they don't like their colleagues, or they don't like what the fans are going to think of them.
This list is dedicated to all those actors who ultimately missed out on mega bucks by choice. Keep in mind, a very mild SPOILER WARNING is in effect.
In 2013, Charlie Hunnam resigned from the production of Fifty Shades Of Grey. It was believed that Hunnam - who the internet assures me seems to live in a world without shirts - left the film out of fear of being typecast, and he probably had a point.
Though he also cited conflicting commitments to Sons of Anarchy as the real reason for withdrawing from the project, the truth is he took one look at the mammoth book sales of E.L. James' 'mummy porn' trilogy and decided he could forge a career better than being typecast as a BSM obsessed fop.
Hunnam mentioned the reason behind eradicating the name 'Christian Grey' from his CV was because he didn't want to be like Robert Pattinson, who now lives in the shadow of the Twilight film franchise, despite the fact he hates the damn thing. Embarrassing as being defined by Twilight is, you can magnify that ten times over for the middle-aged smutfest that is Fifty Shades.
8. Hugh Jackman - James Bond
As Christopher Reeve probably lamented in his post-Superman life, it's hard to escape a role you've once played. Type-casting is alive and well in Hollywood, and probably for good reason - if there's one thing filmmakers tend to dislike, it's risk.
So if you've got someone who seems to embody some time, archetype, or general feeling - for Reeve it was the All-American hero - then you can bet your bottom dollar they're going to go for this sure thing. Of course, this works the other way too - if you're associated with one thing, then some people will assume that's all you can do. For some actors, that's fine, but the vast majority want the world to remember their range, not the fact they kept donning a certain outfit.
The above is what Hugh Jackman felt when he was offered the role of James Bond post-Pierce Brosnan. Jackman felt that if he donned the suit and adopted the drinking habits of Britain's favourite amoral superspy, the fans would keep associating him with 007 for the rest of his life. So Jackman turned them down, and went back to playing Wolverine, again.
7. Mark Wahlberg - Brokeback Mountain
Boogie Nights provides comprehensive proof that Mark Wahlberg isn't a stranger to graphic, sexually-charged films, and after coming off the critically-acclaimed I Heart Huckabees, his dramatic star was steadily rising. So naturally come 2004, he was being considered for more challenging stories and chief among them was Ang Lee's epic about the love between two cowboys. Wahlberg went as far as to meet Lee on set to discuss the film, yet only made it 15 pages into the script before he became creeped out at what exactly the director and cinemagoers were going to expect of him if he took the role of Jack Twist.
Now, someone can be the most tolerant person in the world, but there's a difference between being tolerant and supportive and actually performing homosexual scenes that some people aren't comfortable with, and Wahlberg fell into that camp. Being fair, the way Wahlberg describes the tent scene - replete with 'spitting on the hand' and 'getting ready to do the thing,' - it seemed a lot more hardcore and graphic than the tastefully done final version.
Luckily, Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal were far more game with the expectations, and scored Oscar nominations for their sterling work. However, a little part of me always wanted to hear 'I wish I knew how to quit you' in a Bostonian accent. I imagine it would be quite horrific.
6. Will Smith - Superman
It's a well-known belief that some perceive Hollywood to be a tiny bit racist. While we're definitely past the Birth Of A Nation days, and some might even argue we've outgrown that bizarre black-guy-dies-first trope, it's still believed that casting directors prefer roles to be ethnically whitewashed, if just for the sake of accessibility.
Of course, the one person this very visibly doesn't apply to is Will Smith. Smith's pulling power dwarfs conventional casting rules, allowing him to pick and choose his projects and make conventionally white heroes (for example Wild Wild West's Jim West) more ethnically diverse without picking up the sh*tstorm someone like Idris Elba would for being picked as Heimdall.
Yet when he was offered the Superman role, even he balked. Smith believed that if he did take this conventionally white role, he'd experience such a fan backlash that his career would've been forever tainted. So he turned it down, eventually donning the superhero mantle and alcohol bottle in the flawed Hancock.
5. David Boreanaz - Batman
This one's a slight cheat, because David Boreanaz didn't turn down Batman because of the Batman fans. No, urban legend goes that he turned down Batman for fans of his TV work, as he felt happy and appreciated where he was. In the filmic equivalent of winning the lottery and turning down the money, Boreanaz claimed he was busy with TV work, when in fact he totally wasn't - Angel had wrapped up in 2004, and all he was doing was keeping himself busy with minor supporting roles on the box.
Yet apparently, Boreanaz didn't fancy being part of one of the most critically-acclaimed film series' of all time, a role that would be absolutely anyone's big break, George Clooney aside. In the end, the role obviously went to one-man crazy-bastion Christian Bale, and Boreanaz consoled himself with the lead in Bones. Look, I'm not saying that Bones is terrible show. In fact, I think it's rather good, and something doesn't tend to run for nine seasons without being pretty damn compelling. But still, it's not Batman, and regardless of how much we at WhatCulture seem to give the Caped Crusader a kicking, he's still pretty damn awesome, and Boreanaz opted not to ride that cowl all the way to the bank.
He later spoke out about the story, claiming ignorance and saying it was started by his manager. I really hope it wasn't, because I really want this monument to decision-making idiocy to stand true for the ages.
4. James Purefoy - V For Vendetta
There must've come a point in V For Vendetta's filming where James Purefoy cursed the fans of the graphic novel for loving V's iconic mask. I know that last sentence sounds strange, because as every man and his dog knows, Hugo Weaving was V, and his dulcet tones livened up that film no end. Yet for a little while, it wasn't Agent Smith behind the mask - it was Purefoy, attempting to crack into the lucrative comic-book-movie market.
He eventually left after a struggle with the role that seemed to come down to the mask, and the fact he felt it obscured him almost too much. Being honest, I don't blame Purefoy at all. Being under the warm lights of a shoot in that stiflingly hot black costume, anyone could feel like they were getting a bum deal. Couple this with the fact that no-one will be able to recognise you at any point during the film, and you had a recipe for disaster.
All he wanted was a little face time, or maybe just an eye shot, but he sure as hell wasn't going to get it; everyone learnt their lesson when Sylvester Stallone removed his helmet in Judge Dredd, and none of the filmmakers fancied angering a legion of fans all over again. So naturally, Purefoy left.
3. Sean Connery - Gandalf
Ah, we had to get to this at some point, if only because it's so goddamned obvious that it had to be mentioned eventually. For those of you who don't know what I'm talking about, buckle up, because up until now, all you've felt for Sean Connery is justified hero-worship. Well, when I'm done here, there'll be a smattering of pity in there too.
Before they got the Hollywood-via-Auckland treatment, The Lord Of The Rings registered primarily as a few kooky books stuffed with singsongs, Tom Bombadil, and more labyrinthine fantasy than you could shake a stick at, and this is what Sean Connery was presented with when they asked him to be Gandalf. That, and an offer for £19 million and 15% of the series' total gross. Nope, that's not just one film - that's the whole series, and Connery lost £287 million by turning it down.
His problem went thus: he couldn't believe anyone could understand the damn thing, and felt the current fans were nuts for liking it. I guess that dismissal of fandom is one thing, but when it cost a man a quarter of a billion, you can let him off. Plus, the film he chose instead was The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen - which he admitted he didn't understand either, but hot damn, he wasn't going to miss that - which proved so wretched it provoked his retirement from the screen.
2. Bill Murray - Batman
This entry stands unique as a a rare instance of a studio taking an actor out before he could be savaged by the fans, which is exactly what would've happened to Bill Murray had he followed through on his wish to be a funny Batman in the eighties.
For everyone who thought that Batman was always brooding and serious, I'm sorry to tell you that it wasn't. Originally, Batman was just as susceptible to goofiness as any other hero, and certainly suffered a good deal of silliness in his formative years. Yet it was only writ large for the majority when the Adam West-fronted Batman came to the party, letting the world see just how far down the rabbit hole of stupidity this series could descend.
Whether wielding the Shark-repellant batspray or complaining that he just couldn't get rid of a bomb, it was all amazingly ridiculous. Surprising as this may seem, this wacky Batman had its own fans even when the Caped Crusader went all super-serious later on in the 20th century, and among them was Bill Murray.
Yet by this point it was felt that a serious Batman would be preferred, with the hot-off-Beetlejuice Tim Burton in the director's seat, and Michael Keaton in the title role. For what it's worth, Murray still thinks he would've made an awesome Dark Knight, but a man can only dream of seeing this actually happen.
1. Will Smith - Django Unchained
Yes, we're back with Will Smith again. Ostensibly, Smith turned down Django Unchained because the script didn't allow him to shoot Leo DiCaprio square in the chest. That honour fell to Christoph Waltz, and I guess it's a decent reason to turn down a film - when there's a racist monster in the room, some people might think it's the badass black gunslinger's responsibility to shoot that fool.
Yet it was also rumoured that Smith turned down the film for another reason, and that reason was image. As I've already made clear, Will Smith bucks the trend in Hollywood insofar as he's one of a rare breed of box-office bank-breakers. Cinema audiences love him, and that's probably due to a number of things: he's clean cut, good-looking, funny, and can handle kick-ass action at a canter. His identity as a Golden Calf in Hollywood had been hard earned, and Django Unchained would've given that status a massive kick in the balls. There's a simple saying in all walks of life that you don't bite the hand that feeds, and I guess it applies to Smith here.
Simply put, his screen image has been carefully cultivated to be as inoffensively badass as possible, so to portray a racially-motivated avenging angel could potentially alienate him from large chunks of his audience. So the role went to Jamie Foxx, and Will Smith cheerfully got on with, erm, Men In Black 3. Still, Smith loved it, if from a carefully maintained distance.r
Which other actors quit major roles? Share any we missed down the comments.