9 Changes Warner Bros Wishes It Could Make To Its DC Universe

Hindsight is basically a superpower.

LEX LUTHOR LESS WEIRD
Warner Bros.

The early reactions to Justice League suggest it’s far from the trainwreck it might have been. While critics unanimously agree the big DC Comics team-up is by no means perfect, most had kind words to say about its upbeat tone and bombastic action.

A rocky road has led Warner Bros to this point, with Man of Steel, Batman v Superman and Suicide Squad proving divisive, but Wonder Woman restored optimism to its cinematic universe with her stellar solo debut, and, by all accounts, the Amazon princess is the show-stealer in the ensemble movie.

There are signs Warner and DC have got their act together on the cinematic universe front, though in hindsight, they’d probably be the first to admit that they would do things differently if they could make like Booster Gold and travel back in time.

Beating Marvel to the punch by launching a major female-fronted superhero film first was a good first step on the road to redemption, but the gulf between the MCU and its DC counterpart might not be the chasm it is today had the studios made some of these changes early on.

9. More Standalone Films First

Ben Affleck Batman V Superman Dawn Of Justice
Warner Bros.

Warner Bros executives looked at the Marvel Cinematic Universe next door and turned greener than the Incredible Hulk. When The Avengers hit big at the box office, they wanted a DC-flavoured rival to this bastion of superheroic might yesterday.

The only problem was that the majority of DC Comics’ heroes needed a movie reboot at this point, while others needed a cinematic debut and origin story.

If there’s one mistake a studio must avoid when building a cinematic universe, it’s haste. Marvel, which introduced each of its main characters with solo outings before bringing them together in The Avengers, has the formula down to a tee, and Warner charged to the finish line quicker than Barry Allen in a race against Superman in its desperation to emulate its rival.

Before the Justice League came together, each of its members should have been given standalone films, and good ones at that. Only Superman and Wonder Woman had that privilege, and the latter was messily introduced in Dawn of Justice's joyless dressed reherseal alongside Ben Affleck’s Batman.

Everything about the universe creation process was rushed. Granted, Justice League sounds like it has turned out better than expected, but if Warner had held it back until 2020 to focus on scene-setting solo movies, it might even have been the MCU killer the studio is so eager to make.


8. Tonal Consistency

Batman V Superman Knightmare
Warner Bros.

Even avid fans of the DC cinematic universe have to admit it’s a tonal mess. Much of the criticism surrounding Man of Steel and Batman v Superman is in some way related to the dour atmosphere around Metropolis and their fun-free depiction of Supes.

Two films in and it became obvious to Warner Bros that dark and brooding wasn’t the way to go - especially where heroes like Superman are concerned - and this sudden realisation hurt Suicide Squad, which ended up being a mess of tone-softening reshoots and clunky post-production.

When Wonder Woman came along with overtones of optimism and stacks of charm, the DC movies found the right balance, and this is something they’re clearly striving to maintain in Justice League.

Banter-laden and upbeat is a better fit for these characters, but tonal consistency is now a glaring issue in the sense that Man of Steel and Batman v Superman don’t really feel like the same universe as lighter offerings such as Wonder Woman.

Warner can, to some extent, work the tonal shift into the story by having Superman reborn in a more traditional form in Justice League and have Batman, inspired by the Man of Steel’s sacrifice, see the world in a better light, but you can bet the studio would go for a lighter tone from the beginning if it had the chance to start afresh.


7. A Different Universe Stewart

Zack Snyder Henry Cavill
Warner Bros.

Warner handed Zack Snyder the keys to its DC kingdom and in return it got two divisive Superman films, a messy Suicide Squad and a critically-acclaimed Wonder Woman. Although he didn’t direct the latter pair, he oversaw them both as producer and had some creative influence - let’s not forget Gal Gadot was cast, and first appeared, in a Snyder film.

Add muddied tonal waters to this picture and you can bet the studio isn’t satisfied with a return of one unequivocal hit out of four and therefore regrets its decision to give Snyder such as key role in shaping its answer to the MCU.

Snyder’s passion for comic book movies is not in question, so there’s no reason why he shouldn’t have been involved in the DC cinematic universe in a lesser capacity, heading up one sub-series or taking charge of a lone character’s solo outings, but it feels like the studio has been gradually distancing itself from the filmmaker’s overarching vision.

Both Patty Jenkins and Joss Whedon have demonstrated a firmer grasp of the appropriate tone for characters like Superman and Wonder Woman in their previous films, so there’s a case to argue that one of those should have been the universe steward from the beginning.

Snyder, who dropped out of Justice League late in the day due to a family tragedy, is expected to be involved in the DC movie universe in a diminished capacity going forward, and that should have been the extent of his involvement from the beginning.


6. Superman Rebooted The Right Way

Man Of Steel Superman
Warner Bros.

One of the biggest reasons the DC cinematic universe was built on shaky foundations is because it failed to get the comic book giant’s most famous character right at the first, or second, attempt.

Superman really shouldn’t be that difficult. He’s an archetypal symbol of truth, justice and superheroic optimism, not a brooding alien who demolishes half of Metropolis without a sparing a thought for collateral damage before snapping his rival’s neck (as necessary as that was in context).

Batman v Superman did little to rectify the Last Son of Krypton’s image problem, so killing him off at the hands of a bad CGI Doomsday seemed like the right thing to do. At least this gives Justice League the opportunity to resurrect him in a traditional mould and weave this soft reboot into the story.

It’s fair to assume Warner and DC aren’t best pleased with the way the most iconic character on their books has been handled on screen. Clearly Man of Steel was envisioned as the Batman Begins of the Superman franchise, but it hasn’t panned out that way.

There’s a place for experimentation and deconstruction when dealing with time-tested properties, but characters like Superman are too archetypal for this treatment, as DC has found out the hard way.

Still, at least Henry Cavill looks the part.


5. More Clarity On Batman

Batfleck Dead
Warner Bros.

In some respects, Ben Affleck was a solid choice for the role of Batman. Whether in Bruce Wayne or Caped Crusader mode, the A-lister has brought gravitas and star power to the DC universe.

This, however, has come with a side helping of uncertainty since fresh rumours that Batfleck is about to leave the belfry have cropped up every week since he scaled back his involvement in The Batman, relinquishing the director’s chair and scripting duties in favour of an acting-only role.

Batman is an iconic role and the last thing Warner wants is to have to recast it a dozen films into its cinematic universe. Would the MCU movies have fared as well if Tony Stark suddenly showed up sporting a different face in Iron Man 3? Certainly not from a continuity standpoint.

Bruce Wayne is a layered character with duality at his core who needs multiple films to flesh out his arc. Consistency is needed, and the studio should have tapped an actor who’s in for the long haul, whether than meant locking Affleck into a long-term deal or seeking out another star entirely.

The truth behind Affleck’s apparent reluctance to commit to Batman long-term is still shrouded in mystery, but given that he is the franchise’s most bankable star and a proven asset in front of and behind the camera, perhaps the studio’s strategy should have been creative appeasement.


4. Make The Joker Suicide Squad’s Main Villain

Suicide Squad Joker Jared Leto
Warner Bros. Pictures

Many of Suicide Squad’s biggest problems came in the editing room where scenes were mercilessly hacked to shreds at the behest of meddling studio execs, but there are easy fixes for some of its other issues, such as the lack of a compelling villain.

There was nothing particularly memorable about Cara Delevingne's Enchantress, and it was disappointing when she turned out to be the movie’s main antagonist once all of the cards were on the table, especially since there was a stronger candidate for that role among its cast.

Jared Leto’s Joker was largely squandered in Suicide Squad, with the movie failing to justify his inclusion at every turn. He was given little to do beyond abuse Harley Quinn in flashback sequences, and most of that ended up on the cutting room floor, much to the actor’s chagrin.

The Joker was shoehorned into the film purely because Warner gave director David Ayer the greenlight to use the character. This is one of the most infamous villains in comic book history, not a supporting character who hovers around aimlessly on the periphery.

Had Ayer used the Clown Prince as his primary antagonist and explored his insanity on a deeper level, more fans would surely have flocked to the cinema to see what happens when a band of rag-tag villains squares off against the most unpredictable rogue in the Batman gallery.


3. A More Traditional Lex Luthor

Jesse Eisenberg Lex Luthor
Warner Bros.

Batman v Superman had many problems, and high on the list was Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor. Not only was the Social Network star's performance completely over the top, it was cliched and his villainous plan was predictable, despite having more holes in it than Alex Murphy in the opening scene of RoboCop.

Part of the problem was the decision to reimagine the character as a weird mash-up of Mark Zuckerberg and Heath Ledger's Joker. Sometimes traditional is the way to go, and this was one of those times.

Luthor should have been cold, calculating and dignified, but Eisenberg, who looked like he had been dressed by Wes Anderson in some scenes, was none of those things. Although there had been two versions of the character on the big screen already, there were so many other aspects of this iconic villain that could have been explored, instead of going down the route of half-baked reinvention.

The evidence suggests Warner is well aware this version of Luthor didn't strike a chord with fans are critics, hence why his role was reportedly scaled back for Justice League. If they could take another stab at Batman v Superman, the studio would either cast a different actor or rewrite the role in a way that is closer to the comics.


2. Fewer CGI Characters (Or At Least More Convincing Ones)

Doomsday Batman V Superman
Warner Bros.

Between squandering the potential of The Joker to getting Lex Luthor horribly wrong, the DC cinematic universe has something of a villain problem, and it hasn’t helped the situation by depicting some of its antagonists as CGI abominations.

When Doomsday stomped onto the scene in Batman v Superman, he looked more like one of those Cave Trolls from Lord of the Rings than his fearsome comic book counterpart and, worst of all, the effects were no more convincing than the ones used to create those trolls a decade and a half ago.

Suicide Squad suffered from the same problem when it attempted to bring Incubus to life via hamfisted computer animation. He looked like he had arrived in the movie fresh off the set of Brendan Fraser’s The Mummy, unrealistic even by ancient demigod standards.

Poor CGI continues to be a running them in the franchise: just look at Cyborg in Justice League. Given how much this character’s third-rate Terminator design has been slated since the first trailer dropped, Warner Bros no doubt feels it should have prioritised practical effects (or at least better CGI) in hindsight.


1. More Creative Risks

Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

Warner Bros is showing signs of emulating the Marvel Cinematic Universe on screen, following in its footsteps with post-credits stingers and banter-driven hero antics, but the lesson it should draw from the MCU is that it pays to take creative risks.

Most of the DC cinematic universe movies fall into the vanilla superhero genre, with the exception of Suicide Squad which mixed things up by going villain-centric, but the best Marvel films are the ones that have experimented with different genres.

Captain America: The Winter Soldier was an intense spy-thriller, Thor: Ragnarok has rock operatics at its core and the Guardians of the Galaxy movies are full-on space operas. This is the kind of variety the DC movies need, and they certainly have the characters to pull this sort of thing off.

With any luck, upcoming films like Justice League Dark and Green Lantern Corps will broaden the franchise’s output, the former adding weirdness and the latter sci-fi elements, but these are the kind of risks Warner should have taken earlier on.

It didn’t hurt the shared cinematic universe when the studio decided to take a punt on a female-fronted superhero movie, did it?


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw