9 Distractingly Bad Performances In Otherwise Great Movies
Django Unchained was going so well...
The actors on-screen are always incredibly important in dictating how successful or unsuccessful a film is and over the decades, many movies have been absolutely torpedoed by terrible acting. Naturally, you'd usually expect to find Razzie-worthy acting in overall poor-quality films, but bad performances can sometimes be found within mostly great movies, which is the last place you'd expect to see them.
The following ten movies all contain particularly glaring examples of this. Whether it was due to miscasting, bad directing or a general lack of acting skills from the actor involved, these performances are huge distractions in otherwise superb viewing experiences.
All ten of these movies are still very much worth seeing, but they certainly had to overcome major obstacles thanks to one of their performances not being up to scratch. In fact, some of these films had to survive more than one terrible performance...
9. Contagion: Jude Law - Alan Krumwiede
Contagion is a terrifying, dread-laced, realistic and exceptionally haunting look at the effects of a global pandemic that gets a huge lift from a great cast, Steven Soderbergh's precise direction, a fantastic score from Cliff Martinez and a smart script, but there's one person who really lets the side down and surprisingly enough that's Jude Law.
Jude Law is a talented actor and in his role as an amoral conspiracy theorist he does the mannerisms and expressions for the character just fine; it's his accent that's the problem.
Law does the character with a toe-curling, hideously awful Australian accent and this ruins the entire performance. Why didn't they just allow Law to use his native British accent? Why didn't they get an Australian actor? Who knows? Regardless, this is one of the worst fake accents in recent film history... in fact, maybe ever.
8. Four Weddings And A Funeral: Andie MacDowell - Carrie
Four Weddings and a Funeral is an absolutely terrific British romantic comedy and the best thing screenwriter Richard Curtis has ever done, but as hilarious and touching as the film mostly is, its central romance between Charles (Hugh Grant) and Carrie (Andie MacDowell) is actually pretty chemistry-free since one half of the couple gives such a bad performance.
Hugh Grant does fine work in the film, but MacDowell is very wooden and it's hard to understand exactly while Charles is so smitten with her character. In a film with so many strong comedic turns, this terrible performance is Very distracting indeed.
Seriously, just try to watch MacDowell's entirely bored, disinterested delivery of the line "Is it still raining? I hadn't noticed" at the film's ending, which is supposed to be the film's big romantic moment, without cringing; you'll fail miserably.
Inexplicably, the Rotten Tomatoes critics consensus refers to "winsome performances from Hugh Grant and Andie MacDowell."
Huh? There's nothing "winsome" about this performance, mate.
7. Mystic River: Sean Penn - Jimmy Markum
Mystic River is an absolutely excellent thriller movie that looks at grief, trauma and vengeance in a bleak, thought-provoking and unforgettable manner, but while Tim Robbins and Kevin Bacon are both fantastic, Sean Penn's leading performance as Jimmy Markum is honestly pretty terrible.
Penn's performance alternates between generic broody acting and over-the-top, hammy yelling - most prominently in the infamous scene when the cops find the body of Jimmy's daughter and he bellows "IS THAT MY DAUGHTER IN THERE?" in an unintentionally hilarious manner - and as such he's the most glaring flaw in an otherwise strong film.
Weak acting like this in what is otherwise such a brilliantly acted film is strange enough, but what's stranger still is that Penn won Best Actor for this at the 2004 Oscars, making this by far one of the worst Oscar-winning performances of the 21st century.
6. Django Unchained: Quentin Tarantino - Frankie
Now, we go from one terrible stab at the notoriously difficult Australian accent to another.
Django Unchained is an impressive and audacious Western with four great central performances from Jamie Foxx, Christoph Waltz, Leonardo DiCaprio and Samuel L. Jackson in particular, but despite this being such a well-acted movie there is a Razzie-worthy bit of acting in the film's final act from the film's writer and director, Quentin Tarantino, himself.
Tarantino might be a great screenwriter but you should never, ever let him act since that's one thing he really can't do. His performance in Pulp Fiction was pretty terrible but this one was even worse.
In this brief turn as an Australian slave dealer, Tarantino's performance is deeply annoying and silly, while his Aussie accent is dreadful too. Django Unchained really does go off the rails in the final act and while a terrible plot twist shortly before this character turned up had given some early warning signs, this extremely distracting cameo was pretty much the moment where it became clear Django Unchained wasn't going to live up to its first two hours.
5. Brokeback Mountain: Anne Hathaway - Lureen Newsome Twist
Brokeback Mountain is a powerful, heart-breaking romantic Western that's not only an important film which brought LGBT movies into the mainstream, but is a generally awesome one too. It's further lifted up by the amazing performances of its cast, including the much-missed Heath Ledger, Jake Gyllenhaal and Michelle Williams but there's one big exception and that's Anne Hathaway, who plays Jack's (Gyllenhaal) wife.
Anne Hathaway is quite a lucky actress on the whole. She's done very well for herself but she's tended to be serviceable without ever being great and she's done almost nothing noteworthy since winning the Oscar for her career-best turn in Les Miserables, so how strong an actress she really is is debatable.
Anyhow, her acting chops certainly weren't too well-developed in this early performance, in which she gives a one-note and flat turn that sticks out like a sore-thumb in a film with many powerhouse performances. She also fatally undermines one of the film's big emotional scenes near the end when she talks to Heath Ledger's character on the phone and sounds thoroughly disinterested in the whole thing.
4. The Limey: Peter Fonda - Terry Valentine
The late Peter Fonda had a long, prosperous career and will be remembered as one of the great counter-cultural icons of the 1960s (largely thanks to his role in Easy Rider) but of course all actors have their off days and they sometimes come along in places you wouldn't expect to see them i.e. great movies like this one.
The Limey is a superb, hard-hitting revenge thriller from Steven Soderbergh that has an outstanding lead performance from Terrence Stamp and features some of the most unique, interesting editing ever committed to film, but unfortunately Fonda is very weak as the film's rich, sleazy American villain.
It seems obvious why he was cast: they wanted to have Stamp, a British icon of the 1960s, face off against an American icon of the 1960s but Fonda evidently wasn't quite the right choice. He fails to bring any real menace or nastiness to the character and just seems like a laid-back, rather bored rich man and not like a villain at all.
3. Hereditary: Alex Wolff - Peter Graham
Hereditary, despite its terrible ending, is a mostly strong horror film that effortlessly blends powerful drama with horrifying shocks and also features a monumental lead performance from Toni Collette. She shares many scenes with Alex Wolff, who plays her character's son, and therefore is often required to salvage those scenes.
Wolff is the secondary protagonist of the film and, since he plays a teenager dealing with the accidental death of his sister (which he was partly responsible for), this is a very weighty and challenging role which any young actor would struggle with. Unfortunately, at this time, Wolff just wasn't quite able to pull this off.
In scenes when he's supposed to be angry or distressed he just comes across as whiny and in various emotionally intense scenes he's constantly doing a weird, unintentionally hilarious whimpering noise which reduced everyone at the screening I attended to hysterics every single time.
It's never fun to criticise a younger actor, but Wolff's performance in Hereditary was overall underwhelming.
2. Saw: Cary Elwes And Leigh Whannell - Dr Lawrence Gordon And Adam Stanheight
The original Saw film is a very impressive low-budget horror film which is so intense, clever and thrilling that you overlook a colossal flaw: it's led by two terrible performances.
As two men stuck inside one of Jigsaw's terrifying games, Cary Elwes and writer-producer Leigh Whannell are both pretty lackluster. Despite his talent as a writer, director and producer, Whannell gave a very annoying and unconvincing performance as Adam, while Cary Elwes' flat performance and terrible attempt at an American accent was similarly jarring.
Unfortunately, Elwes' acting (and accent) had not improved when he returned for Saw 3D: The Final Chapter. If he ever does return to the series (and, with the franchise now up and running again, it's likely that he will) hopefully he'll give a better performance and finally do a convincing American accent.
1. The Matrix: Most Of The Cast
The Matrix might be a visually glorious, excellently-plotted and stunningly well-made piece of science-fiction cinema and one of the most beloved films of the 1990s, but much like with Saw, the overall skill of the film distracts from just how awful virtually All of the acting is.
Hugo Weaving is deliciously evil as Agent Smith, Laurence Fishburne is excellent as the quiet, wise Morpheus and Joe Pantoliano is solid as Cypher, but pretty much everyone else gives a terrible performance.
It's somewhat easy to ignore this since Neo is a very good and well-written character, but Keanu Reeves does give a very wooden performance as him. Carrie Anne-Moss, meanwhile, is even worse and most of the other humans who are with them in the real-world give laughably sloppy, amateurish performances.
The Matrix, which turned 20(!) last year, is still a good watch but the majority of the acting is shockingly bad and as a result of this, combined with the fairly clunky dialogue that these actors deliver, it's quite likely that the next time you re-watch The Matrix you might not love it quite as much as you used to.