9 Films Dominated By The Last Actor You'd Expect

adam sandler reign over me Any movie fan worth their salt can usually tell going in which actor will put on a good performance. It may sound like a slight over-exaggeration, but we're experienced enough to know what we're going to get €“ Daniel Day-Lewis will chew scenery in ridiculous ways, Samuel L. Jackson will be reliably awesome and Rob Schneider will be terrible... just terrible. Some things are as constant as the Northern Star, and experienced Hollywood-watchers will be able to spot the filmic turkeys way before they hit the big screen. However, a movie does occasionally surprise even the most jaded film-watcher, as an actor we would have expected nothing from €“ or sometimes, even less €“ gazumps with a tour de force. Whether they're known for terrible films, they're stepping into the shoes of a cursed character or we simply know nothing about them, sometimes actors can turn the tables in the most spectacular of ways. This honestly happens more than you might think so I thought it might be time to catalogue of a few of these unexpected scene-stealers, so without further ado, let's get down to it. Be aware, a mild SPOILER WARNING is in effect. You have been warned.

9. Mark Ruffalo €“ The Avengers

Avengers Pre-Avengers, The Hulk was something of the red-headed stepchild in the Marvel Movie Universe. The big green monster had been the subject of two notable misfires already, with Ang Lee's Eric Bana-starring noble experiment falling down for a lack of action film whiz-bangery and Louis Leterrier's later Edward Norton vehicle being seen as merely passable. There was real fear about slotting the Hulk into the Avengers, because unlike the other Marvel stablemates, he didn't have a sure-fire hit behind him coming in, and the fact Norton became the second Hulk to be dropped for being too difficult to work with didn't exactly fill us with hope. But into the breach €“ or rather, the stretchy purple sweatpants €“ strolled Mark Ruffalo, giving us a new spin on the character we hadn't seen before. To my mind, the Bruce Banner of the previous two Hulks was possibly the least interesting main character a Marvel film had. Both Bana and Norton played the part by focusing on inner turmoil and a need to stay buttoned-down and reined in, making for an occasionally hard watch. However, Ruffalo took the opposite view, giving his perma-tanned Banner a surfer-dude chilled out attitude which was punctuated with occasional outbursts of anger. It made him great to watch, tuning possibly the biggest liability in alter-ego terms into a mesmeric character full of insecurities yet somehow still possessing a breezy self-confidence. His performances alongside Robert Downey Jr's motormouth Tony Stark were incredible and made him a worthy contender for the film's hotly-contested MVP crown. The scene where he eventually hulks out in New York was a moment of fist-pumping awesomeness, and all that pay-off was made possible by Ruffalo's nuanced portrayal.You can tell that Marvel have every faith in their new Bruce €“ they're looking to shoot new Ruffalo-centric films as part of their Phase Three in an attempt to create a new, possibly barnstorming take on the franchise. Be honest, before The Avengers came out, did you really expect that to happen?

8. Sean Combs €“ Get Him To The Greek

Combs A cameo can go one of two ways €“ they can go well, or they can go badly, and the feeling towards it tends to be exacerbated by its briefness. You know that they stuck whomever in the film to make an impression €“ after all, that€™s the whole point of a cameo. So if it falls flat, it really falls flat, reaching such David Beckham-esque (seriously, watch him in Goal) levels of arse-shifting uncomfortable-ness. So when Puff Daddy was cast in Get Him To The Greek, I was understandably concerned. The acting careers of rap stars tend to be something of a mixed bag, so let€™s just say expectations were low. But really, I shouldn€™t have worried, because Sean Combs€™ (as he wished to be known for the film) record label boss was hilarious. It seems to be something of a pattern in the Forgetting Sarah Marshall universe that the mainstays will be showed up by the support, and Combs€™ €˜mind-f**king€™ you-cannot-outrun-me-I-am-black performance even managed to outshine Russell Brand€™s dissolute rock star. Honestly, no-one was as surprised as me, but watching Combs€™ Sergio tell Pharell Williams that he was one shirt away from Carlton was the closest thing to comic gold this performance had. His performance is bound to catch up with you eventually, because as the great man says, you can€™t outrun him.

7. Adam Sandler €“ Reign Over Me

Sandler

Adam Sandler has a bad reputation among the cinephile community, and it€™s not hard to see why. I don€™t think there€™s been a career path in Hollywood more settled upon languishing in mediocrity than the Happy Gilmore star, who long ago realised that his Happy Madison films were going to make him far more moolah than any foray into the proper acting world, Punch-Drunk Love and Funny People notwithstanding. So to see him actually go for broke in something like Reign Over Me €“ which is most definitely not a comedy €“ was refreshing because it was so rare. If you watch Sandler€™s dramatic performances, you know he€™s very capable of pulling off a memorable performance €“ after all, Paul Thomas Anderson doesn€™t work with fools €“ yet when you€™re snowed under by execrable pap like Grown Ups, you do tend to forget. So his turn as Dr. Charlie Fineman was remarkable entirely because it was him in the part. Of course, just taking part in stunt-casting doesn€™t guarantee a good performance, but Sandler here was a revelation, playing a man who€™d lost absolutely everything in 9/11 with such heart-rending pathos that you wonder why he doesn€™t try to this more often. Granted, we all know why he tends to stay away from this stuff, but if it could lead to more performances like this then perhaps he should stop thinking about the bottom line so often. After all, there€™s only so many gold-plated mansions a superstar comedian needs.

6. Brett MacKenzie €“ Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

Figwit OK, this one€™s a bit strange and is probably the least applicable out of all the roles on this list, but I felt I just had to mention it, if only for the barnstorming lunacy it inspired. If you don€™t know who Brett MacKenzie is, then shame on you €“ he€™s a member of New Zealand music-comedy group Flight of the Conchords, who are undoubtedly hilarious and you should totally see them. Now that€™s out the way, I€™ll explain what he did in Lord of the Rings, The Fellowship of the Ring. He was an extra, and that€™s sort of it. He didn€™t have any lines, and he just stood at the back of the Council of Elrond scene and looked serious. However, for some reason or another, a large swathe of LOTR fans took to this anonymous elf, with entire fansites and slash fiction epics being struck up in his name. Because he didn€™t have a name, the fans dubbed him €˜Figwit,€™ an acronym for €˜Frodo is great€who is THAT?€™ Apparently, it had something to with his photogenic nature €“ the two fans who created the website €˜Figwit Lives€™ believed him to be €˜Legolas for the thinking woman,€™ utterly taken it by his wonderful eyebrows and complexion. It got so bad that he was given an autopgraph card in the LOTR Topps Authentic Autograph range, has a documentary named after him which premiered at the Toronto Film Festival and Peter Jackson eventually gave him two lines in Return of King. The elf who tells Arwen that they cannot delay when she€™s on her way to the Gray Havens? Yeah, that€™s Figwit, and now he's in The Hobbit too. Never has a man got so much for doing so little.

5. Christoph Waltz €“ Inglorious Basterds

Landa I know Cristoph Waltz is a huge star now with two Oscars under his belt, but you have to realise how insane it was that he was cast as Hans Landa in Inglorious Basterds. Until Hollywood€™s most famous auteur came calling, Waltz was a jobbing method actor who had only appeared in Austrian soaps and TV movies. Nothing said he would be able to dominate a flick like this, and the fact Landa was regarded as one of Tarantino€™s most unplayable characters makes his accomplishment all the more astounding. I€™m serious when I say Landa was unplayable €“ Tarantino wanted a suave-yet-brutal German, French, Italian and English speaker, and was having trouble casting the role which would effectively be the lynchpin of his alternate-history epic. He wanted Leo Di Caprio €“ who was unavailable €“ and had rejected more established stars such as Michael Fassbender for the role, who he declared as €˜not f**king German enough,€™ despite Fassbender€™s German heritage. The bar was set pretty high, and I don€™t think anyone expected a jobbing and obscure European actor to vault over it with such grace. And my, did he. Landa was a superb creation who won the best supporting actor gong with ease, proving a worthy successor to Heath Ledger€™s Joker of the year before. Waltz upstaged everyone, from emerging young talent like Melanie Laurent to grand A-listers like Brad Pitt. It was utterly totemic, and absolutely nobody expected it going in.

4. Eddie Murphy €“ Dreamgirls

Jimmy It€™s safe to say Eddie Murphy€™s career isn€™t the glittering prospect it once was. The man went from strength-to-strength in the 80s, releasing his live stand-up show Raw to rave reviews and huge box office numbers, as well as fronting a number of megahits such as the Beverley Hills Cop series. He was Paramount€™s most bankable star, and even kept this going in the 90s with films such as the Nutty Professor. Then Pluto Nash happened, and Murphy€™s films have been stinking out multiplexes ever since. He was still an asset to animated films, lending his manic vocal pipes to Mulan and €“ most famously €“ Shrek, but the idea that Murphy in the flesh could make a film box office dynamite had been taken behind the woodshed and shot, Old Yeller-style. It was into this Murphy-malaise that Dreamgirls was released. While he wasn€™t ostensibly the star €“ that honour fell to Jamie Foxx, Jennifer Hudson and Beyonce Knowles, he was still given pride of place on the posters as befitting his status as a supporting player, and I thought that might€™ve been the kiss of death. Yet he was surprisingly awesome €“ he threw himself into the film with gusto, enlivening his role as the self-destructive Jimmy €˜Thunder€™ Early with manic energy, desperate sadness, the occasional comedic moment and last but certainly not least, a brilliant singing voice. I defy you to watch his rendition of €˜I Want You Baby€™ and not find it awesome, and after years in the terrible comedy wilderness, Murphy picked up an Oscar nomination, something overshadowed by Jennifer Hudson's similarly mammoth and Oscar-winning performance. In fact, many people felt he only lost to Little Miss Sunshine€™s Alan Arkin because he released the risible Norbit straight afterward.

3. Brad Bird €“ The Incredibles

Edna Directors have acting in their films before, but it€™s usually either in a blink-and-you€™ll-miss-it cameo (Alfred Hitchcock), a terrible piece of self indulgence (M. Night Shyamalan) or if they€™re already established actors (George Clooney). For my money, I don€™t believe Brad Bird fits into any of these categories, yet he still managed to waltz off with the most memorable parts of Pixar megahit The Incredibles with his role as fashion designer Edna Mode. What made it so great was that it was so unexpected €“ granted, if a director could pop up anywhere and not be noticed, it would be in an animated film. Yet Bird didn€™t seem to be cameo-ing €“ he was taking on established actors at their own game and winning. His Edna was hilarious, full of €˜Milan dahling€™ culture vulture-isms and possessing an acid tongue (€˜my god, you€™ve gotten fat€™) like few other animated creations before her. Bird€™s vocal work made her hilarious, creating a caricature that was a joy to watch throughout. Really, in my opinion the most memorable part of that film was Edna€™s explanation of why capes were no longer recommended for superhero costumes, and describing the various suits to Helen Parr (€˜and machine washable darling, that€™s a new feature€™). Such a performance makes me wonder why Bird doesn€™t lend his vocal pipes to more animations in the future €“ he€™s clearly got the talent to make it into a proper career €“ rather than occasionally cameoing on other films €“ but I guess when you€™ve managed to make the successful jump into live-action films (he directed the excellent Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol) then you don€™t really have to frequent the voice-recording booth all that often.

2. Jennifer Coolidge €“ American Pie

Stifler In a way, you€™ve got to feel sorry for the American Pie boys €“ not only will their careers ever hit the heights they reached with this franchise, but they were pretty much upstaged in their best film too. With the possible exception of Sean William Scott€™s Stifler, nearly all the Tall Oaks gang paled into insignificance compared to original MILF Jennifer Coolidge, otherwise known as Stifler€™s Mom. It cannot be understated just how much of an impact this woman had. Popularising the cougar fad before it had even properly started, Jennifer Coolidge reeked of older-woman sex appeal from when we first saw her, and she probably proved the most memorable part of the movie. Yes, it was all well and good watching the gang finally lose their V-plates, but nothing compares to Finch and the mom going at it on the pool table. What makes this all the more impressive is that Stifler€™s mom is barely on screen at all. She only really appears in the flesh at the very end, yet she makes such an indelible impression that she provides the biggest laugh in the film and popularised the meaning of Mrs. Robinson to a whole new generation of moviegoers. After all, there€™s a reason why she kept turning up in the canonical sequels, and why MILF now features in the Oxford English Dictionary.

1. R. Lee Ermey €“ Full Metal Jacket

Ermey R. Lee Ermey is awesome. I€™ll get that out the way now. A former US Marine and drill instructor, the man knows how to be terrifying and possess the most formidable movie eyebrows in many a long year. But when he went for the role of Gunnery Sergeant Hartman in Stanley Kubrick€™s war-is-hell drama, nobody expected just how well he€™d do. In fact, he was actually turned away from the role by Kubrick when he first auditioned for it, as the great auteur didn€™t think he was nasty enough. So Ermey decided he would go hell-for-leather, recording a tape of him yelling drill instructor insults at extras while dressed in full regalia. In a move wholly unprecedented for the difficult, stubborn and just plain insane Kubrick, he actually did changed his mind. More unusually, he let Ermey write his own dialogue to allow for absolute military authenticity. All those insults you see Hartman spew out over the course of that first act (my particular favourite €“ €˜You climb like old people f**k Pyle!€™) was all made up on the spot by the man. In the final, ridiculous step for Kubrick, Ermey got all his scenes done within two or three takes, a move wholly unprecedented for an obsessive director who cost Shelley Duval her sanity in the Shining by making her swing an axe and cry over a hundred times. Really, you€™ve got to admire it. Ermey was a relative greenhorn as an actor €“ he had featured on a handful of army-based shows before Jacket €“ but managed to enthral the most demanding director in Hollywood. When he finally gets shot, the film suffers for his absences, even in the hands of more established actors. It€™s an incredible unexpected performance, wholly deserving of the Golden Globe nod it received. Agree or disagree? Know of any more? Feel free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.