9 Movie Sequels That Ruined Great Characters
Character development? More like character devolution.
We live in an age in which sequels and prequels seem kind of inevitable. As soon as a movie is successful, you can almost hear the Hollywood execs rubbing their hands together and dreaming up ways to turn the film into a cash grab franchise.
Sometimes it’s not always such a bad thing. We’ve seen some hugely successful franchises emerge in recent years that managed to keep up the quality of their films at least for the most part – take the MCU, for example, or The Lord of the Rings.
But as anyone with a couple of movie sequels under their belt can tell you, for the most part they pale in comparison to the original movie bar a few outstanding examples. Beyond all the usual sins often committed by sequels – rehashing old storylines, digging up plot holes and the like – they also have a tendency to butcher some previously brilliant characters.
Often sequels add an unnecessary amount of backstory that completely destroys the mystique or appeal of a character or recast a role with a new actor whose interpretation off the character feels off. Sometimes it’s simply down to the overexposure sequels give a character – there’s only so much of a character you can take before someone that previously felt like a breath of fresh starts to feel stale and hackneyed.
Whatever the reason, these sequels are all guilty of one thing – ruining characters we once loved.
9. Peter Parker/Spider-Man – Spider-Man 3
In the first two instalments of Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man movies, Tobey Maguire was pretty much perfect as the first big-screen incarnation of the web-slinging wonder boy. Charming in a boyish sort of way, slightly awkward but totally likeable and relatable, he perfectly encapsulated a young man coming to terms with his newfound superhero status.
But in Spider-Man 3, we see Peter Parker transformed from a wholesome and affable superhero into a cringeworthy and cartoonish caricature of evil by way of a space-borne symbiote.
It could’ve been a great opportunity to see Parker go down a darker route but the closest he got to ‘dark’ was taking fashion and hairstyle cues from emo culture and being a d**k to Mary Jane by performing an utterly embarrassing dance routine characterised by hip-thrusts and Parker imploring us to “dig on this”. We did not dig on it.
Funnily enough, Spider-Man 3 marked the end of Raimi’s series despite the fact another sequel was in the works. It was probably for the best really.
8. Rocky Balboa – Rocky IV
Most of the hate for the Rocky franchise is reserved for its
fifth instalment and while it’s true Rocky V is an absolutely awful movie when
you think about it, it was Rocky IV that really did a number on the iconic
fictional boxer.
In the original Rocky, Sylvester Stallone played the boxer as an everyman underdog – a relatable and sympathetic character we could all root for. That shtick stayed the same for first two sequels even though, admittedly, the quality of the series went downhill after the first film.
Yet in Rocky IV we see the underdog elevated to unrealistic levels taking on Ivan Drago and somehow winning even though the Russian brick sh*thouse had previously punched the infinitely tougher Apollo Creed to death. Most ridiculously his victory over Drago wins over the Soviet crowd and is presented as Balboa metaphorically punching an end to the Cold War. That’s just plain silly.
To be fair, the character clawed his way back to respectability with the back-to-basics Rocky we saw in Rocky Balboa and Creed but unfortunately the regrettable legacy of Rocky IV (and yes, Rocky V too) unfortunately live on.
7. The Xenomorphs – Alien: Covenant
Part of the terrifying appeal of the Xenomorphs (and the
face-huggers and chest-bursters – let’s not forget those abominable bastards)
was that they were so … well … alien. The clue is in the title apparently.
Horrifying in all their gooey otherworldliness, the Xenomorphs and all their various other forms worked so well because we had no clue of where they came from or how they came to be just that they were ruthless killing machines. The first four films in the Alien kept up the enigma of their titular villains but then came the much-maligned prequels and – as prequels are wont to do – they pretty much ruined all their mystique.
To find out they – or at least the Xenomorphs we saw in the original Alien film – were created by an uppity megalomaniac of an android who can’t tell his Shelley from his Byron is anticlimactic to say the least. Imagining the Xenomorphs came from some dark corner of deep, deep space and evolved of their own accord was far more effective.
6. George McFly – Back To The Future Part II
After original George McFly actor Crispin Glover declined to
return for Back to the Future Part II over a pay dispute, Robert Zemeckis and
Co were tasked with finding a believable replacement who could fill Glover’s
shoes and match the brilliantly eccentric performance he gave in the first
film.
But rather than simply recast the role as they’d done with Marty McFly’s girlfriend Jennifer Parker which swapped Claudia Wells for Elisabeth Shue, they decided to cast lookalike actor Jeffrey Weissman. Even more weirdly, they had Weissman wear prosthetics modelled on Glover’s face and purposefully filmed him in ways that obscured the fact they’d even replaced Glover at all.
Despite the physical likeness Weissman couldn’t quite pull it off and the result was more poor imitation with a heavy dose of uncanny valley than anything else. The only saving grace about the recasting was that George McFly played a far less central role in the next two Back to the Future films so it didn’t impact too much on their overall enjoyability, fortunately.
5. Marion Ravenwood – Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
The hard-drinking, chain-smoking, Nazi-fighting Marion
Ravenwood we saw in Raiders of the Lost Ark was no doubt the best leading lady
of the first three Indiana Jones movies.
Granted, that may have been largely by default given that Temple of Doom’s Willie was an irritating diva and Dr Elsa Schneider was a Nazi but Marion was still the feistiest and most likeable of the three even if she did end up falling for Indy again by the end of the film.
In Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, however, we see the once tough and tomboyish woman who could drink anyone under the table reduced to a watered-down shadow of her former self that verges on soccer mom.
Of course, if this were real life, it’s likely that 20 years and the experience of motherhood (plus a normal, healthy relationship) later Marion would have mellowed considerably. But this isn’t real life (in case Indy surviving a kiloton nuclear blast didn’t already give that away) and we wanted feisty firecracker Marion.
4. Jack Sparrow – On Stranger Tides & Dead Men Tell No Tales
Call it overexposure or blame it on franchise fatigue but
Captain Jack Sparrow today feels a far cry from the breath of fresh air he was
back when the first Pirates of the Caribbean film The Curse of the Black Pearl
was released back in 2003. Once permanently soused but simultaneously wily and
charming, the last two POTC films saw him morph into something that far more
resembled a drunken buffoon than a formidable anti-hero.
Part of the problem is the shift in focus to Sparrow in On Stranger Tides and Dead Men Tell No Tales. Though Sparrow was undoubtedly the character that stole the show in the first three POTC movies, plot-wise he kind of took a backseat to the various goings-on between Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann which worked well for both the films and Sparrow.
But with Will and Elizabeth largely absent from the last two films, Sparrow seemed to get promoted from secondary character to lead which unfortunately just served to show how caricaturish he’s become.
3. Norman Bates – Psycho IV: The Beginning
Sequels within the horror genre can be particularly damaging
to their villainous characters. Once terrifying enough to inspire fear in the
hardiest of horror fans, horror sequels tend to add more and more backstory
until their villains are the opposite of fearsome. Such is the case with Norman
Bates.
Though the first two Psycho sequels no doubt had Alfred Hitchcock rolling in his grave they weren’t all THAT bad. Sure, they added titbits of Norman’s f**ked-up family history and didn’t hold a candle to the classic original but they were at least vaguely watchable and maintained at least some mystique for Norman. Psycho IV: The Beginning, however, was pure exposition.
Thanks to a fairly explanatory voiceover at the end of Hitchcock’s Psycho we already knew that Norman had a pretty unhealthy relationship with his mother – he did kill her, dig up her body and posthumously assume her identity after all.
But Psycho IV went full-on oedipal with the incestuous undertones of their relationship more than just hinted at with a blow-by-blow account of just how Norman turned out the way he did as he confesses his life and crimes on a radio talk show phone-in.
It’s exposition we didn’t need and didn’t ask for when the minimal details were already enough and far more effective in presenting Norman as a frightening villain.
2. John McClane – Live Free Or Die Hard & A Good Day To Die Hard
When we first met Die Hard’s John McClane back in 1988 he was
a cynical, no-nonsense NYPD cop with a knack for foul-mouthed one-liners who
had the misfortune of finding himself in a rather sticky situation but the
resourcefulness to get out of it – a kind of reluctant hero who simply found
himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and did what he had to do with
whatever he had at his disposal.
The next two films in the franchise stayed true to the original and though McClane blowing up elevator shafts and taking out a villain-packed helicopter by strategically shooting down a power line isn’t exactly the stuff of gritty realism he was still pretty believable as a person. Or at least as believable as an action movie character can be anyway.
But Live Free or Die Hard largely abandoned that and gave McClane superhero-like qualities that gave him the power to effortlessly surf a pilotless fighter jet before leaping to a highway below – completely unharmed of course – and other such silly stuff. By the time A Good Day to Die Hard was released McClane was practically indestructible defying death (and credibility) at every turn despite now being in his late 50s.
Yippee-ki-yay? How about yippee-ki-nay.
1. Darth Vader – The Star Wars Prequels
A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away there once lived a formidable villain called Darth Vader. Clad entirely in black with an intimidatingly raspy voice and usually wielding a lightsabre at some poor innocent, he was once described by Obi-Wan Kenobi as “twisted and evil” and inspired fear in the hearts of millions.
At least that was until George Lucas released that cursed prequel trilogy. Gone was the mystique of the ruthless villain replaced instead with an annoying, blonde-haired moppet who grew into a whiny little bitch of a young man.
Now it’s hard to think of one of cinema’s most iconic villains without also seeing Jake Lloyd squealing “Yippee” or Hayden Christensen awkwardly trying to flirt with Padmé Amidala with the line “I don’t like sand”.
But such is the danger of adding a lengthy backstory to a character once shrouded in mystery. Cheers, George Lucas.