9 Movies Ben Affleck Was Almost Cast In

The Gone Girl star's career could have gone in a very different direction.

Ben Affleck has always had a somewhat dual reputation, which has been really personified over the past couple of years. Winning universal praise (and awards) for his direction and lead performance in Argo, the internet turned against him only a few months later when it was announced he'd be donning the cape and cowl as Bruce Wayne in the upcoming Batman V Superman. Clearly the wounds of Daredevil cut deep. Although he won his first Oscar at the age of twenty-five, to the general public for a long time Affleck was best known for his relationship with Jennifer Lopez, standing as a central part of modern celebrity. This naturally affected his reputation as an actor, with his skill not really coming across in films as dire as Gigli and Jersey Girl. A shift into directing (and a more low-key relationship with his wife Jennifer Garner) have helped his output once again take prominence over his private life. Now with Gone Girl, his latest film directed by the superb David Fincher, marking a definite high in his filmography, and people becoming more optimistic about the new take on the Caped Crusader, it seems like the ideal time to take a look at some of his career what ifs. Here are nine movies Ben Affleck very nearly starred in.

9. Matt Farrell - Live Free Or Die Hard

Live Free Or Die Hard, otherwise known by the marginally less embarrassing title Die Hard 4.0 internationally, was the then-weakest entry in the franchise, although positively looks like a masterpiece next to A Good Day To Die Hard. The film sees John McClane team up with computer hacker Matt Farrell, who is in the finished film played by Justin Long. However, had Bruce Willis got his way it would have been Affleck starring alongside him. Wanting to recreate the chemistry the two had in Armageddon, this choice would have likely strengthened the film's central relationship. Director Len Wiseman, however, was leaning towards his Underworld star Scott Speedman, although Long eventually won out. The film ends with Farrell getting it on with McClane's daughter. Played my Mary Elizabeth Winstead, who is thirteen years Affleck's junior, this could have looked more than a little weird. Maybe it's for the best he didn't appear.

8. Connor Mead - Ghosts Of Girlfriends Past

Another entry in a long line of Matthew McConaughey rom-coms that brought his career to rock bottom, Ghosts Of Girlfriends Past could have turned out very differently. Six years before we got the ultimate remaining of A Christmas Carol, the film was in pre-production with Ben Affleck its star and Kevin Smith the director. If that doesn't sound freaking awesome, remember this is when Smith was still marginally relevant. The project fell through when Gigli, which has become a major smear on Affleck's filmography, utterly bombed. That flop had a major effect on Affleck's career, with Jersey Girl, another Smith-Affleck pairing, completely gutted to downplay the presence of Gigli co-star and Affleck's ex Jennifer Lopez. The Ghosts Of Girlfriends Past we ultimately got is nothing like what Smith and Affleck planned, with a new production studio (the New Line Cinema film was originally Disney's) and a totally different cast, including Affleck's wife Jennifer Garner.

7. Don Haskins - Glory Road

Jerry Bruckheimer may be best known for producing some of the biggest action movies of the past couple of decades (Armageddon, Pirates Of The Caribbean and, erm, The Lone Ranger), but he's also been the man behind many a middling sports biopic. The last of these was the limp Glory Road, which documented the story of the first all-black American College sports team (Texas Western's 1966 Basketball squad). The film caused a bit of a stir for making real people appear racist in an attempt to up the drama, but it wasn't really worth the fuss; no one really remembers it. In the finished film Josh Lucas plays Don Haskins, the usual revolutionary coach who believes in people, but the role was originally taken by Affleck. Having worked with Bruckheimer on Armageddon, this could have been the sort of role to help put the Gigli debacle behind him. The stated reason Affleck left was that old doozy of scheduling conflicts, although subsequent reports suggest the studio wasn't going to offer him enough cash; Disney were only going to pay him $5 million. Daylight robbery or what?

6. Patrick Kenzie - Gone Baby Gone

Ben Affleck the director is, if anything, more revered than Ben Affleck the actor. And it's not hard to see why - when he's behind the camera Affleck has a much better eye for a good project. While he can end up in all manner of Daredevils and Giglis as an actor, all three of the films he's directed have been spot-on. Starting off safe adapting a novel from the brilliant Dennis Lehane set in his beloved Boston, he got increasingly more adventurous. And it all paid off when Argo dominated the 2013 awards season. Affleck was the star of both The Town and Argo (a trend set to continue if the speculation he may direct The Batman is true). He considered doing the same for his debut feature, but ultimately kept entirely behind the camera, with younger brother Casey taking the lead role. Is Casey hadn't taken the role, do you think think it would have gone to Brian, that notorious third Affleck brother? Or Jason Segel?

5. Les Anderson - License To Drive

Ben Affleck first grew to public prominence when he and Matt Damon won the Best Original Screenplay Oscar for Good Will Hunting (in which they both also starred). But that was far from the start - his career had been slowly chugging along with minor roles throughout his childhood. Nothing really that major, but enough to give him the acting bug. One larger film role that almost sat there among turns in TV shows like The Voyage of the Mimi and Against The Grain is that of Les Anderson in the fun eighties comedy License To Drive. He auditioned for the part, but lost out to the much more established Corey Haim. Not too surprising when you consider this was another movie from beloved child star duo The Two Coreys (the other was Feldman). Not getting the role was far from disastrous for Affleck and gave him the time to slowly mature his multi-faceted talents.

4. Bob Kelly - Runaway Bride

A troubled production for a movie doesn't necessarily mean there'll be a bad outcome, but it never builds audience hopes. And the occasional successes - the likes of Apocalypse Now and Chinatown had tortuous journeys to the screen, but ended up being flat-out masterpieces - only serve to make those that don't work out all the more disappointing. Runaway Bride is a generic rom-com starring the woefully over-rated Richard Gere and Julia Roberts, but because it look over a decade to go from initial conception to the big screen there's a real sense of disappointment to the whole thing. Over those years it feels like all of Hollywood was considered to play a part - everyone, from Harrison Ford to Sandra Bullock was attached at one point or another. Ben Affleck was once mooted for the role of Bob, the fourth fiancé for Robert's Maggie, who has left each of the previous three on their intended wedding day. Given how bland the whole thing is, we can't say we're too upset to see Christopher Meloni play the part; there's nothing Affleck could have done to save the film.

3. Talk Show Host - Vulgar

Vulgar is one of the less revered films to come out Kevin Smith's View Askew Productions, mainly because it all strikes as a little pointless. It is a film aimed pretty much entirely at fans of previous Askew flicks, but despite exploring a character first seen in the opening of Clerks and starring many of Smith's frequent collaborators, it's not part of the overarching View Askewniverse (which includes Clerks, Jay And Silent Bob etc.). Ben Affleck is one of Smith's regulars notable by his absence in Bryan Johnson's movie. That's not for lack of wanting though - Affleck was wanting to cameo as a talk show host, but couldn't because he was busy filming Armageddon. In the end that small part went to Scott Mosier, Smith's long-time editor and producer, who has actually cameoed in most of his movies. There is a little reference to him, however, with the titular clown calling a Mrs. Affleck and having a quick phone conversation with her son Benny. How subtle.

2. Ennis Del Mar - Brokeback Mountain

When Heath Ledger was cast as the Joker in The Dark Knight, the fan reaction was rather negative. How could a man who'd played a gay cowboy successfully portray the Clown Prince of Crime? Well, had things gone a little differently, it would have been Ben Affleck's Batman that got levelled with that particular complaint. As if his casting needed any more fan hate. Back before Jake Gyllenhaal and Ledger were cast in Ang Lee's romantic drama, plenty of Hollywood's young guns were considered for the lead roles, including Ben Affleck and Matt Damon. Had they both been cast, that would have most certainly furthered the once-persistent rumours that the duo were more than just friends and screenwriting partners (seriously). While Affleck as Ennis would have been interesting, we can't imagine he'd have even come close to when Ledger delivered; it stands as an incredibly natural performance that helps show the breadth of skill the late, great actor had.

1. Jim Braddock - Cinderella Man

Cinderella Man isn't the best film in the filmography of either director Ron Howard or star Russell Crowe. But that's really testament to how good they can be (let's forget The Da Vinci Code and Les Miserables for now), than a slight against the film. You see, the biopic of heavyweight boxer James J. Braddock is a cracking biopic that feels right at home alongside boxing classics Raging Bull and Rocky. Crowe really went through the wringer for the part, going up against real boxers for the on-screen fights, which resulted in concussion, a dislocated shoulder and cracked teeth. After that you can imagine Ben Affleck wasn't too upset about missing out on the role of Braddock; along with fellow Bostonians Matt Damon and Mark Wahlberg, he was considered for the part. Given that none of those actors look a thing like Braddock it seems like Howard was once again taking his feel-alike tact. Still, we can't see anyone doing the part better than Crowe, who is actually a relatively close physical fit to the boxer, did. Would you have liked to have actually seen Affleck cast in any of these roles? Let us know your thoughts on what might have been in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.