9 Strangest Film Casting Choices (That Actually Worked)
Try imagining Wolverine as a song and dance man. Then, realize that's exactly the case.
Casting a film is a work of art unto itself. Choosing the right actor for the right role can elevate a movie to an unforeseeable success and choosing the wrong actor for the wrong role can doom an otherwise promising film. There are dozens of examples of this in the industry, but there are also the inexplicable casting choices, where the pairing of actor and role is so bizarre and unfounded that audiences feel compelled to see the movie just to know what the combination will yield.
On some rare occasions, these strange casting decisions create not only lasting performances, but iconic, star-making turns that put relatively unknown or underestimated actors on a whole new level of success. Though far and few between, these instances are memorable for how they subvert the expectations of the audience and, more often than not, the producers and studio as well.
This sometimes comes from inexperienced actors turning in performances above their weight class, has-beens proving they still have what it takes, or niche performers breaking out of the confinements of their limiting genres to demonstrate the full range of their capabilities.
9. Hugh Jackman - X-Men
Hugh Jackman's gruff but amicable portrayal of the X-Men's resident berserker has become so ubiquitous with Wolverine that it's difficult to remember a time when his casting was considered controversial.
Before he was known as an action star, Jackman was famous as a song and dance man. He was trained as a theater actor and specialized in musicals and choreography. When he was first announced to be portraying Wolverine, he was not muscular and there was concern that he would struggle to mask his Australian accent.
Comics fans were hardly enthralled by the casting but it took less than five minutes of screen-time for Jackman to put any doubts to bed. From the first shot of him as Wolverine, hunched over in the shadows of a cage fight, he exuded the badass aura of an ageless, unflinching warrior. He'd put on considerable muscle, completely covered his accent, and made the part his own.
8. Jim Carrey - The Truman Show
Some actors are so synonymous with a genre that seeing them attempt anything outside that specific realm of cinema can be jarring. And it's true to say that by the mid 90s Jim Carrey was starting to become typecast as a designated funny man. His entire career had been built on this persona, beginning as a standout comedian on In Living Color and making himself a household name with hits like Ace Ventura, The Mask, and Dumb and Dumber. Even when he tried to be a serious actor, he was only allowed to do so in dark comedies like The Cable Guy or campy romps like Batman Forever.
That's why it was such a shock for audiences to see him in The Truman Show, a mind-bending drama about a man who discovers his entire life has been fabricated for a reality show. The movie was played almost entirely straight and Carrey's earnest performance led The Truman Show to critical acclaim, and for his own career, a second wind. He would further express his range in Man on the Moon, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, and The Number 23 among others.
7. Michael Keaton - Batman
Tim Burton's Batman films were dark and unflinching and a big part of there grit came from Michael Keaton, who become the definitive Batman for an entire generation. His visceral and thoughtful performance as Bruce Wayne/Batman did come as a surprise to comic fans and the film-going public because to that point he had been tied almost exclusively to comedies.
A former standup comedian himself, Keaton's biggest roles before Batman had been as Jack in Mr. Mom, and Burton's own dark comedy Beetlejuice. Audiences knew him as a funny man with great comedic timing and particularly after Beetlejuice, comic fans could have seen him as The Joker... but not Batman.
Comic fans were concerned that Keaton wouldn't exude the raw psychological trauma or the playboy facade of the Batman they knew. He was too short, too slight, and not nearly serious enough. But Keaton was all too happy to prove his doubters wrong. He gave a stirring performance in Batman that involved eerie combat sequences, an honest examination of Bob Kane's creation, and brilliant chemistry with Jack Nicholson's Joker.
6. Heath Ledger - The Dark Knight
It may seem strange to audiences now, seeing as Heath Ledger's haunting performance as the anarchic terrorist Joker in The Dark Knight has gone on to define his tragically short career, but the initial announcement that he'd been cast in the role was first met with ridicule. The first movie in Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, Batman Begins, was a shot in the arm for the franchise that took the character to a darker, more realistic realm.
Ledger, on the other hand, was best known as a pretty-boy leading man. His credits to that date included the romantic comedy 10 Things I Hate About You, the fantasy action movie The Brothers Grimm, and the romantic drama Brokeback Mountain. Even when he was taken seriously as an actor, he'd stayed in safe performances that took advantage of his good looks and confident persona.
The derision he received when he was announced as the Joker only increased when the first images of the movie was released and he was shown in pancake makeup with no context. But then the film premiered and his critics, even those who were able to overlook his passing, were silenced by his raw, horrifying portrayal.
By embracing the chaos of the Joker in his performance, Ledger tapped into a deep, cultural fear that garnered him a posthumous Academy Award.
5. Matt Damon - The Bourne Identity
It seems strange today that there was a time that Matt Damon was ever questioned as a casting choice. The Boston native has proven himself time and time again to be one of the most versatile and chameleon-like actors in Hollywood and has even developed a hobby of doing brief, nigh-unrecognizable cameos in random films just to prove he can fit into any mold.
But in the early days of his career, he was still proving himself. He exploded to mainstream recognition with Good Will Hunting and proved he wasn't just a pretty face with his brief but impactful role in Saving Private Ryan. He proved he could be funny in Dogma and that he could be a tormented villain in The Talented Mr. Ripley. But while he had demonstrated his chops as a leading man, he had never been able to prove himself as an action hero.
That's why audiences were incredulous when he was cast in the film adaptation of Robert Ludlum's popular spy thriller The Bourne Identity. The novel was a favorite of casual readers and nobody wanted to see Jason Bourne misrepresented on the big screen. Fortunately, Damon was able to tick off the last box of his Hollywood checklist and audiences were relieved to see Damon not only handle himself in the action sequences, but successfully demonstrate the character's psychological and enigmatic trauma.
4. Keanu Reeves - The Matrix
Keanu Reeves has had a weird career to say the least, filled with ups and downs but mostly with good performances and constant public reinvention. He got his big break as one half of Bill and Ted and then reinvented himself as an action hero in movies like Point Break, Speed, and Bram Stoker's Dracula. He even tried to be a Shakespearean actor to be in Much Ado About Nothing.
But while he never failed to impress audiences with his comic timing and good performances, many suspected that he would never find his niche in Hollywood and would always be relegated as a solid B-list celebrity. The only people who seemed to disagree were the Wachowski siblings who, in 1999, realized Reeves's natural monotone and facial control made him perfect to be the leading man in an experimental action film they were writing.
And when they announced that the guy who said "Whoa" was going to be the leather-clad badass in a philosophical cyber-thriller, the world collectively laughed. But then The Matrix went on to be one of the most important movies ever made and set the tone for blockbuster film-making for the twenty-first century, due in no small part to Reeves's now-iconic performance as the chosen techno-messiah Neo.
3. Tom Cruise - Interview With The Vampire
It's very telling that there was perhaps nobody more adverse to Tom Cruise's casting as the villainous vampire Lestat in the the adaptation of Anne Rice's Interview With The Vampire than Anne Rice herself, who was very vocal in her criticism of the casting.
And her concerns, as well as those of her legions of fans, were not unfounded. In the novel, Lestat is meant to be a large, intimidating figure representing the seductive but selfish mindset of the aristocracy, who were more than willing to sacrifice human lives for the betterment of the upper class. He is notably older, terrifyingly persistent, and almost invincible. Actors Rice had imagined for the role included Julian Sands, John Malkovich and Jeremy Irons.
But the studio had wanted a younger, more marketable heartthrob of an actor for the role. And in 1994, that meant Tom Cruise. Up to that point, Cruise was known for mostly intense but affable performances in the likes of Top Gun, Risky Business, and Rain Man. He'd never come across as someone who could be dangerous or intimidating. But Rice herself admitted her concerns were misplaced and she, along with audiences, were please with Cruise's sultry and unnerving performance as the movie's antagonist.
2. Jennifer Lopez - Selena
Though Jennifer Lopez is a household name today, she was relatively unknown for the first decade of her career. She got her big break as Fly Girl on In Living Color and had a smattering of television and supporting roles throughout the 1990s. She got her first chance at a leading role in Selena, the 1997 biopic of famed Latin artist Selena Quintanilla.
Any upcoming actress would consider this to be the casting of a lifetime and Lopez certainly celebrated it. But with such a meaty role came a wave of criticism. Selena had been revered as a pop star capable of breaking cultural and racial barriers and brought the tejano music style to a mainstream audience. Her fans around the globe were initially outraged that such an untested and inexperienced actress would be representing such an impactful musician.
But Lopez took their criticism to heart and did extensive research for the role, interviewing Selena's family, friends, and business associates to get as clear a picture as possible of the the singer's tragically short life. She incorporated this into her performance and received widespread praise from critics for her humanizing depiction of the star, proving her doubters wrong and inspiring her to launch her own music career.
1. Mos Def - The Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy
Mos Def has made a name for himself as a rapper and political activist, but his career as a musician started in 1994. Before that, he was an actor on a number of kids shows. After launching his rap career, he continued to do sporadic performances for television movies and shows but, despite garnering critical acclaim, always made sure his work as a musician was more prevalent than his acting.
But in 2005, he decided to take on a comedic role, something he'd never outright done before. He was cast as Ford Prefect in the film adaptation of the classic science-fiction novel The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, a role which had previously been offered to comedy giants Bill Murray and Dan Aykroyd. It required an actor with convincing comedic timing and an affable, laid-back attitude.
In none of his previous roles had Mos Def ever indicated that these were his strong suites and the legions of the books fans were terrified that the integral straight man and foil to most of the novel's dry, witty humor would be bungled by a man who proclaimed himself a rapper before an actor. However, it turned out they never needed to worry. Mos Def let his cool and collected performance mellow out the tensions of the film and elevated its comedy with his measured screen presence.